@jeherrera17 I fully agree, Animosity was their last great album, he added that special dimension to the music, to me Ministry will always be Paul Barker and Al Jourgenson.
@vampyricIust Simply, genius like this is built to be but a brilliant flash, then gone for eternity. Sad but true...we can only pay homage like a thousand pagan rituals before....
it sucks that all these guys are now estranged and that the drugs caused it all to implode, dave has nothing to do with ogre and cevin, barker has been sued by al and bill well he plays for rem now. but the good thing is we all have the music that these individuals have created so for that i am thinkful and i am happy that all the above mentioned are still around, although i give my respects to raven,ward,and dwayne and the others that have past on that were involved in this scene.
@erreur im pretty sure Ogre was doing all sorts of drugs before he met AJ.but i do agree,H was part of downfall,and having member of SP OD didnt help.Al is a piece of shit junkie who dosent care who he brings down with him.Unfortuneately i knew someone personally. she met al in texas mid 90's.she partied a little but was never into h or crack. really sweet girl, just a bit starstruck.6mo later,50lbs lighter,her parents had to literaly kidnap her and into rehab back in Cali.doing well now.fuck AJ
@DrVice1 it is odd. long time ministry fan and a bigger fan of SP. me and my friend always curious how a cuban from texas(among other mid western states)sings with an english-esque accent.
@DrVice1 I have to mention that this is Ogre on vocals. Rave worked the board during the show. If you listen in the beginning, Ogre's pointing to and introducing Rave to the crowd. Trust me, back in those days, if anyone introduced themselves in such a manner, they wouldn't last long.
Those shows were jam packed with great moments...of which most were right on the edge. I miss those days.
fantastic - thank-you for posting this! I just discovered the Magazine version and now to see my late 80s teen heroes (Skinny Puppy & Ministry) were doing it live too is way cool!
@BLACKSUNR1SE ok guys don´t need to get mad i actually thought that Peter Murphy´s version was the original one, but i like it anyway so my apologies to you all.
Wow, I have only ever heard Peter Murphy's version of this.. I thought he wrote it. This is so cool! If you like Ministry's version, try Peter Murphy's version.
I was really impressed with this cover the first time I heard it. Magazine were so fucking innovative, and this version is very close to the original.
True about the American Idol thing. Any band that puts something out today is totally packaged and processed. This video is great. I like this song from Animositisomnia and knew it was a cover, but I didn't know that Ministry had been covering it for so long. I love the start when the drums are going and the song it is getting ready to start, there's what looks like random people walking around the stage
Yeah, and whats even worse is how they seem completely oblivious to things that are much better in taste. Looks like fashion (emo) and corporate-accountants are more in control than ever before!
@volleyballonconcrete Its sad because music was stolen away from the people and now just big business corporate shit and the generation dosnt even know what real freedom they are missing.
Great,,, I wonder why it took them another 12+ years to put it on an album.
Funny thing is, I saw them a few years back and they did this right after playing something from Twitch. Talk about a flashback...the metalheads in the room didn't know what to make of it.
Do you remember which tour you attended or the year of the concert? Ministry didn't officially incorporate any material from "Twitch" into their setlists since 1988's "The Land of Rape and Honey Tour".
I consider "Twitch" and "The Land of Rape and Honey" to be such musical rarities in Ministry's discography. I wish I could have attended the tours for those respective releases (mid-to-late 80s), but alas, I wasn't even born then!
That's not true...this was the Animositisomina tour in...2002? They did "We Believe" in one of the encores. This was at the Phoenix show. At least, I THINK it was "We Believe"...could have been "Just Like You".
And yes, my jaw dropped because I had never seen them play anything from Twitch. They always play Stigmata though, and I've seen a few other TLORAH songs over the past 10 or so years.
@csp42 at first i wanted to agree with you but if you look at the logo on the back of Ogre's jacket and the fact that he is smoking cigarettes seem to suggest this is an older performance.
He covered Joy Division's Dead Souls which he did an amazing job on and he covered Adam Ant, Queen and The Normal's Warm Leatherette. You should research before you make any accusation, you fucking dumb asshole!
yeah that dead souls was just fucking awesome, it did'nt sound just like a nin song, real angry and slow, then hard. OH MY GOODNESS I almost forgot about the embarrassing adam ant being his co-pilot and having him on stage, I'm guessing "stand and deliver" is Reznors fav song by him....
Yet Skinny Puppy made an album with Throbbing Gristle.
If you love Nivek Ogre, check out the upcoming movie REPO! The Genetic Opera. It's a rock opera, and he stars in it, so that means plenty of him singing. ^_^
Even though the video is grainy as hell OGRE'S coolness still shines through! OGRE is the man!
19blando77 2 months ago
that video effect at 4.09 was rich...
sn1ffy85 3 months ago
When Ministry was good.
gamage3 4 months ago
Ministry died the day Paul Barker left, plain and simple.
jeherrera17 5 months ago 3
@jeherrera17 I fully agree, Animosity was their last great album, he added that special dimension to the music, to me Ministry will always be Paul Barker and Al Jourgenson.
Ryanyarb24 3 months ago
@Ryanyarb24 animositisomina was like getting up when everyone has tagged you as being dead
iatrogenicsteve 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Ministry
This Video Is Awesome !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ChristianDeath74 8 months ago
@vampyricIust Simply, genius like this is built to be but a brilliant flash, then gone for eternity. Sad but true...we can only pay homage like a thousand pagan rituals before....
j37h3r 9 months ago 4
love this cover
mojaroar 9 months ago
shame on you einstein, i will stay back in this, MY time! great song, great show and thanks for the video !.
XxCOLDSTEELxX 10 months ago
it sucks that all these guys are now estranged and that the drugs caused it all to implode, dave has nothing to do with ogre and cevin, barker has been sued by al and bill well he plays for rem now. but the good thing is we all have the music that these individuals have created so for that i am thinkful and i am happy that all the above mentioned are still around, although i give my respects to raven,ward,and dwayne and the others that have past on that were involved in this scene.
vampyricIust 11 months ago 4
@vampyricIust Ohhhhhhh, caught in a bad bromance...
gangurobitch 3 months ago
I was at this show...wow I remember this shit...awesome to see it up here!
lolliwag 1 year ago
fucking hell this is FANTASTIC!
punkgirlcandy 1 year ago 2
Original is better- especially the Peel session version
aikido117 1 year ago
geiler song! mein geburtsjahr;-)
8erdling8 1 year ago
this was Skinny Puppy's downfall, Ogre hooking up with Jourgensen and getting all strung out on heroin and turning into a cheeseball rockstar.
erreur 1 year ago
@erreur im pretty sure Ogre was doing all sorts of drugs before he met AJ.but i do agree,H was part of downfall,and having member of SP OD didnt help.Al is a piece of shit junkie who dosent care who he brings down with him.Unfortuneately i knew someone personally. she met al in texas mid 90's.she partied a little but was never into h or crack. really sweet girl, just a bit starstruck.6mo later,50lbs lighter,her parents had to literaly kidnap her and into rehab back in Cali.doing well now.fuck AJ
simptoes 1 year ago
@simptoes not al's fault people couldnt handle the chaos. He could.
eggfleece 11 months ago
@simptoes sad . . . I've always maintained that being an amazing artist doesn't necessarily mean that you're worth a s**t as a person.
chronophagia 9 months ago 2
Oops, I was mistaken. Sounded kinda like Ogre for a reason then. :)
DrVice1 1 year ago
@DrVice1 it is odd. long time ministry fan and a bigger fan of SP. me and my friend always curious how a cuban from texas(among other mid western states)sings with an english-esque accent.
simptoes 1 year ago
@simptoes
And half-Norwegian too..
djanzon 1 year ago
Comment removed
HegelKarl 1 year ago
great but sadly you can't hear anything from the crash drums?
Jauly 1 year ago
Comment removed
DrVice1 1 year ago
@DrVice1 I have to mention that this is Ogre on vocals. Rave worked the board during the show. If you listen in the beginning, Ogre's pointing to and introducing Rave to the crowd. Trust me, back in those days, if anyone introduced themselves in such a manner, they wouldn't last long.
Those shows were jam packed with great moments...of which most were right on the edge. I miss those days.
tescomfvee 1 year ago
Fuckin' A man! Nice Post!
skhooll 1 year ago
holy crap I love this so fucking much!!! thanks for posting! :D
chanceska 1 year ago
fantastic - thank-you for posting this! I just discovered the Magazine version and now to see my late 80s teen heroes (Skinny Puppy & Ministry) were doing it live too is way cool!
EYEmusique 1 year ago
tuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuune
UncorrectSubculture 1 year ago
wow, great quality, thx for uploading this one
panzerny 1 year ago 2
Wow, great audio considering the age. Greatness
rmhanzel 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it´s no bad but i prefer the original song by Peter Murphy.
TheHostel2000 2 years ago
No. It was wriiten and performed by Magazine originally. Peter Murphy's version is a cover.
SonofNightmare 2 years ago
@TheHostel2000 BY MAGAZINE!
BLACKSUNR1SE 1 year ago
@BLACKSUNR1SE ok guys don´t need to get mad i actually thought that Peter Murphy´s version was the original one, but i like it anyway so my apologies to you all.
TheHostel2000 1 year ago
i wasn't really mad i was saying it with a ssssuper gay suthun bell accent!
BLACKSUNR1SE 1 year ago
nice
TheUndert0ker 2 years ago
Wow, I have only ever heard Peter Murphy's version of this.. I thought he wrote it. This is so cool! If you like Ministry's version, try Peter Murphy's version.
pastillegirl 2 years ago
I've heard all three versions, and I have to say this Ministry one's up there with the Magazine original IMO
AJtheory 2 years ago
I was really impressed with this cover the first time I heard it. Magazine were so fucking innovative, and this version is very close to the original.
VernianProcess 2 years ago
Magazine are back together and still shit hot! And I'm so happy!
diasthema 2 years ago
Would agree with that. Spot on.
anthonydansullivan 2 years ago
Comment removed
hausdok 2 years ago
The late Jeff Ward...
j37h3r 2 years ago
@hausdok no
MARYLANDSTATEVOTERS 1 year ago
Really good version.
droogless 2 years ago
True about the American Idol thing. Any band that puts something out today is totally packaged and processed. This video is great. I like this song from Animositisomnia and knew it was a cover, but I didn't know that Ministry had been covering it for so long. I love the start when the drums are going and the song it is getting ready to start, there's what looks like random people walking around the stage
nomad2746 2 years ago 2
And some crazy chick getting thrown off :p
Maverick6429 2 years ago
I love this one so much!
Awesome!!!
elizkawalizka3 2 years ago
its a shame...that now all these kids have is american idol
volleyballonconcrete 2 years ago 23
Yeah, and whats even worse is how they seem completely oblivious to things that are much better in taste. Looks like fashion (emo) and corporate-accountants are more in control than ever before!
blacklightposter 2 years ago
@volleyballonconcrete Its sad because music was stolen away from the people and now just big business corporate shit and the generation dosnt even know what real freedom they are missing.
Wscate 3 months ago
furkin awsesome sound .cant get it out of my head
spassy13 2 years ago
fukkin Great !!! Job !!!@doinIT! awesome ThankXXXX jonny.
yr BRUCE CARKISS
carkiss 2 years ago
feeeeeck! Thanx for this!!!!!
sicksadmike 2 years ago
NICE ONE !!!!!!
dlonegunman 2 years ago
sweet! thanks for uploading this!
REBdomina 2 years ago
Great,,, I wonder why it took them another 12+ years to put it on an album.
Funny thing is, I saw them a few years back and they did this right after playing something from Twitch. Talk about a flashback...the metalheads in the room didn't know what to make of it.
csp42 2 years ago
Do you remember which tour you attended or the year of the concert? Ministry didn't officially incorporate any material from "Twitch" into their setlists since 1988's "The Land of Rape and Honey Tour".
I consider "Twitch" and "The Land of Rape and Honey" to be such musical rarities in Ministry's discography. I wish I could have attended the tours for those respective releases (mid-to-late 80s), but alas, I wasn't even born then!
Lateralus281 2 years ago
That's not true...this was the Animositisomina tour in...2002? They did "We Believe" in one of the encores. This was at the Phoenix show. At least, I THINK it was "We Believe"...could have been "Just Like You".
And yes, my jaw dropped because I had never seen them play anything from Twitch. They always play Stigmata though, and I've seen a few other TLORAH songs over the past 10 or so years.
csp42 2 years ago
That is awesome!! I'm green with envy! :P
Lateralus281 2 years ago
@csp42 at first i wanted to agree with you but if you look at the logo on the back of Ogre's jacket and the fact that he is smoking cigarettes seem to suggest this is an older performance.
ruedauseil 1 year ago
Ogre was, is and shall always be the fucking man.
jackkoffin1 2 years ago 4
Thank you so much for posting this video, it is brilliant.
thisistactical 2 years ago
Woo-Hoo! Yay Heroin!!
asbestosinhaler 2 years ago 2
I see and hear this , then realize... Trent Reznor is a lazy cocksucker.
Who could he even cover as a tribute to what inspired him. No one because it would suck shit,.. he even knows this.
fascistbullygirl13 2 years ago
He covered Joy Division's Dead Souls which he did an amazing job on and he covered Adam Ant, Queen and The Normal's Warm Leatherette. You should research before you make any accusation, you fucking dumb asshole!
lolliwag 2 years ago
yeah that dead souls was just fucking awesome, it did'nt sound just like a nin song, real angry and slow, then hard. OH MY GOODNESS I almost forgot about the embarrassing adam ant being his co-pilot and having him on stage, I'm guessing "stand and deliver" is Reznors fav song by him....
Yet Skinny Puppy made an album with Throbbing Gristle.
I do aplogize for being so uniformed.
fascistbullygirl13 2 years ago
Is that Jeff Ward on drums?
ponmlk 2 years ago 2
Bill Rieflin... (R.I.P.)
artichokhart 2 years ago
?
Jeff Ward has, sadly, passed away. But Bill Rieflin has been REM's drummer for the last 10 years.
skrason 2 years ago 2
Yeah, bro. My bad.
artichokhart 2 years ago
Itś on Animositisomina CD I was think that itś originally by Ministry...oooops
riverstix0007 2 years ago
WOW! what a great cover. that guy Ogre can chant
nipglass04 3 years ago
I was at this concert,great show....
cman7142000 3 years ago
OGRE!!!!
AustinKronix 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
They are awesome
supplechase 3 years ago
funny, i was just listening to Magazine's album 'Real Life' last night. I have the Toronto '88 video. I still need this on DVD! :)
circledrag 3 years ago
Yeah, Ministry hasn't been the same since he left.
nickknox75 3 years ago 2
Awesome, this song appears too in the "Animositisomina" album in a great studio version by Ministry
thrashmayhem 3 years ago 2
Everytime Jourgenson and Ogre teamed up it was a success in my book.... PTP...Acid Horse...or a live show (like this one)
Zangwinger 3 years ago 4
If you love Nivek Ogre, check out the upcoming movie REPO! The Genetic Opera. It's a rock opera, and he stars in it, so that means plenty of him singing. ^_^
FairyGodmoose 3 years ago
Another awesome live version of Light Pours Out Of Me is by Sleep Chamber if you can find it.
GreatestPotential 3 years ago
how long does it take for a dog to starve to death in a laboratory ?
skinnypuppy1 3 years ago
Brilliant version of a classic!
so glad you've posted this video!
boogerbenson 3 years ago
Fantastic. Always loved magazine but this a great version
1x1x1x1 3 years ago
Hilarious.
Ordsall66 3 years ago
oh god this sounds just like pigface all over again, thank you so much
spadesghost 3 years ago
Fucking brilliant
bleueyeddevl 3 years ago
the track on animositisomina is good too
wolfmanjacksaid 3 years ago
Ogre + Ministry = manna from heaven!!!
maledictorchid 3 years ago
Wow Very Fucking Nice! THANK YOU SO FUCKING MUCH!
420dAn 3 years ago
Thank you soooo much for uploading this video! This song rocks, brilliant cover, and love Nivek! <3
j7609 3 years ago
fucking krazy man wooh
cannibaljuice 3 years ago
WOW.....truly awesome find! thanks for posting!
jankk 3 years ago
WHAT A GEM! Thanks!
Monsterious 3 years ago
Ministry+Skinny Puppy+Magazine= happy me! It's actually pretty good quality for 1988 as well.thanks!!
xaxiswye 3 years ago
Thanks
antichay 3 years ago
Thanks for posting this. This is awesome
misterpeligro 4 years ago