you actually put together an serious and dark, thought provoking plot old-west game with lots of gore, kidnapping, rape, murdering of innocent people, with a bloody revolution on mexico with a music from a girl who sings that its not easy to be teenager? yeah, nice combo. i can imagine you thinking "hey thats a good idea"
Jesus everyone fucked Abigail back then - and John probably forgotten to pull out - brutal but honest, what does it have to do with love, sometimes i wonder why John Marston si so stupid, i mean even if he had something with Bonnie while being married - who'll end up hurt? He's a criminal he killed people he surely regrets doing so but having an affair with Bonnie for him won't be that hurting...
@xElizabethxSweetiex Im not stupid! Im well aware hes married! To tell the truth I hate Abigail oh ya, ive finished both games of red dead so dont judge...jeez.
i love the story, but especially the story between John and Bonnie. I hoped soo much that she would talk to him, about her feelings and all that. I was so sad as he died, they never had a chance..
I thought the game was quite touching after you see Bonnie 1 last time before it all ends. I reckon they should incorporate Bonnie into the storyline later on to John Marston's death where she is at his funeral & to her mentoring of young Jack
Really well pieced together video. Bonnie obviously crushed on him. . . but who can't respect his loyalty. John Marston is a lot of things, but unfaithful, he is not.
@DarthSeptic Thank you! =D But yeah, no way would John ever betray Abigail and that's why we love him. I just think that if Abigail had died before John or if they had never met or something like that, he and Bonnie would be a good match.
@maswellasm Thank you making this. I love Bonnie and John together...alot of people say Bonnie is shit and annoying or white trash but I disagree. Shes the only woman in the whole video game who would actually give up marraige life to help her father with the farm! Like she has a little crush on John and John kind of likes her to but both are loyal. Which is why they would never. Sadly.
Nice video! So sad. I love them so much, but I love John and Abigail too. Great video. And where is the hug-shot from? I don't remember that from the game, but maybe I'm just stupid.
@DinosaurDemon Hmm...given that Abigail wears a dress, I don't know that it's comparable. But I get what you're saying- I would always pick a woman in pants over one in a dress. =D
you actually put together an serious and dark, thought provoking plot old-west game with lots of gore, kidnapping, rape, murdering of innocent people, with a bloody revolution on mexico with a music from a girl who sings that its not easy to be teenager? yeah, nice combo. i can imagine you thinking "hey thats a good idea"
Koyaanitsqatsi 1 week ago
@Koyaanitsqatsi lol, you can imagine me thinking? Baby, you don't know me from a hole in the ground. Better luck with your criticisms next time.
maswellasm 1 week ago
@maswellasm what are you talking about? i just said its a nice combo, and if you thought it was good idea then it must be
Koyaanitsqatsi 6 days ago
@Koyaanitsqatsi Oh, I'm sorry! Obviously I misinterpreted the tone of your comment! lol, I feel like an asshole now. Thank you, sorry about that. =)
maswellasm 6 days ago
Jesus everyone fucked Abigail back then - and John probably forgotten to pull out - brutal but honest, what does it have to do with love, sometimes i wonder why John Marston si so stupid, i mean even if he had something with Bonnie while being married - who'll end up hurt? He's a criminal he killed people he surely regrets doing so but having an affair with Bonnie for him won't be that hurting...
Dustjericho 7 months ago
good vid but retarted music
caleb1823 8 months ago
In Red Dead Redemption... do we ever see Bonnie as Jack?
Baiyka 9 months ago
I wish they would tell eachother they're feelings! Its obvious they loved eachother )=
I just wish they will make a red dead redemption 3 go back in time so they get more time together!!!!
Rukia91554 10 months ago
@Rukia91554
Wait what? Noooo John is married stupid. He evidently loves Abigail? His wife?
xElizabethxSweetiex 8 months ago
@xElizabethxSweetiex Im not stupid! Im well aware hes married! To tell the truth I hate Abigail oh ya, ive finished both games of red dead so dont judge...jeez.
Rukia91554 8 months ago
@maswellasm
Is this Scene @1:25 from Undead Nightmare? Because I don't know this scene. And I finished the main game more than one time. Plz explain.
MrTestaccount12345 10 months ago
@MrTestaccount12345 Yeah, that's from Undead Nightmare.
maswellasm 10 months ago
i love the story, but especially the story between John and Bonnie. I hoped soo much that she would talk to him, about her feelings and all that. I was so sad as he died, they never had a chance..
SasuNaru350 10 months ago
Abigail and John are meant to be together. white trash belongs with white trash.
Pepper6464 11 months ago
@Pepper6464 Hm. Insightful, thank you.
maswellasm 11 months ago 2
Is it just me or does Abigail and John look like brother and sister ? ? ?
Pepper6464 11 months ago
I think Bonnie is the only person John Marston hugs back in the game. Ever. Lol
shortbuschick1462 1 year ago 18
@shortbuschick1462 NO! He hugged his wife and kid when he got home
Pepper6464 11 months ago
I thought the game was quite touching after you see Bonnie 1 last time before it all ends. I reckon they should incorporate Bonnie into the storyline later on to John Marston's death where she is at his funeral & to her mentoring of young Jack
yourgasm 1 year ago
Really well pieced together video. Bonnie obviously crushed on him. . . but who can't respect his loyalty. John Marston is a lot of things, but unfaithful, he is not.
DarthSeptic 1 year ago 11
@DarthSeptic Thank you! =D But yeah, no way would John ever betray Abigail and that's why we love him. I just think that if Abigail had died before John or if they had never met or something like that, he and Bonnie would be a good match.
maswellasm 1 year ago 7
@maswellasm Thank you making this. I love Bonnie and John together...alot of people say Bonnie is shit and annoying or white trash but I disagree. Shes the only woman in the whole video game who would actually give up marraige life to help her father with the farm! Like she has a little crush on John and John kind of likes her to but both are loyal. Which is why they would never. Sadly.
Rukia91554 6 months ago
i love it. favourited & subcribed (:
ChasingGracex 1 year ago
@ChasingGracex Yay, thank you!
maswellasm 1 year ago
@maswellasm you are very welcome! :3
ChasingGracex 1 year ago
Nice video! So sad. I love them so much, but I love John and Abigail too. Great video. And where is the hug-shot from? I don't remember that from the game, but maybe I'm just stupid.
Ziroana 1 year ago
@Ziroana Thank you! And don't be so hard on yourself, lol. That particular shot is from Undead Nightmare.
maswellasm 1 year ago
Bonnies pants are way cooler than Abigails, obviously making her the right choice.
DinosaurDemon 1 year ago 2
@DinosaurDemon Hmm...given that Abigail wears a dress, I don't know that it's comparable. But I get what you're saying- I would always pick a woman in pants over one in a dress. =D
maswellasm 1 year ago