There are two British commentary teams, the one commentating on this video; and the one with Christine heading the commentary. I'd have to say that the latter is much better...
I prefer the UK commentators over the Aussies and Americans and because they are positive and polite. I'm not sure if it has to do with culture or not, but I've noticed their opinions are not heavily biased. Christine is classy and she takes the time to explain the different skills, point values and deductions. She offers constructive criticism when necessary. I seek out BBC commentary on YouTube whenever I can. :)
Liz Chetkovich is a VERY sublime commentator, and actually, rather than being biased or vexing, she is TO THE POINT. (Something I personally value in a commentator.)
And the British commentators, believe it or not, can be TOO sanguinous at times; and offer miniscule amounts of criticisms. Or if they offer it, it's about nit-picky things...
Though the BBC coverage is better than the American commentators. Horrible commentators they are... Biased.
I understand what you are saying. :) I can also understand why someone who isn't overly sensitive would prefer the blunt commentary. I hate blunt comments. I am a mom and a caring person by nature, so I empathize with the (mostly teen) athletes when they make a mistake like Christine does. I immediately want to run over and ask "are you okay" instead of simply writing them off as a loser (Liz).
I'd never say a kid is "stocky" (Aussie) or "lanky" (Tesh) on television.
Actually, Liz doesn't say that & isn't that overtly blunt. She wouldn't be that rude & abrupt over something so juvenile as a mistake. Irrospective of being hard, she can also be empathetic... When someone's hard, that doesn't mean they aren't caring. Don't confuse those emotions
Actually, this commentary crew says Shawn Johnson is "stocky" & quote "I didn't not want to like her (Shawn)" & i'm sure they aren't Aussie. :)
Okay, my mistake. Liz is sooo freaking awesome! Aussie commentary is the BEST! They were SO kind to the Amer gymnasts during the 2005 worlds. I am ONLY going to watch Aussie coverage from now on. Thanks so much for changing my mind. I love you to bits. :) :) :) :) lol :) xoxoxox
OMG, you are right! These are the idiots who called Shawn J stocky! Oh well, I only like Christine anyway. I doubt she'd ever say anything like that. Only those men.
Yeah my favorite coverage of any gymnastics is ALWAYS BBC coverage. They give the Americans the props the deserve, but they focus on other teams as well, which I like. They always show WAY more routines and stuff that WCSN or American channels like NBC or ABC never show. Thanks to GYMANGELS for being a true Angel to us Gymnastics fans. We can always count on you!
And enhgland as christine still - the american commentators are no good they dont tell you anything you dont already know christine tells you all about the form the difficulty and all the other stuff an ordinary person wouldnt know sher is great and so is gymangels for uploading the stuff you can only get on sky
yeah, i know, american commentators tend to completely ignore any of the other teams in the competition unless they are a threat to the americans, its so annoying...and i'm american
They are given a limited amount of time. The gymnastics programs don't exactly get great ratings. They use what time they are given as well as they can. Stop ripping the commentators. They are not responsible for half the stuff you all are criticizing them for! Give 'em a break!
CHina returned Cheng Fei and He Ning from 2006, others were injured (Pang Pan Pan) or very close to making it (Zhou Zhourou), who was actually in STuttgart as the 2nd alternate
I just LOVE barbosa on vault , to bad she fell in Beiing! She deserved that olympic gold medal on vault!
Shukaatje 1 year ago
wow this is the best 2/5 twisiting yurchenko i have ever seen! 10 times better than cheng fei's and a million times better than shawn jonhson's!
greysrocks25 1 year ago
that arabian pike front dismount is always so ugly
snofagun1814 1 year ago
Sorry, I meant the GB girl, she has a lot of potential though.
usergio3 1 year ago
She needs to tumble more to the left so she won't go out of bounds and use the floor area to the fullest.
usergio3 1 year ago
the US commentators I like is Bart Connor and Raj Bavsar - they're interesting
her0esfan 2 years ago
I hope the new code of points MURDERS gymnasts who come to a dead hang on bars... Tired of seeing it !
Davylp 2 years ago 12
You suffer when you are small size. What about leg seperation ?
NasDa 2 years ago
So true! The Chinese routines are soooo beautiful but their low to high transitions ruin the whole thing.
bsquared2416 1 year ago 3
I Can Hear Daiane Dos Santos's Music in the back ground at 0:50
Gymbasa 2 years ago
that vault from jade barbosa has to be on of the best 2.5 twisting yurchenkos ive ever seen:)
darkeyes2404 2 years ago
It was AMAZING. Wow.
bsquared2416 1 year ago
BBC best commentators...¡¡¡¡
yaoidanyboy 2 years ago
Yea I agree. I don't like watching the American broadcasts.
AndromedaAiken 2 years ago 3
I agree too! That Al Troutwig guy likes to create drama.
khollaway 2 years ago
eh this isn't bbc commentary.... it's eurosport
bruadair11 2 years ago 3
I really like the Brazilian leotards. I think Barbosa is beautiful, and that vault was fantastic.
xsmile007 2 years ago 4
Such a shame they didn't show Semenova's tkatcheff to giant full.. That skill is truly amazing!
Illja3 2 years ago 5
i loveee all of semonyeva routines she really should have one a olympic metal
csagrl100 3 years ago 14
Was Semonyeva over time on beam ???
gymnastlala 3 years ago
no she wasnt
csagrl100 3 years ago
Lol... That's ok.
There are two British commentary teams, the one commentating on this video; and the one with Christine heading the commentary. I'd have to say that the latter is much better...
Dunntosh 3 years ago
Thank god for BBC coverage! I can't stand Austrailian coverage.
brookenicole222 3 years ago
Why can't you stand the 'Aussie' coverage so much?
Dunntosh 3 years ago
I prefer the UK commentators over the Aussies and Americans and because they are positive and polite. I'm not sure if it has to do with culture or not, but I've noticed their opinions are not heavily biased. Christine is classy and she takes the time to explain the different skills, point values and deductions. She offers constructive criticism when necessary. I seek out BBC commentary on YouTube whenever I can. :)
brookenicole222 3 years ago 3
The Australian coverage is not that bad.
Liz Chetkovich is a VERY sublime commentator, and actually, rather than being biased or vexing, she is TO THE POINT. (Something I personally value in a commentator.)
And the British commentators, believe it or not, can be TOO sanguinous at times; and offer miniscule amounts of criticisms. Or if they offer it, it's about nit-picky things...
Though the BBC coverage is better than the American commentators. Horrible commentators they are... Biased.
Dunntosh 3 years ago
I understand what you are saying. :) I can also understand why someone who isn't overly sensitive would prefer the blunt commentary. I hate blunt comments. I am a mom and a caring person by nature, so I empathize with the (mostly teen) athletes when they make a mistake like Christine does. I immediately want to run over and ask "are you okay" instead of simply writing them off as a loser (Liz).
I'd never say a kid is "stocky" (Aussie) or "lanky" (Tesh) on television.
brookenicole222 3 years ago 2
Actually, Liz doesn't say that & isn't that overtly blunt. She wouldn't be that rude & abrupt over something so juvenile as a mistake. Irrospective of being hard, she can also be empathetic... When someone's hard, that doesn't mean they aren't caring. Don't confuse those emotions
Actually, this commentary crew says Shawn Johnson is "stocky" & quote "I didn't not want to like her (Shawn)" & i'm sure they aren't Aussie. :)
Dunntosh 3 years ago 2
Okay, my mistake. Liz is sooo freaking awesome! Aussie commentary is the BEST! They were SO kind to the Amer gymnasts during the 2005 worlds. I am ONLY going to watch Aussie coverage from now on. Thanks so much for changing my mind. I love you to bits. :) :) :) :) lol :) xoxoxox
brookenicole222 3 years ago
OMG, you are right! These are the idiots who called Shawn J stocky! Oh well, I only like Christine anyway. I doubt she'd ever say anything like that. Only those men.
brookenicole222 3 years ago
that girl on bars is good, the russian. she has a lot of difficulty. but she's not stunning or super graceful or beautiful to watch like nastia
geehollywiz 3 years ago
he ning was so underscored :S
unevercalled 3 years ago
Big kisses for posting this =]
Ta soooo much
hannahbanana369 4 years ago 2
Thank you, thank you, thank you!
narcolepszzz 4 years ago
Yeah my favorite coverage of any gymnastics is ALWAYS BBC coverage. They give the Americans the props the deserve, but they focus on other teams as well, which I like. They always show WAY more routines and stuff that WCSN or American channels like NBC or ABC never show. Thanks to GYMANGELS for being a true Angel to us Gymnastics fans. We can always count on you!
No1ZmeskalFan 4 years ago 7
And enhgland as christine still - the american commentators are no good they dont tell you anything you dont already know christine tells you all about the form the difficulty and all the other stuff an ordinary person wouldnt know sher is great and so is gymangels for uploading the stuff you can only get on sky
NonMatchingUnderwear 4 years ago 2
totally agree !!!!!
oswaldmgr 4 years ago
The best part of this is you it's not American Coverage. American commentators are so biased and I'm an American saying that.
rfillangi 4 years ago 5
yeah, i know, american commentators tend to completely ignore any of the other teams in the competition unless they are a threat to the americans, its so annoying...and i'm american
pme888 4 years ago 7
im an america too, we suck
yiudiumui 3 years ago
I hate that the other teams aren't shown, but it isn't the commentators who make that choice. The coverage is edited by NBC, not the commentators.
tammy842 3 years ago
They are given a limited amount of time. The gymnastics programs don't exactly get great ratings. They use what time they are given as well as they can. Stop ripping the commentators. They are not responsible for half the stuff you all are criticizing them for! Give 'em a break!
tammy842 3 years ago 4
Thank you! My WCSN coverage had no sound.
levlava 4 years ago
I can not thank you enough for posting this =)
tatipheebs 4 years ago
Why did China not holdover ANY gymnasts from 2006?
7Millionaire7 4 years ago
They had Cheng Fei and Pang PanPan was recently injured. I think mostly they wanted to rest there older girls and try out the new ones.
gymnast51389 4 years ago
CHina returned Cheng Fei and He Ning from 2006, others were injured (Pang Pan Pan) or very close to making it (Zhou Zhourou), who was actually in STuttgart as the 2nd alternate
emilayamei 4 years ago
GymAngel, you're my hero! :-)
tide32athlete 4 years ago
OMG! can't thank you enuff!
Lakuilera 4 years ago
thank you masses for this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hollyRGfan 4 years ago