Added: 4 years ago
From: expertvillage
Views: 137,887
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (192)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I learned the violin significantly improved thanks to this tutorial site: vii.nn.cx

  • She tried to teach while she still has tapes on her fingerboard LOL hilarious how a beginner tried to fool another beginners. Her vids are funny! Just dont learn from her vids, ppl! She's fooling you! Or you'll fail just like her xD because all of her vids are for comedy purpose. She doesnt play violin

  • "You always start in the middle of your bow" WHAT?! You can start at the frog or the point of the bow!

  • your G string is out of the tune and you are holding your bow not correctly! how can you teach to play the violin to others??? AT FIRST REMAKE YOUR OWN MISTAKES PLEASE AND THEN RECORD THE VIDEO!

  • FAIL

  • Don't be so rude, guys! ....Although, she does look kind of unsure of herself...

  • @NikkiBo0ze no offense but then should people say how great she is so other people learn it the wrong way and will develop a habit?

  • I bet she likes black guys.

  • @JamesMarshallJohansn

    So what if she does? I had a Polish girlfriend who was hot, thin, blonde(natural) and dated me, a black man.

    Racism is a sickness!!! Btw, Paul Robeson was a black man and many people admired him!

  • Comment removed

  • This person does not know ANYTHING about violin playing. Whatsoever. For the love of music, please don't take anything this person says seriously. It's completely wrong. If you're going to make videos about violin playing, please get a REAL EXPERT--like someone who actually plays violin. I'm sure Wikipedia could even tell you how to play a violin better than this person can...

  • Oh my God, please, please don't mislead people who want to learn how to play violin and hold the bow properly. This is the most unprofessional bow hold I have ever seen.

  • I don't know where "ExpertVillage" gets their experts, but this woman has no business putting up instructional videos on violin technique. I recommend that she finds a good teacher and works hard to correct her bow hold, etc!

  • when i try to play with my bow all i get is a scratchy noise. is my bow too tight or too loose? does anyone have any tips they would be very much appreciated

  • @zena290609 This might sound dumb, but have you rosined your bow properly?

  • @darrenknaus

    yeah i have but thanks for the reply. it sounds normal now, it was just me when i first started.

  • and this is why the world is going to hell.

  • I'm sorry, but that's terrible! You can't call this "teaching". Honestly don't try to learn the Violin with this "advice" or only if you want to rape this beautiful instrument by using a totaly bad technique. By the way, this is no staccato, it could be a spiccato but even that is very poor!

  • Lol its funny that expert village people get alot of you suck they do but lol every one is always hatinh on them

  • i'd like u to upload a video of u in a concert playing ADVANCE music.... and show how good u are (which will never happen)

  • press 5 every couple of seconds for the best part of the video

  • 她的弓歪得很嚴重,是錯誤的,小提琴老師都會糾正這些行為的˙^­˙

  • bad bow hold.... none of that was correct

    furthermore, expert village really needs to figure out whether they have real experts on their hands. i dont know how she wormed through. shes a great actor, for anyone who has no clue about the violin, that is.

  • bad bow hold.... none of that was correct

  • terrible terrible curse you aggggg fcking Horribleee T-T pls someone ban this video for the safety of violin beginners everywhere :(((((((

  • Ok in all honesty,

    How can I get her job?

    Can I submit videos to expertvillage or something?

  • Oh my god, that's more then worse. You don't have the slightest idea about violin playing, do you? :D

  • Does this 'Beach' Even play the violin??? look at how she is holding the bow... I'm not expert but her technique is ALL wrong.. I guess I learned something in my 5 years of playing

    Dam you ExpertVillage #FAIL

  • This young lady is a beginner, not an expert. She desperately needs a teacher herself. If you want to play the violin, you also need a teacher. If you are looking for tips off the internet, there are better examples. There are many Youtube videos of the great violinists and also of some extremely talented young people. Listen, watch and learn. But not from this series.

  • you could also perform the losing weight sound

  • Expert village sucks! Oh and by the way you might want to tune that thing

  • could this woman be any more american lol no help whatso-ever pretty disapointed there isnt one video on youtube for beginners rather annoying really, iv self taught guitar (with help from the net) self taught drums (with help from the net) and now iv got a violin and it looks like i cant self teach it, Iv got to pay some goon to do my hard work?! pisses me off big time

  • beside her videos doesn't help me at all....hey smile kinda makes me aggressive...looks so fake to me and her way to present herself seems as if she tries to bask herself in her lore which she doesn't even seem to own. but maybe it's just me ^.^

  • That is not Staccato

  • Ahh was really looking forward to these lessons (bought a violin today, i have no violin knowledge).

    But then i see all these negative comments, but i cant bother getting a teacher. Cause then i have to do 2 hours buss everytime. Anyone know about a great way to learn violin without taking lessons with a "local" teacher.

    Im not asking for the the great scam called "shortcuts", only constructive advice :]

  • I'm just looking for a video that tells you what violins might be a good idea to purchase and information about it then I came across this and lold at all of the comments.

  • I'm thinking all you people who have nothing but bad to say should get a life. If you're so much better put your own video up. I say good for you Amy for putting up all these videos. Yes you are helping others so keep it up. :)

  • Comment removed

  • @imb4u8 Sorry but these videos are shite. She has a gap between her middle two fingers and her first and second fingers on the bow that are big enough to fly a plane through. That is also not staccato, it is too far down the bow to even be called spicatto. And her bow changes on the long bows sound like breaking glass. People are right to warn against these videos and yes I could do better myself but have no need to as there are many excellent videos that are far better than I could do on youtub

  • @imb4u8 continued::! e. These are not amongst them. On another of her videos she describes herself as an advanced player which is why she doesn't have beginner tape in the first position. She has it in 5th position. No "advanced" player uses this tape! She is herself a novice. Check out the other vids, even sicksicksick9 videos which are hilarious spoofs will teach you more than this no hoper!

  • @imb4u8 the comments are for once constructive criticism, it does take years of practice to play the violin perfectly and I dont think amy is truly ready to teach other novices, her technique is poor and not of the standard required to do her instructor exams. good teachers are masters with their instrument. otherwise how are other beginners meant to progress?

  • .......yikkeeeesss... that "tremelo" was horrible...

  • Sounds horrible. Her bow hand is terrible and lol why is she holding her violin like that?? I am a beginner and this is just teaching me bad techniques. Don't mean to be negative just stating the truth.

  • For God's... I mean she can't even keep a consistent tone!

  • I can discredit everything this woman says. Ready? 0:10 - That's a spicatto, and a very poor one at that. Sticatto is in the upper half and never leaves the string. 0:22 - Your bow hold is literally awful, and your G string is a half a step flat. 0:34 - Have you ever heard Shostakovitch? Quadruple forte tremolo, aka LOUD AS HELL. 0:48 - Volume is dependent upon arm and finger weight; distance from the bridge assists, but usually no more. Also, you rarely start right in the middle of the bow.

  • What really surprises me tough is that she hasn't got a decent intonation in the first position yet, but she's already practising the fifth (With finger tape? C'mon). I mean there are a lot of different violin schools but especially if you wanna (she obviously doesn't) play in an orchestra, it's extremely important to hit the notes correctly. Even if you're terribly unmusical, it won't take you 20 years to "achieve" this...

  • What the hell is she grinning at?

  • my violin sounds squeky

  • This is my favourite instructional video in youtube,i love her bow hold it's damn perfect,i laugh so much with this

  • who did you learn to play from?

  • While I understand & respect the critical comments, I just came to this video because Im looking for tips, not lessons. I'm a guitarist, and have been playing, self-taught, for nearly 30 yrs. Though I understand I'd never be mistaken for a classically trained musician, I have a unique style. My pet peeve has always been people who say there's a "wrong" way to play an instrument, or a "wrong" way to play music. My favorite musicians are people who ignored standard "must-do" musical techniques.

  • @klmullins65 I agree that it's valid to find your own musical style but the violin is much more technically particular than you realize. There really is a "wrong" way to do it. If you do it wrong enough you can even risk developing tendonitis and carpal tunnel syndrome. The right way isn't taught just because it's traditional, it's taught because the "right" way works. There are multiple "right" ways to learn the violin but this video is not one of them. Correct technique makes it easier.

  • @TonicMike , I understand what you,re saying. Thanks for taking the time to explain!

  • You should be taking lessons, not giving them.

  • very nice

  • Why don't some of you nasty scum baggs spend your time posting better videos, rather than putting down someone else, its easy to criticize, not so easy to improve.

  • LOL. This is true entertainment. This lady is so bad at violin that it made me laugh, a lot. Her tremblo was sooo bad it was ridiculous. I can do better with my feet!!

  • lol this is terrible!!!

  • they pay you even been beginer? youy can see closley that she has STILL the stickers for the positions

  • 1. your staccato is not right. thats almost spicaato! ridiculous....

    2.tremelos arent always "very soft"! retard....

    3.your violin is out of tune

    4. you are incorrectly holding the violin. ALWAYS when your playing, even if youre doing open strings as this tard is doing so, DONT hold it by the body, do so by the neck

    5. your muffin tops make me wanna puke

    6. so does your playing

    7. granite youth symphony orchestra? TOURED the usa and canada? haha i laugh at that

  • @gymnast768 ok...i could get down with ya bout the criticism..till u took a cheap shot...like 2 dolla hoe cheap and said somthin bout her weight...weak

  • @sticknthemud1 not that cheap. shes fat. its a life choice

  • @gymnast768 make ur self feel better all ya want...u took a cheap shot that had nothing to do with her talent and i called u out...cut and dry...life choice it may be...but i wonder how many jabs i could throw at u if i were to take one glance at u....hmmm

  • @sticknthemud1 probably quite a few.as ive done with her and as i could probably do to you

  • @gymnast768 ..yes but the difference between u and i...is that im not gonna take a cheap shot...its beneath me<--------my personal opinion....

  • OMG look at her bow hold when she's demonstrating the "short popping sound"! Comedy gold.

  • OMG this woman needsto be shot! 'Lets make loud notes with the whole bow'. She's crap at playing the violin (period) and not a very good teacher! you can make quiet notes with the whole bow too!

  • Never seen a girl hold a bow that way be4... 0.0 weird ppl...

  • the worst player i have seen in my life!! i belive she is crazy!! i dont find anoher argument!!

  • I guess playing the violin doesn't give you much exercise....

  • even though she hlds the violin incorrectly, she just want us to show the strokes of the violin and really? she already know how to hld the violin correctly but not shown in this vid.

  • @EuniceServando actually, when you are playing an open note, you can rest your hand there, but it is not that commonly used

  • YOUR DOING IT WRONNG!

    Hold the violin correctly!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • What do you expect... it's idiot village. Most of their "experts" don't know crap!!

  • Yea, what the hell. her form (the way she holds the instrument and bow) looks horrible...

  • my life just changed, now i know how to hold the bow and play propperly. omg

  • Amazing how easily someone can be deemed an expert today, isn't it?

  • what the hell is a fog?

  • Can't you tell it's out of tune..?!?!?

  • thats not how you hold the violin

  • oh my god, please tune your violin girlfraaand

  • Comment removed

  • omg learn how to hold your bow seriously.... and your violin is out of tune and your bow must be perpendicular to the strings and the bow hair faces at your face not away... and your hand is way to stiff that is why you get pops at bow changes....

  • Im sorry but lady that first bowing is not STACCATO, it's SPICCATO, which is "bouncing bow". Staccato is short and on the string entirely... hence-no lifting.

  • haha she sounds like someone from CNN

  • haha you're right

  • i just starting violin and i don't know if she is even doing this right i play other things like piano and flute but she dosen't look like a good teach i've been playing for 5 years and i have had only a russin teach and there the best

  • russian teachers are the best eh? The only good teachers I've ever had have been eastern european as well...that's interesting you feel the same...

  • Russian teachers follow a different school of teaching... that form is dying out because they get injuries and have poor technique. well and we have found more economical ways of doing things

  • 'it can change EVERYHTING in a matter of moment'

  • I need some Heifetz now

  • thanx

  • I have only just started learning violin (Im 28) Had two lessons by now,just learning how to hold the bow correctly and stuff.Wish I could play some carols by christmas,but watching these videos I thing its gonna be harder than I thought :-)

  • I bought Step by Step by Kersten Wartberg.. they are really good beginner books that come with CDs.

  • dont watch these they are done poorly

  • that's often the case with these "expert" village vids. I saw clip on auto maintenance, and was surprised the guy didn't severely injure himself!

  • this is the WORST way to teach anyone, you shouldn't even be teaching beginners if you can't even tune your violin .. it's nearly a semitone flat!! You really need to sort out your own technique before you pass your bad techniques on to beginner violinists

  • look at her poor bow grip!

  • just because 'expert' is in her username does not make her so. this woman is a novice and does not know what she is talking about. please do not listen to her - go check out ProfessorV. staccato is not off the string. tremolo is not always soft. you don't use the same weight into the string as you vary the distance of the bow closer and further from the bridge.

  • i really wanted to play the violin is it late for me to learn how to play it btw i am 26. please mail me for your answer thanks

  • more better than previous video...

  • she is good teacher, l like it

  • Hahahahahahaha!!!!!!!! I love these lesson videos.

  • This woman's violin is at least a semitone flat!

  • I am curious, how come all these guys that are "experts" on violin are watching this video in the first place?

  • BECAUSE IT'S FREAKING HILARIOUS!!!!!!!!

    But yeah seriously guys... Don't learn violin through video, go get a real teacher.

  • I think she is very helpful. I am a beginner and I've bought so called 'proper' beginner videos by expert players. They are far too advanced for. So, all you snobs out there saying she's doing everything wrong - don't watch !! She does things nice and simple at a nice beginner's pace. We can pick up all the niceties later.

  • OK I'm sorry but for the purpose of violin pedagogy I have to warn people away from these videos. This woman is not a violin teacher, she is a beginner. If you want to learn how to play you need a real teacher. These videos demonstrate terrible bow hold, terrible bow arm technique, terrible vibrato, bad intonation and not even particularly good advice. I'm not commenting just to be negative. You must not trust that these videos are in any way aligned with traditional violin teaching.

  • @mruslan thanks for the warning, what you are saying sounds plausible!!

  • i agree 100%. these are entertaining as heck for those of us who know what quackery it is, but please for the love of all that is holy DO NOT TAKE THIS WOMAN SERIOUSLY!

  • you're good

  • Additionally, you do not usually use PRESSURE when you play the violin. You use the naturally weight of your arm, unless for small moments of emotional emphasis. Just pulling the sound with the weight of your arm is enough to play a full fortissimo.

  • Yuck. Her bow hand is so hideous. The shape is wrong, but at least most who teach violin at least know that the pinky is curved and that the bow is not gripped in such a violent way; the fingers should be used as springs and the bow balanced. Sorry to sound harsh, but seeing is teaching too. Try to utilize correct violin technique yourself while teaching others...

  • Wow! It sounds like soundtrack from tv show "LOST". Really nice lesson.

  • Those terms are used when playing violin, but....

    For quarter note [1 beat]: You don't use the full bow

    You don't use a staccato unless it says so.

  • is it me, or is the violin out of tun in every single video?

  • not helping, sorry.

  • good lesson

  • What? Im 15 and ive been playing violin since i was 4. She totally made up all of those terms- beginner players- dont listen to this lady! Get a real teacher!

  • hey -i am a guitar player- i just got my first fiddle- sorry to tell you though- those are pretty universal music terms...staccato, tremolo, those ARE NOT fake terms- I hope you are joking, otherwise you just dont know important vocabulary.

  • Uh, those terms were real...Sorry to say.

  • this ;ady once again has no clue what shes talking about. o change sound you change bow pressure, not placement.

  • Tremolo? can i put a floyd rose on that thing?

  • lmao send that bitch through a whammy pedal

  • she makes up her own terms and movements

  • I have never commented on a youtube video before. But I must appeal to those who think this is actual instruction: Please. Whatever you do, don' t try to learn from this girl. Almost everything she says is incorrect, and she plays out of tune. And she can't tune her instrument either. I have students who have been playing for 2 years who have more skill than this "expert."

  • But she has pretty eyes!

  • Thank you for the lesson. Very easy to understand.

  • she said crisps 0_o

  • Your right hand locks very stiff. I recommend to make the position more natural and free.

  • You suck.

  • So what are you boys really jealous about, is it that you can't play fiddle, teach or even speak to the general public? And if you have to comment on other people's appearance, could it be that your lacking something on your own body? You guys are peep-sqeeks compared to the courage this young woman has, too bad you'll never have the abilities that this young lady has displayed! Great job girl!

  • WTF staccato doesn't have to be at the frog....

    she knows nothing

  • ouch that hurt my ears. she is supposed to be a expert how can she not tell she is out of tune.

  • she's not a very good teacher...her strings are out of tune, and sTacatto is on the string, while sPicatto is off the string. While she says stacatto, she plays spicatto...though it's easily confused.

  • I must admit, she has a good and clear voice. Easy to understand... Too bad her demonstration of what she is saying is not as up to par.

  • sorry i have been playing the violin for 2 months and even i knew that her violin was out of tune

    awful teacher disgracful VERY disgraceful

  • right on girl hopefully when i get my violin it'll help me alot and guys stop being mean there nothing wrong wiht have a little weight atleast she can teach music i wanna see you guys make a vedio that can teach me how to play the violin and if u don't sound excatlly like her god u guys are mean haven't your pearents thech u any manners? u should be ashamed of your selfs and on why would they make people teach begginers how to play if they don't even know how to play comoon guys think for a sec

  • who cares if she has weight! ok

    whats up with her bow hand.?.! is it proper to have the first 3 fingers so separated then the pinky right beneath the ring finger??!

  • whats up with her bow hand!? why are her first 3 fingers so seperated and then her pinky and ring finger are touching ??

  • Get a real teacher. This chick is a joke.

  • Her last tip is like the only thing that's right rofl

    But to play softer it's usually easier to just put less tension on the strings while playing.

    Spiccato - you play at the BALANCE point which is about 1/3 of your bow length up from the bottom.

  • Hey AndPassTheAmmunation! Don't be so mean.. you act like a grader.. Anyway, I enjoyed the lessons. Hey miss, you are good. But is it possible to get a book and study on my own? I mean I can read notes and play other instruments but I want to try violin now :-) hope to hear from you. More power to you! God bless

  • How about putting a capo on the neck so that you can be in tune!

  • This shouldn't even be on the internet. She can't even hold the bow correctly, the violin is out of tune, her tone is terrible, and you DO NOT move the position of your bow between the sound post and the fingerboard to change the volume.

  • Maybe her violin's out of tune but one must admit she has a big, fat tone.

  • she out of tune i think

  • love it....... u r a great teacher...

  • my words egzactly lol

  • i tried playing stocatto and my bow bounced a lot. is my bow not tight enough?

  • try putting more pressure onto the bow that might help but not having a tight bow shouldnt make a diffrence. anyway if your trying to learn the violin this person is not good at all she is giving really bad

    information. I have been playing the violin for seven years now and honestly this is not the way to learn the violin .

  • I wonder if she cries herself to sleep at night....i would if i was her

  • she can't even hold a bow correctly!

  • She is a HORRIBLE wannabe violinist. She doesn't play well, and her strings are flat!

    What is expertvillage doing? Where do they get these people?

  • mmm i agree... shallow and pedantic!

  • honestly, i don't know if wut she is saying is true or not, but people like u who r saying wut shes doing is wrong, y don't u put up a video showing people thw right way? i mean u shouldn't be critisizing people over their methods until u actually prove that ur methods r right.

  • i never actually said anything about her or her methods... i was just trying to fit in lol! everybody is a critic, and has an opinion, just like u when u told ppl what u think of them. lets not lose any sleep over this

  • Oh really?I see that you don't understand nothing of violin.... if you did you wouldn't say that becouse even a 2 grade suzuki player is better

  • ok jeeze lady u don't need to have your bow that close to the bridge to play stacito! and your tremmlo is HORIBAL!

  • nice video.... that was i learnd from my tutor hehehe...

  • Thank you for these videos. I'm a beginner student with a teacher, but these have helped me in between lessons.

  • Seems more about people being used for ad revenue than violin playing IMO. I believe the "teachers" are doing as well as they can, but the fact is that there are many so much better on YouTube (and elsewhere). This company "teaches" on virtually any subject, but it's a lot more complex to demonstrate violin well than how to change the oil in one's car. People being mean? Overall, I think not, most comments come from people who just plain know what's up.

  • OMG SO BAD!!

  • thank you for the vid

  • LEARN HoW TO HOLD THE FREAKING BOW!!!! THEN TELL OTHERS HOW!!

  • how does it "change everything in a matter of moments"? :/

  • Omg guys just leave her alone, she's fine doing wot she wants omg...

  • 1) u guys are so mean she is fine the way she is.2)u go girl.

  • omg... you ppl are so mean....

  • Oh lord! Tjis is just so sad! She is trying to teach and she knows nothing!

  • lol