„Ideologie ist eine verabsolutierte Idee. Überall, wo es Unterdrückung, Demütigung, Unglück und Leid gibt, ist der Boden bereitet für jede Art von Ideologie. Deshalb ist ‚Das weiße Band auch nicht als Film über den deutschen Faschismus zu verstehen. Es geht um ein gesellschaftliches Klima, das den Radikalismus ermöglicht. Das ist die Grundidee. Michael Haneke
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
In my view the movie was 2hrs. and 40 minutes of nothing exceptional except the cinematography. The story moved at a snails pace and though some really horrible things happen they are nothing compared to the horrors we see everyday on television. They in no way fortale what is to come in WWI. If it's there it's only in the creators mind. It was painfully boring. Like watching grey paint dry.
The interest of the movie isn't in how hard where the events depicted but how the whole village symbolizes a kind of island isolated from society in which the religious authority of the bishop and the domination of the rich lander has some influences. It is interesting in the ambivalence of all caracters also and so many other things I couldn't telle in English (I am French sorry)
So much work just to cast it, my god! Haneke is brilliant in his cinematic style, so strong (though really just common sense) in his moral ideals, and then so humble and casual in interviews you would never expect it from his subversive reputation, more like a friendly grandfather who will discipline us harshly only when needed, without taking sadistic joy in it.
If you love Haneke, be sure to try some films of Bresson, Naruse, Oshima, Fassbinder, and Akerman as well.
Thanks for this comment which opens me new directors I could never heard of by any other mean (except Bresson which I really love). You just made me my holiday programm haha
I 'm so glad for Haneke's win! His work is really interesting,extraordinary and at times extremely breath-taking! I can't wait to see his new film! Congratulations!!!!
Ich finde er hat volkommen recht, ich kann mir diesen Film nur in schwarz/weiss vorstellen, nicht in Farbe!
Ein grossartiger Film!
dearmalika 1 year ago 3
„Ideologie ist eine verabsolutierte Idee. Überall, wo es Unterdrückung, Demütigung, Unglück und Leid gibt, ist der Boden bereitet für jede Art von Ideologie. Deshalb ist ‚Das weiße Band auch nicht als Film über den deutschen Faschismus zu verstehen. Es geht um ein gesellschaftliches Klima, das den Radikalismus ermöglicht. Das ist die Grundidee. Michael Haneke
2006hectordavid 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
In my view the movie was 2hrs. and 40 minutes of nothing exceptional except the cinematography. The story moved at a snails pace and though some really horrible things happen they are nothing compared to the horrors we see everyday on television. They in no way fortale what is to come in WWI. If it's there it's only in the creators mind. It was painfully boring. Like watching grey paint dry.
Pugzz 2 years ago
@Pugzz
The interest of the movie isn't in how hard where the events depicted but how the whole village symbolizes a kind of island isolated from society in which the religious authority of the bishop and the domination of the rich lander has some influences. It is interesting in the ambivalence of all caracters also and so many other things I couldn't telle in English (I am French sorry)
besjordan 1 month ago
So much work just to cast it, my god! Haneke is brilliant in his cinematic style, so strong (though really just common sense) in his moral ideals, and then so humble and casual in interviews you would never expect it from his subversive reputation, more like a friendly grandfather who will discipline us harshly only when needed, without taking sadistic joy in it.
If you love Haneke, be sure to try some films of Bresson, Naruse, Oshima, Fassbinder, and Akerman as well.
whateverhte 2 years ago 2
@whateverhte forgot Ingmar Bergman, Carlos Reygadas and Lucrecia Martel. Cheers!
ofoxy 2 years ago
@whateverhte
Thanks for this comment which opens me new directors I could never heard of by any other mean (except Bresson which I really love). You just made me my holiday programm haha
besjordan 1 month ago
I 'm so glad for Haneke's win! His work is really interesting,extraordinary and at times extremely breath-taking! I can't wait to see his new film! Congratulations!!!!
85ORESTIS 2 years ago
Ah, he's my favourite director of all time, alongside von Trier, so I'm glad.
Houellebecq1985 2 years ago
先刻知らせを受けて感涙致しました!!初のパルムドール!おめでとうございます!!
日本での上映を楽しみに待っています\(^o^)/
omaegahoshii 2 years ago
Congrats! really looking forward to watching it!
thegranny2006 2 years ago
Super! Ich freu mich!!
Bigmac79 2 years ago
Yes. Congratulations. I'm looking forward to this one.
baroh2413 2 years ago
Congrats to the Palme d'Or!
Houellebecq1985 2 years ago 5