American Idol - Michael Johns eliminate - Top 8 results Show

[livethecause]

wow i still cant believe that he got sent home that early i thought he should have made the top 2 him and david cook now that would have been a good show to see i still dont know who would have won if it would have actually happened that way

[deepeye1328]

This really is shocking to me, he wasn't the best in all positions, but he definitely isn't the worst or to be voted off before final.

[xxxtiangarcia]

great singer. contrary to what simon said, it was a great song choice for him and brought out what he can do. wish he was in the top 3, that would be a great fight. archuleta could have been booted out to stage two rockers, mj and dc. Idol's ratings would sky rocket foshu

[mmaa1]

hey snowgrl802 u dont no shit about music. you are so stupid, syesha was the best out of those three. i have a lot of connections to L.A and when i saw them rehearse michael johns

[BBBYpsi]

I agree that syesha is the worse of the 3. Micheal Johns & carley both should have been in the top 3

[TheAnorexicOne]

its a real shame he got sent home!!

he was like my fav of the hole compatition!

i thought he was atleast ganna make it down to the final 3 if not win the hole thing!!

[candie7399]

Such amazing talent...my fav...he will do so well with his career. I can't wait to see what the future holds for this great man.

[jorgerisemberg]

Creo que eliminaron al mejor, una verdadera lástima...

[FireGirlG]

I do have to say, what a GREAT song to go out on!

[FireGirlG]

I wanna see him become the frontman for a great band. I can't wait to get his album. He did get a call from Dolly Parton that she wants to do a duet some time and that she was serious about wanting to write some songs for him.

[georgiagirl2211]

he better come back im defiNitly buying his album when it comes out him and the davids are the only people that can actually sing UNBELIEVABLE

[Enignd]

anyone else want to go kick kristy lee cook off the show? i want to hear michael johns sing more, he really should've stayed. damn you, you noob voter *shakes fist*

[snowgrl0802]

He was way too good to go

[snowgrl0802]

Out of these three I think Syesha should have gone

[tallderektoronto]

Why even say "Last year we did not eliminate anyone during an inspirtation week" when your not planning to do it, why not just rip his gut out at the same time IDOL Prodcution staff ? That was low. Humiliating enough to have Carly & Kriste stay over him. Something is not adding up, Michael, David H & Luke should have gone way further than the mediocre Carly and Kriste.

[southernlady076]

Ryan handled this great singer in a RUDE manner that topped even Simon!M.Johns u r great-singer and entertainer and we will be seeing u again,no doubt!I thought u were for sure the winner but no need to worry many have won and ? r they now?many didn't and r doing just Great!and that my dear is you! Idol u took a great Idol gives back show and turned it to a sucky,rude show that just ruined the entire show.I will still watch only because there r still 2 I like.Boo Idol and Ryan!

[XxIDontLoveUxX]

i didnt get to see this when it aired so i had to see on here who got voted off.

when i found out i was sooo maddd.

im not a big big fan of himm!

but hes a good singer.

and he didnt deserve to go yett!

KRISTI NEEDS TO GOOO NOWW!

ahahaha. ryansss bogusss.

but i believe michael will get big so its aightt.

[tallderektoronto]

there may be a wildcard and if there is hes back

[Smmashley]

im so mad he left but i heard that dolly parton wants to record a song with him

so he's still gonna make it big <3

[davejohnbatista]

what ryan did was purely unethical... totally uncalled for...not just.

[lebrooks]

check out "ode to michael johns" video

[krishaparna]

that's not fair!!

i luv michael johns!

it totally sux... :(

[pinoy1108]

omg look at david cook

he looked soo sad out of everyone else

wtfff?

american idol is gay now

[DJL7792]

what an asshole ryan.. why would he say that if they werent gonna let him stay??

[southernlady076]

So true-I'm with u on this one.

[Phundaze]

WTF Ryan Seacrest!! Last we year.......and tonight we say goodbye to Michael Johns Crap! What kind of ghetto hosting is that! Did he just get butt rammed and could not think stright or what! Tacky!

[southernlady076]

Wish I could have put it into words as good as u did!

[najwa90]

i love u michael!

ur so hot and a talented singer!!

i was shocked to c u being eliminated off that night and cried so hard!

[apsalmistspraise]

i coudn't believe it!

[Lex205]

ryan is a faggot

[zacefronlovee]

he didnt deserve to leave!

[nascarkraz]

How is this a shock to ya'll? The way Ryan phrased "Tonight..." you just knew. C'mon!

[LilWeezy00]

horrible decision

[librawm]

We expect cruelty from Simon but this was handled with unbelievaby poor taste . AI what were you thinking?! Ryan??