Beautiful. The song may have been better had they played like this for the long drawn out jam part. Much better sounding than the random playing and noodling on the album.
1:31 - 1:36 what scale are you playing? sounds phenomenal! i have to say honestly that this is one of the most beautiful playing ive heard in my life. thank you very much, greetings from earth :)
@LaWey Thanks a lot! That is a Bb diminished arpeggio ascending over an A7 chord, and a descending D harmonic minor scale over a Dm chord. Glad you like it.
Some elements were nicely performed but others not so, a waltzy baseline segment in a melodic wistful piece like this one (please?) ! More alarming though was your righthand technique which unfortunately is sadly flawed with that very stiff (and ugly) 'fisto' approach to the strings.. the viewing (and ear)experience was sort of akin to watching someone with a clubbed foot attempting to play football - Sorry :]
@alzoom007 maybe the viewing and (ear) experience for alzoom007 was more akin to a deaf and dumb kid watching you tube, commenting wildly with his thumb up his arse.
@alzoom007 Can you explain what you mean by flawed right hand technique...better still could you show us all how to play with the 'correct' right hand technique? I'm assuming you are an authority on the subject? I look forward to you posting something....
@NWheelerGuitar Yep not a problem.. making a fist when holding the pick ie not extending or showing the 2nd 3rd & 4th fingers with the righthand restricts wrist extension and also interferes with the movement of the pick over the strings . If you listen closely to this example you will note that the wrist is so clenched that these fingers actually mute articulation of the sweep execution..
@NWheelerGuitar Thrip's jazz tuitor probably mentioned this in the same sentence where 'ugly' hand positions were discussed - or ought to have been ! I'll be posting my own Master Class video shortly.. in betweens try viewing the examplary righthand technique of such Jazz Legends as Charlie Christian, Joe Pass & Larry Carlton while you're here :}
@alzoom007 OK I look forward to seeing that! Yes I agree Joe Pass had incredible right hand technique as I recall he used to 'Gyspy Pick' i.e do a down stroke for every new string I believe he used to curl his fingers in (or as you call it a 'fist' technique) like thrip too! I hadn't realized there was any footage of Charlie Christian to look at his right hand technique....
Some elements were nicely performed but others not so, a waltzy baseline segment in a melodic wistful piece like this one (please?) ! More alarming though was your righthand technique which unfortunately is sadly flawed with that very stiff (and ugly) 'fisto' approach to the strings.. the viewing experience was sort of akin to watching someone with a clubbed foot attempting to play football - Sorry :]
Oh I know that, I just find his interpretation really interesting and I loved it as fan of jazzy melodies (I can't say I'm jazz fan) Long live the King
Awsome version, good depth with the reverberation. I could recognise Jango- manouche and bossa chords! You are not an amateur WTF are you doing on youtube, ??..Anyway thanks for posting it..
WOW! This is amazing. I love your playing and arrangement! Thank you for this beautiful post! I am just learning the guitar, one year into it now, and this is completely inspiring! I might take my post down now and redo it! Wow. This is brilliant. min :-)
Watched your video again and really love what you did with the tune. Have you ever thought about using flatwounds? Tomastek-Infeld makes one of the only pure nickel wrap sets like all the cats always used. They sound great.
Fantastic job! Your 53 is super clean. Much cleaner than my 54. So funny that someone wants "tabs" of this. You got the guy's hands right there in front of you playing it. Figure it out!
Amazing, you are the best semi-acoustic player i heard so far =) could you please put some tablature of this online? I visited your site, but couldn't find it.
Wow, you really made an amazing song out of Moonchild (sorry, I believe King Crimson are way overrated and apart from a couple of their songs/compositions I don't really enjoy their albums). Amazing job, great Djangoesque moments inbetween.
Thanks! I almost agree with you about KC. Their albums are generally a mixture of amazing and cringeworthy! More the former than the latter though imo.
awesome!
napness 6 days ago
Beautiful. The song may have been better had they played like this for the long drawn out jam part. Much better sounding than the random playing and noodling on the album.
DoubleO711 1 week ago
@DoubleO711 Wow, that's a nice compliment, I'm not sure I'm worthy...
thrip 1 week ago
Love the sound of the guitar, too bad you jazzed the song up though.
TheCompanyRules 2 weeks ago
@TheCompanyRules whats bad about that? this is what makes it unique and personal.
napness 5 days ago
Magic! reminds me of some Joe pass improvisations !
Colorflow1 3 weeks ago
is this standard tuning? anyways i LOVE this cover. I'm totally downloading this for my iPod :). Thanks!
Makksor 1 month ago
@Makksor Thanks! Yes it's standard tuning.
thrip 1 month ago
Wonderful version. Really like it.
I also enjoyed watching the thumb popping over the neck for the cheeky G7s and F# bass notes!
czgibson 3 months ago
I cried when I heard this. Man you are just incredible. You play with so much emotion!!!
MrGeorgios2020 3 months ago
@MrGeorgios2020 Thanks, it's a nice compliment!
thrip 3 months ago
Show-off! Whew - nice!
teedlebomb1 5 months ago
1:31 - 1:36 what scale are you playing? sounds phenomenal! i have to say honestly that this is one of the most beautiful playing ive heard in my life. thank you very much, greetings from earth :)
LaWey 5 months ago
@LaWey Thanks a lot! That is a Bb diminished arpeggio ascending over an A7 chord, and a descending D harmonic minor scale over a Dm chord. Glad you like it.
thrip 5 months ago
Absolute trance!! Cant see ur face are u R.Fripp??
praveerchandra 5 months ago
magic !
guitarquejamais 5 months ago
There are aspects of this very similar to Summertime aren't there? Very well played 21st century Schizoid man.
gtrfinger 6 months ago
dropping silver stones on a sundial....
teledan105 6 months ago
Keep at it 'Fisto' your 'big break' is just around the corner !
alzoom007 7 months ago
This is pretty impressive. Full of subtle harmonic and rhythmic nuances. Refreshing jazz approach, but remains tender and heartfelt.
Excellent.
kapitanswing 7 months ago
Great interpretation. Beautiful, infact.
I'm sure Fripp would approve. ;-)
DjangoMan1963 7 months ago
Comment removed
shuttlem 7 months ago
Some elements were nicely performed but others not so, a waltzy baseline segment in a melodic wistful piece like this one (please?) ! More alarming though was your righthand technique which unfortunately is sadly flawed with that very stiff (and ugly) 'fisto' approach to the strings.. the viewing (and ear)experience was sort of akin to watching someone with a clubbed foot attempting to play football - Sorry :]
alzoom007 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@alzoom007 maybe the viewing and (ear) experience for alzoom007 was more akin to a deaf and dumb kid watching you tube, commenting wildly with his thumb up his arse.
shuttlem 7 months ago
Comment removed
kapitanswing 7 months ago
@alzoom007 Can you explain what you mean by flawed right hand technique...better still could you show us all how to play with the 'correct' right hand technique? I'm assuming you are an authority on the subject? I look forward to you posting something....
NWheelerGuitar 7 months ago
@NWheelerGuitar Yep not a problem.. making a fist when holding the pick ie not extending or showing the 2nd 3rd & 4th fingers with the righthand restricts wrist extension and also interferes with the movement of the pick over the strings . If you listen closely to this example you will note that the wrist is so clenched that these fingers actually mute articulation of the sweep execution..
alzoom007 7 months ago
@NWheelerGuitar Thrip's jazz tuitor probably mentioned this in the same sentence where 'ugly' hand positions were discussed - or ought to have been ! I'll be posting my own Master Class video shortly.. in betweens try viewing the examplary righthand technique of such Jazz Legends as Charlie Christian, Joe Pass & Larry Carlton while you're here :}
alzoom007 7 months ago
@alzoom007 OK I look forward to seeing that! Yes I agree Joe Pass had incredible right hand technique as I recall he used to 'Gyspy Pick' i.e do a down stroke for every new string I believe he used to curl his fingers in (or as you call it a 'fist' technique) like thrip too! I hadn't realized there was any footage of Charlie Christian to look at his right hand technique....
NWheelerGuitar 7 months ago
@alzoom007 you're a twat.
Romane seems to be doing fine with the same "flawed technique".
This is beautiful playing Tim!
londonbige 6 months ago
@londonbige .. Tim a friend of yours is he ?.. your impartiality is as touching as it is ill-informed !
alzoom007 6 months ago
Some elements were nicely performed but others not so, a waltzy baseline segment in a melodic wistful piece like this one (please?) ! More alarming though was your righthand technique which unfortunately is sadly flawed with that very stiff (and ugly) 'fisto' approach to the strings.. the viewing experience was sort of akin to watching someone with a clubbed foot attempting to play football - Sorry :]
alzoom007 7 months ago
@alzoom007
Your comment is simply laughable! I'd stick to watching Australia's Got Talent if i were you.
kapitanswing 7 months ago
Nice Job!!!
gibder1117 7 months ago
Great job! do you have any tabs for this? Thanks
djsparkyful 9 months ago
@djsparkyful sorry, no tabs
thrip 9 months ago
Awesome!!!!
TwinSparx3005 9 months ago
Awesome!!!!
TwinSparx3005 9 months ago
awesome
BoxCubeSquare 10 months ago
you have an awesome tone!
trilobite3339 10 months ago
Superb, simply superb. Is it played in standard tuning? I might give it a try one day : )
nefryl 10 months ago
@nefryl Thanks! Yes it's standard tuning.
thrip 10 months ago
@nefryl very nice, superb stands for king crimson, this guy is just a fan and he does it good but i rather never play monchild like this,
ALanSaidTrujillo 9 months ago
@ALanSaidTrujillo
Oh I know that, I just find his interpretation really interesting and I loved it as fan of jazzy melodies (I can't say I'm jazz fan) Long live the King
nefryl 9 months ago
WOW WOW WOW WOW WOW!!!
Lightmane321 1 year ago
real nice.
steeltunes 1 year ago
Awsome version, good depth with the reverberation. I could recognise Jango- manouche and bossa chords! You are not an amateur WTF are you doing on youtube, ??..Anyway thanks for posting it..
BDeiste 1 year ago
@BDeiste Just killing time until my big break ;-)
thrip 1 year ago
Oh, god, this is superb. I wish to learn to play this song someday soon...
ilovecheesyguitars 1 year ago
THIS IS INSPIRING!!!
Thanx Mr. Tim Robinson
eldiokan 1 year ago
THIS IS INSPIRING!!!
Thanx Mr. Tim Ribonson
eldiokan 1 year ago
Fantastic Cover !!
MrZee1967 1 year ago
Beatiful
cerpintaxt92 1 year ago
hey man ! great sound you have ! what was the amp ?
jroberto1994 1 year ago
@jroberto1994 Thanks! Amp was a AER Compact 60
thrip 1 year ago
So great, very nice job.
zEsker 1 year ago
hands down the best rendition of this song i've ever heard! I would love to play that! Keep on going man.
EldonFonseca 1 year ago 2
@EldonFonseca Thanks! I have another KC cover in progress, check back soon!
thrip 1 year ago
Truly inspiring my friend...fantastic playing and wonderful guitar tones! I have a 1954 175 with 2 P90's...love it so much!
undergroundjohnny 1 year ago
@undergroundjohnny Thanks a lot! An ES175D eh? Nice!
thrip 1 year ago
WOW! This is amazing. I love your playing and arrangement! Thank you for this beautiful post! I am just learning the guitar, one year into it now, and this is completely inspiring! I might take my post down now and redo it! Wow. This is brilliant. min :-)
practicing4 1 year ago
Can you do epitaph as well? :3
You're way too good man.
Makksor 1 year ago 2
wow i love your cover!
andrewjeff 1 year ago
crimson jazz!! \m/
DeathCalamaro 1 year ago 2
great performance.....great song
anorimos68 1 year ago
@Moonchild042 thanks a lot for your nice comment!
thrip 1 year ago
awesome really nice listneing
darkfoxxy1 1 year ago
Very nice. Thank you!
PeteTownshendFanatic 1 year ago
veeery nice!
janisbliz 1 year ago
are you able to tab this?
such a good version of it and all the other versions aren't detailed enough for someone with as bad aural skills as me!
laycox 1 year ago
@laycox thanks! i haven't tabbed it as yet, sorry. Have you looked on the Elephant Talk website? the one on there is ok
thrip 1 year ago
Amazing job, man!
Congratulations!
emano05 1 year ago
very nice, lovely sounding guitar
daveshaw18 1 year ago
it's a dream!
pfMaya 1 year ago
Muy Bueno Thrip ! (from Buenos Aires
rejtmand 1 year ago
nice really nice man, good mix of jazz with it
necrogrinder666 1 year ago
Very nice version.
Otowa56 1 year ago
beautiful
Elmore3141 1 year ago
such nice tone. awesome man. thanks!
InMusthband 1 year ago
@InMusthband thanks, nice comment!
thrip 1 year ago
Thats a great solo jazz kind of version of it.
Rambo29 1 year ago
Watched your video again and really love what you did with the tune. Have you ever thought about using flatwounds? Tomastek-Infeld makes one of the only pure nickel wrap sets like all the cats always used. They sound great.
veeshead 1 year ago
Fantastic job! Your 53 is super clean. Much cleaner than my 54. So funny that someone wants "tabs" of this. You got the guy's hands right there in front of you playing it. Figure it out!
veeshead 1 year ago
@veeshead thanks, there's nothing like a P90 175!
thrip 1 year ago
brilliant
dane4free 1 year ago
awesome! really nice cover :]
wassermeister 2 years ago
This is beautiful
Bagas 2 years ago
That's So Amazing !!
Love It !!!
Travis1969 2 years ago
Amazing interpretation, adds even more to an already brilliant song! Tahnks for putting online!
Schwertgosch 2 years ago 2
Cheers, nice comment!
thrip 2 years ago
VERY nicely done. I like how you've incorporated your influences.
placidothecat 2 years ago
Thanks :-)
thrip 2 years ago
Amazing, you are the best semi-acoustic player i heard so far =) could you please put some tablature of this online? I visited your site, but couldn't find it.
tghick 2 years ago
Thanks! No tabs as yet, sorry.
thrip 2 years ago
this sounds fucking amazing man! goddamn i wanna play like this some day!
seanlukas 2 years ago
thanks!
thrip 2 years ago
bravooo!! bravisiimoo!! kudos to youuuu!!! :o
davydyyz 2 years ago
Thank you!
thrip 2 years ago
Wow, you really made an amazing song out of Moonchild (sorry, I believe King Crimson are way overrated and apart from a couple of their songs/compositions I don't really enjoy their albums). Amazing job, great Djangoesque moments inbetween.
leozingy 2 years ago
Thanks! I almost agree with you about KC. Their albums are generally a mixture of amazing and cringeworthy! More the former than the latter though imo.
thrip 2 years ago
Wonderful! Very jazzy.
pyroseed13 2 years ago
Thanks!
thrip 2 years ago
Excellent stuff, you did a nice job turning this crimson tune into something with reminiscences of Gershwin and other jazzy influences.
hyperboreal 2 years ago
Hi Alex, I'm very glad you like it! Thanks for listening.
thrip 2 years ago
now this sound's great
joeycanodezo 2 years ago
Thanks, much appreciated.
thrip 2 years ago
Amazing guitar and amazing guitar player
TseeBaeng 2 years ago
Beautiful guitar! I always get a laugh when I hear those diminished sweeps too. It's like the universal way of saying "I like Django".
AtlasTravis 2 years ago 7
Exelent in every way
kitsune10000 2 years ago
Thanks. Glad you like it!
thrip 2 years ago