In general, the 2 are amazing singers! They're individual vocal pipes and personalities give different interpretations to the song - and to the character. :)
Ms. Salonga on the other hand, she has a sweet voice. She's in her mid-30's but she can still sound 16. She has good control of her voice although (as seen in and heard in this video) she overdid the interpretation of the song that's why it sounds a bit forced. Listen to her low notes, that's beyond her vocal range, so it sounds off. Listen to her high notes, she oversung and so it sounded off too (not off-key ok?).
Ruthie Henshall is great and so is Lea Salonga. No need to fight over who owns this song or not. :) Ms. Henshall has as a different tone and quality to her voice. My only comment i guess is that her voice is not so linear. Powerful, yes, definitely, but she can't sustain the tone or timbre of her voice.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I liked susan boyles better then ths person...she's a much better singer, and we can UNDERSTAND her better. even if the wind is blowing or she holds the mic to far form her mouth, we can probably hear susan more then lea,
Oh, please don't compare Lea Salonga to Susan Boyle. Lea is much much better. This video does not do her justice. Watch other videos of her, like when she sang On My Own at the 10th Anniversary Concert of Les Miserables. You can search for that, watch it, then let's see what you think.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I heard and see other Lea Selonga's performance of IDAD,so as others. I say Ruthie Henshall is the best of them all,Ellaine Page & Patti LuPone maybe second then Lea and Hayley Westenra. Judy Kuhn is also good. Saying Lea OWNed this song is STUPID. The first production was in Paris in 1987 then to London then to New York. Lea was only one in a few to performed in it. She is not the best one at it. Fool.
Although Susan brought me here, Lea Salonga has a gret voice. Now Lea is a professional and Susan an amateur, that´s what amaze us of Susan. I also think that Lea is way better than Charice, who will have to wait years to get what Lea already have-
The media bandwagon is seriously blinding too many people.
It's pretty hard to believe how many idiots could claim something as retarded as "Susan Boyle is better than Lea Salonga" or "Lea Salonga is singing this wrongly", the latter being more ridiculous.
I shall ignore the misinformed statement about my country.
I have not typed any more "inane drivel" than you have. You have done the exact same thing to me; Replying to a comment which you disagree with, in a non-friendly manner.
The words "hypocrite" should be flashing in your head now, in reference to yourself.
I'd also like to add that you have not added anything to this discussion, just made a misinformed, hypocritical and well...stupid sentence.
Susan and Lea are both good! Scottish and Philippine accents. It would be interesting to have them both for an interview! Great performers. Heavenly voices!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Susan brought me here. I'm looking for a karoke version to prctice with. Lea you are very good, but you have to master this song and put it in it's place. It's a song that is very beautiful and your voice can control it , but I think your useing anger and not feelings of triumph
dude do you even know who lea salonga is??? She is a tony award winning actress! She played Eponine on freakin' broadway, and was the singing voice of Jasmine in Disney's Aladdin...and the original miss saigon!!! Sorry...Susan Boyle has got NOTHING on lea salonga
The character Fantine isn't triumphant at all. Her life was painful and depressing. Fantine was abandoned and she felt angry and helpless. Lea sang the song accurately.
lea salonga did the best version....
sgtjoe2008 7 months ago
In general, the 2 are amazing singers! They're individual vocal pipes and personalities give different interpretations to the song - and to the character. :)
bluesinger78 2 years ago
Ms. Salonga on the other hand, she has a sweet voice. She's in her mid-30's but she can still sound 16. She has good control of her voice although (as seen in and heard in this video) she overdid the interpretation of the song that's why it sounds a bit forced. Listen to her low notes, that's beyond her vocal range, so it sounds off. Listen to her high notes, she oversung and so it sounded off too (not off-key ok?).
bluesinger78 2 years ago
Ruthie Henshall is great and so is Lea Salonga. No need to fight over who owns this song or not. :) Ms. Henshall has as a different tone and quality to her voice. My only comment i guess is that her voice is not so linear. Powerful, yes, definitely, but she can't sustain the tone or timbre of her voice.
bluesinger78 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I liked susan boyles better then ths person...she's a much better singer, and we can UNDERSTAND her better. even if the wind is blowing or she holds the mic to far form her mouth, we can probably hear susan more then lea,
BlueStreekCan 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ugly Lea! lol
goodpoor1234 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Susan Boyle makes the song I DREAM A DREAM better even if she sang only a few verses, don't you think? Anyone?
I wonder how it would be if she has the time to sang the whole song.
RedNanny50 2 years ago
Oh, please don't compare Lea Salonga to Susan Boyle. Lea is much much better. This video does not do her justice. Watch other videos of her, like when she sang On My Own at the 10th Anniversary Concert of Les Miserables. You can search for that, watch it, then let's see what you think.
jrdagooc 2 years ago 17
Comment removed
juniperbreezesforme 2 years ago
yeah. that was best video I've ever seen..
onyot18 2 years ago
With no disrespect intented to Susan, Lea solonga is a much, much better singer. Check her out on "On my own".
timofmya 2 years ago 9
Lea Solonga OWN's this song. Listen to something that isn't taped from the 10th row of a high school auditorium. You idiot.
timofmya 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I heard and see other Lea Selonga's performance of IDAD,so as others. I say Ruthie Henshall is the best of them all,Ellaine Page & Patti LuPone maybe second then Lea and Hayley Westenra. Judy Kuhn is also good. Saying Lea OWNed this song is STUPID. The first production was in Paris in 1987 then to London then to New York. Lea was only one in a few to performed in it. She is not the best one at it. Fool.
RedNanny50 2 years ago
If you like this, try Neil Diamond's version. Check out the change of lyrics.
Video link posted above.
Meweardesign 2 years ago
Comment removed
Meweardesign 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1 c0ver y0ur m0uth with y0ur hand
2 make a wish int0 it
3 cl0se y0ur hand {make it int0 a fist}
4 h0ld y0ur fist t0 y0ur heart f0r 5 sec.
5 send dis t0 3 m0re vide0s
6 t0m0rr0w will be y0ur best day ever
dzoxxy93 2 years ago
Susan Boyle is nowhere close to lea.
apfanatic 2 years ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Of course, Susan Boyle is far much better!!!
nelsontsjr 2 years ago
Although Susan brought me here, Lea Salonga has a gret voice. Now Lea is a professional and Susan an amateur, that´s what amaze us of Susan. I also think that Lea is way better than Charice, who will have to wait years to get what Lea already have-
Gabyabi 2 years ago
You're a magnificent specimen of a human which has, unfortunately, not evolved from an ape.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago
The media bandwagon is seriously blinding too many people.
It's pretty hard to believe how many idiots could claim something as retarded as "Susan Boyle is better than Lea Salonga" or "Lea Salonga is singing this wrongly", the latter being more ridiculous.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sorry to say...sounds so bad, it's better for her not to sing this song....susan boyle is way way way better....lol
goodpoor1234 2 years ago
Get an ear correction surgery.
Lea Salonga sang this WAY before Susan freaking Boyle.
She's way more skilled, has won more awards, and got there on her own, not through some dumb reality show.
Susan Boyle while talented, is nowhere near Lea Salonga.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You're quite the arrogant, self opinionated little bully, aren't you?
I assume that you are the product of the restricted gene pool that exists in your deeply over cramped Island City State.
It must be very difficult, though, for you to type with those webbed fingers; hence the inane drivel masquerading as intelligent commentary.........
PrivateSchulz 2 years ago
I shall ignore the misinformed statement about my country.
I have not typed any more "inane drivel" than you have. You have done the exact same thing to me; Replying to a comment which you disagree with, in a non-friendly manner.
The words "hypocrite" should be flashing in your head now, in reference to yourself.
I'd also like to add that you have not added anything to this discussion, just made a misinformed, hypocritical and well...stupid sentence.
Have fun.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago 2
wtf?
killhannahlover 2 years ago
Susan and Lea are both good! Scottish and Philippine accents. It would be interesting to have them both for an interview! Great performers. Heavenly voices!
7208ocampo 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Susan brought me here. I'm looking for a karoke version to prctice with. Lea you are very good, but you have to master this song and put it in it's place. It's a song that is very beautiful and your voice can control it , but I think your useing anger and not feelings of triumph
cybervisionstar 2 years ago
dude do you even know who lea salonga is??? She is a tony award winning actress! She played Eponine on freakin' broadway, and was the singing voice of Jasmine in Disney's Aladdin...and the original miss saigon!!! Sorry...Susan Boyle has got NOTHING on lea salonga
h245t 2 years ago 8
and she was also the singing voice of mulan
krnadik 2 years ago 3
The character Fantine isn't triumphant at all. Her life was painful and depressing. Fantine was abandoned and she felt angry and helpless. Lea sang the song accurately.
0jiol 2 years ago 8
Comment removed
kylekchang 2 years ago
the version of lea is greater than susan. the audio seems not clear
cuteasian2007 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Susan brought me here...Lea is great but sorry, Susan's voice is majestic.
xxxxxxkarlaxxxxxx 2 years ago
how dare you> Lea is my idol since i was a kid.
cuteasian2007 2 years ago 3
LEA SALONGA brought me here...she is the best =)
Lecmar91 2 years ago 6
Lea is really the best.
lra094 2 years ago 5
GREAT VOICE, HORRIBLE VIDEO QUALITY.
ryanolaf 2 years ago 3
I'm sorry - this is the best my camera can do. You know, I don't remember anyone saying anywhere that you HAD to sit and watch YouTube!
l30l3nyc 2 years ago
IT'S LIKE WATCHING AN ACCIDENT
ryanolaf 2 years ago
@l30l3nyc but we have the duty of commenting on how terrible the quality is :) jokes
itinkle 1 year ago
Copy and paste if Susan Boyle brought you here
Technobass100 2 years ago
Nice effort for the video 30l3nyc. I wish I had same chance to shoot at Lea. Love her a lot.
fernandosmyng 3 years ago
LEA , YOU SSING THE BEST OF ALL. BRAVO
POLO1396 3 years ago 4
i love broadway. i love i dreamed a dream. i love les mis. and i love LEA! you go girl!
busingkwet 3 years ago 2
Lea is the BEST!!!
Though prefer her playing Eponine than that of Fantine...
pretender963 3 years ago
i loveeeeeeeeee! lea!!!!!
albertbuen 3 years ago 2
I love lea !!!!!!
lucky you!, when is she gona come over london?
nexypointy 3 years ago 2
i love broadway and i love les miserables!
wewewooo 4 years ago 3
I love Lea Salonga!
bridex 4 years ago
Lea is supposed to be my real daughter but the hospital nurse switched her to my current "daughter"
vanessapastor 4 years ago
hahahahahahahaaaa!!!!
ScarBrowGabriel 3 years ago 3
of course i was kidding to cheer you up people. tired of these comments.
vanessapastor 3 years ago
she is my idol....i absoultely love her sooooo much. Every role she's played she has been phenomenal at
broadwaystar2be 4 years ago
her vibrato is so wide and sometimes it overcomes her tone quality
brandonh72 4 years ago
great voice, superb talent
hindangpride 4 years ago
shes great.
leah1santos 4 years ago
LEA SALONGA IS BROADWAY.
mvconnelly 4 years ago 2
can't get enough of this! what an amazing voice! Tnx again for posting!
boyramz2007 4 years ago
well...guess its pretty hard not to ignore him!
boyramz2007 4 years ago
right? I asked him to duck a couple of times...he just gave me the evil-eye!
l30l3nyc 4 years ago