Added: 5 years ago
From: christinerobson
Views: 19,000,241
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (18,236)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I listen to mostly rap but songs like this one reach out an prove there heart in almost everything just have to look an good mix btw

  • Oh so I am an emo because I cut myself and I like this song.Get it

  • Great job on the video... beautiful touching melody and such warm soothing voice.. this is music with real emotional value to it.

  • very beautifully sung as it should be considering the emotional value behind it.

  • i love this song :)

  • its not about how bad you think someones life is, its how well they can handle their problems that determins if they have a bad life, you cant tell people how they feel inside, because that can only come from within

  • rest in peace bonnie lee :(

  • Why the heck r u guys even argueing or tryin to prove a point on who's wrong, rite, fake or real??? Who cares man get off this shit

  • Niceemo I love this song an i'm not emo... Yet I have many emo frendz who like this music! Sooo ya I can see y it reminds u of like emo music :)

  • me gusta mucho la melodía, y está bonita la canción, pero al mismo tiempo triste

  • Or goth life. OPINION! NOT fact!

  • No use denying this song was made for her sister. Lots of these post tht r directed to me and my gf, make it sound like we said this "this song was definately made for emos and nothing else." we r not saying tht! We r saying tht we FEEL like its made for emos bc like Anne said. It's sad, depressing, and hopeless. Thts what most emos who cut and goths feel like! Ok? Let's end this. It is my opinion, my gf's opinion, and every emo and goth in our school's opinion we feel this song represents emo

  • Look. I looked it up, and I won't deny tht this was made for her sister. Just gonna end this. But this song is sad, depressing, and sounds hopeless. @ my skool, including me and my bf, there r about 30 emos (yes they cut themselves), and 25 goths. I took a poll, made all of them listen to this song. Many of them quoted "I feel like this song represents emo or goth life. Sad, depressing and hopeless." so me and my bf r not the only ones who think this sad song can represent emo or goth life.

  • Jojo09777 wow, really? U think I'm NOT emo? Jeez! If I wanted 2, I could send u pics of my arms, my closet, and the music I listen 2!!! But im not gonna bcuz of privacy issues

  • @EmoProdigy12 I think the only part of you that's emo is your anger issue :) If you're so determined to be 'emo' then just be it and stop bothering everyone else.

    Don't you know that people are usually afraid of being called emo? And whoever calls themselves emo are usually perfectly fine. You sound rather arrogant by the way, thinking you're always right, emos are low self-esteemed... just saying ^^

  • beautifully depressing

  • hello neighbour....

  • How bout we all take some Ritalin and chill out.

  • @EmoProdigy12 and u cant determine what the song is about just by looking at the video.

  • @EmoProdigy12How bout we check out what the lyrics mean. The song is about death coming from a child's point of view. When Amy Lee was 6 years old, her sister Bonnie, who was 3 years old, died. Amy was at school when she found out, hence the line "Playground school bell rings again, rain clouds come to play again." What she's saying in the song is what she felt when she found out, and since she was so young, she didn't fully understand the concept of death.

  • ive hit the repeat button too many times

  • Why don't people with disorders get them checked out?

  • In love with this one

  • Let me go, or kill me once time. :'[

  • Evanescence understanding

  •  i miss you ro`9ah :p <3 ro`9ah

  • Tux3n. If u say that 2 my GF again, my multipersonality disorder will kick in, and my fuckin bad ass other personality will come out. Just ask EmoProdigy12. She knows first hand wht that's like, and it ain't pretty

  • 976violet.... Ur so...well idk how to say it. Weird. Y on earth would I make up my bf???? He's real as the day. And being EMO doesn't put limitations on my personality. I am actually as negative as the next EMO, I just don't sound it. Not on here anyway. EMO OUT.

  • @EmoProdigy12 making your username have emo in it and calling yourself emo in almost every sentance doesn't really make you emo....

  • Ok. Ppl listen,'

  • love the piano and the lyrics in this make me cry :(

  • Only an idiot would cut himself because of a song!

  • 819 People wanted to say goodbye.

  • :( hope evanescence will help again...

  • @EmoProdigy12 just cuz ppl cut does NOT make them emo ur encouraging the stereotype that all cutters r emo and also if U look online about this song it will say its for her sister who died not for emos so what if she has bandages on her arms girls at my school will wear bandages in there arms an they don't cut also it could just be an accessory for the video "My Immortal" (some of the video is in this video)

  • ...Why, oh why are people so stupid? And why is emoprodigy12 communicating with her boyfriend over the internet? Is it because he's made up, by her, and she wants us to think he's real? Just asking. Not hating. But she seems...not emo to me, if you understand what I'm trying to say. The way she writes, and the things she says are just too...much...

  • all right. i''m pissed. my gf, emoprodigy12 just told me lots of ppl r hating on her coment tht she feels tht this song was made for emos. NOT HAVING IT! u pick on us emos.... u don't wanna know i have multipersonality dissorder so it aint gonna b pretty.. u hate on my gf, ur more likely to die by my hand. STOP! ps. E> u anne

  • @NicoEmo12. babe ik ur standing up for me AND emos, but no need to get so teed off. k? ppl know we feel this song was made for emos. thts all they need to know. E> u 2

  • @EmoProdigy12 Why the fuck would you commit to a lifestyle that preaches sadness and loneliness? You probably aint even old enough to know what emo actually means. Stop pretending the world is mean to you. I can assure you there are millions of people who has it WAY worse than you do. Pull yourself together dammit.

  • so sad yet so inspiring and beautiful, i love this song!!!!!! :)

  • it's so sad..... :(

  • You Think This Song is Cool ? i thought yes till i saw that

    /watch?v=aOQZX9ss51U

    Thumbs Up So People Can See

  • Comment removed

  • Amy Lee's sister. <3

  • To all people commenting their sob stories or how they are depressed..Instead of whining over youtube, go see a fucking shrink! You look like attention seekers. 

  • Emos dont want to be emo and they dont admit they unless asked. Your a poser

  • if u don't believe it's for emos, JUST LOOK AT HER ARMS! all bandaged up! can't remember what part, but in some part it shows blood coming from her arms!

  • @EmoProdigy12 Lol, if your serious about what your saying...then you are extremly pathetic.

  • like i said. dark song. meant for emos. EMO OUT!

  • <3 it

  • I sang this for my last recital when I quit piano... My sister played cello, my piano teacher played piano and I sung... It's about her little sister dying while amy was in school... ;(

  • dont try to fix me. i'm not broken.

  • This song explains me ....i love amy's songs cus it hits the deep parts ...

  • V.V my "aunt" and 2 "uncles" died when they were born

  • 3 is too young to pass away.

  • this song is beautiful, and dark. i feel as tho it was made just for us emos. this song makes me and my emo bf not think about our emo addiction. :| EMO OUT

  • @EmoProdigy12 It's your opinion to think that but this song was for her sister (Who died D:) So this song does not involve anything about emos.

  • @EvFansOfficle stop hatin on us emos! tht song was meant for emos! ever emo knows it because it is dark and sad! this song represents EMO LIFE! try being in an emo's shoes for a while!

  • @EmoProdigy12 Uhm.. Evfans wasnt 'Hatin'. This song was made for her little sister, Bonnie Lee, who died at the age of 3 and amy found out at school. And Emo Means emotional. And im pretty sure we have all atleast experienced being "Emo" just saying. im not hating.

  • @EmoProdigy12 Dumb fuck face. This song was made for Amy's sister, who died. Not you pathetic emo kids.

  • @ToxicAngelification I CANNOT BELIEVE HOW MUCH U HATE ON EMOS! so many emo h83r$.....h83r$ may mate me f@m0u$, but they r what KEEPS us cutting. This song represents us emos......... lots of ppl wanna fix us of our self inflicted pain but h83r$ rn't helping.

  • @ToxicAngelification i agree bro these ppl think that stuff is made for them but they got a rude awakening coming for them

  • @ToxicAngelification your completly right 

  • @EmoProdigy12 Did i ever say im hating on emos? NO. You just won't accept the fact that this was for Amy lee's sister not for emos. So long story short :

    You're wrong.

  • @EvFansOfficle No, it wasn't written for the lead singer of Evanescence sister and her real name is not Amy Lee. I wrote the song in the '80s and was influenced by many songs from the 70's such as Led Zeppelin, ELO and Lionel Ritchie who released a song of the same title in '84 after I met and started working with Michael Jackson on songs. I also worked with INXS & was a relationship with Michael Hutchence. They released the song Reckless Ways with my name "Amy" in the song.

  • @Boddahism What are you talking about? I know Amy Lee's sister is not named Amy Lee.

  • @EvFansOfficle The lead singer of Evanescence's real name is not Amy Lee, but a stage name as is Amy Lynn and Hartzler. I made up the song Hello many many years ago which the band performs. Inspiration came from the death of my grandmother. It was my grandmother's death on Oct 1, 1983 which also inspired the band name Evanescence from a review of A Chorus Line in the New York Times by Frank Rich printed on Oct 1, 1983.

  • @EvFansOfficle am i? or r u secretly attacking emos? LOTS of ppl do! just ask my bf, NicoEmo12! he and i can PROVE IT! we have a vid! EMOS RULE! EMO OUT. :'(

  • @EmoProdigy12 Dipshit, I'm not attacking emos i really LOVE emos. But i find it ignorant and stupid for you to say 'You're right' Just because you think this song is for emos. But really it's not there was even an interview about Amy Lee saying that this song is for her sister. You figure out the rest.

  • Hey guys my name is kyla, I have a YouTube Chanel Whee I express my talent by singing please share. Kyla1027

  • Hey guys,

    My name is Mallory and I'm 13. I love to make art videos, which is my way of expressing myself. Right now, I have lots of videos on my video editor that I haven't put up yet. However, I do have one video up ("What Girls Do at a Table.") It's not an art video, just a silly video I put up when my friends came over. Making videos, though, (NOT SILLY ONES!! LOL!!) is my passion. <3 Please subscribe and watch my video! And I promise I will be putting up some of my art videos. Rate this up!

  • May the stars watch over you

    May good fortune rule over you

    May peace live in your heart!

    I love you may lee <3

  • the lead singer for evanescence is still Amy Lee, as we speak

  • UP if you're crying right now ): forever and ever crying with this music!

  • wonderfull

  • @ritsukaxkelly nope that's a new band We are the Fallen. Carly smithson took the band

  • This song must be the saddest song ever. :' (

  • Don't get me wrong I'm still a successful person, I just finished school and am working with special needs students in elementary. As well as trying to become a published writer and poet on the side. But I'll always go back to how I've had struggle through adversity to do anything in my life. With the cognitive disabilities I should not be able to do anywhere near what I am with my life. I don't know where to end this, so here is a good place. I hope you all succeed, no matter what happens.

  • My biological father I've never heard from, or of, in my entire life. Nor can I say that I would really care to. My point of all of this is that when you give up a child there is a hole created in the entire fabric of their being. Something is broken inside of them that no amount of love or affection can replace. I now have my own daughter, who I love more than life itself. When I look into her eyes I couldn't even imagine what it would be like to leave her indefinitely.

  • I don't know if I'm just bantering or not, but I feel compelled to leave a message here. I seldom swing in and out of depression, but when I do I'm pretty down. I've had a lot happen to me in my life, I was adopted as an infant and I was diagnosed with several different cognitive disabilities by the time I began kindergarten. My biological mother was very mentally unstable and had disabilities of her own, this I've learned through my parents who have raised me remarkably.

  • Is the band making music again? I thought they called it quits a few years ago.

  • @daj4444 Yes they are still making music, but I heard that Amy Lee, isn't anymore the singer. That some other chick is instead.

  • @ritsukaxkelly Really? According to Wikipedia and their website, she is still working with them. I believe she even talked about their most recent album.

  • don't try to fix me i''m not broken :'(

  • świetny kawałek...

  • :( i love it

  • <33

  • Love this song. I listen to Evanescence all the time, mostly during hard times. I've learned to play two of her songs because I feel dedicated to Amy. She's helped me get through the worst and I thank her for tht :)

  • wenna

    

  • uhhh is this the video cause i dont get it?

  • 4 million views?? you are now at 18 million views!!

  • I remember I use to be in a dark place and would listen to evanescence all the time. Her songs probably saved my life as they reflected exactly how I felt. I know this sounds like I'm advertising (I sort of am), but I have opened a new forum/website dedicated to depression and other painful conditions in life. Come share your story :) growing-pain()info *Take out the brackets

  • @MrBusterofwar Me too :')

  • Her sister is an angle now :')

    I'm sorry Amy..

  • @Dima5342 i wish i was an angle

  • Her sister left too early...I'm sorry Amy

  • This song is eerily amazing, it reminds me of Akira Yamaoka's work. Unbelievably resounding.

  • What happen to amys sister ?

  • @TheJackiee000 She died at a very young age (I think 2 or 4?) of an unknown illness

  • I love this video and her she's awesome !! But Fuk love ;)

  • @ROKSpink Easy solution would be to ask him out which may seem odd to you but if you dont want to actually ask, you can always go back to your thoughts of him not asking you out as dejection

  • Go see them in concert...they're really good...spend some money on them, so we can support great bands, who deserve support...

  • this song is so touchless

  • I love someone who doesnt't even knows.....i don't think he even noticed how much I stay in front of my mirror every day just to look perfect....i straight my hair and dress carefully...i help him when he's in need for something....but I don't know...somebody said once that man never change...never...now I try to avoid eye contact, because I'm afraid that I can fall in love again....

  • @ROKSpink I did the same thing not too long ago. He told me he loved me. He didn't mean it. He used me. He had a girlfriend the whole time that was way prettier and more perfect than me. It hurts.

  • she is the best...

  • Wait a minute what happened to Amy's sister?? ;o xx

  • @LispySpence6 she died of unknown disease at age 3

  • I want to die for a moment or something . Im depressed! :(

  • @Musikloverr100 Well..perhaps instead of telling the world your everythought, you may actually go and get help for yourself?

  • This is a bad time for me to liston to this song... To many memories.... Evanesense is still amazing though great song :)

  • So I never really liked Evanescence much...or at all really...but this song is pretty good.

  • whats up ya'll ;D

  • Amy you bring me to my knees as you haunted my sacrifice you are my immortal now dry your eyes and wake me up bring me to life:)(((jspat

  • Hello i'm still here all whats left of yestarday hello

  • Comment removed

  • crying every time... this song is AWESOME!!!!!

    

  • Hello!! Now you need an update your video is 18 Millions views and couting...from a very good song ever made!

  • awsome..

    

  • for some reason i always feel like 2:46 fits me well...

  • oh my god .. i love this song ..

    its soooo good .. cannot stop crying ..

    it is just wondrefull .. :)

  • 815 dislikes? they must be "we are the fallen" fans......jejejje

  • Comment removed

  • sorry for 815 dislikes...they're my neighbors ;p

  • i like this song

  • Wery touchy song! It's just...beautiful with very much fealings,I...can't explain that is just...wonderful

  • This song saves me every day when I'm feeling desperate...when work, school and whole life fucks me.. :))

  • our tears will Fly to Heaven

    hold on 5 seconds, song "lost in paradise" acoustic

    --> watch?v=r4SteLZtV9Q

  • Realy good song :)

  • I want Amy Lee to be my singing teacher :D

  • If there's one thing you must do in life... Listen to this song!

  • The beste song ever ♥' I Love it...

  • Amy Lee, I feel sorry about your sister. She died too young. :'(

  • @98babis Wow, really?! How did you find this out? <3

  • Comment removed

  • Soon I know I'll wake from this dream

  • GrEaT 

  • volte para mim rk bt

  • You did an amazing job on this video! I know how hard it is to make this types of vids and u totally nailed it! My mom always makes me sing evanescence to her cuz I sound a lot like her

  • I love this song

  • Hey there, I'm a pretty new Amy Lee fan. Can any of you guys recommend songs similar to this one, something like Sally's Song or Immortal?

  • @savetheguineaworm "the last song i'm wasting on you", "secret door", "like you" or "breath no more"

  • @Elias1858 Thanks very much.

  • @savetheguineaworm Hey there, being from Little Rock myself, I've been a longtime fan from the beginning. Well, "Field of Innocence" is similar to this song and another one of my favorites. I hope you like. :)

  • @tiestoboi Thank you.

  • @savetheguineaworm Also look up "Anywhere" "Understanding - Wash it all away" "Listen to the Rain" "October" and "My Immortal"

  • 812 personas no tienen vida por escuchar Justin Bieber

  • k to the top comments

  • I love Evanescence!!!!! especially this song!!! my friends all think I'm weird because I listen to stuff like this that they call depressing and they're into Justin Beiber and Selena Gomez and stuff, but I don't care!!!!! This stuff is real. It's so... I don't know! It's just beautiful. RIP, Bonnie.

  • 812 people don't have a frikkin' life! This is AMAZING!

  • I listen to Evanescence's songs EVERY SINGLE DAY. I think it's her amazing voice, and their talent. Is it wierd of me? I don't think so.

  • @TheElisaloo it just means you have a good sense of music

  • heard this song a 18 787 323 times nd sneezed 811 times damn u haters

  • this song always makes me cry..:/

  • YAA HE IS A BEST SONG ,, I LIKE THIS SONG

  • I'm from Saudi Arabia I was impressed by the song Hamaha Hello

  • I heard this song million times and I never got bored of it... unbelievable voice ^_^

  • im listen this song until 2011..

  • I don't know what it is, but I can't stop listening to this song! <3

  • i love how they made the video.. nice :)

  • *Update* Thanks for the 4 million views!!! <-- this just made me lol.

  • 811 people missed the rightone

  • I still love your editing!!

  • @christinerobson ehm...18,7...thanks for the 18.7 mills... :D

  • I still can't believe I saw them live. Amy's voice is the best (female :P) voice in the business currently!

  • Her amazing Voice makes this so just PERFECT! <3

  • her voice.....just perfect!

  • I love this song so much, it Tought myself the piano part two years ago due to the absolute beauty of it. The even more amazing is that you edited a lot of videos to make it seem like she is actually singing the words. AMAZING!

  • makes me cry everytime <3

  • Классная песня, Эми ты лучшая.

  • cool vid

  • nice vid