@arpeggio1358 Yeah I think you're right. It's all the same person, with several accounts, and it's just a troll, or a relative of hers or something. None of its commentary indicates any level of actual musical education or practical knowledge; I doubt it even plays an instrument.
@lustygoat I wonder if at least one of these "fans" of Decker is joking. I mean, the lady is in her own dreamland as far as pitch is concerned and from the very first note too; and she does a good imitation of a cat on the high notes. Now, nothing wrong with a lady enjoying herself in her own home, but coming to a Caballe video and claiming she is better requires quite a delusion.
@jewelmarkess Gina Colao Decker never said that. I said that. What music schools have you graduated from and when did you attend? I have taught in several and have been an opera critic for 30 years.
@voizovrsn Opera critic? Music teacher? Who didn't know who Giuditta Pasta was and thought that a recording of Callas was actually that of Giuditta Pasta? Who liked video of popera bimbo Katherine Jenkins? I might not be a professional musician but at least I knew who Pasta was, I also know the difference between popera and opera.. Also, let's not pollute this beautiful recording of a real opera great - Montserrat Caballe of a discussion of your amateur friend.
@lustygoat Do you realize how ignorant you sound? Gina Colao Decker is one of the very few singers who can keep correct timing and has perfect pitch. What is your problem? You must be exceedingly jealous!
@hermitcrabbot As an opera critic who is very knowledgeable and familiar with the music as well, I think Ms. Caballe is abusing artistic license when she hangs on too long on some notes,which distort the flow of the melody.
@SakumaRyuichiNG sh's even does not know what she's singing about...very funny...she sings..."o mio bambino caro"... when it's "o mio babbino caro".... great difference... incredibile!... and furthermore...she'is not bravo (male gender) but brava (female gender)..sh'es not a man
@kirification Yes, kirification, and YOU have hit upon Caballet's most famous feature, her dynamic control of the voice.! But her's is not the purest voice for this aria. She sounds a bit raspy on the lower tones and much older sounding than the youthful gorgeous voice of Gina Colao Decker . After all, the woman singing this is in her teens.
@kirification Yes, kirification, and YOU have hit upon Caballet's most famous feature, her dynamic control of the voice.! But her's is not the purest voice for this aria. She sounds a bit raspy on the lower tones and much older sounding than the youthful gorgeous voice of Gina Colao Decker . After all, the woman singing this is in her teens.
@voizovrsn watch the video of Decker singing this aria again. The one from 11-20-11. She's not even on pitch, on the "O...", the "c" in "caro" is swallowed, and then there's the train wreck at the high Ab in "bello". That 3 disasters IN THE FIRST FOUR MEASURES OF SINGING. There is simply no way you can claim that this singer is in any way comparable to someone like Caballe. You are trolling us, or you have a huge crush on her, or you are a complete lunatic.
@strngs69 Of course everyone is jealous of Gina Colao Decker. She is brilliant. I think with her high notes, she should try some coloratura arias. Maybe Queen of the Night's aria, if she does it, she may even achieve Florence Foster Jenkins' level of greatness. In her time Florence Foster Jenkins sold out Carnegie Hall, and we are still listening to her so many years after her death. Plays are made about her. Gina Colao Decker may well try to follow her path.
@jewelmarkess Well you are daydreaming now. You can't even tell a dramatic soprano from a coloratura. You seem to be very confused. So where did you get your musical education from?
@lustygoat Your Hearing aid is in needof re-adjusting. Gina Colao Decker's pitch is PERFECT! Her voice blows that of Caballe,s away. Don't let Caballe's fame blind you and dull your hearing. Others in here have attested to it. Gina has a more even and beautiful voice and listen to those "c's" and "o's" again after you have adjusted your hearing aid!
@voizovrsn Ye gods! I listened to Decker and she's one of the worst singers I've ever heard. Her sense of pitch is awful, she breathing is way off and she audibly gulps for air, she doesn't support the tone, her high notes are screechy. By "o's" did you mean she is singing in the key of "o"? Might be, it certainly isn't in any key I recognize. She's purely an amateur. You need to adjust YOUR hearing aid.
@arpeggio1358 Obviously, you have not heard Gina singing this and now are making it all up. Apparently, you have an "axe to grind" because you are so off-track that your comments appear desperate and pathetic. iYou must be awfully jealous!
@voizovrsn Yes, I have heard Decker. I sent you an e-mail asking if she is a friend of yours and if she has some sort of problem that makes her unable to deal with criticism. I'm trying to be kind, but you're making it very difficult.
@OURBOURFLYNN I have been an opera critic for nearly 30 years, am retired and love to use my expertise to carefully delineate what is wrong with even the "great" singers. I know a great voice and demeanor when I see and hear one. So what is your expertise----jealousy?
@lustygoat Decker isn't even a medium-grade amateur. She's purely terrible; poor breathing, ugly tone, doesn't support the tone, screechy high notes, off pitch. And I don't believe for a minute that voizovrsn is an opera critic. If he/she thinks Decker is a great singer, there's no way he/she could be an opera critic. This same person comments all over Decker's videos, alng with one or two others. I think they're all Decker's family and friends.
I had the good luck of experiencing her at Carnegie Hall and I must say she was put on my "favorites" list. She is nearly flawless. But for tonal quality, I have discovered an unknown who's voice emmanates from Heaven. Gina Colao Decker.
Bue..... como que las medidas se le salieron de ritmo pero... es " la Caballe", gran voz, lindos matices, bello fiato... pero un poco deforme el aria....
Божественный голос!
000Ulrika 1 week ago
Во истину ВЕЛИКАЯ ЖЕНЩИНА!!!!!!!!!!!
DeFender236 1 week ago
@arpeggio1358 Yeah I think you're right. It's all the same person, with several accounts, and it's just a troll, or a relative of hers or something. None of its commentary indicates any level of actual musical education or practical knowledge; I doubt it even plays an instrument.
lustygoat 1 week ago
@lustygoat I wonder if at least one of these "fans" of Decker is joking. I mean, the lady is in her own dreamland as far as pitch is concerned and from the very first note too; and she does a good imitation of a cat on the high notes. Now, nothing wrong with a lady enjoying herself in her own home, but coming to a Caballe video and claiming she is better requires quite a delusion.
jewelmarkess 1 week ago
@jewelmarkess Gina Colao Decker never said that. I said that. What music schools have you graduated from and when did you attend? I have taught in several and have been an opera critic for 30 years.
voizovrsn 1 hour ago
@voizovrsn Opera critic? Music teacher? Who didn't know who Giuditta Pasta was and thought that a recording of Callas was actually that of Giuditta Pasta? Who liked video of popera bimbo Katherine Jenkins? I might not be a professional musician but at least I knew who Pasta was, I also know the difference between popera and opera.. Also, let's not pollute this beautiful recording of a real opera great - Montserrat Caballe of a discussion of your amateur friend.
jewelmarkess 36 minutes ago
@lustygoat Do you realize how ignorant you sound? Gina Colao Decker is one of the very few singers who can keep correct timing and has perfect pitch. What is your problem? You must be exceedingly jealous!
voizovrsn 1 hour ago
very funny...she sings..."o mio bambino caro"... when it's "o mio babbino caro".... great difference... incredibile!...
cercopiteco1 1 week ago
:DD
TehBryanxx 2 weeks ago
What a balance of perfect control and emotion! This is my favorite rendition of 'o mio' so far.
hermitcrabbot 2 weeks ago
@hermitcrabbot As an opera critic who is very knowledgeable and familiar with the music as well, I think Ms. Caballe is abusing artistic license when she hangs on too long on some notes,which distort the flow of the melody.
strngs69 2 weeks ago
i can't help but to say that... to sing like her in her worst performance would be awesome D:
impossible for me to recall a better singer than her... jesus, she's touched by god.
SakumaRyuichiNG 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SakumaRyuichiNG sh's even does not know what she's singing about...very funny...she sings..."o mio bambino caro"... when it's "o mio babbino caro".... great difference... incredibile!... and furthermore...she'is not bravo (male gender) but brava (female gender)..sh'es not a man
cercopiteco1 1 week ago
WOW! She has so much control over the dynamics.
kirification 3 weeks ago 2
@kirification You can even SEE all that control in her girth.
strngs69 2 weeks ago
@kirification Yes, kirification, and YOU have hit upon Caballet's most famous feature, her dynamic control of the voice.! But her's is not the purest voice for this aria. She sounds a bit raspy on the lower tones and much older sounding than the youthful gorgeous voice of Gina Colao Decker . After all, the woman singing this is in her teens.
voizovrsn 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kirification Yes, kirification, and YOU have hit upon Caballet's most famous feature, her dynamic control of the voice.! But her's is not the purest voice for this aria. She sounds a bit raspy on the lower tones and much older sounding than the youthful gorgeous voice of Gina Colao Decker . After all, the woman singing this is in her teens.
voizovrsn 1 week ago
après avoir vu mr been :::D
7180hind 3 weeks ago
Wow, absolutely loved it
autumnleafs09 3 weeks ago
Grazie per la Tua voce ed interpretazione. Eccelsa !
TheDominoni 3 weeks ago
Bravo Montserrat Bravo, 7 personas prefieren a Pitbull i Justin Bieber
manaesfrk 3 weeks ago
NO BIG DEAL
aguacan 3 weeks ago
@voizovrsn watch the video of Decker singing this aria again. The one from 11-20-11. She's not even on pitch, on the "O...", the "c" in "caro" is swallowed, and then there's the train wreck at the high Ab in "bello". That 3 disasters IN THE FIRST FOUR MEASURES OF SINGING. There is simply no way you can claim that this singer is in any way comparable to someone like Caballe. You are trolling us, or you have a huge crush on her, or you are a complete lunatic.
lustygoat 4 weeks ago
@lustygoat SOUNDS AS THOUGHT YOU HAVE A PERSONAL VENDETTA AGAINST THE MOST GORGEOUS VOICE EVER. Could you be jealous of Gina Colao Decker? Hmmmmmmm.
strngs69 2 weeks ago
@strngs69 Of course everyone is jealous of Gina Colao Decker. She is brilliant. I think with her high notes, she should try some coloratura arias. Maybe Queen of the Night's aria, if she does it, she may even achieve Florence Foster Jenkins' level of greatness. In her time Florence Foster Jenkins sold out Carnegie Hall, and we are still listening to her so many years after her death. Plays are made about her. Gina Colao Decker may well try to follow her path.
jewelmarkess 1 week ago
@jewelmarkess Well you are daydreaming now. You can't even tell a dramatic soprano from a coloratura. You seem to be very confused. So where did you get your musical education from?
voizovrsn 1 hour ago
@lustygoat Your ears are hallucinating. And as for voice quality, Gina's is much purer and prettier as is she.
voizovrsn 1 week ago
@lustygoat Your Hearing aid is in needof re-adjusting. Gina Colao Decker's pitch is PERFECT! Her voice blows that of Caballe,s away. Don't let Caballe's fame blind you and dull your hearing. Others in here have attested to it. Gina has a more even and beautiful voice and listen to those "c's" and "o's" again after you have adjusted your hearing aid!
voizovrsn 1 week ago
@voizovrsn Ye gods! I listened to Decker and she's one of the worst singers I've ever heard. Her sense of pitch is awful, she breathing is way off and she audibly gulps for air, she doesn't support the tone, her high notes are screechy. By "o's" did you mean she is singing in the key of "o"? Might be, it certainly isn't in any key I recognize. She's purely an amateur. You need to adjust YOUR hearing aid.
arpeggio1358 1 week ago
@arpeggio1358 Obviously, you have not heard Gina singing this and now are making it all up. Apparently, you have an "axe to grind" because you are so off-track that your comments appear desperate and pathetic. iYou must be awfully jealous!
voizovrsn 1 week ago
@voizovrsn Yes, I have heard Decker. I sent you an e-mail asking if she is a friend of yours and if she has some sort of problem that makes her unable to deal with criticism. I'm trying to be kind, but you're making it very difficult.
arpeggio1358 1 week ago
Comment removed
jewelmarkess 1 week ago
always loved her .......Bravo....
MsBrigitte100 1 month ago
es que es tan simpatica! =P
Erethras 1 month ago
She is flawless, but if its a more beautiful voice you want as well as less schmultz, listen to Gina Colao Decker. The voice of heaven
voizovrsn 1 month ago
@voizovrsn Are you on Gina Colao Decker's payroll? Two plug's on antoher's singer's clip is gratuitous.
OURBOURFLYNN 1 month ago
@OURBOURFLYNN I have been an opera critic for nearly 30 years, am retired and love to use my expertise to carefully delineate what is wrong with even the "great" singers. I know a great voice and demeanor when I see and hear one. So what is your expertise----jealousy?
voizovrsn 1 month ago
@voizovrsn Decker is a medium-grade amateur at best; Caballe is a legend.
lustygoat 1 month ago
@lustygoat You are in need of a hearing aid and bifocals. Gina is a natural soprano with natural allure and talent.
voizovrsn 1 month ago
@lustygoat Gina is new, and just look at the stats. Some people can hear the difference .
voizovrsn 1 week ago
@lustygoat Decker isn't even a medium-grade amateur. She's purely terrible; poor breathing, ugly tone, doesn't support the tone, screechy high notes, off pitch. And I don't believe for a minute that voizovrsn is an opera critic. If he/she thinks Decker is a great singer, there's no way he/she could be an opera critic. This same person comments all over Decker's videos, alng with one or two others. I think they're all Decker's family and friends.
arpeggio1358 1 week ago
the female pavarotti
livefreeinuk1 1 month ago
@livefreeinuk1 Yes, and Gina has a purer voice.
voizovrsn 1 month ago
bravizimo ea le pusies mushizimo empeno
richiman2150 1 month ago
Truly untouchable ..Brava!!
TheXjcar1 1 month ago
wow....speechless
beyzasmum 1 month ago
Montserat, con todo mi cariño, gracias por deleitarnos. La menos hipocrita y mas genuina de las interpretaciones. Petje af. X. Carlos.
vafancULLO11 1 month ago
i like this version
shadowromeo22 1 month ago
force, dignity, and execution - and she makes it look easy. bravissima1
gunsandpocky 1 month ago
Grande maestra...!
mezzolia 1 month ago
I had the good luck of experiencing her at Carnegie Hall and I must say she was put on my "favorites" list. She is nearly flawless. But for tonal quality, I have discovered an unknown who's voice emmanates from Heaven. Gina Colao Decker.
voizovrsn 1 month ago
Dios mio!!!!!! Que bela cantante,Sou brasileiro e nunca vi una cantante com una voz tao bela!!!!!
MisteHiago 1 month ago
cudo
xfajny1992th1 1 month ago
Tomamos las maneras de la callas, y los filados bellisimos de la caballe, y tenemos un perfecto babbino caro.!!!!
maragato23 2 months ago
Bue..... como que las medidas se le salieron de ritmo pero... es " la Caballe", gran voz, lindos matices, bello fiato... pero un poco deforme el aria....
maragato23 2 months ago
bellavoce....
bellavocce10 2 months ago
У Нетребко и голос звучит моложе.
jatwaya 2 months ago
brava, brava! bravissimo!
xxUrFaceLOLxx 2 months ago
Comment removed
dizzlander 2 months ago
that was an epic opening effect!!
TheSquelzy 2 months ago
Vakkert. Elsker deg....
halgje 3 months ago
ma che bello!....
jiriba 3 months ago
my very favorite Diva....Superb....absolutely ...wonderful......Montserrat Caballe
MsBrigitte100 3 months ago
Perfection...flawless breath control!
anubis1974 3 months ago
superbe.
TheDaisycler 3 months ago
Magical ............ just magical
benshiva 4 months ago
Perchè negli acuti non pronuncia le parole? Vedi a 2:00 (pietà) a 1:11 (andrei sul ponte) ecc..
80Mrmirko 4 months ago
@80Mrmirko E uno dei diffati di Caballé purtroppo!!! ma la sua voce rimane incomparabile
liguten 3 months ago
la mas grande
juanmamurillo1 6 months ago
Lovely, dear Montse! And kudos to the conductor and orchestra.
patjan92 1 year ago 10
Indeed she was in bella voce.. What a
lucky audience. Brava, Montse, brava!
Jeanne90275 1 year ago 10
She was in bella voce. Brava!
InBoccaChiusa 1 year ago 2