Added: 3 years ago
From: hdrevolution123
Views: 29,973
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (196)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • make a new one with all voices

  • Ryan way better without hesitation. Jason made Sonic sound like a clown. Which makes sense because it was during these times Sonic games were horrible.

  • i like both but if i had to choose 1 i would choose jason

  • JASON IS MUCH BETTER. I still can't believe they have that crappy new voice. jason forever!

  • 0:00 - 0:03 

  • it took me forever to notice Super Sonic's mouth was moving :P

  • i like ryans voice

  • jason was good as well as ryan.

  • Ryan was beast for the SA series and Jason (with the exception of Sonic X) was awesome for all the sonic games he was in after

    but can we all agree that sonic's new voice from Sonic Colors sucks balls? I know sonic is a child appealing character, but he sounds like a douche now with his new voice by Roger Creig Smith, if they cant go back to Ryan at least re-hire Jason, before this goes too far

  • jason is way better than ryan.Of course jason is the real sonic

  • jason should stick to shadow

  • @hdrevolution123 Whatgame is 1:07 from

  • To be honest, I prefer Jason..:) he makes sonic sound his age and it matches him...:D I think jason did an excellent job..:D

  • I actually like Jason's voice more.

    Both are good.

  • @CaloyPinoy He sounded too gentle when he started voicing Sonic in 2005-2008.

  • @CaloyPinoy Me too.

  • Jaleel White is Best

  • i guess the only thing about jason i dont like is the obvious phrases

  • I prefer Ryan.

  • Honestly,I like them both,But if Ryan changed the "attitude" alittle more,and had lines more along the lines of Jason. For instance,

    "Youll pay!,The here and now that youve stolen? Its time to take it back!!"

    Sounding like "Its time for me to finish this Shadow"?! Full of win^

  • Ryan was iconic, he was the first voice actor for sonic.

  • they sound very similar, but ryan is best

  • I personally prefer Griffith, but they're both Sonic Angels compared to Sonic's newest voice. Search up Sonic Colors Cutscene and see for yourself. But, nothing stops me from the Sonic games, they give me a special feeling when I play them, just like the Legend Of Zelda does. But, that's just me.

  • @EverythingAwesome12 You Don't Like The New Sonic Voice Either?

  • To be completely honest. I like both of them but Ryan Drummond is just a little more emotive and sounds a bit more like how I'd imagine Sonic to sound. Sonic's voice actor was actually one of the ones I cared about the least when they changed the voice actors. Again I would perfer all the old ones back but that wont stop me playing the games.

  • to be honest i like both.

    like if u agree with me

  • In my opinion Ryan is mu- uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu-­ch better than Jason

  • and now there is another voice actor that will voice sonic

  • On most short lines from Jason he doesnt sound that bad and sound alot like Ryan but on the longer lines is where the difference is made. It sounds like he over does it.

  • RYAN DRUMMOND FOREVER!!!!JASON GRIFFITH SUCKS!THAT'S ALL!!!

  • Jason sounds almost alike with ryan....what makes him great! (equally)

  • Jason Griffith Is Better

  • :O sonic's mouth is scaring me...

  • i like drummond better

  • I think jason grifith puts more emotion into it and sounds less robotic

  • Creepy mouth in the video

  • While Jason has improved since becoming the new voice actor for Sonic, Ryan will always be the best (and the official) in my opinion.

  • J . Griff has improved a lot lately. Still I would choose Ryan over him though.

  • jason for the win and that lip and sonics mouth scares me

  • I was so pissed when I played Shadow the Hedgehog and all of the voices were different. They hired all of the actors from the half-assed anime. They exact same thing happened with Pokemon. The companies don't care about fans, they just want money.

  • this video has a point, but if you look at unleashed and black knight, griffith has clearly improved very much

  • I see you stole these clips from another video. gh

  • One is deeper.

  • ryan for the win. The change in voice just screwed everything up. Knuckle's voice kicks ass. No matter what game occurs, knuckles wins, Tails only kicked ass in SA:2B, but sonic... Man, nothing beats Ryan.

  • @Sirus7009 jason beats ryan

  • look at the rest of the comments dude, as well as all of the online forums. according to almost all of the fans, ryan kicks ass. so you might want to get used to people like me saying ryan for the win.

  • @Dejapoo777 nope ryan is better

  • Germall white was better

  • the mouth on that pic creeps me out....kinda reminds me of chucky

  • no reason is YUJI NAKA wasn't on Final games but take a closer look...Ryan drummond wasn't there too !

  • the mouth you put on that pic creeps me out

  • jason he fits in with the new sonic

  • RYAN OWNZ ALL !!!

  • if ryan ownz then y isnt he

    voice acting sonic now?

    okay then...

  • Meh. I say leave Griffith. He feats better in the new games....

  • lol the first 1 sounds like silver

  • jason is good for next gen type sonic games

  • As always Ryan Drummond is the better voice. He should be in Project NeedleMouse!!

  • In my Opinion I like Ryan better

    plz dont thumb down its an opinion

  • Personally, I think Jason Griffith is better. His Sonic voice suits the character better, and he's a better actor, too.

  • jason FTW

  • Jason wins.

  • I think Jason does a better job. In the early Sonic X episodes I didn't like his voice, but it got better. I think his Sonic voice suits Sonic better too, but I also like Ryan. And guys calm down it's just voice acting!

  • I still miss Ryan, but Jason's voice acting is getting to the point that my ears don't bleed when I hear it.

  • Yeah, that point would be when he replaced Ryan.

  • thats the BEST ONE EVER THX I NEEDED SOME VOICES WITHOUT MUSIC

  • If you compare Sonic X episode 1 to Sonic adventure 2, Ryan owns.

    If you compare Sonic and the black knight to "Alright! This is happenin'!", Jason owns.

    Jason's getting better.

  • Personally, I worry about the FUCKING GAME HES IN rather than the bastard behind his voice.

    But hey, thats just me.

  • Eh I like whoever sounds like I dunno...a hedgehog xD

  • to be honest i like Jason Griffith better

  • Drummond and Griffith sounds the same as sonic

  • well a little bit

  • heroes advanced 3 good sonic 06 good me cant decide

  • Yahoo~ XD

  • jason is always improving and hes not that bad

  • i like ryan better than jason... BUT the real problem is tha MAN who took Rouge's voice!!!

  • Yeah, I have nothing aganist the voice actors change. Because I'm so bad at noticing differences, I didn't know notice much of a difference between Griffith and Drummond expect for Griffith sounds more stuffy.

    But when they change Rouge's voice on Sonic Rivals 2, I was like.. a little upset. xD

  • jason griffith ftw

  • sorry but isent it wtf

  • Jason gets better and better in every game.

  • My main issue with Griffith is that they used him for Shadow as well.

    :C I hate it when they do that in general. Granted it's more convenient or whatever.

  • dont forget jet

  • That's right. Lol. I Don't really consider him a memorable character though.

  • Ryan Drummond is better than Jason Griffith They should fire his ass already and bring back the true voice overs for the games. The Sonic Adventure Cast Rocks

  • Ryan Drummond is the real winner

  • sonic japanese voice win all

  • Jason Griffith and Ryan Drummond are both good in their own right. Both work hard and bring their own styles. Ryan's seems to be more younger, not caring, and (at times) more serious, while Jason brings a more mature and experienced Sonic. But thats how I see it, and think they are both wonderful.

  • @yungerrapper They're both my favourite :)

  • I somewhat expected this to be different video from all the other videos, but the dialougue in this video was stolen fron "Clash of the Hedgehogs: Ryan vs. Jason" by RyanVSJason. The only difference here is that speaking mouth on Sonic.

  • They should mix both Ryan & Jason's voices together.

  • Lol! Eliiiiiiise! XD

    Both are good... It's hard to say who is better because Jason is getting better and better!

  • Comment removed

  • My personal favritoe will always br Ryan Drummond. I just felt like he really fit the voice of sonic.

    Dun kill me!!

  • You suck! Drummond was gay! Jason was the best from the start. When they changed VAs I was like " Finally, they fired those retarded Fags!"

  • @TheZyclonestick who did unleashed he was pretty good the new one gives sonic an adult form i miss his old voice why did they change him WHY!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • im a sonic fan boy...and i stil think that Jason Griffith is better voice actor, prolly cuz he has more experience...?

    pleaze dont kill me!

  • both are good voices

  • Thank God! Someone finally agrees with me!

  • Even though I'm a younger Sonic fan, I still like Ryan Drummond better. Jason Griffith just seems a little more childish voice to me. I have very few Sonic games with Ryan but I still think he was more meant to be Sonic. Don't agree? That's your problem.

  • different voice comparison vids keep making me have different opinions!!!

    In my opinion from THIS vid alone, I think Jason Griffith sounds better

    Please don't hurt me ;~;

    XD, usually, I thought Ryan Drummond sounds better from the other vids

  • Both are good. *gets thumbed down by 50 people*

  • both are mediocre.

  • I like ryan more, but this makes me realize that the english scripts up to heroes were awful.

  • Actually the Script in Sonic Unleashed was WAY Worse than this. The dialouge was A Buncha Shit

  • i don't really remember ryan as sonic so naturally i prefere jason

    no offense to ryan fans btw

  • I think, they both do a good job...

  • same here. i definitely think they both do a good job playing Sonic's voice. too many ppl make such a big deal out of it really.

  • than dont watch these videos. They dont involve you they have nothing to do with you and noone is saying anything against you. You dont like that people want the voices changed than dont get involved by watching these videos. the people who you should be talking some sense into are the idiots that bitch about the reviews in these Sonic Games. Go bitch to them

  • i laughed at wut u said. i just wanted to see a good voice comparison. that is why i watched the video. apparently, there was too much background noise for me to really even enjoy the video. btw, i wasnt even bitching about anything. i was just stating my opinion and where in anything that i said sounds like im bitching about something anyway? i wasnt even talking to someone in particular so i wasnt talking sense into anyone. if u thought i was bitching, u thought wrong. calm down.

  • No but your just one of those people who drags on in his snetences saying that gameplay this or how good a game is THAT. Noone want to hear it. The voice acting does matter because it is fanservice and fanservice is supposed to coexist with Gameplay. People like Galleyies, or seeing Sonic with Chillidogs in the new games. Its not just aboout running and jumping. People want to see cool cutscenes and GOOD VAs. Im saying that 4kids as a group arent that good but seperately i have my favorites.

  • thats better. wut r u talking about gameplay this or good game that? i dont even know u.

    i really dont think the voice acting is bad, with a few exceptions though. i still dont see how having Ryan back would change anything. writers make up lines for all actors.

    i thought the cutscenes in Unleashed were awesome, especially the intro. i see wut ur saying as just an opinion like mine. i dont even care if Ryan comes back or if Jason stays, i like both of their Sonic voices.

  • Ryan Drummond sounds alot cooler. He doesn't sound as weird as the new one, the new one just does not fit Sonic. Also Jason Griffith does atleast a good job as Shadow. [My opinion :D].

  • I like Ryan better but Jasons improved so much. I still pick ryan. I still care for the voices but What do you think of it. Are there many fans that still care for Ryan Drummond or has that died out. I hope it hasnt.

  • I do think Jason is getting better each game that comes out. Either that or I'm finally getting used to it. Either way Jason will never sound as good as Ryan.

  • they sound almost same don't ask me why

  • why the hell do people mark other peoples opinion about if they like jason better so what you are all fags

  • i like the new one. and u have to think sonic is older now 17

  • I'll tell you something that unrealistic about ages. After Sonic Adventure 2 there was a 50 year gap between it and Sonic heroes when Sonic was described as 15 years old but 50 years before that, he was living and so was Shadow. The ages are all jumbled in the Sonic series. Don't recognise them, just play the game

  • @hdrevolution123 either you dont pay attention or you just didint realise but its not a 50 year gap between adventure 2 and heroes its like 1 year shadow was created 50 years before adventure 2 battle so really shadow is the original worlds fastest hedgehog although sonic was created by sega first.

  • @Diddstarpure Oh damn you're right. I didn't pay attention :P.

    Shadow lived when Gerald Robotnik was alive, i.e. 50 years before SA2. That makes good sense. Thanks.

  • @hdrevolution123 No problem friend I am a nerd with bloody sonic. :)

  • @Diddstarpure So am I. I just didn't pay good attention as a child playing this game, and I just forgot to "think again"- so to speak.

  • @Diddstarpure Thats true, but Shadow was created using the design of the paintings of Super Sonic fighting Robotnik in the Hidden Palace Zone, So you could say that Shadow was made from, story line wise, from Sonic prophecy. If that makes any sense, because this was mentioned.

  • @DreamKing2 true and well observed

  • @DreamKing2 If i remember that is explained in Sonic Battle isint it? or SA2?

  • Actually no according to the current info on Sonic Websites hes still 15 or 16. u have to read carefully. Sonic is still more Ryan Drummond to me and should be to plenty of people. Hes still young. In Sonic Adventure he sounded way older than Griffith and pulled it off. I wonder what Ryans adventure voice wouldve been like in Sonic Unleashed. It wouldve made the game rock a whole lot more. Sonic is still 15 if u check the sites carefully

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • that picture is so weird.... its like the teeth are moving O_O

  • Jason Griffith is very good, but I like Ryan Drummond better.

    Jason sounds like he's forcing Sonic's voice, while Ryan's voice just flows great with the portrayed image of Sonic

  • is that so? strange, i think the total opposite :P don't get me wrong I'm not dissing Ryan. I just think Jason's better and more natural sounding :P

  • Sonic's new voice actor fits the bill, but I think the previus one was better... or maybe he just had the better lines.

  • I think Jason is alright as Sonic, but Ryan sounds more natural.

    What Jason is REALLY bad at is Shadow. Shadow's first voice was 1 million times better.

  • U LAV IT AT 1:39 - 1:45

  • TOO BAD IT'S ALL OVER... FOR YOU!!!

  • i dont think it really matter honestly lol

  • In fact I agree with you. All these idiotic internet geeks complaining over something so stupid makes them look like losers. It is the fault of the writers for giving bad lines to anyone of these highly capable voice actors. They are just mere voice actors and are controlled by the writer. Stupid Japanese internet geeks

  • the voice acting really doesnt matter, IMO, i like both of them, just some things sonic says are corny, retarded, or just plain stupid. but still, gameplay is what sonic is about...

  • Once again I cannot disagree with you. Some lines written by writers are just ridiculous but otherwise it's the AWESOME super speed gameplay and INCREDIBLE music of ALL sonic games that really matters about making Sonic the coolest and fastest thing alive

  • EXACTLY. like, lets show him the real power of Team work! wtf?

  • The stupid writers seem to think that Sonic games are played by ONLY 3-8 year olds yet it's a bloody 12+ game!

  • yeah, some of these sonic games are waaaay to hard for 3-8 year olds. and the acting doesnt have to be sonic baby-ish lol

  • And unnecessary since legally it is only available for ages 12 and over. The writers think that all of a sudden 3 year olds can play this?

  • yeah, sonic doesnt have to cus or anything, but still some of this is way to hard for little kids to play.

  • I like them both too. I think the real problem is the script, not as exciting gameplay and all the whiny fanboys.

  • Exactly.

  • I've got my OWN Ryan and Jason to say whatever lines I want to hear the Sonic's say. XD I can even get Ryan and Jason to talk to each other =p XD

  • You do? How and what specifically do you mean by your OWN Ryan and Jason?

  • now THAT's hard to explain. I'd have to send you a clip or something. XD All I can say is if I made a video of just a pic of Sonic and a bunch of voice oers I could have the Ryan voice say something from Sonic and the Sercret Rings and the Jason say something about Metal Sonic or Chaos from Sonic Adventure. XD

  • Jasons doing good each game but Im glad SEGA of Japan gices a care to see what the fans think of Ryan. HE wants to come back and to think theres an email address in my profile that if plently people say they want Drummond than SEGA will look at that. I gotta admit. Jasons getting good and Ryan wants back in. This is a tough choice. I choose Ryan though

  • hmm...that's a lot of emails you're gonna have to collect cuz there's the Ryan fan/Griffith haters online,then there's the online gaming community, and then the rea life community, and then average public ppl who may or may not care as much XD You'll need like over 42 million ppl o.o

  • Seriously isnt this a big challenge but I wont whine. Ill take it anyway. Theres no price to lose. SEGA operators have told me that people still express interest. Boy this is gonna be a tough one.

  • well sorry I can't join. I always liked Ryan's better, but he's not THAT much better so it's not worth the time to me. ^^; I mean there's a lot of ppl that express interest...but so far that's only like 13% of the population, other's are like me. Like Ryan better but don't mind Jason or also like Jason, some like Jason better, and then publicly ppl dislike both. XP I see a bigger chance of a 3rd Sonic voice coming than Ryan returning but it's possible. o0 Good luck. XP

  • who knows. If this issue gets attention on a bigger scale than things might change again to someone else or change back. 13% is less than determined for sure. Ive heard 13% from u the whole tiem. I have seen credible sources and SEGA America. Nintendo I called says that more dan 30000 fans still express interest in get ryan back Thanks for your best wishes, and if this issue gets higher attention feel free 2 mak 4 ur input anytime. Thanks for the major points of my challenge.

  • yes, 13%, not 13 ppl. XP 13% means that amount of portion compared tothe total is all. XP 30000 ppl out of 2590000 ppl is a small protion, of course those arent real numbers just a good example, there's a LOT of ppl on the globe. XD And it's just such a small request and it's been done so many times. IF they change it to a new guy or back to Ryan it's fine by me as long as he doesnt sound like Pikachu, but I'm not gonna WORRY about it. cant imagine myself doing so unless it were out of boredome

  • lol I like both vocies but if I WERE to criticize I could say that compared to Ryan, Jason sounds a bit deep and dopey like a nerd hero and the compared to Jason, Ryan sounds like a dweeb hero like these geeks who go to conventions and obsess over stuff like that cuz he sounds silly XD

  • wow 0:23 to 0:28 sounded like the same person. And from this video it seems like they're both passable. I mean, Ryan's is higher and a bit exxaggerated and corny, then Jason's is deeper and a bit more dopey, but atthe same time they both sound pretty good just a slight bit different,but not TOO much. ^^

  • Neither can I here

  • jason plays a great sonic and shadow voice.

  • In my opinion I say he's just a great shadow voice

  • I think he's good at both becuase he doesn't sound exactly like Ryan or exactly like David (and why should he? He's NOT Ryan or David) but he sounds close to not one of them but both of them. o.o that's pretty good. His Shadow's more whisperish and a different attitude, but he COULD sound like David if it was directed to be, but obviously they're SUPPOSE to sound the way they currently do or else they wouldn't sound that way now XD

  • I can't disagree with you

  • My family cannot tell the difference. Hell, most of them are used to Sonic Heroes and Sonic Adventure 2. Yet when they hear "woah!" From a new Sonic game, they are like... "are you playing Sonic?" From the voice alone. Most people cannot tell the difference.

    The only time a difference was noted was when Sonic said "yeah, Smash em up!"

  • I think they sound almost exactly the same.

  • lol I highly doubt it otherwise people wouldn't be arguing about these voices!

  • They sound exactly the same. Anyone outside the internet postings would say the same thing.

    I do not count the internet people to count as the majority in anyway. Most internet people are obsessed with the Japanese, and complain about how their anime shows are being taken away off networks. Guess what? Statistics show that the shows "they" watch, are incredibly unpopular, and have poor ratings, regardless of how much people post about it.

    Adult Swim makes fun of it. u internet people suck

  • Yeah screw the Japanese internet community

  • On the subject of voicing for Sonic. I do like Ryan better, but I've gained a new respect for Jason. He did really good in Sonic Unleashed. You guys should listen to his acting in that game!

  • The most significant improvement in any failing voice actor ever occurring. I recognized the great change in his voice acting in Sonic Unleashed. I think it is due to the mass criticism he received for his voice acting in Sonic X and the ps3/xbox 360 game

  • No, I do not think he "changed" due to mass criticism. Have you read ANY reviews for Sonic Adventure games? The voice acting is thrashed. IGN, Gamespot, 1up, Gaming age. They say Sonic's voice acting was the worst in any game. Did that guy change? No.

    You think the guy cares what an internet group thinks? Professional reviewers hate the voices less than they ever did since the change. Yet, my friends and family cannot tell the difference.

    DBZ voices get bashed too, you know!