Added: 4 years ago
From: FloridaGirl16
Views: 154,403
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ew. O_e

  • Here's my lucky charm:GOD!

  • What the heck is she doing!!!!!!!!!!! Screaming or Dissing the song? To me both.

  • she was shouting the song, not singing it

  • Why the hell she didn't get expelled that night! fucking bitch, she sang it awful!

    she didn't even sing the really hard part of the song (how could I? You...(8))

  • nobody can touch the original but dont judge her on that, it wasnt amazing but it wasnt bad .

  • At Least She Tried

  • shes a good singer, she proved that in the audition but she shouted her way through this.

  • I'm not a big fan of the way she sings at all... But she's still better than me. lol.

  • It was nice hearing a more R&B vocal on this song, but her voice isn't as strong as Lee's. It's to be expected though, Lee has been singing for a loooong time.

  • why is everyone saying this is horrible

    it's not great but it's not that bad

  • UNTIL NOW I DIDNT THINK ANYONE BUT AMY LEE COULD SING THAT damm EXCELLENT

  • there were notes off key

  • she ruined this song!

    Amy would be disappointed!

  • no one but amy can sing this song. i give her points because she tried this song and not some stupid pop song; but she didnt sing it very well.

  • did anyone else threw up when she said 'come on!'

  • only amy can sing that song it made for her

  • only amy can sing that song

  • Okay yeah she can't sing Evanescence songs for a fact but at least she tried right ?

  • Ugh, I wanted to like this but I just can't. :-(

  • The music and the back up vocals sounded pretty horrible.

  • I dunno...I don't like how she sang it...It's too different.

  • @MPCandy Same here :\

  • i think this is done quite well. no she isnt amy lee but she did a great job. for all of you that bash her id like to hear you sing this song as good or better.

  • terrible!

    

  • i really didnt think it was great..but great 4 her..better dan most

  • I love the "rough/edge" in her voice. :)

  • "Well, proud moment; your boyfriend has Pickle on his chest right now."

  • Why are the background vocals so weird?

  • terrible

  • what the hell is this horible

  • why wud u even attempt this?

  • i remember her. she's hot. and an amazing singer. not as good as amy lee. but she still is an awesome singer. and she rocks.

  • She was flat in the beginning. But then it worked. I think anyways...Amy lee is hard to live up to. And she was flat towards the end.

  • She was flat in the beginning. But then it worked. I think anyways...Amy lee is hard to live up to.

  • Yeah, she well and truely murdered that..

  • She's amazing.

    You have to remember this is a COVER.

    You should always make a song your own, and she did it.

    And yes the piano screwed up.

  • the piano got 1 chord wrong at the beginning lol

  • She was alright but Evanescence is definately not the band she should be doing covers of. She doesnt have the same type of full voice like Amy does.

  • I don't know why people are saying she's really good. This is a HORRIBLE song choice for her in my opinion. I didn't like it at all. Of course she's no Amy, but she doesn't even sound half way good. Sorry, didn't like it at all.

  • Great voice!!! You go girl!!! Check out my music by typing in Kristie Murray. Please tell me what you think!!!

  • of course this is not as good as Amy and never can be cuz shes one of the best female vocalists livin on earth!! <3 of course she did pretty good and she is also a very good singer. I hoped she would stay longer at the competition so she could be more sucessful :D

  • they could have also cut it down. they do that on american idol. either way, she handled it like a pro.

    (not as good as amy <3)

  • they could have also cut it down. they do that on american idol...

  • She missed "you would be here with me" at the beginning D: although if I was on American Idol I would be horribly nervous.. so she probably did better than me..

  • @DarknessPrincess110 no, in American Idol they have to shorten the length of the songs to makñe space for the other singers.

  • @pscanyc3 yοս can ԝatcհ tv from аll over the ԝorld oո yοur рс ϳսst by dοwnloadіոց ѕome рrοgram, it's gοt tհοuѕаոds of ϲհаnոеls oո it. јսѕt ցο to linevid com (pսt a . befοre the cοm, it ԝoո't let me рοѕt links fοr sοmе reаsοո) it's a bit prісey bսt it'ѕ јust οոe tіme аոd it ԝοrks reаlly wеll

  • fuf

  • God....that was horrid.

  • Can I get an amen when i say "Epic. Fail."?

  • @xExystancex amen.

  • @xExystancex totally amen

  • @xExystancex Amen... God, you're right!

  • If you don't get metal, don't sing it. This style DOES NOT suit her at all.

  • ....Yah she should stay away from evanescence. She doesn't really have the voice for her. But she's good nonetheless.

  • nothing like the original. Amy has a higher voice and that's why the original is better, and its amy

  • she is okay but you dont get the awsome feeling you get from her real song

  • @TheKatlsBackAgain Umm, it's supposed to resemble the song it pretty good though, and this wasn't bad but my advice is stay away from evanescence songs, her voice isn't really strong enough for evanescence.

  • I like this, she put her own spin on the song, much more beat up blusey, which is kind of what coverers are meant to do, which most of the silly little Evanescence fans seem to be forgetting. A cover isn't meant to sound exactly like the original.

  • i like her boobs....................

  • @metalpan1234 Jajajaja sus pechos me llaman mucho la atención xd

  • She is haorrible at singing this jus AWFUL

  • i heard about this cause amy lee talked about watching it in a interview. gina did ok american idol does shorten the song

  • not good at all

  • fail.

  • shes good and i like her fishnet glovey thing

  • she's not bad i think she did good for call me when your sober amy lee is better

  • I think she did fantastic with this song. It's just that she does it with less emotion in her voice compared to amy. Also her voice is much huskier than amy's. But she'd make a killer rock genre artist.

  • some one did an evanescnece song on ai? they should do this more often... just saying.

  • I think its nice she did the song. She didn't do bad. I think its nice to know some other Evanescence fans out there. If I was on American Idol i'd to Evanescence too. WHO WOULDN'T?

  • i thought she was great i thought there some issues with shortening the song though the organization of it was terrible she couldve sang the full intro

  • shes good but i think she do better on singing a pink song and in the begginig she missed some words but ya she did good dont get me wrong

  • Gina > Lee. It's nice to see when singer can reach the high notes in Evanescence songs when playing live, considering that Lee can barely do it.

  • @arturesteve My God.. I never see a LIE like this. Amy can reach higher notes LIVE than in the studio albums (In Weight of the World live Amy reached C#6)... So if you don't know what are talking about, please shut up and keep this kind of comments to yourself!

  • @NausAllien I know what I'm talking about. I've seen her live and she can't hit most of the high notes. ONE song, maybe, but most songs, definitely not. She runs out of air in a hearbeat.

  • @arturesteve Well at least Amy Lee doesn't lip sync. Would you want her to lip sync instead? And I think she can sing but she mostly has bad performances than good ones in my opinion.

  • @pete2k10 Not lipsync. IMO, being a good singer is not only having a good voice, but also the way you use it and how aware you are about the things you can and can't do with it. It doesn't matter to me in this case, but when I go to shows I'd like to hear vocalists to their fullest, not jumping around like idiots until they need oxygen to make it to the next song.

  • Comment removed

  • @arturesteve wait! amy sings about 10 songs every concert and she runs and jumps and spins and does all that cool stuff on stage, and don't forget that she WROTE those awesome songs and she IS the best at them!

  • @pinklaurarose Writing the songs have nothing to do with your vocal performance. It have to do with how they interpret the song, but that's not what I'm talking about, at all. There are things that a singer can do with their voice and things that they can't. Amy Lee generally has a bad use of her voice and you can tell in her performance. Again, not the interpretation but the actual singing. And please, as if she were the only one "singing 10 songs every concert", that's just a weak argument.

  • @arturesteve anyway, i still don't like the way gina sang.

  • @arturesteve excuse me, but I think pinklaurarose has the point. Saying Gina Glocksen is as good as Amy Lee, or even better, is a huge mistake. And don't forget. Gina Glocksen is still a beginner, and Amy Lee is expert in music.

  • You know what I love about this video besides that (IMO she did awesome with the song) but the "boyfriend" in the audience...is now her husband. I think it's great because she always talked about him being her "rock". I wish she could get signed and make a rock album.

  • i don't know if i like her very much... but hold on!! she has a nice voice!!

  • Of course she won't sound like Amy, no one can sound like her except her.

    But she did ok.

  • all i have to say is that amy lee is the best and no one can sing like her.and gina ,she cannot scream as amy lee as duh.

  • damn shes good!

  • hahahahhahaha wtf

  • I HATED the musicians playing the background track for this. The totally messed it up.

  • She hot and all but this wasnt her song i hated it sorry but she hot:D

  • the problem is that this girls don't understant that evanescence are Metal!!!Pour Amy!!!

  • Reminds me of the female rock singers of the 80s.Great job!!!!!

  • not that great, especially the beginning...

  • mtooo boa... claro q passa LOONGE da Amy né?! uhasusa.. Amy is the best ! Mas ela mandou MTOOOOOOOOOOOOOO BEM ! :DDD

  • She really butchered this song but I still liked her.

  • why evanescence fans flame everyone who sings evanescence, they all think that amy is the best singer, cmon let people sing what they want

  • Um... not bad.... not fantastic... it just is... :( she shoots and OH she misses.

  • She is better than Amy Lee. LMAO!

  • yer if it comes to screaming your vocal chords out,she's a champion!

  • Aww, this was sad. I loved Gina. I was so happy when she sang this song. She didn't own it, but she didn't ruin it.

  • Her voice is so powerful, and she killed those cords.

  • gina is a better singer than carly smithson. i know she doesn't compare to amy lee but she's still better than carly. for one, this is her song selection for american idol and she knows she doesn't compare to amy. and second, carly smithson actually thinks she's better than amy. she's an arrogant wanna be. gina is not a wanna be because she knows there's no way she even close to amy lee's singing. this is just a song selection for her american idol performance. that's all.

  • Well...at least this is nowhere near as bad as Carly Smithson and trying to rip off Evanescence.

    Gina was decent, but she would have been better off singing an easier Ev. song, like...mmm...Weight of the world.?

  • no affence but how did she get into the top 24! crazy there is girls who are better singers than her and they're only like 14 years old!!!! jezzzz

  • she is a horriable singer loser!

  • That was awful!!!

  • God, I hope how they butcher songs, trying to turn 3:50 into 30 seconds. :(

  • By the way she sounds she shouln't picked something more metal.

  • she sux. sry.

  • terrible...

  • haha paula sounds drunk

  • probably because she was lol

  • i'd like to be in her pocket

  • she shoutinish but she good

  • She killed it

  • I think people are forgettin 1 thing,Evanescence did it first so obv its not gonna be as gd, i thought it was gd,not as gd as amy as many people "cant" sing lyk amy does,it wasnt better but it was orite

  • No Gina didn't do a good job.

  • That hurt. Evanescence does it WAY BETTER!!!!!!!

  • She's pretty good...it's a hard song to sing Amy has an amazing vocal range

  • carly's is better

  • American Idol ALWAYS have the WORST backing vocals...the girls are TOTALLY out of key. it's annoying because every season I've noticed that and it makes the lead sound flat or sharp.

    she (Gina) did a decent job but the back ground vocals are shit....I sang pro for over 8 years so I do know what I am talking about.

    Gina just doesn't have the full sound Amy does...so it's just too tinny sounding.

    gotta go listen to Amy now to cleanse my ears.

    :P

  • I think she did pretty good...I mean not as good as the original obviously, but she gave it a good shot.

  • woow she is really good

  • i think no one can sing Ev songs without hurting our ears cause Amy Lee's voice is unique and Ev songs definitely suit with Amy's voice only. not for others.

  • dont she write the songss thogough

  • No "she" wrote the song. It was written by a man, part of a book he's writting.

  • Also, i think she woul;d have been better off to do Bring Me To Life.

  • Not gonna lie: She butchered it. NOT that badly, but it was like she was trying waaayyyy too hard.

    and Amercian Idol: I realise you only give the singers a minute and a half to do a song, but don't chop up a song lke that and expect people to like it..

  • did she sat to luce youre all gay

  • what a dumb bitch.

    fuck her for doin this to evanescence's

    amazing awesomeness.

  • Meh normally she was better than this.

  • cant stand it when people who dont have the voice for this kind of music, cover the songs. really? dont embarrass yourself.

  • AMy does it better but she is really good though

  • No lying, it was so bad it made me cry :'( ?Ugh, I hhhhate it when people disrespect Evanescence songs like this.

  • she did a good job, but if your trying to get a record deal or win you never sing a evanescence song

  • lol yeah all u have to do is talk about sex

  • yeah...especially since most people CAN"t sing like Amy Lee....don't even bother to try because you'll fail.

  • Worst cover ever! its like nr 5 in my top5 WORST WORST WORST

  • this is one of the better covers ive heard

  • shes awesome!! Amy's voice is very hard to cover but she really did an amazing job!! wow. :)

  • Totally. They r so hard to sing. Tht is why amy lee is brilliant. I think gone dun amazin at the start n then like paula said she tried 2 over sing at thevend wen she was a bit out of breathe. But she did a fantastic job. WTF did America vote sanjaya in I remember him he was shit. Blake was quite gd but come on gina should hav bn through .

  • she could totally stay til top 5 (at least). cant believe she lost to sanjaya and blake <.<

  • she was ok.....not as good as amy but ok

  • yeah but who is as good as amy? lol she did a good job tho i think nice voice.

  • Dam xD she's got a good pair of lungs XDD

  • i'm an evanescence freak but can't y'all see how HARD these songs from the open door are to sing? she did great. amy of course will always rock the songs, but she wrote them and they're her range . . . open door songs are so hard to sing, the notes and stuff. she did good.

  • Yeah that wasnt her best.

  • i wanna see her and amy lee duet!

  • that makes both of us:)

  • u know what, she tried her best and that's all she can do....so STOP RAGGIN ON HER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • ok u say shes bad right. but how is she bad cause apparently if ur blind then you can't see that she made it to the finals so shes good at singing people. she just made into her own version and i like it.

  • Comment removed

  • god evanescence fans are so rude... i love Gina... and this performance was really good and who cares if it wasn't as good as Amy's that doesn't mean it sucked

  • yea, i'm an evanescence fan but you ppl give us a bad name! she tried her best and that's all ppl can ask for. and besides, evanescence songs are hard to sing.

  • ya'll give yourselves a bad name.... anytime someone sings a song by evanescence... it is automatically not as good as Amy and is the most horrendous thing that you've heard in your life.... I shouldn't say all of you... cause you obvioulsy aren't that way lol.... but that is the truth

  • no, i'm talking about the rude evanescnece fans. they give us good evanescence fans a bad name.

  • to be honest, i seriously agree with you! All them rude fans judge these awesome people who cover the song, and bash on them, lets see the ev fans TRY and sing the song infront of millions of viewers! but yes, i love Gina, Carly Smithson, AND We Are The Fallen! <3

  • she missed some of the lyrics...and she sucks compared to amy lee

  • omg that sucks for real:))sorry folks that is all is booooring:(see?the real voice of evanescence is much more awesome rhan that

  • obviously amy's isthe best

    carly's sucks...

    gina's is isrealy good

  • she made popy :(

  • She did Ev better than Carly does that's for sure.

  • i think this girl could be a hit singing anna johnson, not amy lee, i liked the performance, but it lost the best of it for her voice

  • I loved this performance, it was very authentic. Gina really showed some personality and growth here.

  • Comment removed

  • I think she would have been better off with a song by Pink...

  • yea i agree

  • umm lol she sang it wrong. wait, unless ur suppose to do that. sorry. and also her voice is not fit for this type of song

  • I prefer Amys version.

  • well umm it was ok but amy sings it way better nd maybe this girl needs to look up the lyrics lolz

  • the guy at the beggining was SOOOOOOOO DULL.

  • if your gunna sing this song get the damn words right

  • she's 'ok''

  • I didn't think it was bad! What the heck are you people talking about??

  • If I were to sing something by another artist, given that it isn't my song, I'd try to imitate the original. She has a nice voice but somehow I didn't love it... I've never seen anyone who could imitate Amy Lee decently. Shoot, if I could shoot the high notes, I think I'd get it

  • Ha, I agree. This song is too powerful not to imitate it- there's no other way to do Evanescence than the dark and powerful depths that Amy does.

  • >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> :S

  • umm nobody should sing, well attempt to sing an amy lee song unless your voice is just as good as or better then amy lee. this was ok but noo.

  • Not too bad actually.She's not close to Amy but she has a voice, too bad she's pressing it too hard and cutting down the soft parts. But after all, not too bad...

  • amazing...