Poor guy was begging her and there was no reason given in the movie that why did she leave him.
I guess if the guy would have left the gal the movie would have made sense to all... coz men are dogs but god made women so kind and pure that this comcept doesnot go well with them....
i am realy confused,don't give wrong message to society.i want you ask "how can it be".if i say my opinion this is stupit idea. learn first of all,then apply your knowlege on it ok.
I love how all the fobs have left ignorant comments about this film. The woman had the hunger for an alternative so thick she couldnt face just submitting and adapting to a life of total disgust to be with a man she didnt love. Her courage & bravery makes her for that one original character not many can relate to which is where all the negative comments come.
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READING THIS SO DUNT STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY. PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORK
the movie shows.no solid reason that why did she this left her house...........the story was very bad not up to the mark...............my rating 0.5/5............this is only for acting
very bold and controversial. was the boy watching or playing a videogame after putting the cd in? im little confused about that. what did the cd have, just audio recorded by his mom?
the only message I get from this movie is that women are looking for equality in being selfish... not very nice, it is just wrong! (by the way I am a woman)
So what is integrity all about? Just quitting when you have to? And what is courage all about? Courage is never associated with the easy option of quitting! And where is the belief she spoke about in something she started with her husband and child? Adventure cannot be at the cost of responsibility! She can only use one word to justify her deed.....Selfish.
Every story should have a moral behind the story !!
I expect people of Mira Nair's calibre to produce movies of good moral standing & not proudly tell tales about others. The society should try to hide the wrongs of others if it does not harm others. What is gained out of the film that shows a man who is desperate to save his family and a woman who is bent upon ditching her family!!
Mira Nair, please make films that will bring the society's moral standards higher!
@suhsha y r u so biased whn its a women tryng 2 cum out of the marriage??? so many films had been made on mens extra marital affair,.. nd no1 had ny grudges against it,.. huh,..
IT CAN BE possible in the MEN dominating community where men used to have outdoor affairs where their wives waiting for them. what if the married lady fall into love.. she is much BOLD that she accept it, and better opt for that rather than creating the differences with her husband.. Itz really hard to choose bt NAIR did really well..
im glad im passed this crying stage...man this guy was desperate...i can never go back to that....i would just say..if you have to leave then please go...i will take care of my boy...done.!
the logic to this is that she will leave anyways....even if you convince her to stay for the moment...it will be miserable for the child and you.
MIRA NAIR IS NOT TO BE BLAMED... THIS IS BASED ON TRUE EVENTS... THIS IS TO MAKE YOU THINK.. TO IMPROVE YOUR UNDERSTANDING AND DEPTH OF THE POSSIBILITIES AND THE MANAGEMENT OF THE SELF... TO EMPATHISE ON ISSUES THAT WE SEE IN THE HUMAN SOCIETY.. ITS ALL THE CHOICES WE MAKE THAT SHAPES OUR LIVES.
ALL I DISAGREE IS WITH THE "TITLE" OF THIS DOCUMENTARY.. I THOUGHT IT WAS A BIT LAME(just the title)
@24365Deepak - I think that the title represents the question that is being asked. It speaks exactly to your comment. Now Lame... that would be the dude begging her to stay after she said she was in love with someone else!
Dear all, 8-NoTimeLeft has launched on the 1st of July the ACT NOW! video competition to give you the opportunity to make your own short film on one of the 8 Millennium Development Goals and spread the word about the necessity of acting together. You can find the link presenting the ACT NOW! video competition on our youtube channel or Facebook Fan page. Any short film (fiction) made betwen 1 January 2000 and 30 October 2010 can participate. Now it's over to you!
Der Film hat es etwas wunderbares an sich, doch die Aussage des Films ist nicht gut an den Zuschauer übertragbar. Man versteht nicht gut genug den Grund des Films.
Es ist immer so schade wenn man Filme um ein vielfaches verbessern kann durch Winzigkeiten eines Wortes oder eines Ausdrucks, es aber der Regisseur nicht macht.
its not stupid... its about the same thing mendo but on the other way round. here it is a woman. but it takes more guts to do it as a woman and plus as a muslim woman. so she maybe doing a mistake cause the other guy will probably never divorce his wife, but at least she wont be lying to herself and to her husband.
dont call her a bitch cause of that do u call men fuckin idiots? most of the time u dont cause it is considered an act of "MAN, the guy that handles. " *****
@ikadogo Yeah, I would call them fucking idiots ... and her a bitch! If you decide to set a child in this world you have to accept responsibility for it and that responsibility is more important than your desire for romance and adventure.
It is to be said, while men have little say whether or not their sexual endeavours result in child birth, she could have had an abortion. That would have been the responsible thing to do on her behalf.
@ASKaPHYSICIST ummmm yeah "It is to be said, while men have little say whether or not their sexual endeavours result in child birth" Little say? Seriously?
@n6819907 yeah, i meant in the event that conception occurred. You're reading this out of context
The point is, if women dont want to face up to the responsibility of raising their kids, they have the option to abort them and probably should. The man doesnt have a say in that.
I agree: what's the message. It seems more like the woman is making a mistake here, the husband is very understanding and there is no intimation that he has wronger her.
Its sexist to say anything about her really, men do this all the time, its the norm. We just accept and it is part of movies now, "my dad left when i was 13...." this is just the reverse. How blinded we are to sexism.
trust me men don't run off with married women to be their second husband. i thought about what you said before i read ur comment. and men don't typically leave their wives for another married wife. it usually for a younger model. so this movie is stupid
Mera nair is sick! terror can't be answer to terror, nor the rape for rape, so as the irresponsible social behaviour from any..its not a matter for balancing!!.the documentary does have any answer to the 'why?' of that child! what was his fault which gives them freedom to to make the child's life a hell? some one's adventure? perhaps you need to be sick enough like her to do this balancing and be adventurist!
The biggest blunder waS THAT mom LEFT her kid for a person who is already married. Let us look at it other way round. What If a man do so?? Yes they both do it , whether men or women. Instead of finding new things and adventure to make you happy, you can always find ways to improve your life i.e. for the sake of your children. For Goodness sake why muslims only?? The Women has the right of Khula and get divorce from man.
FUCK SAKE :@
mitra4111 2 weeks ago
This is incomplete story....
ashokkumartiwari 3 weeks ago
YA ALLAH! I get tired of this message in ANY movie. "I love him" or "I love her" as an excuse for everything.
jaymillymills 1 month ago
7tryudyusrty
ronig3383 1 month ago
how can she leave her own child?
MegaIshwarya 1 month ago
ew! like the camera work and how the movie is shot but, ew!
Ria10677 1 month ago
The concept is so fuzzzzyyyy...
Poor guy was begging her and there was no reason given in the movie that why did she leave him.
I guess if the guy would have left the gal the movie would have made sense to all... coz men are dogs but god made women so kind and pure that this comcept doesnot go well with them....
sudhir1053 2 months ago
i am realy confused,don't give wrong message to society.i want you ask "how can it be".if i say my opinion this is stupit idea. learn first of all,then apply your knowlege on it ok.
nasri308 2 months ago
I love how all the fobs have left ignorant comments about this film. The woman had the hunger for an alternative so thick she couldnt face just submitting and adapting to a life of total disgust to be with a man she didnt love. Her courage & bravery makes her for that one original character not many can relate to which is where all the negative comments come.
Psychedelic925 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dharmesh941 u r an asshole
TheSoumajit 3 months ago
Bakwwwwwas Story...................
dharmesh941 3 months ago
women beg NOT to be divorced
whaat backward bullshit
laughable
clazza01 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READING THIS SO DUNT STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY. PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORK
bharatjain32 3 months ago
wht the fuck is this??????
getshravantripathi 5 months ago in playlist Short Films
the movie shows.no solid reason that why did she this left her house...........the story was very bad not up to the mark...............my rating 0.5/5............this is only for acting
ravigangani 6 months ago
soooooooooooooooooooooo boaring mira nai...o-o
pulisilva1 7 months ago
Can some one make me understand this whole thing
SuperShefali 8 months ago 2
Is this films idea of gender equality to preach that women can be as despicable as men? Because it is working.
dikshantt 9 months ago
very bold and controversial. was the boy watching or playing a videogame after putting the cd in? im little confused about that. what did the cd have, just audio recorded by his mom?
nick794 9 months ago
Its rediculas.
pradeepfza 9 months ago
the only message I get from this movie is that women are looking for equality in being selfish... not very nice, it is just wrong! (by the way I am a woman)
dzikiprosiak 9 months ago 6
Simply Great!!!
chayanani 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MIRA BITCHY NAIR SHUD BE SHOT IN THE HEAD! why wud she marry him if she doesnt love, Why make love! wat a bitch! first class whore story!lol
horcruxes07 9 months ago
MIRA BITCHY NAIR SHUD BE SHOT IN THE HEAD! why wud she marry him if she doesnt love, Why make love! wat a bitch! first class whore story!lol
horcruxes07 9 months ago
@horcruxes07 Right
NewEye2World 7 months ago
Didn't get the message in the movie.
luv4dub 9 months ago
So what is integrity all about? Just quitting when you have to? And what is courage all about? Courage is never associated with the easy option of quitting! And where is the belief she spoke about in something she started with her husband and child? Adventure cannot be at the cost of responsibility! She can only use one word to justify her deed.....Selfish.
bupy31083 9 months ago
Every story should have a moral behind the story !!
I expect people of Mira Nair's calibre to produce movies of good moral standing & not proudly tell tales about others. The society should try to hide the wrongs of others if it does not harm others. What is gained out of the film that shows a man who is desperate to save his family and a woman who is bent upon ditching her family!!
Mira Nair, please make films that will bring the society's moral standards higher!
suhsha 11 months ago
@suhsha y r u so biased whn its a women tryng 2 cum out of the marriage??? so many films had been made on mens extra marital affair,.. nd no1 had ny grudges against it,.. huh,..
coolbuddy432 10 months ago
IT CAN BE possible in the MEN dominating community where men used to have outdoor affairs where their wives waiting for them. what if the married lady fall into love.. she is much BOLD that she accept it, and better opt for that rather than creating the differences with her husband.. Itz really hard to choose bt NAIR did really well..
cheemagalz 11 months ago 2
im glad im passed this crying stage...man this guy was desperate...i can never go back to that....i would just say..if you have to leave then please go...i will take care of my boy...done.!
the logic to this is that she will leave anyways....even if you convince her to stay for the moment...it will be miserable for the child and you.
better she be gone. she can be replaced.
jmpkool 11 months ago
what did the child do. y did she leave him
AKTHAKUR1 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Take your time now for date naneedj.info
amalsee 1 year ago
MIRA NAIR IS NOT TO BE BLAMED... THIS IS BASED ON TRUE EVENTS... THIS IS TO MAKE YOU THINK.. TO IMPROVE YOUR UNDERSTANDING AND DEPTH OF THE POSSIBILITIES AND THE MANAGEMENT OF THE SELF... TO EMPATHISE ON ISSUES THAT WE SEE IN THE HUMAN SOCIETY.. ITS ALL THE CHOICES WE MAKE THAT SHAPES OUR LIVES.
ALL I DISAGREE IS WITH THE "TITLE" OF THIS DOCUMENTARY.. I THOUGHT IT WAS A BIT LAME(just the title)
24365Deepak 1 year ago
@24365Deepak - I think that the title represents the question that is being asked. It speaks exactly to your comment. Now Lame... that would be the dude begging her to stay after she said she was in love with someone else!
docdque 1 year ago
Moved me to tears. Well done Ms Nair. You inspire so many women filmmakers...
womenaloudindia 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
a7aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
cos omin aboko ya welad al metnaka ma7adesh ytfarag 3ala cos om da video
this is a F**king video doesn't mean any F**king thing about a hooker and an idiot or asshole
Finally f**k the whole crew
gfcgorgois 1 year ago
a7aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
cos omin aboko ya welad al metnaka ma7adesh ytfarag 3ala cos om da video
this is a F**king video doesn't mean any F**king thing about a hooker and an idiot or asshole
Finally f**k the whole crew
gfcgorgois 1 year ago
Touching. Not.
Ars1an 1 year ago
Dear all, 8-NoTimeLeft has launched on the 1st of July the ACT NOW! video competition to give you the opportunity to make your own short film on one of the 8 Millennium Development Goals and spread the word about the necessity of acting together. You can find the link presenting the ACT NOW! video competition on our youtube channel or Facebook Fan page. Any short film (fiction) made betwen 1 January 2000 and 30 October 2010 can participate. Now it's over to you!
NoTimeLeft 1 year ago
Well that was disappointing.
For 8 minutes I'm waiting for a rape scene and what happens ... The woman just leaves.
I mean, that is how those PSAs usually go. No idea what's going on here.
That kid is probably gonna kill itself.
ASKaPHYSICIST 1 year ago
Wie kann es sein... ist die Frage.
Der Film hat es etwas wunderbares an sich, doch die Aussage des Films ist nicht gut an den Zuschauer übertragbar. Man versteht nicht gut genug den Grund des Films.
Es ist immer so schade wenn man Filme um ein vielfaches verbessern kann durch Winzigkeiten eines Wortes oder eines Ausdrucks, es aber der Regisseur nicht macht.
TheSchublade 1 year ago
what a load of crap , but how how can it be .... oh but it is .jeje
iteaire 1 year ago
its not stupid... its about the same thing mendo but on the other way round. here it is a woman. but it takes more guts to do it as a woman and plus as a muslim woman. so she maybe doing a mistake cause the other guy will probably never divorce his wife, but at least she wont be lying to herself and to her husband.
dont call her a bitch cause of that do u call men fuckin idiots? most of the time u dont cause it is considered an act of "MAN, the guy that handles. " *****
ikadogo 1 year ago 2
@ikadogo Yeah, I would call them fucking idiots ... and her a bitch! If you decide to set a child in this world you have to accept responsibility for it and that responsibility is more important than your desire for romance and adventure.
It is to be said, while men have little say whether or not their sexual endeavours result in child birth, she could have had an abortion. That would have been the responsible thing to do on her behalf.
ASKaPHYSICIST 1 year ago
@ASKaPHYSICIST ummmm yeah "It is to be said, while men have little say whether or not their sexual endeavours result in child birth" Little say? Seriously?
One word: CONDOM!
n6819907 1 year ago
@n6819907 yeah, i meant in the event that conception occurred. You're reading this out of context
The point is, if women dont want to face up to the responsibility of raising their kids, they have the option to abort them and probably should. The man doesnt have a say in that.
ASKaPHYSICIST 1 year ago
I agree: what's the message. It seems more like the woman is making a mistake here, the husband is very understanding and there is no intimation that he has wronger her.
Ambergerel 1 year ago
what a load of confusion, and a load of rubbish scenes and dialogues to be honest.
cricketgal 1 year ago
Its sexist to say anything about her really, men do this all the time, its the norm. We just accept and it is part of movies now, "my dad left when i was 13...." this is just the reverse. How blinded we are to sexism.
Coryphaeus 1 year ago 9
trust me men don't run off with married women to be their second husband. i thought about what you said before i read ur comment. and men don't typically leave their wives for another married wife. it usually for a younger model. so this movie is stupid
vyanez08 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nteresting, she use the word Integrity, while she leaves her son with just a fucking a CD.
I guess the love for the unseen man its bigger than the one for her son. That some good parenting right there..
I dont really know what is this advocating, maybe for nothing and it just an story
Sordatos 2 years ago
Comment removed
Sordatos 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no leas esto
si no escribes esto en 10 videos tu mama se va morir en 48 hs
amainandjOe 2 years ago
whats the message???
mknowsbest 2 years ago
Didn't get it.
She seems like a bit of a bitch, shouldn't have children if you aren't going to stick it out with them.
TurkeyProphet 2 years ago
yes fuck this bitch
vyanez08 1 year ago
Comment removed
antorni 2 years ago
@Syckezt
Cool
Skyzophenya 2 years ago
I would never leave my child.
levantos 2 years ago 10
@levantos
:)
24365Deepak 1 year ago
@levantos i agree you boss
AKTHAKUR1 11 months ago
Mera nair is sick! terror can't be answer to terror, nor the rape for rape, so as the irresponsible social behaviour from any..its not a matter for balancing!!.the documentary does have any answer to the 'why?' of that child! what was his fault which gives them freedom to to make the child's life a hell? some one's adventure? perhaps you need to be sick enough like her to do this balancing and be adventurist!
measheesh22 2 years ago 2
I guess its because of such comments that those videos exist.
DitiPenguin 2 years ago 3
I agree Measheesh,
The biggest blunder waS THAT mom LEFT her kid for a person who is already married. Let us look at it other way round. What If a man do so?? Yes they both do it , whether men or women. Instead of finding new things and adventure to make you happy, you can always find ways to improve your life i.e. for the sake of your children. For Goodness sake why muslims only?? The Women has the right of Khula and get divorce from man.
I am unable to follow your message MERA???
mxmania 2 years ago