@393sara393 If I can find a sheet music maker, I will. Unfortunately, this was by ear, so it would take me a while. On the plus side, I could probably tweak it if I put it down on sheet music so it sounds a little better.lol
I could have told you that one.lol I never claimed to be an expert. I was just fucking around and pulled this out of my ass one day. I know it's terrible.haha
@fafnir242 dude you dont have to explain to this kind of person who only knows how to complain about other's video or something, just tell he or she to fuck off the video if he or she does no like it. These guys cant grow up anyways, don like the video? fucking do one themselves then. anyways i think you did a pretty good job, 5/5 stars
You are not playing the "real" version or anything close to it as the 6 min long remix plays as. First of all, you're missing out on A LOT of chords on the right hand. The chords are a key part of the melody to get that dramatic, epic feel. When you hit a chord versus one key at a time, the sound is more denser and echoes with a deeper feeling of emotion. Thus the epic effect.
But as I watched your performance, you're hitting one key at a time, pretty much, on your right hand (Treble Cleft).
Very good playing, but the 6 minute version of this song is just a remix.
The official version of Lux Aeterna is only about 4 minutes long. The 6 minute version is just the original Lux Aeterna looped twice, sometimes including Requiem for a Tower (the orchestral version). That's why nobody can find the 6 minute version on iTunes, etc. It's just a remix, not the official thing.
Yeah, I roughly know the melody on guitar. I couldn't play the song well on it if I wanted to, but it's still fun to screw around with a particular melody and see what you come up with.
i'm not like a professional piano player or anything, but judging by the comments so far, your really humble and openminded, and that's all that matters. you'll go far dude! :DD
Thanks. I should probably post more stuff if I can get a hold of a decent camera/recording system. I've learned a few more songs, like neoMAX, Crazy Loop, and I'm currently working on the POLYSICS cover of Mr. Roboto.lol Should be up in a couple of months.lol
Okay, maybe I'm not going to exactly get great on that one, but Crazy Loop and neoMAX, I'm definitely going to have up in a couple of weeks, maybe.lol
hey eric..can you play it..lol probably not i hate people like you always trying to pick out every single mistake someone makes and you can't even do it... grow up bro!
and sorry i hate people like you....someone gives some criticism...that can be taken one of two ways. your the immature person that takes it the wrong way. I happen to be able to play this song and actually play it well for being in my 3rd year of music school. My opinion, Eric is right. Needs some dynamics and you're fine. The notes are all there. Way to go! keep it up!
You're right. I'll take any criticism. It's like they've been telling us at meetings for work: If you don't tell us it's wrong, we can't fix it. That's mainly why I posted. To get feedback and see if I can make any improvements (so far, the most commented fault of mine is the camera.lol).
sorry but its not that good compared to myself and some others that ive seen. But there's always time to learn the full better version....................get the camera fixed..............by the way it wasnt horrible. the tone was the same as the song by clint....just needed some more fingers to the cords
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i agree, this is all wrong played. this dude should not post this video since it gives the completally wrong impression of the song. more practice less recording plox. bai
lol you just like BAM, BAM,BAM with the accords :P left hand :P it could have been more fluent played. Though I know how hard it is to play such beautiful song by ear. If I were you I would practice more and be more gently for the piano, the song builds it self up, so don't start hard, play soft and build it up to FF and then slowy go to pp
If there is sheet music, I have no knowledge of its existence. I did this entirely by ear, so until I can find a free sheet music writing program, my version is going to remain just a learning by ear thing. Do you happen to know of such a program? If so, please help me out here.lol
its not the soundtrack of lord of the rings its the soundtrack of the movie "sunshine". I think you are a good piano player but you need to get a better recording system ! :-)
I also mess around alot with his theme. (also have a vid op youtube :o) Anway this gives me some great idea's. do you have any sheets/midi files for this? or did you do it by ear.
Sadly, I did this entirely by ear. However, if I could actually find a FREE sheet music writing program, give me a couple hours, I could get it down.lol
ah dont waste time on that ill just improvise learning stuff by ear is also fun and challenging :), I dont even like note sheets, Useally I learn stuff from midi files 10x faster. I have the yamaha E403 next to my piano it shows the keys on a display(with pause/play/ff/rw stuff).
Your piano needs tuning my good friend but you did a great job
monkey198705 4 months ago
heeeeey what append with the light..?
eextreme88 1 year ago
@eextreme88 I filmed this at my aunt's house, and her piano is right next to a window, so I had a bad angle.lol
fafnir242 1 year ago
FINALLY someone plays the REAL version, can u put the sheet music, but u could use a better quality cam like u said.
393sara393 1 year ago
@393sara393 If I can find a sheet music maker, I will. Unfortunately, this was by ear, so it would take me a while. On the plus side, I could probably tweak it if I put it down on sheet music so it sounds a little better.lol
fafnir242 1 year ago
i love the part 3:15
910Flameboy 1 year ago
It s terrible. At an exam you would fail with this production...
trezike 2 years ago
I could have told you that one.lol I never claimed to be an expert. I was just fucking around and pulled this out of my ass one day. I know it's terrible.haha
fafnir242 2 years ago
@fafnir242 dude you dont have to explain to this kind of person who only knows how to complain about other's video or something, just tell he or she to fuck off the video if he or she does no like it. These guys cant grow up anyways, don like the video? fucking do one themselves then. anyways i think you did a pretty good job, 5/5 stars
darkn941 1 year ago 2
@darkn941 Thanks.
fafnir242 1 year ago
You are not playing the "real" version or anything close to it as the 6 min long remix plays as. First of all, you're missing out on A LOT of chords on the right hand. The chords are a key part of the melody to get that dramatic, epic feel. When you hit a chord versus one key at a time, the sound is more denser and echoes with a deeper feeling of emotion. Thus the epic effect.
But as I watched your performance, you're hitting one key at a time, pretty much, on your right hand (Treble Cleft).
JGK150 2 years ago
Very good playing, but the 6 minute version of this song is just a remix.
The official version of Lux Aeterna is only about 4 minutes long. The 6 minute version is just the original Lux Aeterna looped twice, sometimes including Requiem for a Tower (the orchestral version). That's why nobody can find the 6 minute version on iTunes, etc. It's just a remix, not the official thing.
Still, great job in the video!
TBarrett12 2 years ago
i think ashgreig has a hand fetish =P
moplessmopless 2 years ago
You know, I really like you. Your hands on the piano are good, and you seem like a really nice person. I'm giving you a 5/5 for that:)
ashgreig 2 years ago
Thanks a lot!
fafnir242 2 years ago
nice job bro i play that song on guitar learned it in two days thanks
heerokazuma 2 years ago
Yeah, I roughly know the melody on guitar. I couldn't play the song well on it if I wanted to, but it's still fun to screw around with a particular melody and see what you come up with.
fafnir242 2 years ago
i'm not like a professional piano player or anything, but judging by the comments so far, your really humble and openminded, and that's all that matters. you'll go far dude! :DD
denouements 2 years ago
oh and fafnir any chance you have just a mic and a macbook? That's all you need for a better recording.
JorV101 2 years ago
No, I unfortunately don't own a Macbook. I wish I did, though. I want GarageBand.lol
fafnir242 2 years ago
ahh I hate garageband, don't even like macbooks. but nice job with the song
jarrod153624 2 years ago
Thanks. I should probably post more stuff if I can get a hold of a decent camera/recording system. I've learned a few more songs, like neoMAX, Crazy Loop, and I'm currently working on the POLYSICS cover of Mr. Roboto.lol Should be up in a couple of months.lol
fafnir242 2 years ago
oh god mr. roboto lol
druglover200 2 years ago
Okay, maybe I'm not going to exactly get great on that one, but Crazy Loop and neoMAX, I'm definitely going to have up in a couple of weeks, maybe.lol
fafnir242 2 years ago
nahh dude do it itlll be funny ive never heardthat shit on piano haha
druglover200 2 years ago
hay yo si te pongo 5 estrellitas.tocan bonito el teclado..
felicidades.. kisiera tokar asi,,..
wwaaa
liekill 2 years ago
I thought that was very good! Keep up the good work. :)
ElizabethBecks 2 years ago 2
way wrong
work on your dynamics bro!
ericDLR11 3 years ago
hey eric..can you play it..lol probably not i hate people like you always trying to pick out every single mistake someone makes and you can't even do it... grow up bro!
itachifangurl 2 years ago
and sorry i hate people like you....someone gives some criticism...that can be taken one of two ways. your the immature person that takes it the wrong way. I happen to be able to play this song and actually play it well for being in my 3rd year of music school. My opinion, Eric is right. Needs some dynamics and you're fine. The notes are all there. Way to go! keep it up!
JorV101 2 years ago
You're right. I'll take any criticism. It's like they've been telling us at meetings for work: If you don't tell us it's wrong, we can't fix it. That's mainly why I posted. To get feedback and see if I can make any improvements (so far, the most commented fault of mine is the camera.lol).
fafnir242 2 years ago
meant for itachifangurl btw
JorV101 2 years ago
sorry but its not that good compared to myself and some others that ive seen. But there's always time to learn the full better version....................get the camera fixed..............by the way it wasnt horrible. the tone was the same as the song by clint....just needed some more fingers to the cords
ASSASS77 3 years ago
Yeah, you're right. I'm taking a piano class next semester, so hopefully by then I'll be able to improve on this.
fafnir242 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i agree, this is all wrong played. this dude should not post this video since it gives the completally wrong impression of the song. more practice less recording plox. bai
Paxadzor 3 years ago
lets see you do better you dumb fuck if all you're going to do is say negative shit don't post at all keep it to yourself
DementedFilms666 2 years ago 2
here's a tip: play it like your playing a dirge (which it kind of is) and I think it'll turn out a lot better
AunShovah 3 years ago
Better yet... Just watch the movie, and play this song by how you feel afterwards.
brain1012 2 years ago 2
That's actually not a bad idea. I may try that.
fafnir242 2 years ago
lol you just like BAM, BAM,BAM with the accords :P left hand :P it could have been more fluent played. Though I know how hard it is to play such beautiful song by ear. If I were you I would practice more and be more gently for the piano, the song builds it self up, so don't start hard, play soft and build it up to FF and then slowy go to pp
missskatergirl 3 years ago
where can you get the sheet music for this?
Raven215167 3 years ago
If there is sheet music, I have no knowledge of its existence. I did this entirely by ear, so until I can find a free sheet music writing program, my version is going to remain just a learning by ear thing. Do you happen to know of such a program? If so, please help me out here.lol
fafnir242 3 years ago
really the way you play isn't that good and it just doesn't go well with the beautiful song
Nehelenja 3 years ago
but nice trying by learning by ear
Nehelenja 3 years ago
its not the soundtrack of lord of the rings its the soundtrack of the movie "sunshine". I think you are a good piano player but you need to get a better recording system ! :-)
Hyallman 3 years ago
Yeah, I know my camera sucks.lol I wish there was a better way to record it, because this camera makes it sound like shit.lmao
fafnir242 3 years ago
i love your version more than a lot of others
i think its too nice ^^ 5/5 :D
cyaaa
Soffi1825 3 years ago
I need to re-record my version of it! If you want to watch mine, it'll be up on DarkAuctor's page in about a day or two! :)
enjoy
I have to admit yours wasn't too good, but it wasn't terrible! it was pretty close!
OctobersParadise 3 years ago
boring... not so good... i could give 3/5 but that will make your rate lower :P
wworm0 3 years ago
It would be lux aeterna,
"Requiem for a dream." is a film that the song was used in.
revlets 3 years ago
I also mess around alot with his theme. (also have a vid op youtube :o) Anway this gives me some great idea's. do you have any sheets/midi files for this? or did you do it by ear.
Dextersworldnl 3 years ago
Sadly, I did this entirely by ear. However, if I could actually find a FREE sheet music writing program, give me a couple hours, I could get it down.lol
fafnir242 3 years ago
ah dont waste time on that ill just improvise learning stuff by ear is also fun and challenging :), I dont even like note sheets, Useally I learn stuff from midi files 10x faster. I have the yamaha E403 next to my piano it shows the keys on a display(with pause/play/ff/rw stuff).
Dextersworldnl 3 years ago
Indeed. Learning from ear is fun. With learning from ear, you get a little more freedom with it than following a set sheet.
fafnir242 3 years ago
You gotta practice more with that version you`re not really serious, are you?
instrumentalpost 3 years ago
I absolutely suck at playing the piano. That and I learned that mostly by ear. Put the two together and it almost always comes out disastrously.lol
fafnir242 3 years ago