I Have Nothing

[925GERSON]

LINDA! gOOD PERFORMANCE!

[AILEMAC62]

very good,congratulation!

[kosolano]

прикольно

[kazegara]

@Kevlee9018 you read my mind !!!!!

[WladOable]

:(( ohh horrible

[karrencciitta]

woahhh.

[Kevlee9018]

Charice Pempengco is 10 times better then her, America Idol? PLEASE!

[2loony4you]

The voice is ok but missing the volume, warmth, and charisma of Whitney Houston. You should hear this sung by Fady Maalouf (2nd runner up of Germany's DSDS in 2008). He's got tons of feelings (also here on youtube!)

[qg6ff]

her voice is her voice, her style... you don't have to be a monstrous vocalist of a black woman to sing this song

[MouriceJr]

but it is true that it sounds better with soul, the song is about a woman with passionate love for a man, it needs power and emotion (a soulful sound) but leona did it well without soul katherine didn't it was justt flat and unimpressive. but if leona had some soul, she would have totally blown it out of the park, but i agree, you shouldn't limit a song to a certain type of person.

[wim1983]

do not touch Whitney's song...u need passion, incredible vocal control, powerful and rich tone...nobody nobody do it better...she sing it not bad...just didn't work...

[wim1983]

Do touch Whitney's song...it is so tough to sing...u need passion, powerful and rich tone....she try her best...not bad...but does not work

[garry12151990]

guys... for me charice is much better than her...

[xhibitionism]

Fact : She's beautiful.

[Ava2500]

THIS IS BAD

[Argonaut22j]

Ehhhh, she sounds like every other singer.

[sweetheart5703]

I love her dad he is so cute! He cries every time he watched her perform!!

[LOLCOPTER]

i wanna hear her sing 'unbreak my heart' then.

[ezzagreat]

she has nothing on leona lewis!! check out leona lewis singing I have Nothing. way way way better :)

[luke4duke]

and Leona Lewis has nothing on Vonzell Solomon :)

[ezzagreat]

just watched vonzell. She still has NOTHING on leona. Have u even seen it? mustn't have! Vonzell doesnt even hit a high note towards the end like leona does

[dadizzie]

Vonzell doesnt have to add a high note to make up for the lack of power and emotion like leona had to. Vonzell KILLS Leona.

[dadizzie]

Agree totally luke4duke

[Johnroberts6666]

Would love to tear that dress apart and lick her tasty Asshole while I squeeze her boobs till she screams

[Jofishi]

HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA! That was random!

[thespa77]

she's awesome, I think she was singing with Chris Botti on PBS at some concert, wasn't sure

[mikeylicious2007]

I think she is better then Leona Lewis. Katherine can hit really low note, but Leona can not. Plus Katherine is more beautiful. She shuld have won AL. I think America has made a mistake to let Talor Hicks win. He is a joke.

[am3ri3s]

in your opinion and many others i see.... but i quite disagree :D cuz i love leona's voice and she is one particular etheral beauty

[SingingJon]

i think jennifer hudson's is better...

[vct33]

This video makes me McPheel kinda funny. Like climbing the rope in gym class.

[xxmaterialxgirlxx]

which means? lol

[hildboldcf1]

gotta love :38...the eyebrow raise...if only she could bite her lip as well...

[TheEvilPuppy]

Why oh why did Taylor win? If Chris or Katherine had won it would have given further credit to the show. Instead that doofus of an idiot won!!! I'm still pissed off about it man.

[xxStYLiShLaDYxx]

SHE IS PRETTY LOVEE HERR!!!

[IQEllis]

LOL @ 1:49!  DON'T you DARE! This was so NOT a good performance imo

[myfeet14]

she fuckin fine

[DancingFan28]

can't believe taylor hicks won over her, still pissed about that

[laine017]

agree :P

[lexiluvz]

omfg. soo agreed. I don't like him. He's not like amazing. I really like her.

[S8301642]

she can do better than that....

maybe a different song no high key....

but good....

[DJBianca2]

she sounds sleepy here, but then shes still great in her other performance

[krissings]

She should have win, not Taylor, he cant sing

[starburst304]

i agree and taylor's record deal people dont even want him no more cause he just did a ford commercial and you never saw him again

[joefalchetto]

Brava!

[FranticDolls]

love her

she is gorgeous~

[whitismygurl07]

she copied vonzell's performance of this song notice the whole microphone thing

[highlighter365]

she's an AMAZING singer, but this wasn't one of her better performances HOWEVER she shouda won that season!!!

[oxford0123]

that was...ok. i still like leona and whitney's versions better.

[RichGirl80billion]

She's a great singer but didn't do good on this on. And on a serious note, it's really has nothing to do with soul. Whitney's song was way too big for her to handle... Her voice isn't big enough like Vonzell or Jhud

[yummypolkadots]

she has great hair

[mandielane]

i like her voice...

but it wasnt her best.

[randompimp]

She did alright, there just wasn't enough soul, she made it sound, like a pop song.

[sherixo]

she's a good singing but i think what missing is the soul. the song is really strong so she should've just let her vocals go and be more powerful. i don't know, that's just my opinion !

[philipthe1st]

i agree

[passionatedisciple77]

SHE CAN SING!!! (CLAP! CLAP!)

She blew!

[cocoangel007]

i'm not feeling it... -~-

she has a pretty good voice but it's not meant for this song methinks

[shoppinqueen2]

not as good as leona.

definitely not as good as whitney!

[SMStar93]

I like her, but I'm surprised Simon took back his comment.

It wasn't great, probably the worst of AI renditions. It was similar to Leona, but no where near Whitney.

[alexluvs2sing]

shacky,but ok.

i think leaona is the best at this song and young charice(:

[musikphantom1881]

good but nothing can beat whitney

[poonpram]

she is fit

[devilknight85]

it isnt that bad rite?

[leygel]

the best of all, her style is magnificent, she's complete, sweet,brave,and che's so beautiful,bravoooooooo.

[poshdoll9]

eventhough this is not a great performance, she looks so gorgeous. She, leah labelle and kristy lee cook are definitely the babes of ai

[1505870394]

charice version me thinks is the BEST

[nightshade0306]

charice did... fantastic! but i think leona's is the best!

[portellita]

k linda voy tienes divino tienes un estilo propio y se te escucha super :)

[ianbering]

this is not her song and so not charice...uhh...i give my vote to the version of leona lewis...katharine's performance is not strong enough...while charice's is too strong for the song...leona has the right key,tone..etc...

[lou18is]

VERY WRONG BUT SHE MADE IT HER OWN

[BettyJFan]

BOOOO....

lol nothing.

[CandySandy678]

shoe looks like she's fighting for every second of the song...

[ssj04]

Ok, after finish watching her sing the song. She is HORRIBLE... She can't carry the tone correctly, can't handle the high note and so on.

Charice Pempengco own this song "I have nothing"

Check it out for yourself...

/watch?v=6jDpMdj4enQ

[ssj04]

Charice Pempengco sung this song much better than her.

/watch?v=6jDpMdj4enQ

[caisse2patatte]

at 1min 23 its very good!!!but its not very good!!

[alfarouqaminu]

it wasnt as bad as the judges made it...it wasnt great i agree, but it wasnt omg terrible~!

[Smuggler1987]

I think Leona Lewis' version of this song is one of the best...Katherine did a good job but Leona's is better in my opinion

[Amiie0x]

good vocals, very good, but she almost coming out of that dress coorr!!

[SoulAndRnBFan]

Really bad. She can't hit the high notes.

Why does these wannabes on American Idol insist on singing Whitney - there will never be another Whitney.

[dadizzie]

Not totally true... although kat didnt do awesome, vonzell sang this song as good as whitney

[SoulAndRnBFan]

Vonzell was GOOD, but still not on Whitney's level. Compare them - come on, she's not on Whitneys level. The range, power, vibrato, phrasing, stage presence - all those things have made Whitney a 240,000,000 selling international star. She's unique. Just like how Aretha was. Barbra. Mariah. Celine. All unique. The next big star will be unique too. Not a copy.

[grruba]

she's amazing.

[megic0]

ick she sucks

[russsianz4ever]

shes very gud! i like her!!!

[therealzeebs]

I love how nobody judges the performance for themself, and just listen to what the judges say and copy them.

I thought Katharine had good control of the song and made it her own. Her transition was also extremely impressive. I enjoyed watching this way more than Jennifer Hudson's, by the way.

[crosscheer47]

wow . .

goose-bumps.

i had McPheever bad

i voted for her like 100 times

during the whole show.

pissed that she lost but over-all . . .

where the hell is Taylor?!?!?

[alowaaaaa]

GO dude/girl +1!

[gostarz03]

Christina Aguilera's version when she was on the mickey mouse club was better!!!!!

And she was like 11 or 12...

[jeffw1990]

that was terrible

[niseethapimp]

TERRRiBLE

[jeanxvre]

im sorry kat but leona sings this song better than you....

i love you kat

[lman161]

probably the worst performance of this song on Idol

[babiinene]

shes too soft.

[ameliaandjunhow]

no she is not too soft. if anything, she is shouting it. what you mean is her tone is too thin.

[ilovevonzell28]

Okay. But we have to stop talking because my mom is getting concerned about who I am writing to on the internet.

[redjjojin]

Sorry if I'm starting the fight again, but I would like to say that I did not reply because i am "afraid" of you, if you think like that, but because the mail came to my spam box. And I would also like to mention that you, ilovevonzell, need to stop being racist or at least remember what you posted... ok~

[ilovevonzell28]

Why are starting this all over again? Didn't I get rid of you over a week ago? Grow up and stop acting like a 9-year-old! You're so damn ignorant! Drop it already! We ended this conversation over a week ago! My God!

[redjjojin]

haha. okay, this one is my fault, but I replied to you, not others and my reason for posting is not to fight with you but to inform you. It actually sounds like you want to start the fight. Lets stop now~

[TheGangstaBoy100]

This is for redjjojin...

SHUT THE FUCK UP BITCH ASS MOTHAFUCKA!

[redjjojin]

woah... -__-;; what did I do again? It's been such a long time.. lol

[TheGangstaBoy100]

Yeah...but you're the one who came back first after it ended!

[redjjojin]

uhh.. Didn't it end like half a year ago? what's your problem?! geez just let it go. ^___^;; have a great life!

[TheGangstaBoy100]

Actually...4 months ago!!!

[dadizzie]

you're not alone redjjojin alot of people have problems with him including me.

[ilovevonzell28]

Please just don't comment on my profile anymore. Please don't!

[ilovevonzell28]

You make no sense. Shut the fuck up!

[carriealways]

thank you thats what i should have said

[ilovevonzell28]

You're telling me I can't spell. How do you spell WAY, W.A.Y. not W.A.A.A.A.A.y. You're telling me think before I post a comment. Before you come telling me what to do, CHECK YOURSELF BITCH!!!!! You and carriealways need to leave me the FUCK alone. Both of you are BITCHES!!!

[carriealways]

it doesnt matter to me what you say about me but really you shaould have respect and should have said she just didnt give the song justice. thats all you needed to say not going on and rambling how a white girl sang a black girls song God forbid get over it

[ilovevonzell28]

Katharine sounds TERRIBLE! No way in hell can anyone say she sounded good after that painful performance. And you spelled should wrong. It's not SHAOULD it's SHOULD!

[carriealways]

just stop fighting and get over it

[ilovevonzell28]

Then why the fuck are YOU still posting comments under my profile. I keep getting emails about you posting you posting video responses under my name. Stop posting comments under my name, BITCH! You're telling me to stop. You need to stop! And stop telling me what the fuck to do. You can't stop me from doing what I want to do. We are on the internet stupid ass!

[carriealways]

you know you are really disgracing vonzell when you write all the crap on here. you are bringing attention to vonzell in a bad way. you are also a main center of attention since you seem to be her biggest fan, you like the highlight on you not vonzell what a good fan just stop disgracing her! have a great day :)

[ilovevonzell28]

You give that dumb country singer a bad name, CARRIEalways. And by the way, you posted the same comment twice Dumbass.

[checotah07]

Carriealways isnt the dumbass here, your 14 year old dumbass self needs to a more representable fan for vonzell.Carriealways and some of the others were just a few fans who think you need more respect

[ilovevonzell28]

You're the dumbass. I am not really 14. Why the fuck are you in the grill BITCH!

[carriealways]

bringing attention to vonzell in a bad way. you are also a main center of attention since you seem to be her biggest fan, you like the highlight on you not vonzell what a good fan just stop disgracing her! have a great day :)

[ilovevonzell28]

First of all who the fuck are you bitch? You are stepping to the wrong person.!

[weenerh]

shit

[suthidol2]

try to watch marielle mamaclay

[JackieDeBurg]

This song is not too big for her. She's got a big voice! I thought it amazing. She had passion and she looked and sounded beautiful. And don't you remember that the next week, Simon took back his negative comment after watching the recording?

[iwitea312]

Agreed!!

Shes got a nice voice!

but this song is way to0 powerful for her,

But she did resonably good,

she got balls for giving it a go,

Il give her that much..

[Blakmajik78]

Katherine should have never touched this song...this song has too much soul and diva in it for her. Vonzell and Jhudson gave it justice...I don't know what the hell Katherine was singing...she can sing though..but this song was not for her...way out of her league.

[lawheaduno]

She's so hot

[Martinalutherking]

Please slap this bitch for singing Whitney and fucking it up!

[NYChica23]

I prefer Jhud's version

[ilovevonzell28]

Me too. Why is a WHITE girl (Katharine) singing a BLACK girl's (Whitney) song? Can you believe she sang "Think" by Aretha Franklin? She is one brave white girl!

[redjjojin]

0_0 Are you serious? What do you think about all those black contestants sing "white" songs. Stop being so idiotic, or crawl back into your little hole and die.

[ilovevonzell28]

You and your whole family need to go die! I am BLACK! You must be Asian. You go crawl into a coffin and get berried. I hope NOBODY shows up at your funeral! HAHAHA!!!

[carriealways]

your a self centered bitch and by the way you miss spelt burried. dont fall in the whole you just burried for yourself.

[ilovevonzell28]

Who the fuck was talking to you! And you're telling me I spelled burried wrong. You spelled hole wrong you stupid bitch! Not WHOLE - its HOLE! So before you come telling me what I do wrong, you better check yourself first! Fuck off!

[redjjojin]

Wow.. What's wrong with your head. You seriously need to go to the hospital to get your head checked up. And how did you know about me being Asian? Are you that interested enough to look up my page? Or maybe you went there to find something you can make fun of because obviously, there is nothing wrong with what I said.

[ilovevonzell28]

That joke about the hospital was wack, corney, and stupid. I am not interested with what race you are. I really don't care either. I just said Katharine sucks, Jennifer Hudson's rendition was better, and Whitney is the original. Do not comment again. Please don't. I just had an argument with someone else on the internet. I don't need another bitch to fuck with me! Thank you.

[hypergut]

Goa puker

[rdushir]

i like this one better than vonzell's, vonzell is great but kat had more persaonality which is big for this song... vocally however, vonzell is a better song.

the best version of this song however is done by alexis jordan... look it up

[queenali87]

wtf...

no body's better than whitney...

[rrhyno]

she's a good singer, but this song is tooo much for her. leave it to vonzell solomon.

[Ssymour]

[1]

Although I'm a devout Leona fan, I must say that I do like Katherine's take on this song. I noticed that a lot of the performances I have seen of "I have nothing" are very different and distinct in their own right.

[Ssymour]

[2]

Katherine's approach has a very "blue-sy" (And yes, I am well aware that "Blue-sy" is not a real word) feel about it.

Leona put's a lot of emotion into her performance (and it really does give me goosebumps) and matches the emotion with her fluid consistancy.

Vonzell's very powerful vocals mean for one of the most amazing renditions I have ever heard.

[FridgeRaider75]

what a load of utter crap what an insult to whitney...leona is amazing compared to this cheese ball ..SHE CANT SING...EWW

[Ssymour]

If it had insulted Whitney, then I don't think Whitney would have taken the time to sit and listen to Katherine perform this song...which she did.

[benXmcrX]

leona's version all the way i think she should have made her own little X factor CD with all the full versions of the songs she sun on it but anyway this is still good dont beat leona closly followed by beverly

[CandlelightedChaos]

she is amazing!

[rustydevilll]

LEONA FTW.

british people ftww

leona is the next whitney.

[Fbalino]

jellybelly: hahahahahahahaahahahahahha

[rehbch]

beverly's version from this year's x factor i think beats them all. way better than all of them

[Adorador19]

Leona es muchisimo mejor.. Leona hizo suya esta cancion.. de hecho la interpreta mucho mejor que Whitney.. Incluso puso de su gran estilo y la cancion quedo genial.. En cambio esta a esta chika. le cambiaron de tono la cancion y no dudo tiene una gran voz pero esta cancion no la hizo suya..

[SweetieWee]

It's good, not bad. But Leona and Whitney are so much better!

[ekluvr]

HORRENDOUS

[andrija23]

poor version...compared to leona's i don t really like it...sounds...weak and creepy

[whisperedmysteries]

I think this was a brilliant performance.

[alerom23471]

No way Vonzell's version was way better plus no-one beats Whitney

[chiddichiddibangbang]

AMEN! no ONE beats whitney!

[TSichaleun]

wardrobe mail function at 1:45 her buttom popped out. LOL

[MattyMcHatty123]

i thought this was a really good performance

[spidey692003]

sEARCH THIS SONG BY LEONA LEWIS THEN, WHITNEY LOOK OUT!!!!

[JollyBlackGiant07]

yall should listen to robyn janelle's version...its killer..

[punkieboy1]

please,,,no one beats whitney no one

[escapelady]

she sounded really nice she just had a little pitch problems. but yall should see vonzell's performance. i have seen them all and overall i think that she done the past. vonzell's voice sounds good from start to finish.

[americanidolfan5]

ok so she smiles some...big deal. other than the few times she smiled, she showed a lot of emotion, and sang beautifully. if you people are just saying its bad because thats what simon said, take it back because simon apologized the next night and said it was a good performance.

Great job kat.

[LeanaMcKie]

He didn't say it was a 'great performance', but rather apologized for his harshness. He said it wasn't as bad the following night.

[americanidolfan5]

well his words were "i watched it back, it sounds different, it was a good performance."

[lembeeno]

Don't be so harsh on her!

She is white!

I mean she did such a great job for a white girl.

I think she diserves an 8.9 in rating

she did marvelous.

and I wish she wouldn't have chosen yellow

it makes her beautiful complexion look like crap

gold or silver would have been a better choice.

[Beyoncefeatshakira]

Heres my ratings(taking whitney gets 10)-

Leona-9/10

Jhud-9/10

Lakisha-8.5/10

Kat-7.5/10

[flipsta8]

dude whitney is shit, my ratings would be- jessica mauboy- 10 (runnerup aussie idol 2006)

tarisai vush- 9 (this yrs aussie idolist top 9 and still going)

[orangeparade]

how about vonzell?

[Beyoncefeatshakira]

I sorry ive never heard of her

[americanidolfan5]

i think kat did better than lakisha though

[osahju914]

what about trenyce season 2

and vonzell season 4

[Beyoncefeatshakira]

Lol i changed my mind. Kat should get 8. I dunno why it sounded more true when I didnt see the video

[magdaTera]

girl you make it all wrong! hate when people dont know what they're sinning about..that was just ish for me

[osahju914]

what theme week is this?

[americanidolfan5]

greatest love songs

[patricia718]

She doesn't show any feeling...she's just singing..feeling gives any song that extra something..she's just plain