Added: 2 years ago
From: kalebnation
Views: 21,433
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (432)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I personally liked "Alice", but coming from a rock fanatic that probably explains why it doesn't bother me. :) I do like her other stuff to though "Keep Holding On" is another big favorite of mine.

  • On December 24,2006 at 8 o'clock in the morning, a young 14 year old boy by the name of Scott Jackson was found dead.Doctors couldn't come up with the cause of his death.His mother checked his emails to see if she could figure out what happened.Turns out he was still signed into myspace.She found he had gone to sleep after he read and didn't repost a chain letter.if you don't repost this to 6 videos a girl with no face will kill you tonight

  • I like it. Maybe it means I have awful taste in music or that I have one of those rancid, distasteful, perhaps even blasphemous things called: an opinion. lol, still love you kaleb.

  • More then 60 seconds

  • Eh.... I dunno.... I kinda like it?

  • go rant to ur mom

  • and NOW SHES BACK!!!!! SHE HAS A HIT SONG CALLED WHAT THE HELL SOOO GO TO HELL!!! HATERS

  • avri l lavignes awsome n first of all her song alice underground is awsome too soo get a life n shutup i bet avril went downhill becuz of her break up with derek wwhibley soo shutup she did change becuz SHES GROWING UP!! soo shutup n get a life haters

  • She was good then, she's good now.

  • avril made a BIG comeback with her new hit " what the hell"

  • Please. SInce when was 'Alice' not good? I mean, are you just saying this beacuse it seems ''cool'' to hate something other people like? Because it seems like everyone is hating on Alice in Wonderland for no apparent reason.

  • to tell the truth I love absautly loved her alice underground vid

  • Dude really get a life

  • I actually liked Alice...dangit.

  • I cant say I was that blown away by it and I normally love her songs

  • fuck you i love that movie and i love avril lavigen

  • wtf i love avril lavigne and tht song is great !!!!

  • Yall are all wrong Avril Lavigne;s song is awsome and she is not a whore and neither is Ke$ha This is one of my favorite songs by far.

  • @TRMS2015 yay i witch you but britny spears ooo uuuuhh eerrr

  • i just had this thought. . .what if Avril became like *looks both ways* Ke$ha? o.O

  • OMG you were RIGHT it is totaly awful. I can still feel my brain dribbling out of my ear!!!

  • I actually like this song. But I have a weird taste in music (which used to normal until people started liking rap.)

    P.S. Seriously though, all people rap about now is :

    1)Clubbin'

    2) "Shawties"

    3) Booze.

    I'm tired of it!

    P.P.S. So yeah. I like that song.

  • Like eating a bowl full of sugar covered MAGGOTS

    In less than 45 seconds it starts to hurt!

    LOL i love you :)

  • I remember when I first heard it, I really liked the capturing beginning, but as she began screaming, my mind then lost interest and kept getting distracted. And that's how it always will be! I only like the softer parts ("I found...myself...in Won...derland") & the instrumental version; I also don't like how she said "Trippin' out", because it reminded me of the so-called drug trip of the classic story.

    IIII!!!!!! I;LL GET BYYY1!! IIII!!!! I'LL SURVIVVVVEEE!!!! IIIII!!!! I WON'T CRY!!!!!!

  • @Sunzu49 She never actually screams in the song lol I just relistened to it because I was sure she didn't. What she actually does is sing a very high note for a long period of time, it's pretty impressive to be honest. But I can understand why some people wouldn't like it due to the frequency.

  • I liked the song, but it really sounded nothing like her old music. At all. I had no idea it was her until the credits.

  • I liked Alice Underground, it had a creepy sort of effect to it,

    it went from slow to fast to a break where the words had an eerie sound to them.

    I thought it was original and interesting.

    but Girlfriend sucked, ever since that song she hasnt been as inspirational.

    Overall, her old music was better.

    But isnt that the same for almost every artist out there it seems?

  • THANKYOU I'm glad I'm not the only one who heard the song and was just appaled. after years of musical silence from her I expected something amazing. Alice underground isn't bad but I dont like it.

  • I still like Avril, but her new music hasn't been as great as her old stuff. When I heard Alice Underground, there were some moments where I liked it but then the chorus came and kind of ruined it for me.

  • I dunno.... I really like that song!!! 

  • I like the lyrics but i think that she should have gone with a more lighter theme since alice in wonderland is in fact mostly a kid movie and there is a lot of color and umm shorter notes o.o

  • wow her song really is very bad the chorus it... just crap

  • Avril Lavigne should go back to her older stuff, from Let Go. She was good back then, now shes just another whore. :/

  • p.s i like all of her OTHER,let me repeat OTHER music

  • i like the lyrics and the first part but she just cant sing the notes. keep holding on is definately better.

  • I TOTALLY agree with you Kaleb! Keep holding on was amazing..this is deffinitly not her best.

  • I NO THE SONGS LYRICS ARE SHIT!!!!1

  • i love the lyrics but the super long notes made my eardrums bleed @___@ oh and coincidently, alice in underground is also the name of an extremely odd manga oneshot by mihara mitsukazu about a girl that abuses her pet rabbit :D

  • i really like both of them a lot. I loved the movie Eragon, and i want to see Alice in Wonderland.

  • Omg this is what i said, i luv the start and it could be so great to be continued like that but she doesnt have the range in her voice to do those long notes, its sounds all over the place, finally someone agrees with me =)

    I am not avrial lavigne hater she is great..but this song eww

  • whatever your gross

  • yeah that song is horrible shes basically screaming nonsense lol its pretty crappy compared to every song she did even if i wasnt comparing it would still sound crappy sorry avril you made a dukie with this one

    old avril is amaizing!

  • Hm, your right...... woah, I used to like that song, yikes, my poor ears! XD

  • I'm on the fence. sometimes i HATE IT and sometimes im rocking out to it and screaming equally as loud as avril.

  • It was terrible. The only three songs that I liked on 'Almost Alice' were The Lobster Quadrille, Tea party, and The Poison. I used to absolutely love Avril, her songs were so original and just...good. What the hell happened to her?

  • @Baratsuki I'm not saying that most of the songs were bad or somethings, but that one especially.

  • I hated this song for a bit , but then it grew on me . Its like mould .

  • I used to love Avril Lavigne when she first came around, and I have to say it's kinda sad how her career went downhill so fast after Girlfriend. Hardly anyone talks about her anymore.

    She DESPERATELY needs a comeback!

  • Hate the song 2 kaleb. I can't blame you.

  • avril's song ROCK! What the hell r u sayin?

  • @Skullycutie118 the opposite of what your saying.

  • i thought the song was amazing. i would like to see any of the haters to sing up there in that pitch and sound good!!!!!!!!!!

  • i like the paramore version of alice (brick by boring brick) this song by avril is that she screams high pitched and its not that good, i like avril its just that this song doesn't do a thing for me. Just an opinion dears.

  • I really like the song and the message that is in it. it is one of my favs right now

  • Yeah, I think she could have lowered the pitch, and I am a big Avril Fan...

  • I agree with Randompd

    I also agree with you, that song was not as good as her others

    I personally like Avril's old songs better than her new ones

    I still like her new ones, just not as much

  • I love Alice (Underground). I don't think it was screechy at all. I have always loved avril and, personally, I think it was a success.

  • I don't know... I LOVED Keep Holdin' On, it was perfect for Eragon, but I don't hate Alice Underground, either. I see what you mean, though.

  • its absolutely horrible its like shes screaming the whole song i think shes stopped writing her own songs and that is why everything since her single girlfriend has been horrible either that or her new clothing line is more important to her than her music

  • I do love the song

  • check out my harry potter video of the new avril lavigne song undergroun already gt 4 rates :)

  • I actually liked the song in the tv spots, but hearing it on the video I completely know what you mean. It's so screechy and piercing. Doesn't sound so great.

  • I agree with you. I love the beginning of the song, it has such good potential. But the rest is..... not fit for her voice. :S I was disappointed too. :(

  • it's a good song, it's just not for her voice

  • OMHeck. I felt like my brain was dribbling out of my ears through that entire song. It was absolutely terrible. I loved the song she did for "Eragon" though.

  • I love the song! What are you talking about?!

  • I don't think the song is that bad but it could have been better.

    1:05 "We'll smoke the monster out!" =D

  • hes wack, i love avrils new song. i made a male cover to it. i fell in lvoe with it after hearing it in the theaters. didnt even know it was her. i love her music tho. check out my male cover.

  • i luv the song im gonna make a harry potter fan vid of it

  • yes, like (the old)avril

    no, don't like the song

    i think she screams far to much!

  • When I heard it, honest to Buddha I thought she singing bad karoke, and this is coming from a long time fan.

  • It's not as bad as I expected after the rant... But it doesn't sound like Avril Lavigne at all, more like Jewel or Alanis Morissette

  • She screams A LOT! Totally ruined the song.

    But her dress in the clip is really beautiful.

  • Eh, it's not the best song I've ever heard, but it's not the worst either. The light version of yodaling (or however you spell it) wasn't very good.

  • i like her new song

  • I Like her new song. it's not that bad. but yea,her first 2 albums were really good. the 3rd one. Well. it was ok, not bad, but pretty good. And i say she still is good.

    And i am an Avril Fan got Old or New.

  • hers songs are great new and old

    allways been a fan

  • after hearing the song a few times, i have to say i disagree.

    i actually quite enjoy the song now, it's definitely different, but i like it. i think it fits the movie being that this movie looks quite odd.

  • I 100% AGREE KALEB!!!

    I like her old stuff so much better.

    I could come up with a better arangement for that song, than her... :x

  • lmao kaleb, i love your 60 sec rants : )

  • while it's not my favorite Avril song, I don't know why you would call it awful. It's still a good song. Granted, Keep Holding On was better, but this is still pretty good

  • i haven't even listend to the entire thing of her new song and "keep holding on" wins HANDS DONE!

  • LOLOLOL. LOVE THE ENDING.

  • its not that bad

  • I completely agree with u! Alice Underground was terrible!! I love Avril's first two albums but after that not so much.. and Keep Holding On was beautiful I loved it even though I was super disappointed with Eragon, that movie totally butchered the book..

  • Ok. I just listened to it. Besides all the shrieking the lyrics make her sound like she's in some sort of drunken stupor. But then again, Alice in Wonderland is supposedly about an acid trip...

  • I haven't heard it yet.... not so sure I want to?

  • like the old punk aril this makes me dislike her more

  • She went from my favorite singer to...... bleck. I love her, yet I hate her now. What HAPPENED?!

  • Me and my cousins are huge fans! (Like you said she was pretty popular) but this song basically makes us HATE her!

  • i hate the song

    but i have to say i like the video for it! lol

  • i have to DISAGREE with you kaleb. the song isn't THAT bad that you have to complain so much.

  • I am so freaking disappointed with the soundtrack they have chosen for this AMAZING movie.

    I mean tokio hotel and avril lavigne.. seirously?... SERIOUSLY?!

  • omg! thought that song was horrible. thank GOD im not the only one. keep up the great videos kaleb!

  • i liked the song until it reached the first minute. i was alright, but the chorus was bbbbaaaddd. the "iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii­iiii" s were terribblleee.

  • I disagree. I liked the song. I wasn't crazy about the vocals but it'd make a good soundtrack song. Especially for this movie.

  • lmao xD

  • I used to be a fan of her old stuff. And you're right, the beginning of the song is quite nice, and then it just takes a turn for the worse.

  • Love the rants... deciding my opinion right now *rewatches*

  • I'm with you, Kaleb. That song made me want to shove a pencil in my ear. Although, I did really like the piano, that part was great.

  • I am going to shamefully admit to liking this song D: Sorry to the haters. It is a bit high pitched but she seems to pull it off quite well...

  • I agree with you Kaleb, Keep Holding On is way better

    I really like Avril but this song was not as good as usual, and when she sings more shrilly, it sounds like her microphone can't handle it.

    the music video is interesting though

  • O.o yah, I listened to it and my dog ran to the other room ^_^

  • I have to go listen to it!

    I used to really love her but the third album isn't really my taste :P Pluse in the first two I was younger... Like what?10-14? anyway... it doesn't speek to me much anymore :P

    I'm going to listen to it right now XD

  • I like it :)

  • ...her 'sense of style'? That makes sense(!)

    What ARE you on about? XD Her style's changed SO much since she first came out! She's all pink and... stuff now... She was MILES better before but she's still epic.

  • I cba to look but I'm pretty sure you've had enough of Avril lovers spamming with rants to change your mind and stuff. I know you're not gonna change your mind so all I'm gonna say is this. Avril wins. She is awesome. Alice (Underground) I s BLOODY epic. You have a hearing disability. I'd get that checked out.

    (Please, nobody reply to this, I can't be bothered xD )

  • i agree with you squishybobb :) avril is bloody epic! good choice of words.

  • I hate that song, I hate her music, always have, pretty sure I always will. her attitude on idol made me pretty sure I don't like her as a person either :P

  • LOTR REFERENCE!!!

    and I really liked her old stuff. and the eragon song. her first album I pair with young Harry Potter because I loved both at the time... sigh... oh early millennium.

  • you guys know that owl city's technicolour phase is in the album?

  • I actually quite enjoy the song :)

  • i actaully like tht song! the music video is pretty awesome!

  • HAHA! man this song sucks!

  • I thought it was pretty interesting maybe it could be a little bit better.

  • Yea its pretty terrible...oh god. its like these terrible out of tune high notes that just SUCK she just keeps going "AHHHHHHHH EE AHHHHHHHHHH EE AHHHHHHHHH I will not hit the ground AHHHHHH" again and again and again...

  • She seemed to be sreaming at us then whispering at us then back to screaming! I did sorta like Avril, but that song! UGH!

  • old music ^^

  • it BAD!! i mean i really like her stuff too but it's not that good

  • Just Heard it. Yip, Sugary Maggots certainly come to mind...I gave up listening half-way through!

    -Rachel

  • Is it really that BAD? I haven't heard it, so I wouldn't know...:D

    -Rachel

  • i think you're right. It's not that I like her much but she has a lovely voice and the song is just like screaming! i don't like it either

  • the song is awesome!! stfu!

  • that song was HORRIBLE. HORRIBLE. HORRIBLE. UGH.

  • all she does is oh aaa oh! rubbish

  • BAHAHA GOSH xD you're so right. I love avril but this song is aweful

  • I'm a huge Avril fan. And I actually really love the new song... I like you're rant though. :)

  • I dont really like the chorus where she gets 'louder' it kind of sounds like she is yelling. other then that it's ok.

  • i luv her music and i thsi this song its great and i would rant bout all the things that make its great but i dont hav time

  • Its not THAT bad kaleb lol.. the movie is trippy.. so the songs kind of trippy too..

  • Agreed.

    Sooooo disappointed.. I adore Alice in Wonderland and I loved Avril back when I was growing up, SO upset that the combination failed...

  • Ahahahahaaaa Well, I am not a HUGE fan of hers, and I sorta agree with you, Kaleb. :) xAvrilFreak gets *ROASTED* WHAT!

  • it's not my favorite song of hers, but i don't think it's absolutely horrible. i definitely love her older stuff way more though

  • i like alice underground.

    i think it really works with the story of alice and wonderland.

    i honestly dont understand why you dont like it :S

  • I like the song... Sorry Kaleb

  • You can't spell "you're". Boom...roasted.

    --Kaleb

  • Ahh, Kaleb. You make the world a better place. :D

  • I personaly being an

    Avril Lavigne fan

    having all her cd's love this song i didnt like keep holding on that mutch it was over played and the song company made it popular by playing it over and over again.

  • OLD MUSIC. I also grew up in the 2000's... her new music is so much worse then the old.

  • ok it sounds like shes...honstely i dont know what to compare it to other than a screaming banchee..spelling? not so sure

    but ..i LOVED avril but not with this song..JUST NO.

  • oh my goodness your so very right!

    i love avril but come on this is just sad, i love the beggining but its just gross after just the first few seconds. YUK!

  • I'm a fan of Avril. But I like her old music the most. I like both Keep Holding On and Alice Underground.

  • the song was cute, it's just the chorus sucks more than (fill in the blank here). I too am/used to be a hardcore avril lavigne fan. I agree that Keep Holding On is so much better, but your vloggity video made this song seem so much worse than it really is. Keep Holding On gets a rank of 9, Alice Underground gets a rank of 5.5.

  • i liked it at first then it kept going and i was like okayy then it kept going and i was like uhhh

    and i love keep going on!:D

  • Eh, I was indifferent to it...It had a nice tune and was catchy, but it wasnt my favorite thing ever

  • I like the song but her voice doesn't sound good in the chorus.

  • the first high was like ok...

    then she kept going and i was like oh it is kinda maggoty lol

  • I really liked that song haha. I thought it was good! But everyone has their own opinons! Grad to hear yours Kaleb haha

  • I didn't like the chorus, but I like it alright. It definantly wasn't her best song, but it wasn't horrible. And I was a kid in the early/mid 2000's, too. ^^

  • i thought it was pretty good... i mean i guess keep holding on was BETTER but alice underground wasn't AWFUL

  • I didn't think it was THAT bad. It's not the best. But it's not terrible.

  • Yes! Thank you! I loved it at the beginning, but once it got to the chorus...*insert unimpressed face here*

  • I'm a closet fan of avril lavigne, but i'm interested to hear her alice song, based on your review O.o

  • i loved her first album...then she sold out.

  • i didnt like it either. I LOVE avril but this song was a little too "dark" for a disney movie...in fact I think the alice movie is too "dark" to b a disney movie.

  • i listened to it. it's not so bad. AND I AM A CRAZY ALICE IN WONDERLAND FAN! so yeah, i would say if i hated it,, but it really wasnt bad

  • omg i love avril. i remember singin to sk8r boi when i was younger! i still love her now! i love Alice Underground. its different then what she usually things and she is an amazing singer. I love ya kaleb but i gotta disagree :)

  • Your stupid...Its an awesome song. Avril is so talented...:)

  • I personally love the song but that's just my opinion.

  • Hey, Kaleb! Your links in your blog are no longer accesible for the videos. Sony Music got to them.

  • i love the song! espeacially compared to the complete pobby, preppy, annoying ones she made not too long ago....i really miss her old punk self.

  • I haven't heard the Alice song yet, but normaly I like Avril Lavigne, she has some good stuff.

  • I really really liked it.(:

    People stop hating.:(

  • Sounds like she tried to do some Lacey Mosley (singer of Flyleaf) kind of singing. More... rockier... more powerful vocals that get the listener more interested.

    Though the problem is that some don't like the screeching noise. I, however, love it and can't wait until the soundtrack comes out.

  • i agree avril lavigne has some great songs. i suppose i am a little young to love songs like sk8er boi but thanks to my sister i know all the great songs from the early 2000's but this song is pretty bad... not the worst song ever but the worst avril for sure

  • its true.. im afraid the song is kinda suckish. i mean alice song was so bad. I prefer the song that she did for canon which is call inocence...

  • omg u were rit the song is ok but just until like 40 seconds :(

  • I thought the song was really really good

  • I used to be an Avril Lavigne fan, but then I started disliking her voice. I think the song isn't that bad, but some parts of the chorus sound veery terrible, like she wasn't hitting the right tone. but I like the beginning. but maybe it's one of those soundtrack songs that are played in the ending of the credits.:) haha

  • I agree that Avril's best movie song was Keep Holding On, but I fervently disagree about Alice Underground being like eating sugary maggots. Alice Underground is VERY different from her usual music, but that's because it's for a movie. It's not her song, she didn't write it. She's singing the song because she's recognized in the music industry and loved by many people.

    Alice Underground was okay, not amazing, but definitely not like eating sugary maggots.

    YOU SO WEIRD SOMETIMES, KALIP!

  • I disagree. I mean, yeah - it's different from her old albums, but it's not "Bloody awful".