I loved your reading of this - beautiful delivery. It is the oddest thing to know that people share these sames sorts of feelings about people...I think the genius of Murakami is that he takes these feelings that are so often discarded and writes them down - and the reader knows exactly what he's talking about...the shared experience of meeting the 100 % perfect stranger....
i think his stories are primarily meant to distort what would be widely accepted as the traditional sense of value. that is, modern authors seem to create narratives with cues that simply elicit responses that were paired with those same general cues throughout our pasts (ie, the homogeneity of values within the target audience). murakami seems to take a different approach, he makes the most mundane actions seem out of the ordinary and vice versa. thats what i like, the ambiguitys almost creepy
this video perfectly captured the essence of murkami. a lot of people pay too much attention to the physical details like the character's ethnicities or the setting, but they are mostly irrelavent details. a major theme of murakami's work is suffering and dealing with loss, which is a part of the human experience. when reading murakami, cultural differences are not as apparent since people will identify more with emotions provoked by universal issues (death, romance, coming-of-age).
hmmm....I'm honestly not meaning this to be racist, but I think that the story may have been better with actors of asian descent. Haha, no offense intended, just that when I read this story I imagined the speaker as a handsome asian man, not a small white man with glasses. See what I'm saying? :)
@o0Affinity0o Would that really affect the story so much? I think not, it's quite universal, speaker could be male/female, any race, any age and still, it works. That's what's beautiful about the simplicity of the piece.
hmm.. not in tokYo but in Tempe, Arizona. would that be correct? nwayz, wonderful wonderful video. u missed some part but im sure Murakami would still love it like we do. Kudos!
i started reading Murakami last year. and i fell in love with "kafka on the shore". and then came, this video. i've read this short story 6yrs ago, it captured my heart but i didnt know who wrote it. i just cant believe its
Murakami. guess kafka is not my 1st Murakami experience after all
nice job, but y didnt u finish it ? There was alittle bit more to the story and i felt that that little bit really made the short story tie together and made it great. Anyways, still for what u did do, good job.
I am reading these days The Elephant Vanishes and this short story is part of it. It's the one 'til now (have not finished yet) that caught most of all. The nice fairy tale is sweet and maybe true in life. Murakami always surprises me.
Speaking as a huge fan of Murakami, I must say that I really liked how you captured the simplicity of this piece. Your film making is great, and I congratulate you on making a fantastic short film!
good job on this - I've been looking at how people "do" Murakami all over YT - I love how everyone seems to have a different voice of his they hear - cinematography is great
wow,u left out alot of it,n yea if anybody would really like to have illustrations for the story u should check out this japanese manga(what we call it comic).The name is 100%perfect girl by Wann it's a really interesting manga that greatly relates to this story
Great stuff -- I felt quite emotional at the end of that. I think I've had similar thoughts before, and this is what makes Murakami so good at what he does: We relate to his unusual view of the world.
Really nice interpretation of the story- I liked the way you made it your own yet retained the atmosphere of Murakami's writing. And it wasn't overblown like the film version of Toni Takitani. Well done.
Well done for the most part, but why leave out one of the most important parts of the story, what he would have said? That was the most memorable part of it, for me.
Murakami is not an original Japanese writer. He has nothing really to say, He is no great intellect, not memorale, there is an aura, but when i think back there is nothing. He is not brillian, but writes adequate stories. His characters are average and so is he. He is the writer of the age of people with nothign to say. Lets settle for adequatitude.
fair statements moloko36. in my humble opinion there's more then that to Murakami's work. i tend to think there is subtle genius in the way his characters are portrayed and/or created, w/ storylines that whisper emotions, and echo an unknown/familiar memory. his modest manner and matter a fact way draws this reader in. he is a author who may have nothing to say (to some), but who presents that nothing in such a way that it may very well be something more. this skill's at least above average?
@moloko36 aura is everything. Aura is more important than anything else. Aura can transform a solid, unchangeable, concrete object and turn it into something else entirely, without changing any of it's physical or chemical properties.
I agree with the previous commenter, your lead actor definately has the right kind of voice for the voiceovers in this short film. I'm abit curious about the setting of the film, is there any specific meaning or themes by placing him in a dark room?
That was pretty nice. You're one of the better actors at narrating this story (at least from what's posted on YouTube). VERY tough to translate Murakami and his atmospheric writing to film.
why did you miss the important ending??
alexlovescherylx 1 month ago
Nice work.
Rocketboy5 6 months ago
I loved your reading of this - beautiful delivery. It is the oddest thing to know that people share these sames sorts of feelings about people...I think the genius of Murakami is that he takes these feelings that are so often discarded and writes them down - and the reader knows exactly what he's talking about...the shared experience of meeting the 100 % perfect stranger....
logotrix 10 months ago
That is a beautiful adaptation of the story, but I really wish you would have included what he would have said to her, it's my favourite part!
karrado4 11 months ago
Nice adaptation of Haruki Murakami's story!
byvalm 11 months ago
Me gustó, bastante...MAGNIFICO TRABAJO!
Lawlietrock 1 year ago
i think his stories are primarily meant to distort what would be widely accepted as the traditional sense of value. that is, modern authors seem to create narratives with cues that simply elicit responses that were paired with those same general cues throughout our pasts (ie, the homogeneity of values within the target audience). murakami seems to take a different approach, he makes the most mundane actions seem out of the ordinary and vice versa. thats what i like, the ambiguitys almost creepy
riseabove24 1 year ago
Comment removed
riseabove24 1 year ago
this video perfectly captured the essence of murkami. a lot of people pay too much attention to the physical details like the character's ethnicities or the setting, but they are mostly irrelavent details. a major theme of murakami's work is suffering and dealing with loss, which is a part of the human experience. when reading murakami, cultural differences are not as apparent since people will identify more with emotions provoked by universal issues (death, romance, coming-of-age).
alexisgonzaludo 1 year ago
hmmm....I'm honestly not meaning this to be racist, but I think that the story may have been better with actors of asian descent. Haha, no offense intended, just that when I read this story I imagined the speaker as a handsome asian man, not a small white man with glasses. See what I'm saying? :)
o0Affinity0o 1 year ago
@o0Affinity0o Would that really affect the story so much? I think not, it's quite universal, speaker could be male/female, any race, any age and still, it works. That's what's beautiful about the simplicity of the piece.
sapphchick 1 year ago
Great!! the way u tell this story is just simply out of the box!!
stupid02 1 year ago
I think this is better than the finished story. The voice acting is incredible. Director really knows how to do a voice over. really, kudos
cdunwood 1 year ago
hmm.. not in tokYo but in Tempe, Arizona. would that be correct? nwayz, wonderful wonderful video. u missed some part but im sure Murakami would still love it like we do. Kudos!
desiderata143 1 year ago
i started reading Murakami last year. and i fell in love with "kafka on the shore". and then came, this video. i've read this short story 6yrs ago, it captured my heart but i didnt know who wrote it. i just cant believe its
Murakami. guess kafka is not my 1st Murakami experience after all
desiderata143 1 year ago
This was an extremely simple story and you captured it simply magnificently!
Now for a Wind Up Bird movie! (just kidding I will not request the impossible!)
OM3N1R 2 years ago
100% wonderful video
Anchiovy 2 years ago 2
Where could I find more short stories of this kind of romantic mystic nature this story is amazing.
gammergq 2 years ago
nice job, but y didnt u finish it ? There was alittle bit more to the story and i felt that that little bit really made the short story tie together and made it great. Anyways, still for what u did do, good job.
kokujin72 2 years ago 4
MH is a wonderful author
theagnostix 2 years ago
Great ,soulful, interpretation.
Paul186 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love this story
mzmariagina 2 years ago
I am reading these days The Elephant Vanishes and this short story is part of it. It's the one 'til now (have not finished yet) that caught most of all. The nice fairy tale is sweet and maybe true in life. Murakami always surprises me.
FranceschinaSacca 2 years ago
Where could I find more romantic magic stories of this kind?
gammergq 2 years ago
Speaking as a huge fan of Murakami, I must say that I really liked how you captured the simplicity of this piece. Your film making is great, and I congratulate you on making a fantastic short film!
superlox3 2 years ago
you make puppies cry~~~~~~~~~~
lilsonic206 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you fucking suck donkey dick you blow......im going to do this a hell of a lot better you dike diver
lilsonic206 2 years ago
good job on this - I've been looking at how people "do" Murakami all over YT - I love how everyone seems to have a different voice of his they hear - cinematography is great
revolotus 2 years ago
wow,u left out alot of it,n yea if anybody would really like to have illustrations for the story u should check out this japanese manga(what we call it comic).The name is 100%perfect girl by Wann it's a really interesting manga that greatly relates to this story
whereisurheartmybaby 2 years ago
Great stuff -- I felt quite emotional at the end of that. I think I've had similar thoughts before, and this is what makes Murakami so good at what he does: We relate to his unusual view of the world.
shimmeringreflection 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1. copy and paste
2. send this to 9 other videos.
3. hold your breath for 10 seconds
4. press refresh twice
3. LOOK AT YOUR BACKGROUND IT WILL BE FREAKY"
XxTheSweetestAgonyxX 2 years ago
that's why there is Craiglist,Missed Connections section and you will find the one u didn't had courage to approach by.
StarVenusshinning 3 years ago
Really nice interpretation of the story- I liked the way you made it your own yet retained the atmosphere of Murakami's writing. And it wasn't overblown like the film version of Toni Takitani. Well done.
ellecrane1 3 years ago
i think moloko is on to something...but i love reading his books. personally i think sputnik sweetheart was better than norwegian wood.
StephenKuma 3 years ago
this is really good man. it's interesting how the story is presen
1234sss 3 years ago
Well done for the most part, but why leave out one of the most important parts of the story, what he would have said? That was the most memorable part of it, for me.
TalkingMoviezzz 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Murakami is not an original Japanese writer. He has nothing really to say, He is no great intellect, not memorale, there is an aura, but when i think back there is nothing. He is not brillian, but writes adequate stories. His characters are average and so is he. He is the writer of the age of people with nothign to say. Lets settle for adequatitude.
moloko36 3 years ago
Well, moloko36 you're wrong. Your opinion is just...incorrect.
Revise it.
:P
RowanSpry 3 years ago
fair statements moloko36. in my humble opinion there's more then that to Murakami's work. i tend to think there is subtle genius in the way his characters are portrayed and/or created, w/ storylines that whisper emotions, and echo an unknown/familiar memory. his modest manner and matter a fact way draws this reader in. he is a author who may have nothing to say (to some), but who presents that nothing in such a way that it may very well be something more. this skill's at least above average?
falseauthentic 3 years ago 6
@moloko36 aura is everything. Aura is more important than anything else. Aura can transform a solid, unchangeable, concrete object and turn it into something else entirely, without changing any of it's physical or chemical properties.
magegirl8 11 months ago
this has grown on me, but i still can't condone this story though you, dan, are fantastic
tomaszbethell 3 years ago
i lied. I can hear the voiceover now. murakami is a wonderful, and I think you did this story justice.
ImprobProductions 3 years ago
i actually liked it. the voiceover cannot be heard though. I really like the cinematography
ImprobProductions 3 years ago
I really like the voice of the guy! It was 100% perfect :)
DefectiveQueen 3 years ago
yes it was as memoriless as she was.
captured his trite and repeating feeling quite accurately
friendsofthefruitsof 3 years ago
yeah, of all the versions i've seen done of this, this one is easily the best version. Great job.
rodgerswan 3 years ago
I agree with the previous commenter, your lead actor definately has the right kind of voice for the voiceovers in this short film. I'm abit curious about the setting of the film, is there any specific meaning or themes by placing him in a dark room?
Great short though :)
mbhwee 3 years ago
I love this story, one of my favourite short stories from Murakami.
natsala 3 years ago
That was pretty nice. You're one of the better actors at narrating this story (at least from what's posted on YouTube). VERY tough to translate Murakami and his atmospheric writing to film.
Branner 3 years ago