He might've had a cold or something. He does sound kinda nasally and stuffed up. But yeah, you're completely right. When I saw them in late '07 he sounded great so idk.
They most def don't suck i saw them in Nebraska and the opened for Rise Against and to tell you the truth Silverstein and comeback kid had the crowd pumped!
no your both wrong. he normally sings that deep, but when they record its a whole different setting. he goes into a little room, and sings to a microphone. no cupping allowed.
Shane's singing has improved ton since this! People who base Silverstein and how well they perform live in THIS video FAIL. Because if you watch any recent performance, they're fricken amazing.
This is one of my favorite songs from Silverstein, these guys are awesome!, there one of a kind, they have so many good songs like Discovering the waterwaterfront, November, Call It Karma. Smile in your sleep, First Wrapped in blood, when broken is eaily fixed, already dead and acouple more!.....one of the best bands in the WORLD!!!!
I like this song, but I can't stand at emo concerts how people just sit there, doing the rock hand symbol, emo should never have that, I respect emo, but I don't give a fuck, you don't do that hand sign, they aren't rock. ACDC, and people like them deserve that.
I hate when people only judge silverstein by the way the singer sings you have to understand what he is saying and what he means! Don't be so freaking close minded.
Wtf? How is he bad at screaming? He can't sing to well, but hes actully quite good at screaming. Compared to most bands that i've seen live of this genre of music hes quite talented. Alot of other bands who have screamers for this genre can't yell for shit and if so they cant do it for long.
bs man this dude fucking blows at screaming maybe he got better but here this dude fucking blows i have seen some great fucking screamers and he for sure ant one
now if you stared reading this dont stop its really scarey!ok send this to five other videos in 143 minutes.When you are done press F6 and your crushes name will apear on the screen in big letters this is weird because it does work.If you break this chance you wont have a crush in the next five years....
It's an older video, you can tell. In all the older stuff Shane's hair is short, Billy has no beard, Josh kinda has short hair and Neil has really short hair. Now days Shane and Neil both have long hair and Josh and Billy sport the beard.
awesome performance
SlipknotInside9 1 year ago
i could never sing when i have colds..... lucky for him he can do it ! WOHHO best band EVER !!
kilmore146 1 year ago
He may have a cold or something affecting his singing, but that scream is killer; far more amped up than usual.
tfalcone86 1 year ago
coooool
MrAtreyurulez 1 year ago
this is not the best presentation of silverstein, back on 09 when they come to chile, was so much better LIVE.
anyway .... silversteins till beeing the most great band on my life (:
xfakemousx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
he cant sing live :\
123musicdude456 2 years ago
the backup vox is kinda out of tune..! wat a shame!!
necrophagists 2 years ago 4
i dedicate this song to my ex-girlfriend :,[
maplelavigne 2 years ago
i saw them before and they were flawless
shane is definitly under the weather here
scarykids619 2 years ago 2
i love their cover of "Apologize" for Punk Goes Pop 2!!
ralphy1211 2 years ago
man bill sucks so bad
bleedingangel9 2 years ago
jajaja
aparte de lo desafinado que esta cantando en este video, creo que sigue teniendo esos gritos geniales ;)
el guitarrista se lleva el premio por mas desafinado en la parte final xD
SebazeroX 3 years ago
even if he has a cold his scream still sounds awesome but yeah his voice is a little off
LeeTronX 3 years ago
no!!! he is totally fine, his voice is great!!! perhaps he could have done it better..BACK EVERYTHING THAT I DID!!!! beautiful
renachon 3 years ago
what the fuck is with his voice? has he got a cold?
MrCharming123 3 years ago
thats the old shane...
HardcorePunkmusic29 2 years ago 3
nice song. Would somebody care to explain the lyric?
misschica51 3 years ago
LOL
Avertious 3 years ago
i saw them in 2006 and his voice was just like on the album ( clean voice and scream ) so i dont know what the fuck is wrong now
anyways, awsome vid man thanks
sirundying 3 years ago
He might've had a cold or something. He does sound kinda nasally and stuffed up. But yeah, you're completely right. When I saw them in late '07 he sounded great so idk.
InRegards2Myself777 2 years ago 7
wow bills "wait for you" is so out of key
lol
why is shane Fucking GOD!?
vmac93 3 years ago 2
aahahah
way out of key
siduk16 3 years ago
this is super duper old but still veryyyyy gooddddd best band ever .. 2 bad he doesnt scream like that anymore
omgitsbrandonwtfhaha 3 years ago
<3!!
ashesofher 3 years ago
"screams" "how do i explain everything!"
ugh i want to have sex with his scream.
donellexrachelle 3 years ago 2
check out my BROWN EYED DECEPTION VIDEO
this band needs to be herd of!
siduk16 3 years ago
awesome ,as always
LINKchris87 3 years ago 3
the screams are good even at live!!!
jemierry23 3 years ago 3
is shane sick here?
he not singing like he normaly does
skaterman339 3 years ago
he might be cuz his voice sounds thicker than normal but i'm in a band and we sound a lot different playing live than our recording
ashesofher 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
check out my video of this song.
rate and comment please
SourRedSox20 3 years ago
good god i need to see this band again
xXdieXromanticXx 3 years ago
wtf his scream was sooooooo good here omg
omgitsbrandonwtfhaha 3 years ago
You can't really hear how it comes out since it's recorded directry from the mic
xEmorginal 3 years ago
sounds horrible
TheMitty5 3 years ago
their live is ok!
da7lee 3 years ago
damn.. Shane scream very well in this one..
i wish i was there.. =(
shahrel7x 3 years ago
I played Amped 2 just hear another great Silverstein song!!! These guy just JAM!!!
Rebel4Liberty 3 years ago
Silverstein rocks myself!
litosxrs 3 years ago
really clear vid :o
SERGIOCHAOTIC 3 years ago
watta clear vid.. nice2222x!!! lub silverstein!!! so much... -kenDirtz
mjeez1 3 years ago
silverstein rocks..
awesome! freakin' good
litosxrs 3 years ago
cool very hight!!!
xxvaibanezxx 4 years ago
hes straight edge
Trevortothet 4 years ago
no hes not, Paul the drummer is and I believe one of the guitarists is but Shane drinks.
shawn147 4 years ago
he seems drunk to me
chicksand3 4 years ago
They most def don't suck i saw them in Nebraska and the opened for Rise Against and to tell you the truth Silverstein and comeback kid had the crowd pumped!
Bufriend11 4 years ago
they don't suck live. They're actually pretty good. the first time I heard them was when I first saw them like 3 or so years ago.
smiley88x3 4 years ago
i love all songs from Silverstein
kohoutiveminko 4 years ago
*________________________________*
mirumo93 4 years ago
they will tear your sOUL APART
LETLOVETURNUSGREY 4 years ago
*.*
afonsu 4 years ago
...
mmjjake 4 years ago
dude... my fav song by them... love it!!
BadBoyLatip 4 years ago
hes voice is really deep but theyre still really good live
skate17sing19 4 years ago 2
his voice is definetly one octave lower than it is on his cd's. . .anw silverstein 4 eveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeer!!!!
1llu510n15t 4 years ago
I'm sure Shane sings an octave lower live than he does on the records.
ScarsAndStripes 4 years ago
no actually he sings it the same normally. this is just a long time ago.
Guitarist4Life1210 4 years ago
no your both wrong. he normally sings that deep, but when they record its a whole different setting. he goes into a little room, and sings to a microphone. no cupping allowed.
thestartingline21 4 years ago
yeah his voice is kinda shitty here
but ive seen them live about 6 times and they do not suck live at all
this is just when they first started out so they aint like perfect
donellexrachelle 4 years ago 2
yeah his voice is kinda shitty here
but ive seen them live about 6 times and they do not suck live at all
this is just when they first started out so they aint like perfect
donellexrachelle 4 years ago
nice...song.......
PilipinazZzz 4 years ago
shane cant sing worth shit live.....hmmmm
QuiNnm503 4 years ago
this was ages ago. they rock live now. go do some research.
Guitarist4Life1210 4 years ago
no they dont. go do some MORE research.
thestartingline21 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah he sux live-.-
danne1337 4 years ago
Shane's singing has improved ton since this! People who base Silverstein and how well they perform live in THIS video FAIL. Because if you watch any recent performance, they're fricken amazing.
Guitarist4Life1210 4 years ago
deffinatley not one of there best shows
BrielleThoeni 4 years ago
sfx- red light pledge
wugi07 4 years ago
oops.wrong. its "when sorrow seems forever- red light pledge"
wugi07 4 years ago
watch this cover.its awesome... search for sfx- red light pledge(cover)
wugi07 4 years ago
i saw them live recently and they were fucking amazing. they sounded a lot better then this
Libertaay 4 years ago
fucking awesome.!!!
wugi07 4 years ago
ditto to that there awesome!!!!
LadyLiife72 4 years ago
i love this band but when they play its not as clean.
crippledsquirel2 4 years ago
This is one of my favorite songs from Silverstein, these guys are awesome!, there one of a kind, they have so many good songs like Discovering the waterwaterfront, November, Call It Karma. Smile in your sleep, First Wrapped in blood, when broken is eaily fixed, already dead and acouple more!.....one of the best bands in the WORLD!!!!
15blank15 4 years ago
f*ck yoou!!! haterzz lolz
sherwinkole 4 years ago 2
How can you say they suck live? This video is great!
DRINKTHEPOISONFFS 4 years ago 3
Well,they re cool when u hear their CD,or seeing Niar's previus Videos(Coz they are famus coz Niar i can say) but when u hear em live,they suck,realy
AdanosTheMage 4 years ago
All Groups suck Live ,:p
look at My chemical romance, Billy talent , ..
Also the screaming screws up his voice live.
JenteVh 4 years ago
how come there is no mush pits
gahrockets9 4 years ago
I like this song, but I can't stand at emo concerts how people just sit there, doing the rock hand symbol, emo should never have that, I respect emo, but I don't give a fuck, you don't do that hand sign, they aren't rock. ACDC, and people like them deserve that.
Yoso11 4 years ago
this show was amazing!!! i almost died but it was wayyy worth it!!
leslielame 4 years ago
his scream is geniuine
graeheartdos 4 years ago
he sounds drunk off his ass
liljohn817x 4 years ago
hmm i wonder how he gets that scream without screwing up his voice??
jonnyissecy 4 years ago
I hate when people only judge silverstein by the way the singer sings you have to understand what he is saying and what he means! Don't be so freaking close minded.
ilovemyppj 4 years ago
Possibly my favorite songs. The older version is better than the one off of When Broken Is Easily Fixed.
I love Silverstein and I can't wait to see them again!
Promise me you will stay here until the red light will change . . . .
ABrokenCitySky 4 years ago
He's so awesome at screaming =O that was ok..singing wasnt fantastic but it didnt suck.
Guitarist4Life1210 4 years ago
ive been to 10+ concerts with them
2 of them like blew my mind they were so good...a coupel were ok and about 50% of em blew balls bad liek this 1
darktripod222 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You must come and see this YOUTUBE for adults only no restrictions come and see free videos PORNOVUE COM
crazymamy18 4 years ago
wow i reli like this song but not live singer is so fucking bad at screaming
nothate 4 years ago
Wtf? How is he bad at screaming? He can't sing to well, but hes actully quite good at screaming. Compared to most bands that i've seen live of this genre of music hes quite talented. Alot of other bands who have screamers for this genre can't yell for shit and if so they cant do it for long.
cone34 4 years ago
bs man this dude fucking blows at screaming maybe he got better but here this dude fucking blows i have seen some great fucking screamers and he for sure ant one
nothate 4 years ago
silverstein doesnt suck live there vocalist does:)and there all assholes in real life kinda like that ignorant motherfucker silverstein 309
WTFMANIMPISSED 4 years ago
I Love this song so much
bloodlessdude 4 years ago
hey hey we speak in english her in america... not that crap
silverstein309 4 years ago
pörtlek özge gözü büyük seni salak gözü büyük açıköğretim grubu
mavisimsekhasan 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THIS ACTUALLY WORKS!!!
1)say the name of the guy or girl u wanna b with 4 the rest of ur life 2 times
2)say ur best friends name 5 times 2 urself
3)then post this to 5 videos and then press F8 and u'll see ur crushes name on the screen
from:makeavelimisses
squeekers17 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THIS ACTUALLY WORKS!!!
1)say the name of the guy or girl u wanna b with 4 the rest of ur life 2 times
2)say ur best friends name 5 times 2 urself
3)then post this to 5 videos and then press F8 and u'll see ur crushes name on the screen
from:makeavelimisses
squeekers17 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THIS ACTUALLY WORKS!!!
1)say the name of the guy or girl u wanna b with 4 the rest of ur life 2 times
2)say ur best friends name 5 times 2 urself
3)then post this to 5 videos and then press F8 and u'll see ur crushes name on the screen
from:makeavelimisses
squeekers17 4 years ago
This is silverstein's best song, no doubt. i love it. "Promise Me You Will Be Here, Untill The Red Light Will Change."
HelsinkiVempires 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
now if you stared reading this dont stop its really scarey!ok send this to five other videos in 143 minutes.When you are done press F6 and your crushes name will apear on the screen in big letters this is weird because it does work.If you break this chance you wont have a crush in the next five years....
LadyLupe 4 years ago
suck on live :(
bravows 4 years ago
you suck live!
ilovemyppj 4 years ago
i didnt mean this to silverstein some stupid kid put they suck live and i was responding to that fag! Silverstein is my favorite band!
ilovemyppj 4 years ago
wish I could take back everything taht I did, LOVE IT!!!!
bloodlessdude 4 years ago
i ate japanies in columbus with Silerstein (Josh,Neil,Shane,Bill and there random friend todd it was a kick ass night) will from aiden was there too
Jerkface55 4 years ago
where was Paul? :O
screamlouder69 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!!.
MrBlankman 4 years ago
love it
bloodlessdude 4 years ago
when broken is easily fixed of 18 candles the early years
Atreyu1980 4 years ago
orgasmic!
bloodyboy91 4 years ago
haha i got pose. taena loser. astig nang silver!
derekgo 4 years ago
i like to listen to this song before i skateboard, my friends say i would never listen to silverstein because i'm black, but i'm emo
sk8boardpeep 4 years ago
ang lufet tlaga ng silverstein astig idol ko sila bangis ng growl idol ko tlaga sila
buboygwapo 4 years ago
its from when broken is easily fixed
nsosvocals 4 years ago
i feel like i died and went to heaven hearing him scream woooooo
torturedheart0815 4 years ago
what cd is this song on? if any one knows please tell me
concertjunkie88 4 years ago
it was first on their When The Shadows Beam EP, but they improved it, and put it on their first full studio album, When Broken Is Easily Fixed.
screamlouder69 4 years ago
When The broken Is Easily Fixed
along with
smashed into peices and Giving Up
albert9307 4 years ago
old but still best.
pri3st14 5 years ago
Hes a pretty good screamer, thats it. The lyrics are wayy emo.
AntonTHPS 5 years ago
Wow they rock.
taandesrosiers 5 years ago
yapp its old its like the one giving up
pri3st14 5 years ago
and theyre playing on ESP's, they dont usaly anymore
killyourstory 5 years ago
Ha, I love it
It's an older video, you can tell. In all the older stuff Shane's hair is short, Billy has no beard, Josh kinda has short hair and Neil has really short hair. Now days Shane and Neil both have long hair and Josh and Billy sport the beard.
Bubbles911 5 years ago
lol sry dude i wasnt paying attention i was thinkin of a differnt video but yah your right
homefrog182 5 years ago
this is a newer video i think because shane's hairstyle and billy has a beard and in the old days he didnt
homefrog182 5 years ago
no way where the hell this vid come from
hmmp...my favorite song
red light pledge^_^
pri3st14 5 years ago
this looks like kinda older video of them
idk Im probablywrong
but I love these guys<3
xXRayTayXx 5 years ago
this song is sick
Psilocbin 5 years ago
pak u
buboygwapo 4 years ago
ahhh.
i love this song.
=]
HopelesslyHopeful 5 years ago
me too i love this song
buboygwapo 4 years ago