Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (28)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is the first time I heard this concerto spiritually performed by Jewish musicians with eternal beauty.

    Tse Tse !

  • 歌词:

    东方红,太阳升, 中国出了个毛泽东

    他为人民谋幸福

    他是人民大救星

    他为人民谋幸福

    毛主席,爱人民

    他是我们的带路人

    ~~~~~~~~~~

  • such a lovely lady :)

  • This is a fine rendition of the YRC. I've just come back from Beijing and heard it twice at the NCPA there. Chinese audiences love it! One performance was with a "Chinese" orchestra rather than a Western orchestra: the traditional instruments give a whole new dimension of tonecolour to the concerto and make the last mvmt especially more exciting.

  • I have just discovered this piece and played Nadia's rendition first 4 movements. A great performance! That said, this concerto's parts are greater than its sum. To me it comes across as a hodge-podge of beautiful vignettes that left me unsatisfied overall. Not much Chinese about it really - sort of reminds me of the old stereotype of Japan/China stealing parts from the West and gluing tham together to make something to hang their flag on.

  • @edgey4u that's because chinese music is almost exactly what you think of it as. It's pentatonic (well, we have micro-tones, but since this is written in western notation, no micro tones) and it's asian, congratulations sherlock.

  • 太慢了

  • @goldsilverpenguin well, i think she is quite strengthful as a lady!!

    you can't compare her with Lang lang after all, he is a much bigger and stronger guy :P

  • The Yellow River Piano Concerto - Nadia Weintraub: 4th mov."Defend the Yellow River"

    NadiaWeintraub 25 videos Subscribe

  • @ac3761G The Yellow River Piano Concerto - Nadia Weintraub: 4th mov."Defend the Yellow River"

    NadiaWeintraub 25 videos Subscribe

    ==2011417apcac==

  • Boy oh boy, does she look uncomfortable in that piano seat and with heels, like

    a straight-jacket in the dress. My favorite piano concerto. Lang Lang looks more natural playing it. Brass here wasn't exactly with the tempo.

  • @TheDoninwhiting Uncomfortable maybe but lovely and passionate, definately!

  • Well.so-so...

  • shes rather slouched

  • Love the marching part of the music.

  • it's very slow version.,,

  • Sounds like a practising version....

  • Great fun; great performance - of the only piano concerto ever to be composed by a committee! Thanks for posting.

  • I am touched because the pianist is trying hard to present the beautiful of this work although there is somehow lack of chinese emotion. Good work!

  • so fuuuuuny! :)))))

  • Technically good. But lack of chinese national emotion.

  • Far more stately than Yang Yang! And prettier!

  • Wow! Fantastic! Greetings from China.

  • Bravo!

    Kudos to Nadia Weintraub, Yi-An Xu, Herzliya Chamber Orchestra, and Israel !

  • Very powerful. Where is this performance?

  • This is really wonderful. Your pianism is superb, very good articulation and much feeling. I do hope this work achieves more visibility as time goes on. The melodies are beautiful and the work is rich with arpeggios, octaves and scale work.... piano in all its glory.

  • אלוהים איזו יצירה,מקורית וחדשנית,והביצוע של נדיה באמת מעבר לכל דמיון.והכל בעל פה!!!עוד הרבה כבוד היא תביא לארצנו.

  • Superb!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more