Found out about this song thanks to Rocksmith. Found out about Pearl Jam thanks to Guitar Hero 3 a several years ago. I love the musical sounds in this song!
HEY KIDS hear that? it kinda sounds like human beings talking...not computer. this is what they used to call talent. the meaning of that word has been changed to what you wear and how much computers can fix your voice. all the real talent in the music business right now is the computers.
hen he holds that note, and then I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, etc, yeah talk about raw emotion coming through clearly in his voice and the melody of the music-one om my fav's by them"all the love gone black........" and t
Adding to my last post.people like lady whatever her name is are as numb as a piss stone.as long as they do what they are told.All you need these days is to look like an abortion with legs to get the publics attention,and you will go platiNUMB! Open minds need not apply.
this track should be played to all the young kids that listen to lady ga ga ,and the like.and realise music aint about how you look ,its about what you feel.
@gandykin You're right but music is not about realizing what it's truely about. Music can mean different things to different people, and it's up to each of them individually to experience music as they like. If they like music about meaningless shit without any emotion whatsoever; let them. They just miss out a lot :)
my world turned to black on 12-16-11 at 10ish pm when you died. i love you so much. i cradle broken glass everyday. my month has been black. y,y,y,y,y, did you have to die?
@ProjectDingmans He makes a perfectly good point, so I can't understand your animosity. To make a video like this takes time and effort; in doing so you show that you love the music you are willingly sharing with others. It is not too much to ask that the words are correct, so that those who will listen to the song that you are showing them, can sing along correctly, or even make a video of their own.
this song helps when ur depressed...reminds me of my gf(ex) onley been 3 weeks i feel like im dead already. fuck my life... but thanks pearl jam for helping me get threw it a little easier.
How quick the sun can...drop away...Miss you Grandma, miss you bro. Tattooed everything all the love gone bad, turned my world to black tattooed all I see, all I am, all I'll be...miss you too mum, though I barely knew you. I love you all. Yeaa..
The lyrics are wrong in this video and many others I've seen. It is not "Were laid spread out before me." Correct: "Her legs spread out before me." Also, it's not "I know you'll be a sun." Correct: "I know you'll be a star." Wish people who make these videos of songs with lyrics would get the words right before making the video(s). Kind of an insult to the artist (the creator(s)) when the words are wrong.
"i know someday you'll have a beautiful life, i know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky, but, why, why, why can't it be oh can't it be mine" Waw one of the best set of lyrics ever written about love. So damn true. this song is amazing.
Whoever broke his heart like that should feel really fucking guilty knowing the fact that Eddie made a song out of it. Shows so much sadness and confusion in the song
This was my dads song to my mom-he died 13 years ago of brain cancer-i was 3 years old. and my only video i have of me and him together has this song playing in the backround.
my highschool boyfriend whom i broke up with for reasons i still to this day do not understand....recently told me he constantly listened to this song when i broke up with him. =( i should have had my ass kicked!!!
On the line "How quick the sun can drop away" always brings the first tear to my eye from this song because it's so true. It can all end in the blink of an eye. :( so sad
92% of teens have turned to pop and hip-hop.If you are part of the 8% that still listen to real music, copy and paste this message to 5 other videos. DONT LET ROCK N ROLL DIE !
i thought it was OLD MAN WASHED IN BLACK TATTOO'D EVERYTHING i cant spell. ANYWAY I SOUNDED TO ME LIKE HE LOST HIS (FIRST)TRUE LOVE TO SOME OLD TATTOO GUY LIKE IN JACKSONVILLE.GOT COKE?LIFE IS ALWAYS CHANGING SO SHARE THE LOVE!
Eddie Vedder had a black daughter named jeremy who he assured was still alive so he went with the even flow and gave her one last kiss.. during the sex he told her to just breathe, he`d be a better man and later, an animal
Please explain this further, ever since I read your comment it made me think a lot about all their songs, and since then I can't stop thinking that this song could be about what he did to his daughter when before I always related to it thinking it was a break up between a first love.
@intimidatorfan69 bump break up. Anyone can break up. This is a 'someone took my bleeding heart, threw it on a cement floor and stomped on it until it exploded' song. Or maybe someone took my virginity and never talked to me again. Either or really. Where's John Cusack when we need him?
Why can't it be mine?
Alainiam 6 hours ago
Found out about this song thanks to Rocksmith. Found out about Pearl Jam thanks to Guitar Hero 3 a several years ago. I love the musical sounds in this song!
MajorVidGamer 3 days ago
I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, i know you'll be the sun, in somebody else's sky but why, why, why can't it be, can't it be mine
Pearl jam lyric's are so perfect
walter3124 1 week ago 2
Comment removed
MannysFresh365 1 week ago
masterpiece
unrealgamr23 2 weeks ago
lot of jimi Hendrix influence here...
togetherwestand32 2 weeks ago
@togetherwestand32 Agreed, I was just listening to Hendrix and thought of this song!
BudgieMetalworks 1 week ago
Makes me sad :(
ONL1NEG4MER 3 weeks ago
does anyone else want to fuck when they hear this song?
lindsey0870 3 weeks ago
@lindsey0870 You read my mind. ._.
Mady1355 3 weeks ago
@lindsey0870 Big time!!!! :-)
frantzous 1 week ago
Just wow.
iosonoalain 3 weeks ago
Love this!
UnsolvedMystery182 3 weeks ago
Beautiful lyric's.
sunnysdelight1 3 weeks ago
Beautiful lyrics.
APCTOOL16 3 weeks ago
~why can't it be, why can't it be mine???~....
thedarksoulyo1 1 month ago
Comment removed
thedarksoulyo1 1 month ago in playlist Rock On!
This has been flagged as spam show
HEY KIDS hear that? it kinda sounds like human beings talking...not computer. this is what they used to call talent. the meaning of that word has been changed to what you wear and how much computers can fix your voice. all the real talent in the music business right now is the computers.
cdude1313 1 month ago
quando il genio è cervello ma soprattuttto stomaco e cuore
valeriozizza 1 month ago
@valeriozizza chi diavolo importa fottuto frocio ??!!!!
eyeridealmost 1 month ago
portami quella grandissima p@òe98@@#a di tua sorella che sicuramente torno etero
valeriozizza 4 weeks ago
hen he holds that note, and then I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, etc, yeah talk about raw emotion coming through clearly in his voice and the melody of the music-one om my fav's by them"all the love gone black........" and t
annyisit79 1 month ago
Adding to my last post.people like lady whatever her name is are as numb as a piss stone.as long as they do what they are told.All you need these days is to look like an abortion with legs to get the publics attention,and you will go platiNUMB! Open minds need not apply.
gandykin 1 month ago
this track should be played to all the young kids that listen to lady ga ga ,and the like.and realise music aint about how you look ,its about what you feel.
gandykin 1 month ago 5
@gandykin You're right but music is not about realizing what it's truely about. Music can mean different things to different people, and it's up to each of them individually to experience music as they like. If they like music about meaningless shit without any emotion whatsoever; let them. They just miss out a lot :)
Kadajpwns1337 1 month ago
i fucked it up with a girl so naturally i came and listened to this song :(
michaelmyers1993 1 month ago
my world turned to black on 12-16-11 at 10ish pm when you died. i love you so much. i cradle broken glass everyday. my month has been black. y,y,y,y,y, did you have to die?
rozhedman 1 month ago
If I died during this song i think I'd be ok
theSANCH81 1 month ago 5
:50 to :60 guitar fills sound like Yellow Ledbetter kind of, maybe that's why they cut it from the record.
1201zj 1 month ago
my fave song ever!
kikipeach74 1 month ago
@kikipeach74 mine too!!!!
bceltica 1 month ago
still listening to this in 2012...and still heartbroken..
MrJabate 2 months ago 41
@MrJabate i know mate me too.damn this was our song
ULTRASID 1 month ago
@MrJabate I feel it too, man. After all these years, whenever this is on the radio, or on at a bar or party, it still stabs me.
rattusmortis 1 month ago
@rattusmortis This song has been stabbing me in the heart for ever it seems.
g9v11 1 month ago
@MrJabate Yeah, know the feeling...
reinaluna 3 weeks ago
@MrJabate I fuckin know the feeling Bro.
Alainiam 6 hours ago
Comment removed
MrJabate 2 months ago
"I know you'll be a STAR* in somebody else's sky"
Sorry had to say it..
QCpowarr 2 months ago
This is one of the best songs about unrequited love ever made...
mfdgtq 2 months ago 2
Happy Birthday, Eddie!!!
Promiatv 2 months ago
Pearl Jam.. yet another band that actually HAD talent.. unlike just about every band including Maroon 5(Prob the MOST OVERRATED BAND of alltime)
cirojoseph1 2 months ago
Happy Birthday Eddie you god
Oilers97Byrne 2 months ago
THIS SONG ROCKS MY WORLD AND I KNOW MY KENNETH WHERE EVER YU ARE BABY YU THINKING ABOUT ME TO THIS SONG:( I LOVE YU BEBE!! URS 4EVER YURI!
DTRUTHHURT5 2 months ago
I understand molucues and atoms and electrons = I don't understand why they all accumalte to this song...but they do
Atroxiocus 2 months ago
This song just does something to the soul. Painfully beautiful.
alevisepic 2 months ago 47
no coments
TheMrJnr 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
oh she thinks i dont know oh that hurt get them out peroid
taralyons1 2 months ago
This is one of the best songs ever..
TalorinSath 2 months ago
un buen tema........................
fsarevaloa 2 months ago
She ran back to his arms when she heard the song he had wrotten to her!!!
PochaquitaDavis 3 months ago
this is probably one of the single greatest songs ive ever heard.
nevvereverr 3 months ago
AWESOME SONG!
w127smc 3 months ago
@fredje89 im not
notchjohnson1 3 months ago
Best song ever!
hombtaylor 3 months ago
Six people are crazy
theulmmett 3 months ago
this might be one of the greatest song ever dude.
dramamama1820000 3 months ago
Pearl Jam are such underrated songwriters.
opa2299 3 months ago
Pearl Jam!
kcizzle1987 4 months ago
Make my toes curl with pleasure.
phantomtowers 4 months ago
This song has gotten me through some tough shit. Thanks Eddie.
Lisbonfalls44 4 months ago
Spectacular
ibanezslx 4 months ago
this sucks COCK!
70s80sglam 4 months ago
@70s80sglam I love getting my cock sucked, so what your saying is this is amazing. I couldn't agree more.
Chapter1Tormented 4 months ago in playlist Chapter1Tormented's favorites
@Chapter1Tormented no are you retarded
70s80sglam 4 months ago
@70s80sglam I'm not the one saying, "this sucks cock". That would make you the...less intelligent one here. Let's be respectful.
Chapter1Tormented 4 months ago
@Chapter1Tormented y?
70s80sglam 4 months ago
@70s80sglam Why NOT?
Chapter1Tormented 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@70s80sglam well then why don't you get the fuck out of here? and clearly your taste in music is flawed
lighttheboll 4 months ago
I literally cannot stop listening to this song, it's my favourite Pearl Jam song :D
sm7supernatural 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ESTA CANCIÓN ES BRUTAL Y MORTAL......LA AMO ♥
yuligomitaz 5 months ago
ESTA CANCIÓN ES BRUTAL Y MORTAL......LA AMO ♥
yuligomitaz 5 months ago
@yuligomitaz Have to agree with you
MrAldentcoleman 4 months ago
god damn the ppl on this site are more stuck up then a 14 year olds boner stop fightin and chill damn
mrtall1994 5 months ago
these arent the right lyrics...
haleyjo1234 5 months ago
@haleyjo1234 feel free to explain the right ones then superman!
bearus08 5 months ago
My favorite Pearl Jam song!!!!
cmwhidden 5 months ago
Comment removed
silversplender 5 months ago
Comment removed
silversplender 5 months ago
@ProjectDingmans He makes a perfectly good point, so I can't understand your animosity. To make a video like this takes time and effort; in doing so you show that you love the music you are willingly sharing with others. It is not too much to ask that the words are correct, so that those who will listen to the song that you are showing them, can sing along correctly, or even make a video of their own.
Chapter1Tormented 5 months ago in playlist Chapter1Tormented's Favorited Videos
Comment removed
silversplender 5 months ago
Best song ever made.
heat8167 5 months ago
this song helps when ur depressed...reminds me of my gf(ex) onley been 3 weeks i feel like im dead already. fuck my life... but thanks pearl jam for helping me get threw it a little easier.
rainingbloodonu 5 months ago
@rainingbloodonu im here for u man
undeadbobcat 5 months ago
yeah man........everytime i hear it it reminds of a certain ex.......and then when its over i think how lucky i am to be shot of the crazy wench
badboybubby1001 6 months ago
I just felt the urge to go back in time
blacksabbatho 6 months ago
How quick the sun can...drop away...Miss you Grandma, miss you bro. Tattooed everything all the love gone bad, turned my world to black tattooed all I see, all I am, all I'll be...miss you too mum, though I barely knew you. I love you all. Yeaa..
Chapter1Tormented 6 months ago
You forgot to add "Too doo doo too, too doo doo [many times until fade]" at the end!
PromiserOfDeath 6 months ago
The lyrics are wrong in this video and many others I've seen. It is not "Were laid spread out before me." Correct: "Her legs spread out before me." Also, it's not "I know you'll be a sun." Correct: "I know you'll be a star." Wish people who make these videos of songs with lyrics would get the words right before making the video(s). Kind of an insult to the artist (the creator(s)) when the words are wrong.
silversplender 6 months ago
@silversplender im pretty sure he got the "were laid spread out before me" correct.
CodyXWay 4 months ago
Comment removed
silversplender 6 months ago
Comment removed
silversplender 6 months ago
always makes me cry after a breakup
1Latinakisses 6 months ago
"i know someday you'll have a beautiful life, i know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky, but, why, why, why can't it be oh can't it be mine" Waw one of the best set of lyrics ever written about love. So damn true. this song is amazing.
thepeach444 6 months ago 11
sorry man, but this subtitle is wrong.
4EverMetalMusic 6 months ago
why cant they make songs like this anymore?!
bryannacake 6 months ago
You have to be completely Crazy to Dislike this song...
MCRbetterthanBieber 6 months ago 2
Nirvana may have started grunge and alternative but Pearl Jam made it mainstream. They did it better. Eddie Vedder is a damn wonder.
viper2375 7 months ago
My favorite pearl jam song:)
esme09alice 7 months ago
This is one of my top 5 favorite songs ever. Grunge had pure meaning.
jc66159 7 months ago 31
Whoever broke his heart like that should feel really fucking guilty knowing the fact that Eddie made a song out of it. Shows so much sadness and confusion in the song
iantobia 7 months ago
tatuó mi mundo de negro... todo lo que veo, lo que soy y lo que sere... (y los tatuajes no se quitan) :´(
zsaltax 7 months ago
Beautiful fucking song. Probably not the best to hear when down or drunk.
chigon89 7 months ago
I knew it was something I just couldn't quite put my finger on what it was.
sonnieandjacob 7 months ago
It could just be me but am I the only one who thinks that Black and Yellow ledbetter sound very very similar
sonnieandjacob 7 months ago
@sonnieandjacob They are both in the same key
DieByTheDrop 7 months ago
This was my dads song to my mom-he died 13 years ago of brain cancer-i was 3 years old. and my only video i have of me and him together has this song playing in the backround.
saraking2895 7 months ago 34
@saraking2895 Sorry to hear that, my dad also died of cancer.
Tigerballer122 2 months ago
Comment removed
saraking2895 7 months ago
I tear up everytime I hear this song. It reminds me too much of her
rageagainstboxhead 7 months ago
rolololololololooooon
starciasca 7 months ago
my highschool boyfriend whom i broke up with for reasons i still to this day do not understand....recently told me he constantly listened to this song when i broke up with him. =( i should have had my ass kicked!!!
tiffanyag84 7 months ago
its i knw youll be a STAR in somebody elses sky
landon501996 7 months ago
im committing suicide to this song
notchjohnson1 8 months ago 16
@notchjohnson1 awesome, i'll look for it on the news
darknight6664533 8 months ago
@notchjohnson1 Me too
FizzyPops3434 7 months ago
@notchjohnson1
and so do I
666gzu 7 months ago
@notchjohnson1 me to bro
The90srockfan 4 months ago
@notchjohnson1 I really hope that was sarcasm.
FlaKey511 3 months ago
@notchjohnson1 damn it dont do that!!!!
nini0183 3 months ago
@nini0183 why not? whod care? no one
notchjohnson1 3 months ago
The feeling... that you get from this song is just indescribable...
1959GibsonLesPaul1 8 months ago
this is the most beautiful song ever
vampirstudmuffin 8 months ago
On the line "How quick the sun can drop away" always brings the first tear to my eye from this song because it's so true. It can all end in the blink of an eye. :( so sad
Jayomi09 8 months ago
I love this song but it reminds me so much of that special girl that I knew years ago that I miss dearly still
zzzombie888 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You say Katy Perry,I say Nine Inch Nails
You say Lady Gaga,I say Evanescence
You say Miley Cyrus,I say Soundgarden
You say T-Pain,I say Three Days Grace
You say Justin Bieber,I say Linkin Park
You say Jonas Brothers,I say Green Day
You say Ke$ha,I say Papa Roach
92% of teens have turned to pop and hip-hop.If you are part of the 8% that still listen to real music, copy and paste this message to 5 other videos. DONT LET ROCK N ROLL DIE !
MarkeSharke 8 months ago
why can't beEeEeEeE MaaaAAAA HaaaAAAA HARGH HARGH INNNNNEEE ?
simmerahluwalia 8 months ago 8
i thought it was OLD MAN WASHED IN BLACK TATTOO'D EVERYTHING i cant spell. ANYWAY I SOUNDED TO ME LIKE HE LOST HIS (FIRST)TRUE LOVE TO SOME OLD TATTOO GUY LIKE IN JACKSONVILLE.GOT COKE?LIFE IS ALWAYS CHANGING SO SHARE THE LOVE!
311superfly 8 months ago
everytime i listen to this song its like my ex WROTE it about me.
uscgirl212 8 months ago
EPIC SONG
supermanben123 9 months ago
This song comes on every time I'm driving alone. It's probably the best driving song ever... It's so chill...
gokusgirl4ever 9 months ago
@gokusgirl4ever i got satellite i listen to pearljam radio all the time
supermanben123 9 months ago
@supermanben123 fuck yeah, i do too.. all the time!
bdassvids 8 months ago
I always thought he said, she took empty cabins
TalpatJuh 9 months ago
VERY POWERFUL song! Every time I hear this song I sing it out so loudly where my throat hurts afterwards!
Fonzi79 9 months ago 2
@hollahoe88
Your Point?
NOMNOMSUSHIBEAR 9 months ago
3 PEOPLE ARE BLACK.
hollahoe88 9 months ago
@hollahoe88 -.-
SimplyShaded 9 months ago
@hollahoe88 I had the urge to yell at you, then I realized the song was called Black. Lucky day for you, my friend.
But on that note, amazing song. Makes you drown within your own doubts, fears, and love- all at the same time...
xoDerpNessox 9 months ago
@hollahoe88 lmao. you lord
Smurchison 9 months ago
Eddie Vedder had a black daughter named jeremy who he assured was still alive so he went with the even flow and gave her one last kiss.. during the sex he told her to just breathe, he`d be a better man and later, an animal
metallicarocks37 9 months ago
@metallicarocks37 I wanna add to this....
Go.
kikai74 9 months ago
@metallicarocks37
Please explain this further, ever since I read your comment it made me think a lot about all their songs, and since then I can't stop thinking that this song could be about what he did to his daughter when before I always related to it thinking it was a break up between a first love.
Nothingface1612 7 months ago
@Nothingface1612
It's not a serious comment. It's a play on the titles of different songs.
tonyspinningg 6 months ago
i cant stop crying whit this song
goriloman 9 months ago
Love what you have today, tomorrow is might all fall apart.
Life is short. Live it well god damn it! You only get one!
clintewoodyt 10 months ago 6
you got the lyrics wrong
markdh21 10 months ago
BEST BREAK UP SONG EVER!!!
intimidatorfan69 11 months ago 93
@intimidatorfan69 That's funny, because I imagined a couple making love to the tune of this song. OH THE IRONY.
Stef04343 9 months ago
@intimidatorfan69 you know this song is about a murderer right?
minkbob 8 months ago
@minkbob No, It's about a break up
vicadin9 8 months ago
@intimidatorfan69 i broke ur thumbs up button
korneths13 7 months ago 2
@intimidatorfan69 bump break up. Anyone can break up. This is a 'someone took my bleeding heart, threw it on a cement floor and stomped on it until it exploded' song. Or maybe someone took my virginity and never talked to me again. Either or really. Where's John Cusack when we need him?
whitegirlblackshirt 6 months ago
I think this is my favourite pearl jam song. Class
Teddybhoy32 1 year ago
Essa banda é fóids
Oficina da Arte
palazini
Palazini7 1 year ago
if u like eddie vedder watch the movie "into the wild"
manosTimy 2 years ago
You're damn right. And eddie vedder is still looking better and better with age.
vita63640 2 years ago 33
@vita63640 Betterman LOL
MrEinstain 8 months ago
@MrEinstain what?
vicadin9 8 months ago
This song us truly amazing.
xxAnarchyGasMaskxx 2 years ago 46