@skeetskeetskeet420 Sorry, but his range is not close to Jon Foreman's, nor does he sing quite as loud. Also, David Cook is slightly off-key at certain key parts in the song (notably the high parts), and has to strain quite a bit. You're right, Jon Foreman live is on another level. His stage presence is simply amazing.
I have to agree with most of the people here in that he ruined it. :<
@windrixx lol cool story bro.. Jon Foreman sucks live, at least David can hit valid notes.. keep telling me cool stories though, these are much more fun
@skeetskeetskeet420 Mmm, i love the "cool story bro" response. Almost as creative as the "shut up" response, but a lot less... angry? (Feigning indifference doesn't work when you proceed to argue, btw)
Why don't you listen to the video you're commenting on? Just listening to the chorus makes it evident that he can't hit the notes in the chorus. Don't tell me he can hit "valid" notes (wtf is a valid note anyways); anyone with even decent relative pitch (clearly not you) can tell that it's off.
@windrixx Simply watch him sing other songs, he nails shit almost 100% of the time, just because he didn't nail this, doesn't mean he cannot sing... He has a great voice, one of the few from American Idol, god that show is gayyyyyyyy. Also I said cool story bro BECAUSE IT WAS A COOL STORY.... I was not feigning indifference.. I only say it when I MEAN IT!!!! I LOVE YOUR STORIES BRO!!!! SO MUCH!!! I SWEAR!
.
Jon Foreman still sucks dicks for money though... just sayin homie
@skeetskeetskeet420 Jon Foreman is a much better artist than you could ever be. I'd ask you to explain why he "sucks dicks for money", but I doubt you're intellectually capable. Sorry.
And I'm not saying that David Cook can't "nail shit almost 100% of the time"; I'm just saying that he can't nail this song. Not even close.
@windrixx I said he sucks dick for money, and you ask for an explanation?? HE SUCKS DICKS FOR MONEY, THAT IS THE EXPLANATION WHAT THE FUCKKK ARE YOU REALLY SERIOUS??? clearly? you are FUCKING with me right? And Jon Foreman cannot nail this song live, he sucks dick when he performs too, audio dicks... sucks em... then gets off stage to go back to his hobby of blowing dudes in back alleys for money since his band sucks and wrote 2 good songs ever
read Don't laugh at this! Just do it Start thinking something you really really want cause this is astounding the person that sent this to me said their wish came true 10 mins after they read the mail so I thought what the heck You have just been visited by DrSuess's Cat in the Hat. He will grant you one wish Make your wish when the count down is over 10,9,8,7,6,5,4,3,2,1 MAKE A WISH Send this to 10 videos within the hour you read this. If you do, your wish will come true
obvoisuly you will like the original singer/writer of the song, at least these people try to immitate them as well as they can , jesus give them a break
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Horrible, he was shouting the whole time, how could someone who shouts beat someone who sings in a heartfelt way and is a truly fantastic singer? what is wrong with america
OMG i love David for singing this song. I love it. He is an amazing singer and the fact that he had to guts to sing a song from a christian band on a tv show shown around the world is amazing and i give david mad props. Peace!!!!!!!
if u love him so much, go and suck his sweaty nasty purplish cock, bc this fucker has not talent, he looks like a dog with rabies, he needs to fucking shave and shower, i swear i saw ticks crawling around his hair, motherfucker looks like some type of medical experiment gone wrong.
o fuck u u shuldnt say n e thing cause i bet hes way much better looking and talented than u!!!! he can sing any type of song and can david a? idnt thnk so (not saying he sucks) but david deserved to win so shut up u dnt kno wat ur sayin god...david didnt do n e thing to u but sing his heart out and having all this stress and this is wat u say wow watever
aaa David Cook FTW!!! ppl plsssssssssss VOTE all 4 hrs this tuesday!! it's crucial.... it seems like he's singin 1st and ALL 6 AI winners won from singin 2nd we NEED to BREAK that trend soooo VOTE!!!!!!!!!
FYI ... The flower on his guitar was a shout out to his fans, the Word Nerds, who had over 60 flower arrangements delivered to his dressing room before the show that night. :)
Pitchy? I thought it was fine... but I have to agree with Paula... I want him to sing the WHOLE SONG!!! Maybe the producers should change the arrangements :)
It's a great song, and it's just cool that David Cook sang this song for us to hear it again in his voice. Hope he records this, of all the three songs, I like this the best actually.
I love how Paula says she wants more in that minute and thirty seconds. How about, I dunno, you actually DO give them more time so you can fit a beginning, middle, and end in there. Less time on the commercials and advertising crap and more time singing.
The Switchfoot version is better because David's voice seem to crack in this performance. but, I am excited for the studio version because I feel like it is gonna end up like his Our Lady Peace's "Innocent" performance-not that good on LIVE but better as the RECORDED version
Not as good as his first and third performances, but I think his voice is a bit tired. And rightly so....it's been a rough week for all of them. They should have a week off between home visit and the last two weeks!
Wow, Innocent AND Dare You To Move - as personal choices - I am entirely, wholeheartedly impressed. Where has this incredible talent been my whole life??? I so appreciate a view askew --Keep to it ! --I truly cannot wait for whats to come—
CookMeNow, WN#766 here. Representin' for my WordNerds. Thanks for posting that, idolmusic08. We international Cook fans appreciate it more than you'll ever know. Love you, David!!!
NO variety? Archuleta sounds exactly the same in every song. I just can't hear him on any radio station. David Cook has such a great style for the radio, and he'd be alot more popular.
I actually really liked this, when I heard he was singing a Switchfoot song I about died, they never sing songs from people I know and I LOVE Switchfoot. Major kudos in my book. He did a good job =D
i hate arguing on the internet, but NEVER compare david cook to nickelback. they are sell-out rock band. their singer has no where near the talent that david cook has. i would love to see them try and arrange an andrew lloyd webber song or dolly parton. this kid doesn't just know how to sing, unlike archie.
i LOVE him. He has such a variety of styles he can sing...and he's amazing at all of them. Archuleta sounds the same in every song. David Cook better win!
if he was able to get more than a minute 30 of this song, he would have brought the house down. it is one of my favorite songs, and he was made to sing this song.
did he win? lol jk
SeaTheWhirled 8 months ago
I told myself if he kills this song I will be ruined. HE KILLED IT! MY CHILDHOOD IS SCARRED!
TheAlissLynn 10 months ago
meh...i don't think this song was good for him...
Bluessoulphoenix 1 year ago
i LOVE YOU
iLuvEnriqueSagapw 1 year ago
KILLLED this song. horrible
blinkitback 1 year ago
@blinkitback listen to switchfoot live... the guy cannot sing even remotely on the same level as David Cook.. So you are a retard
skeetskeetskeet420 1 year ago
@skeetskeetskeet420 Sorry, but his range is not close to Jon Foreman's, nor does he sing quite as loud. Also, David Cook is slightly off-key at certain key parts in the song (notably the high parts), and has to strain quite a bit. You're right, Jon Foreman live is on another level. His stage presence is simply amazing.
I have to agree with most of the people here in that he ruined it. :<
windrixx 5 months ago
@windrixx lol cool story bro.. Jon Foreman sucks live, at least David can hit valid notes.. keep telling me cool stories though, these are much more fun
skeetskeetskeet420 5 months ago
@skeetskeetskeet420 Mmm, i love the "cool story bro" response. Almost as creative as the "shut up" response, but a lot less... angry? (Feigning indifference doesn't work when you proceed to argue, btw)
Why don't you listen to the video you're commenting on? Just listening to the chorus makes it evident that he can't hit the notes in the chorus. Don't tell me he can hit "valid" notes (wtf is a valid note anyways); anyone with even decent relative pitch (clearly not you) can tell that it's off.
windrixx 5 months ago
@windrixx Simply watch him sing other songs, he nails shit almost 100% of the time, just because he didn't nail this, doesn't mean he cannot sing... He has a great voice, one of the few from American Idol, god that show is gayyyyyyyy. Also I said cool story bro BECAUSE IT WAS A COOL STORY.... I was not feigning indifference.. I only say it when I MEAN IT!!!! I LOVE YOUR STORIES BRO!!!! SO MUCH!!! I SWEAR!
.
Jon Foreman still sucks dicks for money though... just sayin homie
skeetskeetskeet420 5 months ago
@skeetskeetskeet420 Jon Foreman is a much better artist than you could ever be. I'd ask you to explain why he "sucks dicks for money", but I doubt you're intellectually capable. Sorry.
And I'm not saying that David Cook can't "nail shit almost 100% of the time"; I'm just saying that he can't nail this song. Not even close.
windrixx 5 months ago
@windrixx I said he sucks dick for money, and you ask for an explanation?? HE SUCKS DICKS FOR MONEY, THAT IS THE EXPLANATION WHAT THE FUCKKK ARE YOU REALLY SERIOUS??? clearly? you are FUCKING with me right? And Jon Foreman cannot nail this song live, he sucks dick when he performs too, audio dicks... sucks em... then gets off stage to go back to his hobby of blowing dudes in back alleys for money since his band sucks and wrote 2 good songs ever
skeetskeetskeet420 5 months ago
bad
dabbuhl 1 year ago
Amazing band!
linkinahmed 1 year ago
CRAP
BoxMyHeart 1 year ago
BUTCHERED the song. BUTCHERED. don't argue w/ me lol. he did. lol okay fine argue if u want lol
ShaltNot07 2 years ago
i agree with both the first 2 judges
ShaltNot07 2 years ago
Just completely ruined the song. Bad.
CrazyKewlx3 2 years ago 6
he won because he can play the guitar and sing at the same time thats talent!!!
PRchica101 2 years ago
I wish he sang the whole song! i like this better then Switchfoot!
fuddy12345 2 years ago
I think hes left handed o.O Hes using a left handed guitar. David archuleta is left handed too lol
hais2640 2 years ago
I just love this version....I really love it...Go DC....
biancacookhook 2 years ago
i love this song!
david cook totally aced this song<3
XskaterockenceXpo 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think that Cook should have NOT over done that dare you to move part because that was one of the best part of the song.
illusionmofo 2 years ago
sounds better with switchfoot...........
neobryce 2 years ago 4
blasphemy
bradyblair09 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this guy is a sellout. This is an acoustic song and he is Faking with an electric. what a douche. All for show.
mattmylescheesys 2 years ago
I cant decide if I like the original or this one better.
Its always tough to decide with David Cook XD
narutofan966 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
plz watch and rate my short video of David Cook's Idol journey from the auditions to the coronation
watch?v=Hy7rd2Kpe-E
I just love this guy
coolidge909 2 years ago
wow, that was short....one verse and one corus?
Heartless216 2 years ago 6
i like his better than switchfoots version
RJJ513 2 years ago 2
Even better than the original one.
atomicfad01 2 years ago
no way
turkeysub10 2 years ago 2
Nice version of David Cook!
lyle2324 2 years ago
"everyone's here. everyone's watching you now. everybody waits for you now"
i can see how he could relate to this song as a performer.
AMAZING performance. i dont think he got enough credit for it
rocketrun87 2 years ago 4
this performance was awesome!
54spiritedwill54 2 years ago 2
i like david cook's emphazised chorus better than switchfoot's
Rock10punk 2 years ago 5
the chorus was amazing!
Volcomstone000095 2 years ago
personally, i was a david a. fan
but this was wonderful
aptacek93 2 years ago 2
I am in luv with David Cook he is sooo hot
Stargazer1617 2 years ago 5
this song is awesome!
Sahira8CiCi 2 years ago 3
David is amazing!
tinna288 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
islandshawty62695 3 years ago
its ok........ but i think it was a little scratchy except the chorus
edwardsmyboyfriend 3 years ago
wow..
switchfoot does sing it better
but david deff did an awesome job on the chorus..
made my heart stopp<333
alegrec001 3 years ago
DAVID sings this better than the original! ^_^
1jen108 3 years ago
obvoisuly you will like the original singer/writer of the song, at least these people try to immitate them as well as they can , jesus give them a break
Ballinfrls 3 years ago 3
i agree switchfoot is better overall, but when David hits the chorus..."Dare you to move", my heart just stops.
mymusiclist999 3 years ago 5
jon foreman is better
dillibar02 3 years ago 5
rip max 1992-2008 this song ta u suxz the way u had ta go ull b rembered....=[....
wannadrive45 3 years ago
he's alright but the real switch foot was better
Marth757 3 years ago 2
another outstanding performance from david cook
rifqiah 3 years ago 2
whatever. david cook deserved to win. granted this wasnt his BEST performance, but he is still amazing
snowbells7 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is horribe
dc is not a good singer!
UglyBettyFanatic 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What the fuck is wrong with you?!?!
probowler94 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dc sux
UglyBettyFanatic 3 years ago
hey are u a good singer??just lyk dc???
if not STFU!!okay!!! so erking
nonengOGE 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and so are you... sucker
tonstagnant 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sorry
UglyBettyFanatic 3 years ago
No nothing's wrong with me, it is shouting why don't you try comparing David Cook's high notes to Syesha's or Archuleta's then you'll notice.
pencilcut09 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Horrible, he was shouting the whole time, how could someone who shouts beat someone who sings in a heartfelt way and is a truly fantastic singer? what is wrong with america
pencilcut09 3 years ago
That's not shouting. Obviously you dont sing. Maybe something is wrong with you not America
darwinwap 3 years ago 3
he could have done better
everyoneloveskayla 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
man he totally killed this song! i mean it was so fuckinn bad! he cant sing and shouldnt have won. he can suck dick
poopbeans2 3 years ago
dude u can suck dick
STFU!!!
martirox01 3 years ago
Can you even sing? I bet not.
STFU.
Die in hell...
Rockerchic1002 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok im sorry
UglyBettyFanatic 3 years ago
OMG i love David for singing this song. I love it. He is an amazing singer and the fact that he had to guts to sing a song from a christian band on a tv show shown around the world is amazing and i give david mad props. Peace!!!!!!!
salvation721 3 years ago
Bleh!!
BarnBum194 3 years ago 3
mrharduk881 you obviously have no life if you say things like that about people. If you dont like him...dont watch the video and dont comment!
I <3 U David Cook!
KK1725 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david cook american Ido!!!!?????????DAVID ARCHULETA AMERICAN WORLD IDOL!!!!!!!!YES!!!
MinnieMartha 3 years ago
em ä little boring, but he is good
atzedenr1 3 years ago 2
Come on everyone please vote now! He is worthy! Dont let David a win! Vote now
VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE!
david772 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if u love him so much, go and suck his sweaty nasty purplish cock, bc this fucker has not talent, he looks like a dog with rabies, he needs to fucking shave and shower, i swear i saw ticks crawling around his hair, motherfucker looks like some type of medical experiment gone wrong.
mrharduk881 3 years ago
o fuck u u shuldnt say n e thing cause i bet hes way much better looking and talented than u!!!! he can sing any type of song and can david a? idnt thnk so (not saying he sucks) but david deserved to win so shut up u dnt kno wat ur sayin god...david didnt do n e thing to u but sing his heart out and having all this stress and this is wat u say wow watever
punkrock803 3 years ago
what are you talking about??? just like he said: " every girl´s crazy for a sharp dressed man " lolllllllll!!!!!!!
sweetgirl545 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
aaa David Cook FTW!!! ppl plsssssssssss VOTE all 4 hrs this tuesday!! it's crucial.... it seems like he's singin 1st and ALL 6 AI winners won from singin 2nd we NEED to BREAK that trend soooo VOTE!!!!!!!!!
Shereeda2202 3 years ago
THE BEST
lollipopeater8 3 years ago 7
I want "MOAR" too Paula...lol
katicakittykat 3 years ago 3
I LOVE YOU DAVID COOK!!!!! <3 Im voting for you and I hope you win!
missangels69 3 years ago 9
I KNOW!!!
I WISH HE COULD WIN HE DESERVES IT.. HE'S THE BETTER OF THE TWO..
but david a has teeny boppers voting all night blaaaah
aubreeeeeey 3 years ago 3
THANK GOD he's in the final 2!!! :)
linamarie7235 3 years ago
I disagree with the judges
I liked it
It was simple and raw
Pretty and I wish he would've recorded it instead
caisson333 3 years ago 6
lol. He has a flower on his guitar.
I love this song. I love that he sang it.
MY AMERICAN IDOL!!!
bubbutuby 3 years ago 2
FYI ... The flower on his guitar was a shout out to his fans, the Word Nerds, who had over 60 flower arrangements delivered to his dressing room before the show that night. :)
FoolsApril64 3 years ago 4
This is CookMeNow checkin' in. WordNerd #766. I love David Cook and my peep in WordNerd land! WOOT, WOOT, WOOT! Ain't he a real HUMDINGER!
shg2fish 3 years ago
*waves to shg2fish* FoolsApril64 WordNerd#1323 ... and that he is! A HUMDINGER! *smiles broadly*
FoolsApril64 3 years ago
i like dave cook but i love switchfoot and i thought he butchered it.
glutenfreeheather 3 years ago
Pitchy? I thought it was fine... but I have to agree with Paula... I want him to sing the WHOLE SONG!!! Maybe the producers should change the arrangements :)
Kansiov 3 years ago 3
It's a great song, and it's just cool that David Cook sang this song for us to hear it again in his voice. Hope he records this, of all the three songs, I like this the best actually.
djayzm 3 years ago 3
switchfoot rox! they were on j leno tonight and rocked the house!
gordonfan09 3 years ago
Didn't really like it. The first verse sounded horrible. The rest was better, but still not great.
And the whole time, he was like yelling. It looked like he was in pain.
I don't particularly like either David's or Syesha, but in my opinion, Syesha's voice is the best. But unfortunately, I know she's not gonna win.
Oh well.
iLaughAtConcrete 3 years ago
love ur name lol
caisson333 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i noticed that he yells dring all his songs... i really hate that about him. im not gonna lie.
pollietodays 3 years ago
If that's yelling
then it sounds fucking hott
except that last note
I like his songs and how he sings
even tho i like david a. more
caisson333 3 years ago
this performance was awesome!
gambekar 3 years ago 5
hmm, one of my favorite of all time Christian Songs... glad He sang it...
marypatb 3 years ago 6
hah! everytime david say "R" like in bartender, he does the hand gesture like in the pirate joke!
jennystarz 3 years ago
I love how Paula says she wants more in that minute and thirty seconds. How about, I dunno, you actually DO give them more time so you can fit a beginning, middle, and end in there. Less time on the commercials and advertising crap and more time singing.
Havoc721 3 years ago 2
The Switchfoot version is better because David's voice seem to crack in this performance. but, I am excited for the studio version because I feel like it is gonna end up like his Our Lady Peace's "Innocent" performance-not that good on LIVE but better as the RECORDED version
chatterbox1229 3 years ago
Love the Barrrgh tender crack!
Not as good as his first and third performances, but I think his voice is a bit tired. And rightly so....it's been a rough week for all of them. They should have a week off between home visit and the last two weeks!
wyldrein2 3 years ago
Nah it was better then switchfoots version i think.
ckbarnett73 3 years ago
It was better that switchfoot version
ilovedavidcook25 3 years ago 3
Wow, Innocent AND Dare You To Move - as personal choices - I am entirely, wholeheartedly impressed. Where has this incredible talent been my whole life??? I so appreciate a view askew --Keep to it ! --I truly cannot wait for whats to come—
jmcc199 3 years ago
vote for him he is the best
buccsrule25 3 years ago
he's oozing talent
greenanimal 3 years ago
i agree that he wasn't better than John Foreman but ya knw, atleast he tried and he actually picked a christian band!!! WOO!
GOOOOO DAVID COOK!!!
Hawknelsonluver101 3 years ago
love switchfoot love DC loved the song
mileysdouble 3 years ago 2
This wasn't DC's best, but he definitely rocked out and deserves to be in the F2.
SelenaKK01 3 years ago 2
It was kind of awful compared to Switchfoot's verison, but I LOVE that he sang it.
countrymusiccowgirl 3 years ago
Jon Foreman is better. But Cook was sounding good at the end.
Simon was wrong in saying it's not melodic.
The song is amazing
TachycardiaPaul 3 years ago 2
really hope this song is made for the studio version because it would be AMAZING. just like paula, sadly, i wanted more.
hrhawk06 3 years ago
I hope so too.
AcousticLove19 3 years ago
He is. SO. DAMN. FIIIIIINE.
Good God. Look at those arms. Gah.
MonkeyBonkers 3 years ago 2
david deserved to be american idol not some small fry like archuletta
thefellowhuh 3 years ago
CookMeNow, WN#766 here. Representin' for my WordNerds. Thanks for posting that, idolmusic08. We international Cook fans appreciate it more than you'll ever know. Love you, David!!!
shg2fish 3 years ago
Switchfoot rocks!
StarMesa 3 years ago 2
Switchfoot is waaay better. jon foreman is a better vocalist. but he did good. i just like sf version better
JessicaLievanos 3 years ago
NO variety? Archuleta sounds exactly the same in every song. I just can't hear him on any radio station. David Cook has such a great style for the radio, and he'd be alot more popular.
linamarie7235 3 years ago 2
amen!
TheMovieKingIsMe 3 years ago 2
I actually really liked this, when I heard he was singing a Switchfoot song I about died, they never sing songs from people I know and I LOVE Switchfoot. Major kudos in my book. He did a good job =D
TobiSkye 3 years ago
He has no variety. Same generic Nickelback/Hinder feel to every song. He shouldn't win and I hope he doesnt. Too generic to be an idol.
octopusXonXfire 3 years ago
You're funny.
MonkeyBonkers 3 years ago
i hate arguing on the internet, but NEVER compare david cook to nickelback. they are sell-out rock band. their singer has no where near the talent that david cook has. i would love to see them try and arrange an andrew lloyd webber song or dolly parton. this kid doesn't just know how to sing, unlike archie.
hrhawk06 3 years ago
I <3 David Cool
Jess9958 3 years ago
WOW! Man He Rocks!
TheMovieKingIsMe 3 years ago 2
That flower on his guitar ... it's a shout out to his fans ... the Word Nerds!! What a guy!
COOK FTW!! I wanted MORE!!! :)
WN#1323
FoolsApril64 3 years ago 2
I know what pitchy is and it was kinda pitchy at the beggining.
joepatrick55 3 years ago
When he was home on Friday for the filming of his hometown you couldn't go anywhere around here, jeez!!!
I live 20 minutes away from his hometown, it was packed.
vintagemarilyn 3 years ago
hmmmmm
i love this song
he was smart to choose it
and the chorus sounded great...
but..........
he was rather flat on the 1st verse
ravengirlkitkat 3 years ago
i LOVE him. He has such a variety of styles he can sing...and he's amazing at all of them. Archuleta sounds the same in every song. David Cook better win!
linamarie7235 3 years ago
if he was able to get more than a minute 30 of this song, he would have brought the house down. it is one of my favorite songs, and he was made to sing this song.
hrhawk06 3 years ago 2
Hum... the judges are nuts... That was incredible.
Deathcabforugly 3 years ago
He is AWESOME!!! He NEEDS to win!!!!!!!
whoishotinhere 3 years ago 2
It was David Cook's night!! He's our next American Idol.
KansasGirl30 3 years ago 3
Not my favorite of the night, but he should still win. DC rocks!!
jewelswoolf 3 years ago