Longoria and Dice-K were suppose to b good, so they weren't "surprise players" but overall i pretty much agree. Also i would put Ludwick #3 and Quentin #4
I agree with Zobrist, but Hill has always had the talent but because of his long term injury he couldn't show off his talent, and Romero , Look at Romero's stats, he's only started in the bigs this year, he is easily the rookie of the year
Yeah, Zobrist is a suprize. thats what im saying about josh hamilton. hes always had the talent. just injuries prevented him. i personally dont think romero should be ROY, at least not right now.
Romero doesn't have talent to be a halladay.. he has 3 good pitches, 4sfb, 2 seamer, and a sweeping Curve, he's working on his change, but halladay is just too dame good to be classified with this rookie..
i love how every1 who commented on this vid doesnt even know wat a SURPRISE PLAYER is i agree with this except i would put hamilton first lee second and idk about longoria people knew he was going to be great im not critizising ur opinion im just saying
lincecum is not underrated. If anyone it's J.A. Happ or J.C. Romero. But Romero took steroids, so now he deserves to be underrated and has a small one. He was one of the players that took the suspension with manny. I think Utley is overrated though. Maybe Jayson Werth or Ben Francisco for 2009. Philly is gonna repeat or lose in the NLCS
cole hamels world series and playoff mvp, should be on there! never made an allstar gm and still hasnt but 08 he killed it.
elit0610 1 year ago
you put ryan dumpster on the list????
tvasbinder 1 year ago
cliff lee?
lmaoo,
some fluke season
halladay deserved the cy young.
Kihustle 2 years ago
@Kihustle cliff lee is raw you fag
mr11fawful 1 year ago
@mr11fawful
my shit is raw, cliff lee sucks fat dicks.
he can't maintain a well era .
Kihustle 1 year ago
Dempster is not underrated, but your #1 underrated is here now. World Fuckin' Champions!
flyersfan345 2 years ago
Longoria and Dice-K were suppose to b good, so they weren't "surprise players" but overall i pretty much agree. Also i would put Ludwick #3 and Quentin #4
69ajack 2 years ago
everyone knew hamilton was great then he did crack so everyone forgot about him. this list is awful
marlinsfan4life 2 years ago
none of these people are that suprising
OldyAlex123 2 years ago
for 2009 you gotta have Adam Lind and Ricky Romero. Crazy numbers
ilovegames14 2 years ago
no romero, im sorry u must be a jays fan, u gotta have like zobrist and hill but not romero buddy
marlinsfan4life 2 years ago
I agree with Zobrist, but Hill has always had the talent but because of his long term injury he couldn't show off his talent, and Romero , Look at Romero's stats, he's only started in the bigs this year, he is easily the rookie of the year
ilovegames14 2 years ago
Yeah, Zobrist is a suprize. thats what im saying about josh hamilton. hes always had the talent. just injuries prevented him. i personally dont think romero should be ROY, at least not right now.
marlinsfan4life 2 years ago
Romero doesn't have talent to be a halladay.. he has 3 good pitches, 4sfb, 2 seamer, and a sweeping Curve, he's working on his change, but halladay is just too dame good to be classified with this rookie..
ilovegames14 2 years ago
JOHNNY CUETO OWNS!!!!!!!
hitdoctor24 2 years ago
i love how every1 who commented on this vid doesnt even know wat a SURPRISE PLAYER is i agree with this except i would put hamilton first lee second and idk about longoria people knew he was going to be great im not critizising ur opinion im just saying
bobisnot5 2 years ago
wheres tim licecum and goevony soto alexi ramizrez and kouske fukudome
yousporrune 2 years ago
not lincecum, hes to good to be a surprize
marlinsfan4life 2 years ago
lincecum is not underrated. If anyone it's J.A. Happ or J.C. Romero. But Romero took steroids, so now he deserves to be underrated and has a small one. He was one of the players that took the suspension with manny. I think Utley is overrated though. Maybe Jayson Werth or Ben Francisco for 2009. Philly is gonna repeat or lose in the NLCS
flyersfan345 2 years ago
armando gallaraga
kingofweirdos 2 years ago
wheres chipper jones?
cenafan9210 2 years ago
chipper is beast ..
Ballplayer300th 2 years ago
ok where the fuck is felix hernandez?
ABOVEANDBEYOND5 2 years ago
ok how the fuck is it a SUPRISE that he performed well. he has always been a great player BITCH!!!
Santa0ninja99 2 years ago
he was like 10-11
slsportskid43 2 years ago
Mike Aviles???????????
BMRAIDER92 3 years ago
and where is lincecum....
peytondaniel1993 3 years ago 2
yeah.. tim lincecum kicked MAJOR ass and nobody really thought he could do it?
Lutziepv08 2 years ago 2
what about Dustin Pedria
stcolboy15 3 years ago
wheres Mike Mussina? the dude was considered to be washed up and then gave one of his finest years and won 20 games
Jobafan08 3 years ago
yah i agree wuts with that
OldyAlex123 2 years ago
Jay Bruce?
ninjan7ckmaniac 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Joba Chamberlin?
FinalSmash9 3 years ago
in 2008? Suprise? no
Santa0ninja99 3 years ago
edison volques was my numba 1 this yr
thrill44rocks 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ps.. its Alexi Casilla..
Rachelizabeth47 3 years ago
sorry my bad
Santa0ninja99 3 years ago
Evan Longoria should have been higher IMO
Rachelizabeth47 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how about Alexi Ramirez
Ro11out24 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WAT ABOUT BRAD LIGHTS OUT LIDGE
ED7796 3 years ago
He was always good. It wasnt that big of a suprise of 08.
Santa0ninja99 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
missed jayson werth
cndncxn4554 3 years ago
great video
5*
LADs55 3 years ago 5