yea.. Regina's a bit too graceful sometimes. That's the only thing I don't like about her style. Sometimes it's overdone. And Amanda is just wreckless which I always love lol. Regina did very good with this song though... both versions are pretty good... but I wish I could find the recording Amanda used for her myspace page cuz that was very good.
@Remembrance1692 I am with you on that. Maybe we can get a bunch of people to beg her for a free download. XD (Considering the assholes of Myspace disabled ripping...)
in my opinion Amanda Palmer does a better job than Regina! i love Regina she is an amazing singer/pianist but this song is dark and Amanda Palmer has a rough unique voice that fits the songs mood more than Regina spektors soft voice! Amanda Palmer ROCKS!!!!
i love amanda palmer so much xD
i love regina spektor too.
i cant decide who does this better....
amanda definantly suits it though.
wow.
xxnae 2 years ago
yea.. Regina's a bit too graceful sometimes. That's the only thing I don't like about her style. Sometimes it's overdone. And Amanda is just wreckless which I always love lol. Regina did very good with this song though... both versions are pretty good... but I wish I could find the recording Amanda used for her myspace page cuz that was very good.
Remembrance1692 2 years ago
@Remembrance1692 I am with you on that. Maybe we can get a bunch of people to beg her for a free download. XD (Considering the assholes of Myspace disabled ripping...)
xXprettyxkittyXx 1 year ago
Amanda's version is good, but sorry - Regina does a much better job.
turnip1987 2 years ago
youre right, shes definitely got the voice for this
1ataloss1 3 years ago 2
in my opinion Amanda Palmer does a better job than Regina! i love Regina she is an amazing singer/pianist but this song is dark and Amanda Palmer has a rough unique voice that fits the songs mood more than Regina spektors soft voice! Amanda Palmer ROCKS!!!!
hubbabubbajosh 3 years ago