AS Goldman Sachs and other world wide banking criminal syndicates enslave us by making loans to countries they can never pay we don't fight back. As Nations collude with arms dealers from Brussels, to Dallas, we calmly sit and watch as they destroy our lives and planet and do not fight back. It's long past time to dismantle the corrupt governments and banking system and start over world wide revolution. Just ignoring and not actively fighting aint gona do it. It's fight or be anihilated
I still have my VHS copy of the concert when it hit the store shelves. Also have a Live in Berlin Roger Waters T shirt that I try not to wear for fear of something happening to it. I love the album, but this live rendition with other musicians is phenominal.
She was the most shameful part of the show. It is the ilk of Skinhead O'connor and her hatred for people and God that erected that infernal wall in the first place.
in my opinion, this is why they broke up.....waters saw this vision, which is a total vision of himself. the rest wanted to be more of a band, and they did, and he did this...very impressive.............................
Many thanks to sound engineer Gary Bradshaw, who let the circuit breakers blow during the performance of Sinead O'Connor for making this concert to an unforgetable succes!
I'm a HUGE Floyd fan.. Waters is the bomb I actually enjoy it when Gilmour isn't trying to do the whole damn thing himself. at least Waters collaborates with other musicians who fit the profile per song. Waters has the floyd voice, I do love David but he is just a nickel and dime guitar player if you ask me Wright and Waters' bass lines are what make Floyd stand out.
Thanks for this, going to see Waters in June and can't wait, the original Floyd may be gone but instead of arguing the toss why not just accept we all have something in common here and enjoy the fuckin concert for what it was...awesome, with or without Rick and David.
@acerbicvoice Like I sed, squib, a Roger production. Whole damn thing was Roger until He fired Ricky and David rebelled during the 78-79-80 recording sessions. By the time of Berlin what did Roger have? Nothin 'ceptin Nick. It is NOT Floyd. It is Roger, and obviously, derp, he could not play all the parts himself live. Jeezus do they teach you twinks anything in school today. NO! Wait! We don't NEED no ed-u-cation! Tune into Radio KAOS and call yo' mama in the morning. dwep.
Sorry ducks but I still cry when a listen this version of The Wall ... This tour The Wall 2010 is rich in effects of High tecnology but poor in the musically sense Sounds like a fussion of HTecnology and original version with out original musicians
I'm going to see this show in Montreal in october . The ticket was a gift From a friend that told me i HAVE to see this.... I saw The Floyd in the 80's. And since Gilmour ...That's just not Floyd................. I will go.I will enjoy Watters... But just not the same... That feeling...that voice...that guitar............. Just too bad....
I love pink floyd but to be honest it is not the same with out gilmour, wright, and mason i no it hurts some of u out there but this version sucks, sry but am being honest
@adevezar Goodbye Blue Sky. Al Gore does the same thing, preaches against Global Warming and how we have to reduce our Global CO2 Footprint and he uses private jets himself and Former Vice President Al Gore and his wife, Tipper, have added a Montecito-area property to their real estate holdings, reports the Montecito Journal.
@adevezar they really sucks? amazing grammar there my friend. youre stupid nation is probably wasting 10 times the resources the waste. so you better shut your dirty mouth before i whoop your ass
Solo una mente INTELIGENTE es capaz de abrirse a otras propuestas y delegar en otros su obra sin temor a perder por ello su ESENCIA eso es lo que me demuestra Roger Waters en esta version de THE WALL ....ES MAGNIFICA!!! y CONVENGAMOS 300 mil personas no se reunen asi nomas en Europa.. Siento que todos se han reunido a ayudar a derribar EL MURO !!
Hey thanks Anselcat! I got so confused! I thought the Scorpions and Sinead O'Connor were in Pink Floyd from way back in the Syd days. Dang! My bad. Thanks so much for clearing that up for everyone!!
Best music imo still comes from the isles. And i'm an American.
something needs to happen to mainstream music. a complete implosion or something. because mainstream rock is a like waking up to a bad case of diarrea.
this show was the best,,i love how they all came together for a cause.........bunch of great artist everyone unique in there own way just like all of us.
Dovrebbero essere presi da esempio, uno dei migliori gruppi musicali del mondo, che ha insegnato a tanti cos'è la musica , altro che pop, dance e altre stronzate che sono state create dalla tecnologia !! PINK FLOYD FOREVER
Dave, Nick, and RIck were willing to play with Roger in Berlin after Roger stated in an interview that he might late Dave play guitar, but when Dave said he and the rest of the band would be willing to play Roger said, and i quote "I don't know where Dave got that idea"
This has always been a Roger Waters production@Anselcat1952. it is sad that they all couldn't be there but it is what it is. This is Rogers gig. This show was amazing and still is.
@cloudchaser07 No. He will tell you so too. To Be Floyd it must be all four or three minus Roger, When Richard died Floyd was no more. Nicky was the only constant from Syd onward and he agreed with David.
David can sing Floyd today if he pleases, but he would introduce it as "a song by Pink Floyd" Floyd, in other words, died the day Richard did. "My Partner. My Friend. Floyd is no more. I will never perform as Pinkk Floyd again." said David. I believe him. RIP Roger/Syd and Ricky..
True, but the wall is really Roger's story (mixed with that of Syd Barret) with Pink Floyd as back up, if we are going to be honest. Don't get me wrong, I love Pink Floyd, but read Rogers Bio and you are reading the background notes for the Wall
You're right on the creativeness of Pink Floyds LYRICS. But without Gilmours soulful playing, Ricks keyboard playing, They where the SOUL, Roger was the BRAIN, he needed the others to get his message across, otherwise he wouldn't be NO WHERE.
I have to completely agree with this statement, This is filled with much truth but sad floyd couldn't come to a understanding and reunite for this occasion. Pink Floyd 4 ever. God rest your soul rick
I thought this was the best part of the concert. Sinead was great. You can see Roger smiling a lot here - so he's happy with it. For those rippijg on the people in this show please realize, this was not mean to be a "Pink Floyd" concert. It was a berlin wall celebration. Think of it as a broadway show. Some acts were bad (Joni Mitchell, Van Morrison) but many were good.
shit I love the old school...I love all those bands, Pink Floyd , Led Zeppelin were and are the best... where are the new bands? they don´t rock like them.... viva el verdadero rock......
syd ,was the beginning .roger and gilmore kept it going .roger bailed out . and gilmore kept the band going . I think pink floyed is david gilmore . roger walters should be roger walters doing pink floyed ,even though he is the voice .david kept the band going ...
i agree with colugino...add the guitarists in there too!...those would be some pretty big shoes to fill with gilmour gone....they are not going to be able to put every single gilmour lick in there, its impossible, this isnt guitar hero...lol...snowy white and the others hold gilmour as their role-model and i personally think they do a hell of a job...they are putting their own feelings and styles in the music around gilmours foundation and framework...thats one of the great things about music!
Some were lip synched after the show for the dvd and some of the rehearsal footage was used, for example sinead o'connor refused to lip synch her mother rendition so twe used the rehearsal version.
I have been reading comments left on all the videos of this concert by the Brittany Spears and Hannah Montana children. It was one of the most amazing concerts of the day. Most weren't even sperm yet and writing comments about something they will never understand. Pink Floyd was and is one of the greatest acts of all time. They put on a CONCERT. Not two hours of lip syncing. And so what if some of the people singing weren't up to your standards. We don't see you up there singing!
I was there. Backstage. As well as backstage at Live Aid. The Wall made Live Aid look like a road show in terms of production values and excitement factor. It was unforgettable.
I really enjoyed the videos. It took me back to crazy times in my life when I was a teenager. When I would feel down and out, this song would always come to mind.
Umm....everyone on this show ruined The Wall. Roger should have just used muppets, instead of "special" guests. Notice how he needs about three guitarists to cover David Gilmour. LMAO. It was a very honorable thing to do a show for that moment in history, yes. But its about as entertaining as sandwiching your head with two bricks.
Yes! Exactly!! David Gilmour is like my idol, so the thought of the wall without him playing is like blasphemy to me. It just made me speechless. How insanely dull these guitarists are. Its as if Roger auditioned them, and asked, "Can you read guitar tabs, rather than play with your heart and soul? Because thats really important to me." I know one of them is Snowy White and he played backup guitar for floyd since 1975. But based on his playing here, he must have fallen asleep during class lol
Granted, at the beginning of Empty Spaces there are some killer licks, and the guy who sings and plays Young Lust kicks ass. I don't remember who either of them were unfortunately, but props to 'em.
Yes, i do agree. If i were able to just have certain scenes on tape or something, i would want empty spaces/young lust, and in the flesh with the scorpions. Those were cool versions. The guy playing and singing young lust is Bryan Adams. If you're still not sure...he sang the songs "summer of 69'" and "Everything I Do".
The David Gilmour ego??? Have you never heard roger waters? Hes so full of himself, he shits his face out each morning and must reapply it. Ca Ira was a miracle for him. Must have realized there are topics to use, OTHER than his dead father finally. Atleast the other three kept it going, and tried new things. Well, not anymore, but neither is he, except touring dark side of the moon. So he must be lost for ideas now, funny how theres only one. So get your fucking facts straight.
you have to realize that the all pink floyd idea is roger's. & if u don't understand that the great artists make once in their life brilliant music & then all the rest is crap, your have nothing to do with music, its more honest to play again and again your best music for the people who admire you and look up to you, than slowly fade away in sad and confused creations,if someone don't have something important to say its better to shut the fuck up, so this is what davido have to do s.t. .f.u.
All his idea?? well for starters, syd started pink floyd. Get that fact first. And then to go on to roger, if you truly believed that what his role for them is what makes the whole band. Then you might as well just throw away all your fucking cds and keep the lyrics. Thats all that shithead did. As far as music, he didnt know shit. Try listening to one of his solo albums. Might as well be an audiobook. I bet you didnt even know he spit on a fan at a concert???
Roger told the story about that in the special features section of the DVD of "Pink Floyd The Wall". In fact, he said that when he spit on a fan, it was the turning point for him that made him take a deep look at himself and inspired the writing of "The Wall".
Yeah, Syd started it, Roger and David kept it going, but I think Parsons' engineering on Dark Side really brought them to the top. In reality, each member of the team contributed greatly to their success.
Ohh yeah, i agree defenitely. It wasn't coincidence that he won a grammy for dark side. He engineered the last two beatles albums as well, so he's one who knew what he was doing. All four did bring their own ingredients to make anything they did, magic. Just wish they'd get along.
You are 100% right dude. Roger Waters was the heart and soul of Pink Floyd. Gilmour was very good, but he was a follower. Roger was the deepness. No Roger - no dark side, the wall or much of anything else.
I think I've fallen in love with the woman who sang Mother. But Joni Mitchell needs to get the fuck off the stage for destroying my favourite song off this album.
Yeah, what the fuck what Joni trying to do anyways? Not only was her singing terribly off key, but it completely ruined the moods you receive from the lyrics and sounds.
i usually hate the knob heads who point out when people have said something wrong but... as much as i have respect for all those who try and help poverty stricken Africa. this concert was actual for the memorial fund which is for all those families who need to rebuild their life in war torn countries.. sorry.
roger can still rock without gilmour but the female vocals make it a wee bit sucky
btw gilmour is awsome but he wasnt the heart of floyd waters was, he wrote most songs but to be fair by the final cut he was being a bit of an asshole
The first female vocalist was amazing, and she definitely had a grasp on the character she was portraying. You can really see it in her eyes. The second vocalist didn't impress me so much.
este concierto es la verga, aunque me habria gustado mas si no hubieran invitado a los demas cantantes, pero no ay pedo, lo que si no me gusto fue como cantaron la cancion "goodbye blue sky" pero los solos de guitarra en "another brick in the wall II" son lo mejor¡
They give you a concert you'll never forget.And I always spend most of my money to get the best seats in the house. Wow what a performance, what a show!
regular, pero me gusta mucho Mother..
MrJaimeton 2 months ago
Levon Helm, Garth Hudson, Rick Danko, and of course Roger Waters... holy fuck
EmFayg 2 months ago
AS Goldman Sachs and other world wide banking criminal syndicates enslave us by making loans to countries they can never pay we don't fight back. As Nations collude with arms dealers from Brussels, to Dallas, we calmly sit and watch as they destroy our lives and planet and do not fight back. It's long past time to dismantle the corrupt governments and banking system and start over world wide revolution. Just ignoring and not actively fighting aint gona do it. It's fight or be anihilated
geezerdombroadcast 4 months ago 2
this tune rocks and sends a great message to all
soarneagle 4 months ago
this tune rocks and sends a gret message to all
soarneagle 4 months ago
I still have my VHS copy of the concert when it hit the store shelves. Also have a Live in Berlin Roger Waters T shirt that I try not to wear for fear of something happening to it. I love the album, but this live rendition with other musicians is phenominal.
harp99 5 months ago
grande sinead o^connor gran cantante de lo 90
cristianalfonso335 6 months ago
@cristianalfonso335
She was the most shameful part of the show. It is the ilk of Skinhead O'connor and her hatred for people and God that erected that infernal wall in the first place.
haitipi 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Closely listen to an Inception dvd made before the January 8th Tucson shooting, especially around, ""Do It.""
jamestargetedindiv 6 months ago
Dear friend, WATCH THIS IS WORTH THE MONEY LIFE EXPECTINNCY IS SHORT, tHANK YOU, MY bUDDY
lchongusa2025 7 months ago
pink floyd is a genius
skincrawler100 8 months ago
rick danko, levon helm and the doc.....come on man.......sinead should have been honored............
feeeball 8 months ago
in my opinion, this is why they broke up.....waters saw this vision, which is a total vision of himself. the rest wanted to be more of a band, and they did, and he did this...very impressive.............................
feeeball 8 months ago
A country divided by two different superpowers could come together then, but Pink Floyd couldn't.
And yes, I did just compare the split with the Cold War. :P
PlankofWood1 9 months ago
I cannot believe I just read that "David Gilmour is just "a nickel and dime guitar player."
Possibly the most pathetic statement I've ever heard.
whh0157 10 months ago 7
Many thanks to sound engineer Gary Bradshaw, who let the circuit breakers blow during the performance of Sinead O'Connor for making this concert to an unforgetable succes!
Alpinerbergen 11 months ago
I'm a HUGE Floyd fan.. Waters is the bomb I actually enjoy it when Gilmour isn't trying to do the whole damn thing himself. at least Waters collaborates with other musicians who fit the profile per song. Waters has the floyd voice, I do love David but he is just a nickel and dime guitar player if you ask me Wright and Waters' bass lines are what make Floyd stand out.
Ara7ius 11 months ago
u forgot pulse and devision bells al made by floyd the wole band in amazing
stop hating plz why this was the last good music of the 80 and 90s
Rooiuhdakduif 11 months ago
Where the fxxk is Dave???
9soo 1 year ago
@acerbicvoice How did you know her??? It´s unbelievable!!!!
Tefipunkrock 1 year ago
I love this show and I love Sinead! In Argentina we love good music too!
Tefipunkrock 1 year ago
Thanks for this, going to see Waters in June and can't wait, the original Floyd may be gone but instead of arguing the toss why not just accept we all have something in common here and enjoy the fuckin concert for what it was...awesome, with or without Rick and David.
wakeupsheeple81 1 year ago
Oh no NOT HER!!
lala5732 1 year ago
hahahahhahahahahahhahahhhahahhahahah
frotenberguen 10 months ago
Respond to this video... PS: I'd rather be kinda dumb than like you, wholly and completely stupid.
Anselcat1952 1 year ago
@acerbicvoice When were you born? Yesterday? Most probably after 1989.
Anselcat1952 1 year ago
@acerbicvoice Like I sed, squib, a Roger production. Whole damn thing was Roger until He fired Ricky and David rebelled during the 78-79-80 recording sessions. By the time of Berlin what did Roger have? Nothin 'ceptin Nick. It is NOT Floyd. It is Roger, and obviously, derp, he could not play all the parts himself live. Jeezus do they teach you twinks anything in school today. NO! Wait! We don't NEED no ed-u-cation! Tune into Radio KAOS and call yo' mama in the morning. dwep.
Anselcat1952 1 year ago
is The Wall concert in Berlin, wall larger than the one 2010 concert one Roger Waters is doing now?
noveltyskateboards 1 year ago
anyone can tell me, which songs are those?
brianfer123 1 year ago
@brianfer123 Mother and Goodbye blue sky,
jzweig1 1 year ago
YES!
ghosterdude 1 year ago
Sorry ducks but I still cry when a listen this version of The Wall ... This tour The Wall 2010 is rich in effects of High tecnology but poor in the musically sense Sounds like a fussion of HTecnology and original version with out original musicians
anamgify 1 year ago
one of my top 3 favorite solos from the wall
pinkfloyd257 1 year ago
good performance but I agree not Pink Floyd and I would like to see O'connor with hair
grimrepoer2003 1 year ago
As good as it gets. The best concert ever.
TheChazraz 1 year ago
As good as it gets.
TheChazraz 1 year ago
I recall spending a day trying to get a flight out to Berlin for this with no luck.
Ausgezeichnet!
GARGLER42 1 year ago
what is with all these guests...that chick singing goodbye blue sky SUCKS...she totally ruined the awesome song
seanmitchell88 1 year ago
this stinks
bleekblock 1 year ago
I doubt if floyd could even do it better! this is epic!
Lysemykt 1 year ago
Senead o connor needs to get outa here. this is roger waters not gay
RustedPieces1 1 year ago
I'm going to see this show in Montreal in october . The ticket was a gift From a friend that told me i HAVE to see this.... I saw The Floyd in the 80's. And since Gilmour ...That's just not Floyd................. I will go.I will enjoy Watters... But just not the same... That feeling...that voice...that guitar............. Just too bad....
exafy 1 year ago
Roger Waters in bringing this to toronto Sept 18 2010,
Can't wait
look for me I'll be the one with the cloud around me lol
luvdagras 1 year ago
I love pink floyd but to be honest it is not the same with out gilmour, wright, and mason i no it hurts some of u out there but this version sucks, sry but am being honest
nrmhrrs100 1 year ago
These idiots are singing theyr own guilty.
They drive cars, major cars, they use major resources from the planet.
Most of these people don't feel the planet round and round.
They think that they gone change anything in politics but they are sing what they loose in democracy.
This guys in Politics will be worst than Stalin or Hitler, Pol Pot or European Comunity.
Imperialism was ever the goal of Pink Floyd.
That's why they really sucks.
adevezar 1 year ago
@adevezar Goodbye Blue Sky. Al Gore does the same thing, preaches against Global Warming and how we have to reduce our Global CO2 Footprint and he uses private jets himself and Former Vice President Al Gore and his wife, Tipper, have added a Montecito-area property to their real estate holdings, reports the Montecito Journal.
adriaan880121958 1 year ago
@adevezar they really sucks? amazing grammar there my friend. youre stupid nation is probably wasting 10 times the resources the waste. so you better shut your dirty mouth before i whoop your ass
Logankeller352 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
these are the people who fuck tha planet to have a major concert.
Floyd sucks.
adevezar 1 year ago
@adevezar You Suck!!!
nfc127 1 year ago
The Wall is what idiots do when they recognize themselves as alls, or isiots.
adevezar 1 year ago
@adevezar IDIOT!
Mante53 1 year ago
WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE?!
sraluvssnakes 1 year ago
Solo una mente INTELIGENTE es capaz de abrirse a otras propuestas y delegar en otros su obra sin temor a perder por ello su ESENCIA eso es lo que me demuestra Roger Waters en esta version de THE WALL ....ES MAGNIFICA!!! y CONVENGAMOS 300 mil personas no se reunen asi nomas en Europa.. Siento que todos se han reunido a ayudar a derribar EL MURO !!
anamgify 1 year ago
Just a little friendly badgering. . .of course this is Roger Waters solo, and an amazing group of other people doing some great work.
7BokChoy 1 year ago
Wait a second, hey Anselcat so you're tellin' me that 'the Band' wasn't referring to Pink Floyd all along? Dude I'm so lost right now!
7BokChoy 1 year ago
Hey thanks Anselcat! I got so confused! I thought the Scorpions and Sinead O'Connor were in Pink Floyd from way back in the Syd days. Dang! My bad. Thanks so much for clearing that up for everyone!!
7BokChoy 1 year ago
thie is nice
JUSHOSKI 1 year ago
Berlin...perfect plase for this concert...
Always choose perfect place for a concert...
and like other one for Pompeii
mussashe 1 year ago
i was there in 1990... almost 20 years ago already... geez.
dvanderp71 1 year ago
barbershop trio for the chorus of mother = EPIC WIN
theartofshred 1 year ago
Who else could put Sineade, The Hooters, and The Band Together on one stage, and one song, and make it sound this perfect? ROGER !!!!
Just awesome.
marcusdolby1 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
For all the Pink Floyd's fans! There's a new version of "IF" (atom heart mother) on myspace gariac. Enjoy it on myspace gariac popmusik!
MrGariac 2 years ago
so much emotion from Sinead...lacking these days....so much manufactured crap..
Bangoliers 2 years ago 3
agree 100% music today is recycled garbage!
Best music imo still comes from the isles. And i'm an American.
something needs to happen to mainstream music. a complete implosion or something. because mainstream rock is a like waking up to a bad case of diarrea.
m7abel 2 years ago 3
LOL she didnt perform live as her ego is bigger than her bald head. This is a rehearsal
TheUtubesuxass 1 year ago
I love how Roger Waters is watching her and smiling, like he enjoys how she's singing his song
raspberryicedtea 2 years ago
"mother" - The wall 1979
oscarivan1021 2 years ago
"mother" originalmente lanzada en "the wall" 1979
oscarivan1021 2 years ago
this show was the best,,i love how they all came together for a cause.........bunch of great artist everyone unique in there own way just like all of us.
666Angelfuck 2 years ago 2
Dovrebbero essere presi da esempio, uno dei migliori gruppi musicali del mondo, che ha insegnato a tanti cos'è la musica , altro che pop, dance e altre stronzate che sono state create dalla tecnologia !! PINK FLOYD FOREVER
vascotube84 2 years ago
cherry FROM PHILIPPINES
This is one of my favorite song by the pink floyd, I LOVE YOU GUYS!! MORE POWER.
danple15 2 years ago 2
Dave, Nick, and RIck were willing to play with Roger in Berlin after Roger stated in an interview that he might late Dave play guitar, but when Dave said he and the rest of the band would be willing to play Roger said, and i quote "I don't know where Dave got that idea"
jhnh95 2 years ago
Dude, nobody LETS David Gilmour play guitar
nickringer 2 years ago
(Y)
acinorcana 2 years ago
VIVA Pink floyd Queen Rammstein War Guns n Roses Nirvana Genesis por siempre el Rock y el Metal
TheSoyoman 2 years ago
viva old times
syfiasz 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
W W W . 50U . ORG <--- Download this Video in FLV,Mp3,Mp4 or 3GP for Mobile Phone
faithamistadi 2 years ago
Nice to see Rick Danko and Levon Helm!!
gbc77000 2 years ago
this was dubbed, at the gig the sounds fucked up, a few parts were dubbed after the show :O((
TheUtubesuxass 2 years ago
I love the fact some sad old fuck has given a thumbs down lol, this was not live it was the rehearsal, some facts are just too painful i guess ;O))
TheUtubesuxass 1 year ago
as good as this, it is not Floyd
it is a Roger solo production.
Damn good, but NOT Floyd
Anselcat1952 2 years ago 38
This has always been a Roger Waters production@Anselcat1952. it is sad that they all couldn't be there but it is what it is. This is Rogers gig. This show was amazing and still is.
bnbamity 1 year ago 4
@Anselcat1952 So is it Floyd when David Gimoure sings comfortably numb?
cloudchaser07 11 months ago
@cloudchaser07 No. He will tell you so too. To Be Floyd it must be all four or three minus Roger, When Richard died Floyd was no more. Nicky was the only constant from Syd onward and he agreed with David.
David can sing Floyd today if he pleases, but he would introduce it as "a song by Pink Floyd" Floyd, in other words, died the day Richard did. "My Partner. My Friend. Floyd is no more. I will never perform as Pinkk Floyd again." said David. I believe him. RIP Roger/Syd and Ricky..
Anselcat1952 10 months ago
@Anselcat1952 I agree 100%
NarLiv 9 months ago
@Anselcat1952 I was there and I agree 100 % . Even though I love Paul Carrack, Bryan Adams, etc... It wasn't Pink Floyd...
hyperchipper 6 months ago
@hyperchipper
True, but the wall is really Roger's story (mixed with that of Syd Barret) with Pink Floyd as back up, if we are going to be honest. Don't get me wrong, I love Pink Floyd, but read Rogers Bio and you are reading the background notes for the Wall
haitipi 5 months ago
Joni Mitchell doing Goodbye Blue Sky = one of the most touching pieces of music recorded. Ever.
joshwood47 2 years ago
You're right on the creativeness of Pink Floyds LYRICS. But without Gilmours soulful playing, Ricks keyboard playing, They where the SOUL, Roger was the BRAIN, he needed the others to get his message across, otherwise he wouldn't be NO WHERE.
rdaws73 2 years ago 4
I have to completely agree with this statement, This is filled with much truth but sad floyd couldn't come to a understanding and reunite for this occasion. Pink Floyd 4 ever. God rest your soul rick
dking70 2 years ago 15
Adoro i PINK FLOYD!! Questa musica è pura magia, veri maestri della musica rock !!
vascotube84 2 years ago
i was told she was a B---h!!!
but how ironic she was at the end of the show.
TEMPmichaelhansen 2 years ago
thanx for posting this concert. I'm obsessed with rock and this was a missing piece.
nowUfunny2 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
So I remixed this song with Queen.
It's on my profile page, just sitting there doing nothing. it wants you to come watch it.
sorry for the weird comment.
i get bored writing "check out my awesome remix!" all the time.
StingChameleonREMIX 2 years ago
He can sing ! Wow with so much feeling.
barbi1sky 2 years ago
it's she!
Splash38 2 years ago
Now let's see if she'll bust a picture of the Pope again.....
coneyraven 2 years ago 2
lol barb it's not a he, it's a girl, her name's Sinead O'connor
spike427 2 years ago
I thought this was the best part of the concert. Sinead was great. You can see Roger smiling a lot here - so he's happy with it. For those rippijg on the people in this show please realize, this was not mean to be a "Pink Floyd" concert. It was a berlin wall celebration. Think of it as a broadway show. Some acts were bad (Joni Mitchell, Van Morrison) but many were good.
aitraining 2 years ago 4
Not a Sinead fan normally, but she nailed this I thought. Very heart felt and well done. Great choice to have her do this.
aitraining 2 years ago
What year did the band do this in?
polerbear1000 2 years ago
1990 I believe.
aitraining 2 years ago
The year when Berlin wall was down 1990
triunp 2 years ago 4
9 Nov 1989
TheUtubesuxass 2 years ago
The wall came down in 1989 this was performed in 1990
TheUtubesuxass 1 year ago
4:34 gave me chills :)
Commando2936 2 years ago
Joni Mitchell ,truly an enlightened being ,make no mistake....
134being 2 years ago
Orgasm after orgasm!
123457Fel 2 years ago 2
shit I love the old school...I love all those bands, Pink Floyd , Led Zeppelin were and are the best... where are the new bands? they don´t rock like them.... viva el verdadero rock......
fredualdo 2 years ago 2
scabdates
celerno 2 years ago
me too but , exists bands like muse or deftones , this bands playing very good music...
oodeftonesoo 2 years ago
Since my dear you have revealed your deepest fears ,I sentance you to awaken ,after you've died to the past of course!
134being 2 years ago
John Lilley at 2:45!!
blohrmann 2 years ago
joni mitchell butchered this song
Sublimerules6 2 years ago
Joni Mitchell wrote Both Sides Now.Now being the operative word!
134being 2 years ago
Joni mitchell an enlightened woman that most rare of beings.
134being 2 years ago
syd ,was the beginning .roger and gilmore kept it going .roger bailed out . and gilmore kept the band going . I think pink floyed is david gilmore . roger walters should be roger walters doing pink floyed ,even though he is the voice .david kept the band going ...
billiey61 3 years ago
hehe...
views 99.999 and 100.000
Pistolav 3 years ago
i agree with colugino...add the guitarists in there too!...those would be some pretty big shoes to fill with gilmour gone....they are not going to be able to put every single gilmour lick in there, its impossible, this isnt guitar hero...lol...snowy white and the others hold gilmour as their role-model and i personally think they do a hell of a job...they are putting their own feelings and styles in the music around gilmours foundation and framework...thats one of the great things about music!
zeroaoshi1 3 years ago
Was this a reshoot. I saw the original concert on tv and there was a lot of technical problems at this point. Powerful stuff though.
egapnala65 3 years ago
Some were lip synched after the show for the dvd and some of the rehearsal footage was used, for example sinead o'connor refused to lip synch her mother rendition so twe used the rehearsal version.
TheUtubesuxass 1 year ago
I have been reading comments left on all the videos of this concert by the Brittany Spears and Hannah Montana children. It was one of the most amazing concerts of the day. Most weren't even sperm yet and writing comments about something they will never understand. Pink Floyd was and is one of the greatest acts of all time. They put on a CONCERT. Not two hours of lip syncing. And so what if some of the people singing weren't up to your standards. We don't see you up there singing!
colugino 3 years ago
in my opinion, this is the greatest live performance ever.
apollo2132000 3 years ago 10
Honestly, for me too. The best!
This song is wonderful!
hairany 3 years ago
I was there. Backstage. As well as backstage at Live Aid. The Wall made Live Aid look like a road show in terms of production values and excitement factor. It was unforgettable.
blohrmann 2 years ago
I'm not even a Sinead fan, but she did a fantastic job, I must say.
As for whoever that is that did Goodbye Blue Sky...I can't say the same, and we'll leave it at that.
hbzombi 3 years ago 3
I really enjoyed the videos. It took me back to crazy times in my life when I was a teenager. When I would feel down and out, this song would always come to mind.
pfg777 3 years ago
Merci Beaucoup dude <33 j'adore ce show je l'écoute presque toujours =D
marcskate12 3 years ago
Umm....everyone on this show ruined The Wall. Roger should have just used muppets, instead of "special" guests. Notice how he needs about three guitarists to cover David Gilmour. LMAO. It was a very honorable thing to do a show for that moment in history, yes. But its about as entertaining as sandwiching your head with two bricks.
colourfaze86 3 years ago
not only does he need three guitarists but for the most part they're playing cheap note-for-note excuses for guitar solos
RigsbyPaul 3 years ago
Yes! Exactly!! David Gilmour is like my idol, so the thought of the wall without him playing is like blasphemy to me. It just made me speechless. How insanely dull these guitarists are. Its as if Roger auditioned them, and asked, "Can you read guitar tabs, rather than play with your heart and soul? Because thats really important to me." I know one of them is Snowy White and he played backup guitar for floyd since 1975. But based on his playing here, he must have fallen asleep during class lol
colourfaze86 3 years ago
Granted, at the beginning of Empty Spaces there are some killer licks, and the guy who sings and plays Young Lust kicks ass. I don't remember who either of them were unfortunately, but props to 'em.
RigsbyPaul 3 years ago
Yes, i do agree. If i were able to just have certain scenes on tape or something, i would want empty spaces/young lust, and in the flesh with the scorpions. Those were cool versions. The guy playing and singing young lust is Bryan Adams. If you're still not sure...he sang the songs "summer of 69'" and "Everything I Do".
colourfaze86 3 years ago
roger rules, the david gilmour ego was to idiot for an idea like pink floyd so fuck the old fat bastard
spyrons9 3 years ago
The David Gilmour ego??? Have you never heard roger waters? Hes so full of himself, he shits his face out each morning and must reapply it. Ca Ira was a miracle for him. Must have realized there are topics to use, OTHER than his dead father finally. Atleast the other three kept it going, and tried new things. Well, not anymore, but neither is he, except touring dark side of the moon. So he must be lost for ideas now, funny how theres only one. So get your fucking facts straight.
colourfaze86 3 years ago
you have to realize that the all pink floyd idea is roger's. & if u don't understand that the great artists make once in their life brilliant music & then all the rest is crap, your have nothing to do with music, its more honest to play again and again your best music for the people who admire you and look up to you, than slowly fade away in sad and confused creations,if someone don't have something important to say its better to shut the fuck up, so this is what davido have to do s.t. .f.u.
spyrons9 3 years ago
All his idea?? well for starters, syd started pink floyd. Get that fact first. And then to go on to roger, if you truly believed that what his role for them is what makes the whole band. Then you might as well just throw away all your fucking cds and keep the lyrics. Thats all that shithead did. As far as music, he didnt know shit. Try listening to one of his solo albums. Might as well be an audiobook. I bet you didnt even know he spit on a fan at a concert???
colourfaze86 3 years ago
Roger told the story about that in the special features section of the DVD of "Pink Floyd The Wall". In fact, he said that when he spit on a fan, it was the turning point for him that made him take a deep look at himself and inspired the writing of "The Wall".
Yeah, Syd started it, Roger and David kept it going, but I think Parsons' engineering on Dark Side really brought them to the top. In reality, each member of the team contributed greatly to their success.
cjlandry 2 years ago 3
Ohh yeah, i agree defenitely. It wasn't coincidence that he won a grammy for dark side. He engineered the last two beatles albums as well, so he's one who knew what he was doing. All four did bring their own ingredients to make anything they did, magic. Just wish they'd get along.
colourfaze86 2 years ago
It seems like Parsons is behind the scenes on all this cool stuff but his own music isn't my taste. What's the deal!
nickringer 2 years ago
You are 100% right dude. Roger Waters was the heart and soul of Pink Floyd. Gilmour was very good, but he was a follower. Roger was the deepness. No Roger - no dark side, the wall or much of anything else.
aitraining 2 years ago 2
Amazing, I have loved this entire live album since it came ouy and still can't get enough. naysayers rot in hell
vegasmt 3 years ago
Friggin' dyke ruined Goodbye, Blue Sky. Lemme quote bmann92:"May Joni Mitchell rot in hell" Couldn't have said it better, man.
chiodosfan4life 3 years ago
did Joni even bother to listen to the song first?
richardshort2001 3 years ago
I think I've fallen in love with the woman who sang Mother. But Joni Mitchell needs to get the fuck off the stage for destroying my favourite song off this album.
RigsbyPaul 3 years ago
Mother was sung by Sinaed O'Conner (sp?). Good voice even if I didn't like her political statements at the time.
Narxist 3 years ago 3
damnit goodbye blue sky was fucking terrible.
trev90ed 3 years ago
Yeah, what the fuck what Joni trying to do anyways? Not only was her singing terribly off key, but it completely ruined the moods you receive from the lyrics and sounds.
TehEMan 3 years ago
Fucking amazing.
wilska1337 3 years ago
Semplicemente, meravigliosi!!
vascotube84 3 years ago
I can't speak for my whole generation, but I can speak for me.
Momma is the sweetest person I'll ever meet!
fig8slomo 3 years ago 2
I think its quite good myself.
StrayGator 3 years ago
arrghghgh that bitch completely ruined goodbye blue sky.
playdead616 3 years ago
may joni mitchell rot in hell
bmann92 3 years ago
ya man whats with all these random musicians, get the original 4 or dont play at all
Wizard421 3 years ago
four genius
Gernaseb 3 years ago
the second woman, joni mitchell, sounds like shes about to die. x.x
kailixkilllerr 3 years ago
needs less random musicians and more Rick Wright, Nick Mason and David Gilmour. Roger Waters by himself with random musicians is like...wtf...
TRIARII117 3 years ago 4
i usually hate the knob heads who point out when people have said something wrong but... as much as i have respect for all those who try and help poverty stricken Africa. this concert was actual for the memorial fund which is for all those families who need to rebuild their life in war torn countries.. sorry.
matthew3415647 3 years ago
the second woman is joni mitchell
shortykane 3 years ago
roger can still rock without gilmour but the female vocals make it a wee bit sucky
btw gilmour is awsome but he wasnt the heart of floyd waters was, he wrote most songs but to be fair by the final cut he was being a bit of an asshole
ollieb12319 3 years ago
I agree for 99% of it...Gilmore imo is a doucher.
pigfaceddog 3 years ago
a bit yes lol but the final cut is also a very good album.
kimikajee 3 years ago
yea i loove not now john and a gunners dream!
ollieb12319 3 years ago
Voice of a legend!!!
x
MeganMassacreTM 3 years ago
Momma sounds manly and a little country
250R1983lover 3 years ago
go on the irish....sinead oconner followed by a fellow irish james galway on flute.
dub8ire 3 years ago 2
Totally agree,dude!
Hasjiesman 3 years ago
The first female vocalist was amazing, and she definitely had a grasp on the character she was portraying. You can really see it in her eyes. The second vocalist didn't impress me so much.
IamTHEpainTRAIN 3 years ago
The first female vocal, as you call her, is the great SINEAD O´CONNOR singing with ROGER WATERS and THE BAND!!!!!
hypatiavelasco 3 years ago
Gracias prometheee por deleitarnos con este video, sencillamente espectacular!!!
ricardomanguera 3 years ago
I agree...I was not there, but these vids shov it all ;)
osano 3 years ago
este concierto es la verga, aunque me habria gustado mas si no hubieran invitado a los demas cantantes, pero no ay pedo, lo que si no me gusto fue como cantaron la cancion "goodbye blue sky" pero los solos de guitarra en "another brick in the wall II" son lo mejor¡
sssssssooooooooo 3 years ago
the red socks are the boston baseball team duh
deserai2jayde 3 years ago
THIS SUCKS
I adore Pink Floyd, but no Gilmour= no Pink Floyd.
EVERY female vocal is a sucky one! I want David Gilmour!
brodequinnn 3 years ago 2
Brodequinnn I totaly AGREE with you!
This sucks.
No Gilmour= No Pink Floyd!
And yes I hate most of the female vocals.
What A Shame!
I have seen Pink Floyd live 3 times in the USA!
They Fucking rock (with Gilmour)
They give you a concert you'll never forget.And I always spend most of my money to get the best seats in the house. Wow what a performance, what a show!
cuteblanca2 3 years ago
Don t you know who is the hairless girl singing "Mother"
gusta2087 3 years ago
Sinead O'Connor
NicktheIrishman 3 years ago
Great stuff this - who's the ugly bint in the second half??
angeldraws3 3 years ago