Actually, They changed several lyrics just to make the song for Meet me in St.louis. the writers of the movie made them change them because they thought it was too dark. I agree, no one sings this like judy, But JT is a close second. And the song was written to talk about how the year is tough and how to look forward to christmas, And the happies ruined the best christmas song ever! Hang a shining star doesnt even fit in, U get mad when people sing it that way, Sinatra is an over rated dope!
James actually released this song on his October Road CD in 2002 and had recorded the original lyrics to the song because it's just his style but I saw an interview with him that he chose this version to record as a reflection of the times....with 9/11 so fresh in our hearts and minds, he felt that this more solemn, melancholy version was indicative of our hearts and mindset.
James Taylor can sing anything ...and i love him....all the troubles of this sad world seem a little further away when James Taylor treats us to a ballad or two ....any time of year
This song always takes me back to the late 50s/early 60s, when I was a little kid looking out my grandmother's living room window at all the Christmas lights at the houses on her street. And the snow was over my head (which was a lot closer to the ground back then). It's true, you never know what you've got 'til it's gone.
I have watched this video for a couple of years now, and it still gives me chills. Love the spare arrangement, the sincerity of the vocal, the little personal touches James gives it. He is being himself and that is what matters, even if he had to check the lyrics, or if perhaps a higher key would have suited him more. Nobody has ever touched me by being perfect.
Minstrel here! I made a warm and nostalgic love song on a cold lonesome Christmas day. It's called "Sweet December". Feel free to listen on my channel and get cozy. :) I also made a response to ds awesome video. :)
I dedicate this song to the love of my life who is overseas serving our Country, and spending yet another Christmas away from his family. James sings that "in a year" we all will be together and that's exactly when he will finally be coming home to us, if the fates allow. Until then, my love, we'll just have to muddle through somehow. Merry Christmas baby, I love you.
Great song! TY for posting it for us all to enjoy! I have a new original Christmas song, and I'd be grateful if you came to check it out on my channel's main page at YOUTUBE DOT COM/billmills or click on my name to the left of this message. Please leave a comment and/or rate the video. I sure hope you enjoy my Cristmas song "(We Should All Be Together) Christmas Day"! TY again...
Such a classic song. You can also check my live version of this song in my profile, I hope you'll like it. Comments and ratings are always appreciated.
3 For the customs of the people [are] vain: for [one] cutteth a tree out of the forest, the work of the hands of the workman, with the axe.
4 They deck it with silver and with gold; they fasten it with nails and with hammers, that it move not.
5 They [are] upright as the palm tree, but speak not: they must needs be borne, because they cannot go. Be not afraid of them; for they cannot do evil, neither also [is it] in them to do good.
I'm glad I can say the same thing. I actually can't wait for Halloween to pass so everyone is in full Christmas mode. Haha Sorry it's just my favorite time of year.
Don't you mean when did hang a shining star replace muddle through, Judy Garland started this song, and she sang muddled through, it related to the film, but commercialized Versions put in hang a shing star to make it less depressing and more appealing as a chritmas song.---i have no idea why, because the early version is more heartfelt and warm.
Was it, well ive learned something new today, as this is my favorite christmas song of all time--have you heard the version by Jane Mcdonald she is my favorite artist to cover this song.
Yes at least someone agrees with me--When was the last time you hung a shining star on the highest bow--but i can tell you how many times ive muddled through, old lyrics do make more sense.
Well, he is putting a jazzy spin on it which he is not usually known for. He is a folk/rock singer-songwriter and musician. I like it. It's my number two favourite non-traditional Christmas song of all-time currently.
@trvwatson The Judy Garland original lyrics (which JT sings here) came out during WWII, when millions of soldiers were away from their families under dangerous circumstances, so the "muddle through" was appropriate for the time. Later, someone changed the lyrics to "highest bough" to reflect happier times. My mother (who was a teenager during the war) cried when I played the JT version two Christmases before she died and I'll always remember how she reacted and how my family felt. I miss her so.
Its true, Christmas is not all tinsel and candy-cane--and i always feel sorry for the ones that have lost family or are alone for some reason and are bombarded with constant images of happy families and happiness, it seems such a shame that people cant have a Christmas song that represents being sad at Christmas, A Christmas carol is still the best holiday film to be seen at Christmas, and thats all about a miserable old man and ghosts, but i guess there was Elvis lonely this christmas
@trvwatson Last year I heard the writer, Hugh Martin, interviewed on Fresh Air. He said that Frank Sinatra was going to do the song but objected to the line about muddle through somehow, that it was too sad. He asked if it could be changed. So it was changed to hang a shining star...etc. I always think of that when I hear this tune. I much prefer the original lyrics and this version is my favorite.
SOME MORE OF THE ORIGINAL DARKER LYRICS (THAT JUDY GARLAND REFUSED TO SING--SAYING THAT THEY WERE TOO DARK...)--->> " HAVE YOURSELF A MERRY LITTLE CHRISTMAS, IT MAY BE YOUR LAST...
I like the fact that he decided to stick with the darker lyrics "until then we'll have to muddle through somehow". I always preferred that over hanging stars on boughs or whatever.
I completely agree! The original lyric sung in Meet Me in St Louis that you mentioned is much more fitting, after all it's the intended lyric so it should be sung! =)
Now I can go to bed and sleep with sugar plum dreams in my hand thanks to this little song sung by Sweet Baby James. Goodnight and Merry Christmas Everyone!!!
Don't you like the song? Stop listening to cds and go out more often.. see live shows for a change. There's no perfection, the important thing is the feeling you send to the audience.. here there's sooo much good vibes.
yea im not a retard. i know everyone makes mistakes. but he just makes alot of them. and please dont tell me to go out more. just to let you know, i am paralized from the waist down. it happened after a car accident about a year ago. so its very hard for me to get around. please dont say things like that until you know who you're talking to.
I was just joking.. AND saying that live is just live.. there,s mistakes. On the quantity of live vids I have from him it's not so bad.. plus, the song is so good that I just forgive the mistakes..
most of the time it's because you can't hear yourself very well, or just a bad night.. I've had some on stage myself.
ok i forgive you. sometimes, i just get really upset about my situation because im not used to it yet. thanks for not getting to heated. it was my fault not yours. :) peace and god bless. :)
Now that we know your paralyzed,......GET OUT MORE. I have NO sympathy for invalids that use their,....situation, to get by with NOT LIVING. I think your lieng anyway,.....if not. Think of Tiny Tim,....in a Christmas Carol,........
just to let you know, i am still living and trying to live a normal life. but it is really hard for me because of my disability. i did not ask for this. so please don't taunt me or make fun of me. I try do be as 'normal' as possible. its people like you that give me low self esteem and set me back. and by the way, i've never seen a christmas carol... i'll watch it soon....
Thank you very much for posting this sweet video! My favourite Xmas song! Full of best feelings!!!!!! Hugs from Brazil! Have yourself a merry little Christmas!
snowflake button
jammab88 1 month ago
Actually, They changed several lyrics just to make the song for Meet me in St.louis. the writers of the movie made them change them because they thought it was too dark. I agree, no one sings this like judy, But JT is a close second. And the song was written to talk about how the year is tough and how to look forward to christmas, And the happies ruined the best christmas song ever! Hang a shining star doesnt even fit in, U get mad when people sing it that way, Sinatra is an over rated dope!
dgriff07 1 month ago
i love you, james taylor!
phisofide 1 month ago
今年は一緒に過ごせないから、せめてゆったりとリラックスしたX'masが過ごせますよに...愛しい君へ、優しいジェームスの歌声をプレゼントさせて下さい。
ippukujack 1 month ago
@ippukujack 私の日本語は少し荒いですが、メリーあなたにクリスマス、そしてハッピーニューイヤー。 :)
M0D3Mofficial 1 week ago in playlist James Taylor
This has been flagged as spam show
watch?v=zBy9t171DEM
(James Taylor would love to hear this woman's sweet voice)
MrBlueSkyMrNight 1 month ago
my favorite christmas song by my favorite singer
theshingles100 1 month ago
James actually released this song on his October Road CD in 2002 and had recorded the original lyrics to the song because it's just his style but I saw an interview with him that he chose this version to record as a reflection of the times....with 9/11 so fresh in our hearts and minds, he felt that this more solemn, melancholy version was indicative of our hearts and mindset.
tybeegirl16 1 month ago
Nice.
jeffreydebra1 1 month ago
Merry Christmas! to all ♥ [2011]
villasoliman 1 month ago in playlist More videos from fecela1
he is bald, i just wanna suck on it
Zebadane 1 month ago
What a wonderful version by a legendary entertainer!
themannydanny 2 months ago
"fuck face book in the face"
kidHays21 2 months ago
James Taylor can sing anything ...and i love him....all the troubles of this sad world seem a little further away when James Taylor treats us to a ballad or two ....any time of year
bekindunlimited 8 months ago
This song always takes me back to the late 50s/early 60s, when I was a little kid looking out my grandmother's living room window at all the Christmas lights at the houses on her street. And the snow was over my head (which was a lot closer to the ground back then). It's true, you never know what you've got 'til it's gone.
cwnidog 11 months ago
Best version ever!! JT's the greatest!
daviemcf 1 year ago 2
I have watched this video for a couple of years now, and it still gives me chills. Love the spare arrangement, the sincerity of the vocal, the little personal touches James gives it. He is being himself and that is what matters, even if he had to check the lyrics, or if perhaps a higher key would have suited him more. Nobody has ever touched me by being perfect.
mrchrisization 1 year ago
It's too low for him. Should have raised the key a bit. He's struggling, particularly in the beginning.
Qwinkly3 1 year ago
Minstrel here! I made a warm and nostalgic love song on a cold lonesome Christmas day. It's called "Sweet December". Feel free to listen on my channel and get cozy. :) I also made a response to ds awesome video. :)
darcon81 1 year ago
HAPPY CHRISTMAS EVERYONE IN THE WORLD
bekindunlimited 1 year ago
It's no fire & rain..
oh dear me
visiocomb 1 year ago
Did anybody notice him checking the lyrics written on his palm at 1:50. Priceless.
darkoanton5 1 year ago 5
I love this by James. I have been madly in love with him since I was 14. I still love him at 53. He just gets better and better.
Brennna 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I dedicate this song to the love of my life who is overseas serving our Country, and spending yet another Christmas away from his family. James sings that "in a year" we all will be together and that's exactly when he will finally be coming home to us, if the fates allow. Until then, my love, we'll just have to muddle through somehow. Merry Christmas baby, I love you.
arealfortune 1 year ago
Comment removed
arealfortune 1 year ago
Comment removed
arealfortune 1 year ago
Comment removed
arealfortune 1 year ago
Comment removed
arealfortune 1 year ago
Comment removed
arealfortune 1 year ago
Comment removed
arealfortune 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great song! TY for posting it for us all to enjoy! I have a new original Christmas song, and I'd be grateful if you came to check it out on my channel's main page at YOUTUBE DOT COM/billmills or click on my name to the left of this message. Please leave a comment and/or rate the video. I sure hope you enjoy my Cristmas song "(We Should All Be Together) Christmas Day"! TY again...
billmills 1 year ago
Such a classic song. You can also check my live version of this song in my profile, I hope you'll like it. Comments and ratings are always appreciated.
NikolaMusic1 1 year ago
James this is a bit early ..but HAPPY CHRISTMAS .......John ,Maeve ,Clare
bekindunlimited 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jeremiah 10
3 For the customs of the people [are] vain: for [one] cutteth a tree out of the forest, the work of the hands of the workman, with the axe.
4 They deck it with silver and with gold; they fasten it with nails and with hammers, that it move not.
5 They [are] upright as the palm tree, but speak not: they must needs be borne, because they cannot go. Be not afraid of them; for they cannot do evil, neither also [is it] in them to do good.
derekdb2 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
omg i hated him in dharma and greg now i even hate him more....
Anf26Hollister 1 year ago
@ xXmidnightXxXwriterXx
I'm glad I can say the same thing. I actually can't wait for Halloween to pass so everyone is in full Christmas mode. Haha Sorry it's just my favorite time of year.
Speedy94Retta 1 year ago
soooo im rlly glad im not the only one listening to christmas music in september..haha !!
xXmidniteXxXwriterXx 1 year ago 3
a beautiful song sang by a beautiful man.
dytexplo 1 year ago
here we are.
KMurderful 1 year ago
This song make me sad..
Scumata95 1 year ago
JT FOREVER FOR ME!
treu 1 year ago
the one and the only great JT !!!
IrishDaddi 2 years ago
Merry Christmas James.
Am looking forward to see your show in Japan coming April 2010. Wow
tokyofujii 2 years ago
James Taylor live, wow! Such a touching expression of this wonderful Christmas classic!
pete9939 2 years ago
AMAZIN
dylf14 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from Spain
RWHISTLEG 2 years ago
Nice, nice your voice and your music.
Tu me recuerdas mi juventud.
Mari Lima-Peru
Guga28full 2 years ago
have yourself a merry little christmas
TheProshooter 2 years ago 2
JT much look better for me if he play his acoustic guitar..
proworks 2 years ago
I remember decorating the tree last christmas listening to this song. Now I've decided that it's THE song to listen to.
bsus1412 2 years ago 11
Merry Christmas to my wife Mia and to my daughter Anezka May. Love Papa
Bacolodnon75 2 years ago
his voice is amazing!
BACMusic 2 years ago
his whole face is amazing!
powerkor 2 years ago
when did "have to muddle through somehow" replace "hang your star from the highest bough" ?
powerkor 2 years ago
James Taylor can do whatever the fuck he wants
DylMek13 2 years ago
Wikipedia "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas." You'll read the back story and original lyrics.
apnagra 2 years ago
Comment removed
cmcclain1215 2 years ago
Don't you mean when did hang a shining star replace muddle through, Judy Garland started this song, and she sang muddled through, it related to the film, but commercialized Versions put in hang a shing star to make it less depressing and more appealing as a chritmas song.---i have no idea why, because the early version is more heartfelt and warm.
trvwatson 2 years ago 18
@trvwatson It was Frank Sinatra that asked the songwriters Blaine & Martin to change line to "lighten it up".
gboot2786 1 year ago
Was it, well ive learned something new today, as this is my favorite christmas song of all time--have you heard the version by Jane Mcdonald she is my favorite artist to cover this song.
trvwatson 1 year ago
@trvwatson No I have not. But the best version I've heard is from Luther Vandross. It's on youtube you should check it out.
gboot2786 1 year ago
@trvwatson
I agree 100% I hate the "Hanging a Shining Star" version ... I lyrically doesn't make sense anyway .... I am glad James sung it properly!
vdeogirl 1 year ago 2
Yes at least someone agrees with me--When was the last time you hung a shining star on the highest bow--but i can tell you how many times ive muddled through, old lyrics do make more sense.
trvwatson 1 year ago
@vdeogirl --check out Jane mcdonald version its the best, and she sings the original muddled through lyrics.
trvwatson 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@trvwatson
I agree 100% I hate the "Hanging a Shining Star" version ... I lyrically doesn't make sense anyway .... I am glad James sung it properly!
vdeogirl 1 year ago
Well, he is putting a jazzy spin on it which he is not usually known for. He is a folk/rock singer-songwriter and musician. I like it. It's my number two favourite non-traditional Christmas song of all-time currently.
canucktheclown 1 year ago
@trvwatson The Judy Garland original lyrics (which JT sings here) came out during WWII, when millions of soldiers were away from their families under dangerous circumstances, so the "muddle through" was appropriate for the time. Later, someone changed the lyrics to "highest bough" to reflect happier times. My mother (who was a teenager during the war) cried when I played the JT version two Christmases before she died and I'll always remember how she reacted and how my family felt. I miss her so.
gnukev 1 year ago
@gnukev i feel for you, man. peace...
utubuser10 11 months ago
@trvwatson I have no idea why they changed the lyrics either ♥♥
NYChica23 2 months ago
Its true, Christmas is not all tinsel and candy-cane--and i always feel sorry for the ones that have lost family or are alone for some reason and are bombarded with constant images of happy families and happiness, it seems such a shame that people cant have a Christmas song that represents being sad at Christmas, A Christmas carol is still the best holiday film to be seen at Christmas, and thats all about a miserable old man and ghosts, but i guess there was Elvis lonely this christmas
trvwatson 2 months ago
@trvwatson Last year I heard the writer, Hugh Martin, interviewed on Fresh Air. He said that Frank Sinatra was going to do the song but objected to the line about muddle through somehow, that it was too sad. He asked if it could be changed. So it was changed to hang a shining star...etc. I always think of that when I hear this tune. I much prefer the original lyrics and this version is my favorite.
cowtime13 1 month ago
Thanks for the posting of this--JT is awesome!
angeljenny55 2 years ago
Beautiful version of James Taylor's. I love the slow, jazzy feel. ;-)
SexyProfess 2 years ago 2
Great song..
ff621 2 years ago
I love James Taylor's singing, but that was a sour note at 2:03
musicase64 2 years ago
no one's perfect
weltschmierz5 2 years ago
i love his version of this song, its my favorite.
cgn82 2 years ago 3
Ohh I love this song *-*
ZhEnA92 2 years ago
Comment removed
lsabw 2 years ago
SOME MORE OF THE ORIGINAL DARKER LYRICS (THAT JUDY GARLAND REFUSED TO SING--SAYING THAT THEY WERE TOO DARK...)--->> " HAVE YOURSELF A MERRY LITTLE CHRISTMAS, IT MAY BE YOUR LAST...
NEXT YEAR WE MAY ALL BE LIVING IN THE PAST."
Talk about dark!!!
km2711 2 years ago
I like the fact that he decided to stick with the darker lyrics "until then we'll have to muddle through somehow". I always preferred that over hanging stars on boughs or whatever.
CyckOne 2 years ago
I completely agree! The original lyric sung in Meet Me in St Louis that you mentioned is much more fitting, after all it's the intended lyric so it should be sung! =)
gottamatch 2 years ago 4
A beautiful rendition
sarieltheseraphim 2 years ago 2
James Taylor is the shiz. I don't know what it is with his voice but it drives me crazy!!!!
dsb188 2 years ago 3
I agree it does not get any better than this !!!
odeonpacific 2 years ago 2
Thank you.
Blessings always,
Grannyrain
grannyrain 2 years ago
This is probably the best version I've heard...it puts me in the Holiday spirit all the time
mavaega02 2 years ago 3
James Taylor is awesome. I grew up listening to his music.
spartanloki555 3 years ago 3
James' Christmas album is the best!
garyblech 3 years ago
wow that story makes me want to cry
IPwnYou00 3 years ago
what story? my story?
ilov2talk 3 years ago
yes
IPwnYou00 3 years ago
Now I can go to bed and sleep with sugar plum dreams in my hand thanks to this little song sung by Sweet Baby James. Goodnight and Merry Christmas Everyone!!!
SantaBarbaraDianne 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
The white image of Jesus is the biggest Antichrist that deceived the whole world. Whoever has that image is CURSED.
According to the bible, Jesus Christ was a Black man with woolly hair. Anything different is the Antichrist
Spread this word of God to everyone you know and save them.
marcgorit 3 years ago
at 1:10 and alot of other spots, he goes Out of tune
ilov2talk 3 years ago 2
yep.., so?
Don't you like the song? Stop listening to cds and go out more often.. see live shows for a change. There's no perfection, the important thing is the feeling you send to the audience.. here there's sooo much good vibes.
:)
loranalary 3 years ago
yea im not a retard. i know everyone makes mistakes. but he just makes alot of them. and please dont tell me to go out more. just to let you know, i am paralized from the waist down. it happened after a car accident about a year ago. so its very hard for me to get around. please dont say things like that until you know who you're talking to.
ilov2talk 3 years ago
how could I have known that?!
I was just joking.. AND saying that live is just live.. there,s mistakes. On the quantity of live vids I have from him it's not so bad.. plus, the song is so good that I just forgive the mistakes..
most of the time it's because you can't hear yourself very well, or just a bad night.. I've had some on stage myself.
:)
no insult intended
nothing personal
ok?
peace
:)
loranalary 3 years ago
ok i forgive you. sometimes, i just get really upset about my situation because im not used to it yet. thanks for not getting to heated. it was my fault not yours. :) peace and god bless. :)
ilov2talk 3 years ago
Merry Christmas to you my friend!
:)
loranalary 3 years ago
Merry christmas to you too! :D Thank you for all your kind support
ilov2talk 3 years ago
Now that we know your paralyzed,......GET OUT MORE. I have NO sympathy for invalids that use their,....situation, to get by with NOT LIVING. I think your lieng anyway,.....if not. Think of Tiny Tim,....in a Christmas Carol,........
30millioncrabs 3 years ago
just to let you know, i am still living and trying to live a normal life. but it is really hard for me because of my disability. i did not ask for this. so please don't taunt me or make fun of me. I try do be as 'normal' as possible. its people like you that give me low self esteem and set me back. and by the way, i've never seen a christmas carol... i'll watch it soon....
ilov2talk 3 years ago
I apologize.
30millioncrabs 3 years ago 2
Thank you. I accecpt your apology.
ilov2talk 3 years ago
lol and he knew it
readingleejh 3 years ago
These aren't mistakes or sour notes, he's intentionally changed the music to strike a more melancholy mood.
MrDannyWelch 2 years ago
Such patience, phrasing and relaxation. All "American Idol" contestants should listen to this before they try to overwhelm a song.
tedsgarage 3 years ago
they won't listen..
anyway they don't deserve it!
let them play "star",and get manipulated all right by the "machine" and let's keep the good songs with a nice feeling for us..
:)
loranalary 3 years ago 2
Thanks for sending me this clip :) And to all of you: Merry Christmas from Belgium.
zombfan 3 years ago
love this version.....
funkysoulguy 3 years ago
at 1:20 - 1:29, if you hum it kinda like you're at 2:28, its really good harmony
:D
ilov2talk 3 years ago
JT ... I LOVE YOU.
saezacct 3 years ago
James Taylor gave the greatest concert I ever attended.
bamapagedesign 3 years ago
His voice calms my soul....
zedLavjune 3 years ago
he's amazing.
It always amazes me how he can sing so well when it doesnt even look like he's trying.
downie123 3 years ago
Amazing- he is a legend who transcends generations
ivanalisavac 3 years ago
** Merry Christmas **
LazzariJ 3 years ago
Thank you very much for posting this sweet video! My favourite Xmas song! Full of best feelings!!!!!! Hugs from Brazil! Have yourself a merry little Christmas!
rodrigormendonca 3 years ago
beautiful bass guitar
pizzaROX 3 years ago
wow breathtaking...everything i thought it would be
bluejacketsfan57 3 years ago
I seriously don't know how he sings like that....he doesn't look like he can sing at all
samnaps1 3 years ago
a legend singing my favorite Christmas song
NikonPhoto07 3 years ago 3
Amazing moment... Full of sweet feelings! Great artist! My favourite Xmas song!
Merry Christmas from Brazil!
rodrigormendonca 3 years ago
I love James Taylor. His voice is amazing and so soothing ^^
MurdocKicksAss 3 years ago 2
hes cool!! my mom likes him...........
lbm97 3 years ago
your mom likes me too ;)
ny13isles39 3 years ago
LOL
JASONWCACURA 3 years ago
JT is still underrated. That's how good he is. The best.
grandcranium 3 years ago 3
And the great Larry goldings on piano.
wihimvandorst 3 years ago 2
way to go J.T
jromanr01 3 years ago
Awesome! JT at his best! His voice just mellows with age. Happy Holidays everyone!!!
dfszczepan 3 years ago
Her Highness is singing Christmas!
oysterpippo 3 years ago
positively my fave version of the song! Go james!!
Woo
punkrocklola 3 years ago 2
wonderful!
heiwa2007 3 years ago
grandissimo James..
fradry 3 years ago
James is the best! Thanks for posting.
Captaind41 3 years ago
este james es crack
Floro920 3 years ago 2