Each time I come back to listen to this, makes me smile from ear to ear each time without fail =D Wonderful passion and wonderful interpretation from an amazing pianist! All these people caught up on a few wrong notes....lets see you try to play this live and have no mistakes whatsoever! *sigh* Just learn to enjoy the music rather than look for a persons mistakes!
The very very deep B he plays at 3:06 gives me the chills every time I listen to this sonata! That note here is one octave deeper than in the original, however it's a perfect sign for the Grandioso motive to start!
Yundi Li intentionally takes the furious and dramatic part, that he plays before, into the Grandioso by playing this particular deep B as an end of the connection between the furious part and the Grandioso.
It's great how he can so keep the drama of the music and cause goosebumps! :-)
@darrenabcd1 Yes, they all memorize each note. Best interpretation ever? You've heard them all since the sonata was written? How old are you? Just curious.
@jgrab1 I agree with you. No one heard all pianists playing that sonate.
I think it is greatest recording I've ever heard, but at the same time, there is so much of things in sonata that could be expressed more nicely and could line some parts better together.
The public didn't dare to applause... I am mesmerished... that it means to be an artist of international level and not a playing machine... how many musician could do that? Yindi Li beetween the Gods...
Did anyone "get" his expressions? At the end, the expression of exhaustion? It is as if it is Liszt himself performing it back in the day...exhausted after pouring out everything into his performance for the crowd. What you saw here is Yundi Li reliving that experience literally and absolutely. Impeccable.
He make alot of mistakes? is messy but i dont really care i just love his emotion. Wow i look at the score wow i would make a hell lots of more mistake Lol
OMG... I'm speechless... this playing includes everything... technique, passion, emotion, structure, power... This is the best performace of this piece, no question.
wooooooooow!!!!!!!!!!! his tone at 10:00. he makes those high chords ring like bells =D =D how i wish i owned a steinway like that =p he could probably make my piano sound like that though
Some people knock this performance saying that it isn't musical enough, but I feel he has such a tremendous passion and wonderful energy for this Finale. Suits this masterwork very well!
I get so sick and tired of snobs pointing out his wrong notes...this is an INCREDIBLE performance and he has the perfect energy for this work! A pianist with the skill and musicality to play this masterwork!
If an amateur was playin everybody would give him 5.. just look at other videos at youtube.. But when the best of the best is playing they really love to criticize.. even though this is far better than anyone could ever play it.
I actually love this performance - it is full of passion and the energy that is needed for this grand work. I agree he could be a bit more musical in some areas, but I still love it.
i find this performance lyrical + beautiful - esp. his touches at the softer sections of the piece - while retaining the necessary flair and excitement for a Liszt piece. Yundi Li excels at this kind of 'late' Liszt or Chopin pieces which contain so much poetic contents, because he got both the 'hard' virtuoso skills + 'soft' touches. Don't think it carries too much emotions or spiritual inspirations but don't worry they will come when reaches 50 years old
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I can hardly believe I'm saying this, but I really hate this interpretation. Yundi Li is probably my favourite pianists, but I find this performance rather bad. It sounds so... mechanical. I even prefer my own amazingly flawed playing over this. Hopefully Yundi Li will not become a robot pianists, because only a couple of years ago he was amazing enough to win the Chopin competition.
Alexei Grynyuk's performance is the best one I've heard of this masterpiece, but I doubt that others will agree.
I know exactly what you mean. Murray Perahia is one of my favorite pianists and as he has gotten older, his recordings are more mechanical and robotic than his recordings from when he was yougner. It is a shame to see such amazing pianists becaome robotic. Maybe it happens after the hundreds of recitals? lol /shrug
They are already flooding the market with their cheap inferior, products worldwide undermining and undercutting other nations far better quality goods we don't really want that to extend to churning out production line pianists that have no uniqueness or individuality that sound like every other one. At the moment we have a few that are good including Yundi Li, If someone has something unique about them, they deserve to succeed,leave mass marketism to the pretentious pop world.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i think in 8-10 years he's gonna be disappeared, because new chinese robots are going to win competitions and degrade the spirit of great piano playing...
Its a negative point, but a valid one. What we don't want is China flooding the classical world with masses of pianists(millions learning at the moment) that are no different to any other. Even Lang Lang has highlighted the point that the education is not anywhere the standard of Western music education and he even went out to the USA to further his education. We don't want an overcrowded mass market that exists in pop music because it will destroy classical music's unique position in the arts
your comment doesnt have anysent, its true there is a lot of asian players getting into the market, but whats the problem if they are good, I think yundi li is much better than west pianist, as for example kissin, yundi li is a first class musician, so dont say stupid things that make you look as racist, cause west music is not only for occidental players
What is anysent? Anyway to clarify, Why is it when someone who has an opinion that someone doesn't agree with they automatically assume them to be racist?. Quite frankly it is becoming tiresome and boring to hear this constantly.Nowhere in the dictionary does it state you are racist if you "don't agree with cheap,inferior products or pianists flooding the market".The definition is someone who is against someones race,colour or religion of which I am clearly not as I have good ethnic friends.
Also where ever we are subjected to cheap inferior goods or pianists or whatever it wouldnt be acceptable,if it was in the UK would still be a valid point,Dont confuse differences of opinion with racism.The two are completely different and as I said I admire Yundi Li's talents or anyone who has genuine unique ability,so I couldnt be further from what you are insinuating but I am not offended by your comments, I could take your view of me as racist because you disagree with me but I choose not to
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
watch your language, buddy. You don't understand it is not about racism, but about tradition of great pianism we try to save. we can have conversation any time about pianists, but not at this level
ohvg61 you make a valid point, racism is the new power over free speech and it is being mis-used to destroy anyone's right to disgree with someones point of view. Is it anymore racist for say a non-white person to inflict racial abuse than a white person inflicting it? No of course not, it is not acceptable from any culture towards another.Freedom to have a different view point is however acceptable and should not be confused with racism which at it's core is a form of fascism which I'm against
I disagree so much. The recording is textbook, but just that,textbook. Here he gives the work his stamp of personality, something missing on most of his studio recordings.
Each time I come back to listen to this, makes me smile from ear to ear each time without fail =D Wonderful passion and wonderful interpretation from an amazing pianist! All these people caught up on a few wrong notes....lets see you try to play this live and have no mistakes whatsoever! *sigh* Just learn to enjoy the music rather than look for a persons mistakes!
darkkerrigan 1 month ago
where can I download this? best version of this sonata imo
osmsm 2 months ago
the coughing @10.01 unbelievable ! ..... if you do that at such a sensitive dramatic moment in the piece you should not be sitting there !!!!
GerritsHenry 4 months ago
Sometimes this piece kinda sounds out of tune ... ( sometimes at the beginning )
xBleach4Eva 4 months ago
The very very deep B he plays at 3:06 gives me the chills every time I listen to this sonata! That note here is one octave deeper than in the original, however it's a perfect sign for the Grandioso motive to start!
Yundi Li intentionally takes the furious and dramatic part, that he plays before, into the Grandioso by playing this particular deep B as an end of the connection between the furious part and the Grandioso.
It's great how he can so keep the drama of the music and cause goosebumps! :-)
X3nion 5 months ago 35
Brahms fell asleep while Liszt was playing this for the first time xD
alsa005 6 months ago 6
Maybe Franz Liszt occupied his soul.
darrenabcd1 6 months ago 4
This is unbelievable, memorized each note?! Such a long performance! Best interpretation ever! Marvelous!
darrenabcd1 6 months ago
@darrenabcd1 Yes, they all memorize each note. Best interpretation ever? You've heard them all since the sonata was written? How old are you? Just curious.
jgrab1 5 months ago
@jgrab1 I agree with you. No one heard all pianists playing that sonate.
I think it is greatest recording I've ever heard, but at the same time, there is so much of things in sonata that could be expressed more nicely and could line some parts better together.
I'm trying to do that, but it takes time : )
lajtnga 4 months ago
@jgrab1 I'd say, that the best interpretation of this sonata was, when it was played by angry Liszt when Brahms had already fallen asleep :-D
davidmirth 3 months ago
Very powerful, vibrating and intense interpretation! Bravo!!
infozas 7 months ago in playlist Liszt, Franz
Wow?!Wow!?Wow!!Wow!!!WOWWWW!!!
littleasshole26 8 months ago
love to build up from about 4:50 to 6:30
osmsm 1 year ago 5
10:12 made me start crying...like not just a couple teardrops....legit crying...
fledgehog 1 year ago 5
@fledgehog is it like "sob.... " or "MUAAAAAAAAAAAA *waterfall"
lhrmeonom 9 months ago
テンポがバラバラ。
rxtkp 1 year ago
The public didn't dare to applause... I am mesmerished... that it means to be an artist of international level and not a playing machine... how many musician could do that? Yindi Li beetween the Gods...
Lexaander90 1 year ago 3
Did anyone "get" his expressions? At the end, the expression of exhaustion? It is as if it is Liszt himself performing it back in the day...exhausted after pouring out everything into his performance for the crowd. What you saw here is Yundi Li reliving that experience literally and absolutely. Impeccable.
9b8 1 year ago 5
5:42 is awesome... and 6:04 is also very nice
abcedmond 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Grande Liszt..Grande Yundi Li ...ma grande anche il gran coda Steinway & Sons....
NuovoCurioso 1 year ago
Comment removed
NuovoCurioso 1 year ago
Grande Liszt..Grande Yundi Li ...grande anche il gran coda Steinway & Sons...
NuovoCurioso 1 year ago 3
veramente un capolavoro... grazie a liszt e a yundi li. :)
MrNavarra94 1 year ago
oh MY!!!!!! Even one note was wrong, still oh MY!!!!
pianotalent 1 year ago
excepcional interpretacion.
perezlince 1 year ago
Bardzo Pięknie 5*****
ykpatr 1 year ago
I'm left speechless. Thanks Yundi for Liszt!
rdsabd 1 year ago 3
One feels as if this piece asks of the concert grand piano to go beyond it's full powers of expression as an instrument.
lurgidbee 1 year ago
oen of the best renditions ever
richclayderman 1 year ago
Best pianist ever. Almost completely flawless. If not flawless. This is the best that this sonata has ever been, or ever will be played.
tigertolyy 1 year ago 2
He make alot of mistakes? is messy but i dont really care i just love his emotion. Wow i look at the score wow i would make a hell lots of more mistake Lol
NodameSpecial 1 year ago
Yundi Li is undoubtedly a godlike, magical master!!!
chenyg1119 1 year ago
marvelous!
hhyuen2785 1 year ago
OMG... I'm speechless... this playing includes everything... technique, passion, emotion, structure, power... This is the best performace of this piece, no question.
madlovba2 2 years ago 6
wooooooooow!!!!!!!!!!! his tone at 10:00. he makes those high chords ring like bells =D =D how i wish i owned a steinway like that =p he could probably make my piano sound like that though
sadromantique 2 years ago 5
@sadromantique You just have to get use to your piano and control the sound well =)
NodameSpecial 1 year ago
Amazing, what energy!
prokofievace1979 2 years ago 2
DAM GOOD!
michaelkam 2 years ago
Wonderful !!!!!
gerardbedecarter 2 years ago 2
i have this DVD Yundi Li
superstarduc 2 years ago
Some people knock this performance saying that it isn't musical enough, but I feel he has such a tremendous passion and wonderful energy for this Finale. Suits this masterwork very well!
darkkerrigan 2 years ago 4
DAMN! He OWNES that piano! I can't get enough of this video <3
darkkerrigan 2 years ago 2
I get so sick and tired of snobs pointing out his wrong notes...this is an INCREDIBLE performance and he has the perfect energy for this work! A pianist with the skill and musicality to play this masterwork!
darkkerrigan 2 years ago
yeah you are right
Yundi Li real do a fantastic performance
on this , I still can't understand why this mv only 4.5 points....I think he deserve 5 points of course
blogAL526 2 years ago 3
神乎奇技李雲迪 名符其實鋼琴王子...
blogAL526 2 years ago
*cough cough* why can't the audience shut up??
coffemuse 2 years ago
I can't understand why such fantastic music only 4.5 points , of course I give him 5 points
blogAL526 2 years ago 3
If an amateur was playin everybody would give him 5.. just look at other videos at youtube.. But when the best of the best is playing they really love to criticize.. even though this is far better than anyone could ever play it.
Laban54 2 years ago 6
I like the Sonata from his CD, but this is the first time i watch him playing this piece. Thanks for sharing.
His hands are amazing starting 5:52
Cattytea 2 years ago
Love it!!! Energetic and exciting!!! Bravo!
partitasa89 2 years ago
Master-piece and master-pianist...nothing to say. Just listen and...enjoy! And also many many thanks to who posted this video
degreplayspiano 2 years ago 7
it´s a DVD, i´ve got it.
he plays the 4 chopin´s scherzos,a nocturne, this sonata, and more thing´s
is very interesting, you can buy it if you want, i recomended it to yo
Jamespianista 2 years ago
Can you tell me the exact name of the DVD? I would really like to purchase it. It would make a wonderful addition to my collection! Thanks
darkkerrigan 2 years ago
yes, it´s
Yundi Li
Chopin/Liszt
Live in concert.
Jamespianista 2 years ago
some dummy said it was a part of the video collection of the Chopin competition ^/^
vincentws03 2 years ago 3
I don´t know
maybe
Jamespianista 2 years ago
duetche grammaphone [spelling is close] recorded all of his CDs & DVDs. they have a website.
bellstretcher 1 year ago
Comment removed
XavierParis11 2 years ago
its a greatest sonata and Yundi Li percect,thnx Yundi
nedolem 2 years ago
This is a phenomenal performance.
AHN5D 2 years ago 32
Loved somewhat longer pause and following rich bass on 7:05
AHN5D 2 years ago 2
I love Yundi Li play this peice!
he is a real pianist!
Fantasie0643 2 years ago 7
Comment removed
stratoscreamer 2 years ago
I actually love this performance - it is full of passion and the energy that is needed for this grand work. I agree he could be a bit more musical in some areas, but I still love it.
darkkerrigan 3 years ago 3
wow....XDDDDD i can only do that if i speed up my piano videos lol.
jickypicky 3 years ago
amazing... but fazil say's version is better than this..
pinkshroud 3 years ago
no applaus? xD
Klinkibergi 3 years ago
Silence at the end of a great work is the best part. It is the moment where time freezes and a moment of absolute beauty reveals itself.
ayuprnkcller 3 years ago 12
I agree with Corleone1337 .
If you had heard his record of this piece
you must be touched more!
stegben 3 years ago
i find this performance lyrical + beautiful - esp. his touches at the softer sections of the piece - while retaining the necessary flair and excitement for a Liszt piece. Yundi Li excels at this kind of 'late' Liszt or Chopin pieces which contain so much poetic contents, because he got both the 'hard' virtuoso skills + 'soft' touches. Don't think it carries too much emotions or spiritual inspirations but don't worry they will come when reaches 50 years old
randomguy10 3 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can hardly believe I'm saying this, but I really hate this interpretation. Yundi Li is probably my favourite pianists, but I find this performance rather bad. It sounds so... mechanical. I even prefer my own amazingly flawed playing over this. Hopefully Yundi Li will not become a robot pianists, because only a couple of years ago he was amazing enough to win the Chopin competition.
Alexei Grynyuk's performance is the best one I've heard of this masterpiece, but I doubt that others will agree.
Corleone1337 3 years ago
I know exactly what you mean. Murray Perahia is one of my favorite pianists and as he has gotten older, his recordings are more mechanical and robotic than his recordings from when he was yougner. It is a shame to see such amazing pianists becaome robotic. Maybe it happens after the hundreds of recitals? lol /shrug
darkkerrigan 3 years ago
Piu Mosso(2:06)--This is a pre climax and Yundi's way of bringing that tricky climax(because the real climax happens later)is amazing!
AHNharmony 3 years ago
I prefer Valentina Lisitsa's emotion in music but yundi ly have a good technic too :)
The lisitsa's version is so different...:)
antony59370 3 years ago
They are already flooding the market with their cheap inferior, products worldwide undermining and undercutting other nations far better quality goods we don't really want that to extend to churning out production line pianists that have no uniqueness or individuality that sound like every other one. At the moment we have a few that are good including Yundi Li, If someone has something unique about them, they deserve to succeed,leave mass marketism to the pretentious pop world.
TheGreatPerahia 3 years ago 6
lol youtube arguments....
its like tetris.... no one wins, and even if you do, no one cares
eggplant1994 2 years ago 8
Although there is something wrong at 1:48,I think it's a wonderful job,even compared with Shura Cherkassky or Martha Argerich.
Liujiashu 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
completely mechanical interpretation of Liszt Sonata, without any vision or imagination. Listen to Bolet version, you will know what i mean...
ohvg61 3 years ago
love horowitz most
albertzhang2008 3 years ago
why does this get voted thumb down? he only said, he likes Horowitz most, what's wrong with that?
ohvg61 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
very good; some flashes of brilliance. A-/B+.
clean up the wrong notes, work on the overpedalling, and concentrate on: the music. you can hit every note, yet fail to sing.
don't.
slothvader 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck you
blargen456 3 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
well, someone's immaturity is showing here.
bravo.
slothvader 3 years ago
no thanks, just eaten, and I never do it on a full stomach!!.
TheGreatPerahia 3 years ago
I can't wait to see what he's gonna sound like in 8-10 years.
AngelinaTaylor 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think in 8-10 years he's gonna be disappeared, because new chinese robots are going to win competitions and degrade the spirit of great piano playing...
ohvg61 3 years ago
Its a negative point, but a valid one. What we don't want is China flooding the classical world with masses of pianists(millions learning at the moment) that are no different to any other. Even Lang Lang has highlighted the point that the education is not anywhere the standard of Western music education and he even went out to the USA to further his education. We don't want an overcrowded mass market that exists in pop music because it will destroy classical music's unique position in the arts
TheGreatPerahia 3 years ago
but it's too late, this is already happening
ohvg61 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
your comment doesnt have anysent, its true there is a lot of asian players getting into the market, but whats the problem if they are good, I think yundi li is much better than west pianist, as for example kissin, yundi li is a first class musician, so dont say stupid things that make you look as racist, cause west music is not only for occidental players
bastianloewe 3 years ago
What is anysent? Anyway to clarify, Why is it when someone who has an opinion that someone doesn't agree with they automatically assume them to be racist?. Quite frankly it is becoming tiresome and boring to hear this constantly.Nowhere in the dictionary does it state you are racist if you "don't agree with cheap,inferior products or pianists flooding the market".The definition is someone who is against someones race,colour or religion of which I am clearly not as I have good ethnic friends.
TheGreatPerahia 3 years ago
Also where ever we are subjected to cheap inferior goods or pianists or whatever it wouldnt be acceptable,if it was in the UK would still be a valid point,Dont confuse differences of opinion with racism.The two are completely different and as I said I admire Yundi Li's talents or anyone who has genuine unique ability,so I couldnt be further from what you are insinuating but I am not offended by your comments, I could take your view of me as racist because you disagree with me but I choose not to
TheGreatPerahia 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fucking racist!!!!!
I am sure your mother nd fathers are republicans and you are a fucking mommy kid, that with luckc can play fur elise
bastianloewe 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
watch your language, buddy. You don't understand it is not about racism, but about tradition of great pianism we try to save. we can have conversation any time about pianists, but not at this level
ohvg61 3 years ago
ohvg61 you make a valid point, racism is the new power over free speech and it is being mis-used to destroy anyone's right to disgree with someones point of view. Is it anymore racist for say a non-white person to inflict racial abuse than a white person inflicting it? No of course not, it is not acceptable from any culture towards another.Freedom to have a different view point is however acceptable and should not be confused with racism which at it's core is a form of fascism which I'm against
TheGreatPerahia 3 years ago 3
he is absolutely impressive,
yundi li is going to give us some thing to talk abbout
bastianloewe 3 years ago 5
thx 4 sharing !
yenloo1209 3 years ago 5
I disagree so much. The recording is textbook, but just that,textbook. Here he gives the work his stamp of personality, something missing on most of his studio recordings.
jgrab1 3 years ago
young master
aaabbbccc5 3 years ago 7
he leaves the audience silent at the end. brilliant
jcasbell 3 years ago 40
@jcasbell They all do. Kinda the point.
jgrab1 5 months ago
this is good
tikihjruy 3 years ago 8
good stuff
frelidae 4 years ago 10