Added: 4 years ago
From: sunshinez95
Views: 145,742
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (218)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • just got cheated on in this long relationship. its the only song that makes me feel better while balling all throughout it...

  • life is bipolar, beautiful for some, for others the fucking saddest.

  • Speechless.

  • Now you see me, now you don't. Now you need me, now you don't...

  • Another underrated band/song. Good music is like this is not Eminem, REAL music gives you connections to your own life and has meaning behind the lyrics. It seems everything today is just a cheap scam to make money and just awful. I mean looking at the comments you can see that people have memories be it good or bad come back with this song or start thinking about it. It happens everywhere now though in music, video games, television and movies. Good things showing up #1 on a chart is impossible

  • @MrMinecraftiest don't talk smack about eminem.. just cause youve never done drugs doesnt mean his music doesn't make connections to someones life. i personally don't listen to him that doesn't mean his music isnt "real".

  • Impossible for me to forget this song </3

  • summers on Long Island with my now fiance just laying in my room with the lights out listening to these songs miss those days summer 03 forever

  • this song brings me back to the good days with my buddies im no longer friends with. fucking miss those times man

  • I remember listening to this and feeling like, what is wrong with me that nobody knows I'm here? I feel like It doesn't matter what I do because nobody cares... So finding other people that understand how I like a girl and she doesn't give a fuck about me, makes me feel better. Thank you FATA for helping me keep living in this terrible world...

  • these songs are timeless

  • There is no hope.......kill yourself, Give in! There will never be a break, it will only get worse! DO IT! DO IT NOW!!!!

  • @VrkasTheSkulltaker Your a waste of sperm, egg and skin.

  • @TheSeabuscus Yeah? You gonna go back to mommy's basement and hike up your sleeves and cut over it ?

  • @VrkasTheSkulltaker Oh yeah bro. You know me all to well. Cut my wrists and black my eyes! But in the real world thats what you should be doing.

  • I want to cover a part of this song the video probably will be up by after tomorrow so subscribe and feel free to request songs

  • This is what heartbreak sounds like...

  • @terdsandwich78 nice SP reference btw :)) you nailed it....this IS heartbreak.....we all need to experience it ....so we can value that which comes along later...happiness!

  • Awesome song.....so underated

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE this song!!! c:

  • <3333 great song!!

  • their best album, Melanie was a great bonus

  • @kimmayxxx Melanie brought a whole new dimension to FATA ...the monolog, tragic stories.didn't she do other songs too? memory is failing.....I mean I like milligram' to no end and the others, but she puts a special edge on things....like the gal that sings now and then on COF songs...nymph/death of love...don't recal her name...anyone?

  • @solicanthia Liv Kristine is the girl that sang on nymphetamine. :)

    Melanie brought FATA to a whole new level, i agree with you on this one.

    this song simply changed me. most certainly one of my top 3 favorites of all time. <3

    brings tears to my eyes every single time

  • whos the lady singin?? anyone know?

    

  • @pjnuccioIII Her name is Melanie Wills. She has her own band called One True Thing.

    

  • they put the two songs toghether? sounds good

  • long time no see beautiful!

  • damnit, i was 37 views past being the 123,456th viewer. so close

  • love it!

  • i can relate so thing song SOOO much.. i listen to it when i'm sadd.

    maybe one day i'll relate to the fiction we live <3 it's so sweet

  • fav band since mid school

  • shes good with fata.

  • @xxdubs I agree! I wish they had more than the two songs (that I know of) together!

  • @LostAngel547 Melanie was in Short Stories with Tragic Endings btw one of my favs

  • I love this song. I hope I never have to experience this, though...

  • love this song it has a lot of meaning to me extremely beautiful voice by Melanie and it's just such an emotional, beautiful song....words can't describe it ...

  • The girl who sings in this song is Melanie Wills and she plays in the band One True Thing.

  • I love that someone put the two of these together...the first time I heard it was on a playlist back to back so I thought it was one song. I love both!

  • it's amazing how in tune you can get with a song. i listen to it often and can help but feel the passion in the music and the connection with the lyrics. truely an out of this world song.....

  • how loving is this? this is indeed a love song...i miss this band...and the first girl who tells me they love this...i will marry her!

  • how loving is this? this is indeed a love song

  • This is a really beautiful song ... And i like the lyrics alot they are verry deep

  • i absolutely love this song, so amazing and the words just mean so much to so many people. been my favourite since i was about 14 and i still love it to this day.

  • For the longest time I've been only listening and singing to Autumns part of the song and never knew there was more to it until just yesterday and I was really touched when I heard the guy part =)

  • @Acemegagamegirl wow.....where have you been? my buddy sat my ass down and told me to listen......then once this gorgeous song was over.... he made me listen to the fiction we live... i think i cried haha

  • Doesn't matter What Gender you are.

    If you have loved someone or crushed on a person.

    You will feel that thing in your chest that makes you wanna cry. : \

    <333333333333333

  • @pollochikan21

    totally agree,as i read it, i started crying :( as i heard the "fiction part"

  • @xxXsTreamxx Yup, it really is.

  • @pollochikan21 thats totaly truth.. if u someday loved someone U will feel it...

  • ...I totally shed a tear... xD I've only heard the girl's part of it, and then I was watching a video of how to play it on guitar and he mentioned that it sounds a little/bit different than "The Fiction We Live", so I looked that and heard it and... yep... xD ;-;

  • Possibly one of the most brilliant songs.

  • The guys version is equally as good as the girls version. This song is beautiful no matter what you say. & I love it to death.

  • Why isn't The Fiction We Live longer?! It would be so much better if they just made it like a minute longer.

  • I wish I could like the girl version and dislike the guy version because isn't very good.

  • @austinha11

    Your crazy! CRAZY.

  • Only YOU can give the breath of life. <-- Powerful!

  • visions of you, then you're gone . . .

  • <The Good Music of old times.... and still moves your insides like the first day....

  • really good song

  • This song makes my heart ache <3

  • Her voice makes me happy in my pants

  • this song gives me goose bumbs o.o so beautiful :'D

  • 5 jerkoffs? id expect many more... this ones worthy of hatin on ;)) love it :D

  • @MrDeAD1313 ya gay

  • " If the sky were to suddenly open up, there would be no law, there would be no rule. There would only be you and your memories." The moment you think you escaped your demons, they become your only friend(s), and personally, I hate my demons so much that it is the only reason i fight through my episodes.

  • this songs is amazing , it almost describes what i feel these days .

  • It is so fucking beautiful <3

  • i dont know what to do anymore .. im struggling and have been ... people always say "you need to learn to cope with your manic depresssion" i think i should just go and join all my friends and family that i've lost.....

  • @suicidesucks08 never... You might be depressed but it's okay. I was like that for a long time... but trust me. You were given life for a reason, don't waste it. And killing yourself only hurts your friends and family still alive. Go listen to The Loss by Hollywood Undead... and The Last Night by Skillet. Both good songs about suicide... it's so not worth it. I don't even know you, and I don't want to see another human being hurt. Email me if you want to talk I'll listen, seriously.

  • @Snickerzchik props

  • Melanie Wills Has The One Of The Most Beautiful Voices I Have Ever Heard...

  • Melanie Wills Has The One Of The Most Beautiful Voices I Have Ever Heard...

  • Actually, emo WAS a style of hardcore. Indian Summer, Orchid, Saetia, Heroin, Joshua Fit for Battle, Neil Perry. That shit was emo. From Autumn to Ashes do not play emo music. These two songs are fucking amazing regardless.

  • i like this song

    i want that you say me please... in waht page a find this song

    please please =)

  • one word: beautiful

  • Comment removed

  • there is no such thing as emokid every humanbeing animal any living creature has emotions, emotional songs has been around for thousands not hundreds of years

  • beautiful song

    I had never heard the end of the song

    is very cool

  • whoever synced these 2 songs is a genius

  • Yeah FUCKFACE LOL

  • I think Melanie and Fran need to do a side project, but it'd probably be pretty hard to top this song.

  • i stopped looking up FATA when they broke up and my real life began with their sound... i come back three years later and all their songs go from 143 views to -5074 thousand im just weirded out by the change. are they becoming mainstream cause im freaking out but im happy they finally are getting the attention they deserve

  • @9256371459 i mean 74 thousand

  • @9256371459 They aren't together anymore.

  • @9256371459 No one I know has heard of them. They broke up :[

  • Who the fuck cares about labels? These songs are amazing, period

  • @saijq

    I'll drink to that

  • this is awesome and perfectly meshed, thank you for uploadage

  • So is there not an official music video for this song?I know not all songs get a music video made, but I was kinda hoping :P

  • Guys relax and her name isn't Autumn her name is Melanie Wills and she used to be in a band called One True Thing, she was never in FATA. She just did a song with them. RELAX!

  • Autumn is a fictional character, notice the name of the band. From Autumn to Ashes. And a lyric in his song says 'we only exist in this song'. This is fantasy.

  • You don't have to be emo to like this song. I'm a classical/opera styled musician but I truly love this song and appreciate this meaning. If people can't see that, then they truly don't understand music.

  • Comment removed

  • this song.. :(

  • i can relate so well with this song. every word.

  • loveyoureself77 well said

  • im so confused...i thought from autumn to ashes was hardcore? wtf is this?

  • @RemySaysRawrr Most of their stuff IS hardcore.. but ... I guess working with Melanie Wills he decided to do something different for once..

    I love their heavier stuff too, but this is just beautiful.. a statement... then the response... does it make you like FATA less now just because they didn't scream in one of their songs? I hope not...

  • This song is so pretty.(: I could just fall asleep to it.

  • This is so sad, so deep, what a beautiful voice. Emo? Well, yes it has emotion, but not emo, good grief!

  • umm.. where can i get this song ? I've been looking everywhere can't find it, would love fer this version, cause it has both songs on here, and its amazing. so if yu can help me out w/ that, that would be so awesome ! but umm.. okay well thats all i was wondering. I want'd to sing this song fer my talent show at my school and i would like to sing this version, that would be awesome !

  • don't worry about being emo. it's 2010. break the cycle.

  • Just heard the CD......Good stuff!...I'm 47....

  • @jballzzz lol, nothing wrong with that! all the power to ya.

  • I Freaken love this band and Melanie just sings so good in this song she was a nice feauture. I Wish this guys got back together=(

  • nice song!!! and a beutifull girl

  • i really loved that song and entire album

  • Amazing :)

  • Melanie Wills

  • who is that girl???

  • @SANDXcalliber

    mannnnnnn if you dont now what your talking about jus be quiet lolll @her name is autumn she used to be in the band

  • @runxaxmuck thats what i fucking said dumbass -_-

  • @SANDXcalliber i was laffing at your boneheaded statement lol her names melanie fucc tard

  • @runxaxmuck No its not its autumn -__- i know I fucking know her!

    try learning how to spell next time its laughing* not laffing. Yeah and im the Fuck tard*.

  • @SANDXcalliber believe what you want lol, I know how to spell but this is america and i can do it any way i choose lollll stop getting so angry

  • @SANDXcalliber No its Melanie Wills..it says on the cd..Autumn is not a real person..

  • awesome song. <3

  • beautiful i have been in love with this song for years....still amazing

  • @ericjamesrobb

    Same I still love it years later

  • Thanks for posting this, was looking for both songs in one,

  • this song is soo beautiful! The lyrics are absolutely amazing and soo true!

  • Its sounds so much better with the girl starting before the guy :)

  • i break in two <\3 such a nice song

  • its so beautiful i love it

  • i herd the guy one before the female

  • Wow.. I have never heard this version with the guys voice. o-o I like it though! <3

  • DARN IT!

    FREAKIN LOVE THIS SONG <33

  • could hear it 100 times. it's beautiful ♥

  • I love this song.. it plays such a beautiful story.

  • <3 i fucccking love this song.

    i cant stop singing it.

  • Me too.

    It gets stuck in my brain.

  • awsome!

  • I love this song *-*

  • i wish they would put this version on myspace i have been looking for it to put on my profile but i only can find the one with just the guy singing rrr still love the song!!!!!!!!!

  • acutally it is not that sad but emotional

  • its sad but its really good

  • i love this song

  • I managed to get both songs playing at the same time, it's pretty cool. :)

  • for real, i just managed to do it, someone should edit a video to play them both at the same time!

  • There's a good remix of 4 FATA songs, these are 2 of them, called Autumn's Duet :)

  • so many emotions

    i love you kevin

  • this song of FATA is beautifull

    other = is "short stories with tragic endings" in the final part...

  • One the most beautiful songs in the world.

    Thanks for uploading.

  • did someone knows more songs

    but where the gilr sang?

    sorry for my bad english

    hehe i dont peak it very well

  • her name is Melanie Wills shes in a band called one true thing.

  • thanks a lot =)

  • Great songs

  • just. shut up dousheshnozzles im sick of your self irrogance, your pity, and self inflicting pain. you got a problem, and yes, i have problems too, do some other shit besided cry and cry and cry and cut and cry and cry more and cut and somehow survive, so you can get a damn pity party..dye your hair. pusssssnutz

  • aight aight. get all defensive and cry about it..

    i know who the people are who listen to this peotic misery, you. all of you. and yeah i do live with my moms, i don't have to pay rent or make food. good deal to me. EMO is not a type of music you predictable, endeffinate, ellusive, mistake of a human body, you dumb fuck waste. emo is named after the self enflicted kids that have emotional stress, stop posin get out of your sisters pants and run away. and yes, i love talkin shit over the CPU. <3

  • the emo genre of music is distorted but there is a emo and a screamo and either of them are what is dipicted by todays media

  • ehhhh if anything the person who's emo right now is you. But it's alright. Being a dumb fuck waste is fun :/

  • i aint emo or something..

    i dont like to judge ppl by the music they like or the band..

    music ofc does not make you something u might not be..

    if u like,u hear..

    if u dont,u dont..

    so,no matter the lyrics,or the music,u cant tell thats an emo band or somethin..

    or u are emo yourself...

    you just like that song..

    damn...

    From Autumn To Ashes ftw...

  • juz cuz we listen to this song doesn't mean we're emos. What's so emo about this song? Aren't all songs based on emotions? Dont we listen to songs because it touches our soul? So if we're touched by this song that make us emo? I'll admit that this song reminds me of someone I'd lost but that doesn't mean I'm a person who slits my wrists, weeps 24/7, and write suicide letters. I bet MOST people listen to this song because they can relate to the meaning not because they're emos. So stop labelling.

  • ^True Dat. Respect.

  • The entire first part of your rant was emo. Just sayin.

  • labelling's fun. I'll label you assss the-person-who-has-nothing-bet­ter-to-do-(and-probably-lives-­with-his-mother-loser-freak)-t­han-labelling-people-as-emo-ov­er-youtube.

  • copy paste that epic words

  • @loveyourself77 exactly but no one can lie we all have suicidal thoughts i have and tried failed only a cig stopped me. this is bout love which we all feel and is hard for us all but its worth it in the end

  • @loveyourself77 you just executed them all :)

  • @loveyourself77 WELL FOOKIN SAID

  • @loveyourself77

    May I add that people that post comments about being emo are either just childish or have been brought up in a family or social group that tut at showing any emotion

  • @loveyourself77 lol your right all songs are based on emotions look at eminem calling him emo no he raps he raps his emotions some people sing it lol idk

  • @loveyourself77 Emo is a type of music. It doesn't mean you slit your writsts, so do the world a favour & shut your fucking mouth because you're obvioulsy unaware of the meanings of the words you use. You're gonna tell someone to stop labeling? I'd rather be called emo because of the music I listen to than if I cut myself or was suicidal.

  • omfg what an idiot.

    u kno the definition of emo??

    its a TYPE OF MUSIC.

    and this isnt even the type.

    why dont u go find something better to do than harrass kids that might actually have something wrong with their lives.

    thanks a lot. 0_o

  • they should make one where they sing it like this, in order so that i can add it on my myspace. cause its like they guy version is answering to the girls. and its so sweet yet depressing

  • these two songs are superrr cute<33

  • i like this song :D

  • i dont wanna watch this cuz it reminds me of me getting dumped, but i love the song, i dont kno what to do :S

  • Have the seedee, {CD}

  • i love melanie's voice.

    its just so beautiful.