Added: 2 years ago
From: whoakittykat
Views: 65,747
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (147)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she should have been in the finals!

  • she does it too wave-ry in voice.

    she changes pitch too much

  • This season is filled with greatest female talents all of them are great i would have put all girls to top 10 instead os Tim,Aaron, and micheal lynche

    and put Lily Scott, Michelle Delamor and Katelyn Epperly or Haeley Vaughn

  • Looks eerily like Pris from Blade Runner.

  • Andrew, Tim, Aaron, Casey, Lacey, and Paige were all a huge waste of space. I would have thrown all of them aside to get Lilly in the top 12.

  • Lilly should've gone farther than Paige and Lacey. I'm proud of Lilly, she's amazing.

  • this song sucks

  • @robzombay72 how about you go sucka penis

  • She almost good enough for the original and thats pretty darn good! plus, shes gorgeous!

  • Gosh.

    She rocked.

  • lily was AMAZING she has RAW TALENT she was AMAZING!!!! like her voice is soo original and it is beautiful!!

  • I personally think it is an absolute joke that she was eliminated so early on, but with Idol I have learned personally to expect illogical voting patterns and to be surprised when practical voting is applied. Any one who always seems to be outside the box in terms of originality and keeps it real, rather than being all syrupy and predictable, always seems to go unfairly early, Which in my opinion makes the program an overall fail.

  • Lilly shouldn't have gotten voted off! IMO she's way better than Paige, Katie, and Lacey.

  • After Lilly was sent home by the admirers of Tim Urban the no-singer, Simon's hero from zero, then Tim could become the new American Idol.

  • Do some Eva Cassidy girl....you ROCK!!! Idol is too shallow for you. You're gonna find your own niche. Best of luck!

  • HEy Guy's Lilly has a facebook acoount , search Official Lilly Scott . Run by our dearest idol herself . Lilly !! add her s your friend , ayt ? thanks

  • HEy Guy's Lilly has a facebook acoount , search Official Lilly Scott . thanks

  • i love lilly :) :) :) :)

  • She sooooooooooooooooooo should have made the top 12!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Go lilly shes he best out of all of them she left :( she is so cool

    she dident deserve to go.she shoud win :)

    but when as between kaite her i new it i knew it but i dident want to beleve it

    :(

  • yes,I agree that Lilly got robbed! I am a 54 year old who does know Patsy Cline and did vote for Lilly many times. There should have been a judges Save Card played at this stage of the show too, Keep stayin true to your music! Post on the intenet!

  • Just hope some label scoops her up ... she was too good to fade into oblivion

  • she was my favorite. Can't believe it took soo long for Paige to be eliminated.

  • Her leave made me not watch the rest of the season (and what's left), I'll probably check the finale to see what a dumb choice they made, but no way can I watch the show each week knowing the BEST of this season was eliminated so early. Proof the system is flawed, it should be judges decision on who goes/stays. Most of America obviously doesn't know what they're doing, keeping Paige and Garcia in and eliminating Lily Scott, what a joke.

  • She has some great originals on here now. Just do a search for Lilly Scott edgewater coffee shop

  • Its bullshit that that Page girl and the girl with the wolf eyes was still there!! I never wouldve thought theyd send her home.. I just home she puts out a record!!

  • Lilly, you are still my number 1! I hope someone gives you a record deal soon b/c I'm gettin' tired of listening to just these 4 tunes over and over! Good luck, girl - You are amaZING! BluesMaman.

  • ridiculous that she is not still on the show. RIDICULOUS.

  • unfortunately any redneck with a cell phone can vote. that means you

  • Redneck lol Im far off from being one.

  • I think they should use the Judge's Save to bring Lilly back!

  • it wasn't in play yet. we were like an episode away from it coming in to play.

  • idiot judges save only works for top 12 and above!

  • I would have bought her music :(

    To think I had hope to today's music :/

  • lilly should have continued, but no, this guy tim had to stay, and he doesn't even sing at all!

  • Cant belive shes not there anymore,some of the survivors SUCK bring her back!!!!!

  • She kinda looks like the girl from Blade Runner.

  • this girl sings better than siobhan and crystal

  • why didnt she stay ? UGH!

  • Lilly is by far more talented than Lacey and a few others. Tough break that she didn't get enough votes.

  • I love Lily. I thought she should have stayed.

  • Great voice. Unique style. Indie meets jazz.

  • Lily is the best ever THANK YOU for posting this! O:)

  • Lilly wasn't voted off. The producers fixed it and got rid of her because they didn't want her splitting votes with Siobhan and Crystal.

  • I like this!

  • Unique talent, I liked what she did with Patsy Cline but a little too sophisticated for the American audience. "Me finks" she will do well in the music industry.

  • She deserved to stay! Stupid girl beat her.. I hated that other girl.

  • Sorry i ment to give it a thumbs up :)

  • @Aoi1290 Agree. It is because America listenes to judges and not to the singers.

  • I'm not watching anymore.

  • me and my sister to

  • I can;t believe lily was voted off America Idol last week. She has an unusual sound and is so talented. I don't think that America got it right!

  • the BEST

  • America is completely stupid...Lily was the best singer from the girls! the show is boring without her now.

  • She is so awesome i love her!!!! <3

  • her and alex were two of my favorites.

    they would be people i would listen too.

    then again, most things i listen to aren't exactly on the radio.

    :\

  • I looooved alex's voice soo much too.. and lilly was just amazing.

  • Comment removed

  • I'm pissed that she had to leave.

    Katie is an unmature, and terrible singer compared to Lily.

    She deserved to stay.

    I hope she comes back next year.

    ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

  • @TheMorningValentine

    too bad she can't because she made the top 24. D:

  • Shes 28. She can't.

    D:

  • No. Lilly is only 20.

  • Katie is a great singer, and its not her fault that she beat her but if anyone should go home on the girls side, its Paige Miles,although you are right Lilly is 10 times better than Katie.

  • fuck katie,that what i hate most ,american votes for bullcrapping glamour more than a real talent..indeed it not katie fault but stoopid teenager..since daughtry,then lambert and now lilly scott..i just hope chrystal or didi made it..not like the others junk...it time american idol made a real change to find the real talent...decrease the viewer's vote.power to the judge...dont worry lilly,,you're great than american themselves...

  • I wouldn't go THAT far...

  • i agree Katie was acctually my least faveorite on the show lilly was the top person i wanted to win

    i hope she either comes back or someone signs her and she's famous

    (but to me shes already famous)

  • @TheMorningValentine : "unmature"?

  • A travesty she has gone in favour of Katie (what?!)

  • she was one of my favorites.!

    cant beleive she got voted off :(

    PS: this song was my fav performance by her :)

  • i cant believe it eith =/

  • What a huge mistake! Lilly and Alex off. I just don't get it............BUT, I would get their cd's if someone is smart enough to launch their singing careers.

  • i liked her too, but be reasonable....most of the voters are grade school & junior high school girls. heck, my neice used to vote 20+ times a week when she was 8. it's a show for teeny boppers, not adult musical hipsters. right?

  • KATIE SUX BIG TIME. She is way off key, she is young and needs more blossoming, she should have not beaten out Lilly Scott!!! I just hope she made enough impression for some label or band to notice her to take her much higher in life.

  • Thanks for making this video. I am so sad and angry that this most talented artist was voted off. She is the best1

  • It's quite simple why she didnt make it... she didnt fit the mold. Im surprised people dont realize it. Yeah, she was a fav of mine as well. But none of my favs you'll ever hear on the radio. The best music is never heared by the general public. The business is all about disposable music. For those of you still in the dark, watch the Johnny Bravo episode of the Brady Bunch..... That's the music ndustry in a nut shell.

  • america is crazy!! LILLY was the best and most original on the show this season

  • Why is she gone? She was the most original and best of the season. Please, someone give her a record deal, she would be such a hit.

  • Alex and Lilly off? LOL! Caps off this season, for sure.

  • Comment removed

  • have boycotted the show. lily was my favorite. america is afraid of originality, and it fucking sucks that canadians cant vote, because lily would still be there.

    i fucking hate how goddamn closed minded the americans are. FUCK YOU.

  • @JAJohnson, Sorry you hate me, haha... cause I am American. But I sadly agree with you. I listen to more bands in EU than in my own country. Radio sux, even 98% of digital satellite sux and not worth buying. Thank god for MP3 players where I can put several my own albums on it to last me throughout the day.

  • she is better than katie but michael is going to win

  • She should have made it. Not that Katy isn't good, but Lily is SO much better. If anything, that red haired girl shouldve got voted off.

  • I can't believe that Katy got to stay. I mean some people MUST be smoking the crack pipe or something. I love Lilly.

  • i know right! katie sucks! lilly,alex,and kaitlyn deserved to stay.WTF!

  • i'm sooooo upset...why was she voted off the show tonight?!!!...she has one of the most unique voices i have ever heard.

  • why the hell was she kicked off?

  • simon is such a turd to say that crystal has more power!  i still like crystal...

  • i love her voice! >)

  • my favorite!!!! of the girls. she should definately win

  • Ur a dick for only posting part of the song.

  • they only sing a part of the song...i don't think it was actually cut off...the other videos only run a few seconds longer...

  • Unique artist, charming and oh my gaaaaawd drop dead sexy!~ Great new artist A.I. win or no...

  • I WANT HER TO WIN!!! (shes my favorite)

  • shes going to win.

  • She was my favorite, and then I heard Crystal. So I have two favorites this year from the girls. They both should end up in the top 3.

  • I used to go to school with her.

  • @10434741043474 how was she as a person? haha

  • I love her sound. Not the same old thing the others are doing. Hope she gets a recording contract no matter what happens on idol. go Lilly.

  • She did a great job tonight and she's in last place. Vote vote vote 866-436-5707 it would be a crime for her to be voted off the show now.

  • GO BEATLES :)

  • i hope she wins!! she is soo awesome and i llloooove her style of singing!!

  • I love Lilly. She's so good and refreshing. :D

  • lilly you are the next CARRIE UNDERWOOD LOVE YOUR VOICE AND CLASS ACT JEFFIETUNE WILL BE VOTING 4 U GIRL

  • I LOVE HER

  • This girl and Lambert are the two best.

  • @kmvoss lol i totally think our souls are in sync n_n

  • You know what they say about two souls in sync...

  • lilly has such a beautiful voice!

  • She was really good here without even trying. I've seen a lot of people on this show start out really great and then completely tank out. But something tells me she won't disappoint. I hope I'm right.

  • probably the most talented of the girls.

  • She is gonna win for sure! (: Go Lilly Scott!

  • Thank you guys!! I'm Lilly Scott's Cousin!! I'm her mom's cousin!!! :)))

  • YAY! Give her a holler! we're supporting her all the way. =D

  • YAY!!! Thank you for supporting Lilly!!! =DDD

  • I love that girl. Totally see her in the top 12.

  • I like this girl shes sooo unique !

  • I love this girl. I can't wait for more great performances like this one =D

  • she is my favorite I hope she wins

  • I'd love to hear her cover The Cranberries - Linger

  • yes yes yes yes!!!

  • THANK YOU!! I wanted to ear this but I couldnt find it...

    It kinda looks like Megan Joy, so i lve it!!

  • If you get real player you can download the video from american idol's website and even convert for an ipod if you want.

  • either her or Tim Urban are going to win! <33

  • tim urban?

  • I KNOW RIGHT?!

  • tim urban???

  • are you a worster??

  • tim urban ???? are you serious ????

  • LOL at tim urban winning. Are you retarded? Ok, only half-retarded because Lily Scott has a really good chance of winning.

  • Tim Urban jajajaja good joke that guy is lame with all the respect he deserves LoL

  • Yeah right! That kid has talent. He just doesn't know how to show it.

  • can anyone please upload her stuff from her band Varlet.I wanted to buy their songs but its out of stock!

  • They only have 2 songs on their myspace page now. I've been trying to find it too. She had to make it disappear for the show I guess.

  • LILY!!!!!! <3 i love her.

  • I second that....her and did were my favorite

  • I like her and didi the best!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more