Kanye West "heartless & pinnochio story" live @ gibson amphitheater 12/09/08

[Jaymaul009]

The vh1 storytellers version of this was the most beautiful performance of kanye's that I've ever seen.

[TheAK4722]

"If I never had anything...then i would still have everything.."

meaning if he never became big n still lived in chicago he would still have his mom who was everything...damn thats deep.

[ninerent]

wow this performance was just amazing... kanye is just something else

[tillet123]

eh not his best performance. not much emotion in his voice

[ChuckNorris813]

still come back to this video after 2 nd a half years just love it thanks for posting it

[22EaglesFan]

dumbass crowd..

[PudgyOrange]

the part about his mom was so sad :(

[ChiiKo21]

does anyone have the original video of this performance which goes 10min ???

[Teximexico]

The build-up from 7:50 to the end is unreal. Amazing performance.

[corbettlove12]

Shut up crowd

[trajuan4sho]

I HATE KANYE BUT HE IS REAL TALENT AND THE PERFORMANCE WAS INCREDIBLE...

[warleyvipers]

one of the very few artists i know who if he wants to , can completely shut a crowd up and just get them to admire his lyrics and prescence

[timwdv]

FUCK TAYLOR SWIFT!! SHE CANT PUT OUT THIS TYPE OF CHARACTER AND KARISMA, A REAL ARTIST RECOGNIZES REAL WHAT HE SAID TO HER WAS DESERVING. HOW YOU GONNA HAVE HER COMPETE WITH SOME OF THE GREATEST FEMALE R&B ARTISTS AND WIN. WTF???

SO HEARTLESS SO HEARTLESS  SO HEARTLESSSSSSS

[ExstasyAirlines]

@timwdv nigga i pretty much said that on my old profile...it has 67 thumbs up....

[nana4567891]

Just amazing performance!!

I love Kanye...

[00tuoyo]

Jesus, this is some really sad shit!

[CartmanLandZ]

dude i have so many memories of this song

[crinklecut489]

"he lost his soul to a bitch so heartless!!!!" -the best part of the song, even though his ego is bigger than life is very talented!

[MrSilentdeath69]

That's real talent right there I'd like to se him sing without all his fancy voice enhancers

[KeiVirus]

HOW COULD YOU BE SO GAYFISH~

[lobolouie13]

AGAIN MUCH LOVE TO WOODINI, THIS CONCERT WAS THE SHIT, AND LET EM ALL WHO DIDNT GO HATE ON US THAT DID!!

[DannyBadeaTV]

808's and heart break album was all dedicated to the fact he lost his soul to the devil. wake up!

[wearealljazznoise]

@DannyBadeaTV LOL.

[DannyBadeaTV]

@wearealljazznoise lol got cha! pl dumb as fuck always tryna tlk bout him n the devil.

just apperciate good music and call it a day!

[DjOfOzMoses]

i liked this heartless performance better than the one on the album...

[dulli78]

to all the people hating on kanye using autotune ...go listen to one of the millions of the songs without it you fucking haters

[dude99399]

some of you guys are douche bags because artist have feelings too they have to deal with all the bullshit. And kanye actually is singing what he is feeling and people are dissing him even worst "ohh nigga that aint hood shit" Who gives a fuck not all music is about having fun or having money.

[TheOriginal1200]

"TO A BITCH SO HEARTLESS", was epic.

[iamdaillest24]

this is obviously saying money truly cannot buy you true happiness

[killemdevil]

best performance for heartless. "BABY its me, you must not remember me." that was deep

[MrFudgebunnies]

Douche bag

[tigerturd0001]

Kanye West Ur The Shit Fuck The Haters They Make The World Go Round! :)

[philbanks305]

tigerturd is right, everybody was brownnosing taylor

[philbanks305]

dopest performance i've ever seen, period. <----

[RaulValdovinos]

dang, this song reminds me of senior year in high school, haha, great performance kanye!

[goodgurl1983]

passion

[xXxB33th00v3nxXx]

nice suit

[love33basketball]

i absolutely love him<33

[mtnlogistics]

you could feel his pain in pnnochio story. you know he's talking about his mom and amber rose breaking up with him.

[tigerturd0001]

i still like kanye i dont give a fuck wat he said to taylor swift he was right anyway....everybody was just kissing taylors ass

[October124eva]

str8 like that

[jeterlover03]

@tigerturd0001 I don't think anyone was kissing Taylors ass...And it's not like what he did is the end of the world, it was mean, and trashy, but it's not like he shot her. I think he deserved some of the back lash, but when I watched the VMAs this year and she did that whole Kanye interrupted her montage for her performance...I was thinking OVER KILL....there's nothing wrong with being pissed but man, get the fuck over it....

[ExstasyAirlines]

@jeterlover03 ok? nothing of what you put made sense? i dont care about taylor or what you think he deserved dick head, i was never mad i was glad he interrupted taylor...so in retrospect i have nothing to get over...

btw thats my old account

[domnokes2011]

@tigerturd0001 I wish he would have done that shit to a dude. He would have gotten his ass whipped

[BlinKid182]

been there... it was fucking amazing !

[BLeeDiCe]

hes one of my favorites but he needs to learn to shut up and stop doing stupid stuff its ruining his rep

[eviatarBBB]

kanye is the best

[TJ2029]

OMG this is soo sick

[808heart1]

Ok thx

[808heart1]

I search what us the title of the music ( or lyrics) between heartless and pinocchio story. If you can say me ?!

[crazylikeafox3]

I think his little part between heartless and pinocchio story is ad lib - like he thought it up on the night to connect the two songs together. Hope that helps.

[ChrissDutch]

It's freestyle so you won't find any lyrics or music ;)

[bigboistunnahah]

its on 808s thou

[miamiboy67]

kanye killed this shit!!! one of tha greatest in tha business

[Q8AB]

Did he say "to a bitch so heartless" ?! at 8:11 ?

lol that's funny but emotional... cool

[luffaren91]

I'm new to kanye west..

He's using playback, right? But sings with the playback..?

Sounds really good tbh

[eplc]

It's not playback, no.

[ExstasyAirlines]

@luffaren91 auto tune

[BIGBOI911]

wats up wit all this gay fish shit....

GET OVER THAT SHIT ALREADY...

dat shit got played out the same week it started....

[imsigningin]

ur a gay fish

[BIGBOI911]

no wonder why your so stupid...

your into lacrosse....

i wont judge..

[imsigningin]

do u like fishdicks?

[WESTSIDENLUEZZ]

to a bitch so heartlesss! good video

[YungPenguin]

go kanye whoop ! :D

[Richelle177]

watched this with my son on FUSE ..love the version..he is awesomely talented and i love R&Roll..he is a force so reckon with with it!!

[aek5941]

guys lets be honest kanye west shows up all the other rappers and performers coming out with 4 platinum albums, several multi-platinum, and some people talk about how he has no talent. so i guess they think that are the definition of talent and everyone else has it wrong.....

[Bri11201]

if someone calls kanye a gayfish one more time!!!

[SupaHBac]

shit gets annoyin rite? lol

[Bri11201]

I hate it. people hate on kanye soo hard he is just great

[SupaHBac]

do u liv in new york cuz u most def look like som1 i kno

[evtomoec]

obviously sick, but addictive! new beat in this one made it more catchy than the studio version!

[julesryan12]

AUTO TUNE!!!

[dulli78]

@julesryan12 ...so?

[baigaiz112]

GAAAYAYYYYYYYY FIIISSHHh

[Andreithepala]

he has an amazing voice live

[NessaViiv12]

AMAZING!

[themightiness]

Wow I didn't realize he sucks balls live.

[Swagga113]

5 star ratings seems to disagree

[fashiondork5567]

I just think he was out of breathe so thats probably why he's singing kinda flat and breathless. I love it!!!!!

[fashiondork5567]

I just love Kanye and me and my friends are dancing to one of his songs live tomorrow afternoon. I think we r doing heartless and I love this song. I just wanted to say his live version was not the best but still good! I think he's Amazing so plzz no hate! I really like him and I can't imagine wearing a suit and running around while trying to rap and breathe. So I wanna give him some good credit for that.

[bigg781]

Coldest story ever told.

[ultimatesoul123]

i just love the song heartless

[NYCbrownman1]

NYC sawn

[ganki23]

stop saying stupid things about kayne...remember that he's one of the best rapers alive...he's one of these few rappers who can match music(intrumental) with lyrics..so stop hating

[NYCbrownman1]

yea he is #5 on yahoo music

[Eromulex]

MOTHAFUCKIN GAYFISH!

[Swagga113]

why are you "dissing" him based on events that never happened?

[tupsiesoc]

* K@NY€ TH€ B€ST *

[texsogifted]

One of The Greatest Performers of All time

[miitch23]

you keep the camera really still haha its awesome. any performance, easily the best right now, and always!

[stlMO09]

people just think hes all pop until they see him live. then they see he puts his heart and soul into his music and you have to respect that

[TeamBlowout]

my favorite artist...GO KANYE!!!

[trut00001]

maaaan, this goes deep dawg

[dukeboyrocks]

kanye is the best!!!!!!

[Traybg]

phenomenallll.... hot damn, always with the right words on the right time with the right style and expression. what a performance that is....

[OleBeich]

i realy love kanye!<3 that guy is the best rapper ever in history!

[BreezyGaGa]

FUCK YOUU WHOREEE ,

KANYE IS MY HOMIE HES MY HUSBANDDD

GO FUCK YOURSElF!

[sUiCiD3AZT]

girl you is fuckin crazy

[BreezyGaGa]

ANDD WUTTT?

[musickabuser667]

im a metal head and this is good stuff

[DeucezWild13]

Kanye is so awesome but he's still a gay fish. jk lmfao

[woodini6969]

hahahah shit was great!!! lol

[gameova38]

@DeucezWild13 choke a south park writer with a fish stick

[MarkoDilber]

the song pinnochio story does something to me wow

love kanye's work

[HazemElCobain]

hes a fucking god

[1Akz1]

Alow the beef!

[tubzuk]

kanye is all about the live performances, he puts more into than any other artist, although at the end of the day, its all about the money, you really feel its genuinley for the fans with this guy, i was at a concert in manchester, the band didnt play as he liked, so he stopped and started again, shit was crazzzzyy! kanye's a beast!

[BassT2k7]

so true!

[r0cker6]

how could you be so heartless ? bitch !

[eshawty11]

man hes got emotion

[riv619]

i was at this show in LA. Kanye has really developed as a live performer. He had the whole entire audience in space with him. He had live vocalist, full band, african drummers, and a string section. It was Amazing as the song says.

[wildrnesxperienc]

This guy is a real talent. As a poet really. Very powerful stuff. Pinocchio's Story really speaks to me.

[iheartamber]

8:12 my fav part.

Kanye: "to a bitch so heartless"

Some guy: "yeaaaaaaaaaaaa"

[jaxmariafan]

that random guy made me laugh

[aj33zy]

he sounded like an animal from the wild hahaha it was more like yeaenhhhhhh

[ZweiSchwestern]

ahah

[skyline462]

WOW....just amazing ... the lights, the ending nice...

[amercia13]

damn he knows how to make sick ass conccerts

[coolshig]

fuck i love the lights and stuff

my god

i wish i could have seen this live!!! :(

[aj33zy]

i cant wait to see him live

[omgguleh]

did anyone else notice the mistake when he's talking about the apartment.. me and my momma would still be in that apartment, 3 apart- 3 stories so highhh

[wizeman77]

Hey omgguleh, He's human, like you & me. And yes, we noticed... Kanye did his thing...

[aj33zy]

no he doesnt he says me and my momma would still be in that apartment, 3 apartments 3 stories so high. 3=3

[spikss90]

this was my first best concerttt ever!!!!!

i was soo hyped!!!!!!

[Freduce88]

The lights is insane andthe two songs combined is freakin awesome man....Kanye is one of the best song writters of our time and performer too...he knows how to hype the crowd and how to be real and connect wit them....great performance...the overal show looks amazing

[junioraci]

THE GOD

[shemale98]

great footage, great lights, but there is way too much recorded music in the back. it takes away the fact its live

[wizeman77]

Killer Footage! The Best I seen in a minute from a spectatar!

[snowddoogg]

i dont like this type of music but thank god there is a song for us men that have had our heart broken before by a woman  or should say BITCHES SO HEARTLESSSSSSSS

[RealAssyrianBeauty]

yehh u noticed that too? poor guy.. i feel bad for him :[

[lawreelove]

He didn't change because his mom died, he changed cuz a BITCH broke his heart. I feel his pain, love can be a bitch. MUCH LOVE TO KANYEEEZZZYY!!!

[melo778]

sweeeeeetttttt

[RobCash76]

Lost his soul to A BITCH SO HEARTLESS. I got goosebumps from that.

[DeucezWild13]

kanye west is the shit

[yunnsanco59]

awesome shit....

ITS ME

[yaboy2raw]

tjfunny u some shit he doesnt sound like this that the person recording it

[joeswanson]

kanye is the man!! he is one of if not the best performers ever!!

[geethelad]

this shit is epiiiic

[director212]

Kanyes got the sickest stage show ever loved Glow In The Dark Tour shit was epic!

[yunnsanco59]

man i gottta download this

[thisisshaz]

kanyeeeee is ILL. props on this footage.

i saw him back in May for the glow in the

dark tour, shit was ill...

his set is always live.

[joeljjfox]

"...to a BITCH so HEARTLESS!!!!!!" hahaha i love it.

In my opinion, Kanye's best concert ever.

[gunitballa87]

kanye has so much passion in his performances. i was at this show and this was my 1st kanye show. i came out a bigger fan than i already was of his work. he has the catalog and performance skills to be one of the best performers in hip hop history

[revit]

video is mad good quality...i wish kanye starts rappin again tho

[aznboy15dn]

wat a good song :)

[mariosimon524]

if i was back in the chi me and my mom would still be in that apartment 3 stories so high if it was all a dream and i never got anything and that i would still have everything..............amazin­g

[ReemQueen]

So much emotion in his songs. It's amazing. And yeah, he might not be the worlds greatest singer, but hell, he's got passion.

[mrikenna]

dis shit baught tear to my eyes {wat does it feel like } i juss wanna b a real boy...cauz kanye he keeps it real boy

[SkillZamatic]

BITCH SO HEARTLESS!

[brian2553]

"You're Memory Must Be Failing You..I Don't Know What Your Friends Are Telling You"

This should be a song itself.

[brian2553]

baby...IT'S ME!!!

[Kidprodigy07]

tru shit bro, that part sounded like a dope as hook

[sickwidit311]

the end made me sad :(

[sickwidit311]

the lighting and screens in kanyes performances are so freakin awesome

[dude99399]

awesome kanye but plz go back to rapping

[Natureman1101]

i would let him have sex with me

[jjdmi11]

lmaoo wow

[eddyALLSTAR]

Stop fuckin hatin on him haters cuz this is music to my ears!!!

KANYE IS DA BEST FUC DA REST!!!

[tonkykong]

kanye is the motha fuckin man!!!

[YeeZyKaws]

Wtf are you talking about he dont lip sync u ass!

Btw 10/10 this performance was awsome!!!!

[MJBinc]

lol ya, actually if u go as far sayin he's lip syncing thats practicully a compliment since hes not

[YeiTomohisa]

where can i download mp3s of all his performances here???

[ThatCoolGuy1990]

He need to play the superbowl foreal, the only good half time show in the last 8 years was probaly when U2 played and when Prince played

[bluegum1]

Excellent video quality. Probably better than the AMA or SNL appearances. Thanks. Kanye's talent is unmatched right now, but a singer he is not.

[dmavs4131]

bitch u really dont know shit so shut the fuck up