I do love this, I have a question though. You keep the gendered pronouns in regards to Jim, so this leads to two conclusions. Either Jim is a transguy who hasn't transitioned yet in which case, not a girl despite looks. Or Jim is a transgirl and Pike is being an utter asshat by using the wrong pronouns. So, ummm... I get that you're just using the original script but if you're familiar with trans issues this is what comes to mind. For me at least.
After watching this, anyone else think Ashleigh Harrington would be a perfect choice to play a younger Carol Marcus if that character was brought in to one of the sequels?
OK lets talk constructive critique. (Keyword Constructive) - Kirk, makeup makes you look like you just got in a fight, but you don't act like it. Your facials should be causing you to wince in pain just a tad. You are more comfortable in front of the camera than Pike, but still the dialog is too methodical and sounds stage acted. Remember ladies you are not on stage so you do not have to over act it. Be more subtle and natural as the camera catches everything.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
OK lets talk constructive critique. (Keyword Constructive) Pike - you are not talking naturally and are focusing too hard on the consonants, indicating that you aren't as comfortable in front of the camera as you need to be. It hurts believability. Your voice stays a little too uptight, another sign of being nervous.
I saw this on Night of the Living Trekkie's facebook page... o.o I was like maybe it's ZOMZBIES.. but I was like this is the most interesting thing I've ever seen... o.o I like it
I want this movie to be real SO BADLY. This entire idea is one of the greatest that I have ever heard of. What other films are you going to do? I can tell you, I would give vast amounts of money to see a scene or two from Inception re-done like this.
That was really cool! I liked the idea of this and Pike was awesome. Kirk had all the looks and litlte motions from Pine in the movie down so well. I wish I could see the whole movie genderswapped!
As a thespian and a feminist (and, of course, a trekkie), I love this concept. This particular scene felt a little flat, but I'll definitely be following you guys with high hopes.
Wait! Just out of curiosity, since the male Kirk was a womanizer in the Alternate-Prime Universe, is female Kirk a manhunter in this universe? If so SIGN ME UP!!
That was hot
InuManiac906 2 months ago
I finally watched one! Great job Ash and Kat!
isaokish 2 months ago
Best Kirk ever.
FemSpock. Now!
But seriously, doing marathons on this channel now. This is brilliant. Totally explores the differences between genders for characters onscreen.
SirThomaline 3 months ago 2
Great work Cheese.
djdannyray 4 months ago
I do love this, I have a question though. You keep the gendered pronouns in regards to Jim, so this leads to two conclusions. Either Jim is a transguy who hasn't transitioned yet in which case, not a girl despite looks. Or Jim is a transgirl and Pike is being an utter asshat by using the wrong pronouns. So, ummm... I get that you're just using the original script but if you're familiar with trans issues this is what comes to mind. For me at least.
Other than that, love it a lot.
NethDugan 4 months ago 3
I love how much this looks like the real movie
spaceman7474 4 months ago 2
This is incredible, Im blown away at the quality you can find on youtube these days
pizzalove15 5 months ago
these womans are such good actors like i was really enjoying this lol :)
AMCMovieQuest 6 months ago 2
This looks like it was directed by George Lucas.
devourerofbabies 7 months ago
After watching this, anyone else think Ashleigh Harrington would be a perfect choice to play a younger Carol Marcus if that character was brought in to one of the sequels?
MrDavidHarrison 8 months ago 3
This is so many levels of awesome, it it's amazing! I'm saving this to be burned onto DVD later. More, ladies, more!
Neville6000 10 months ago 3
OK lets talk constructive critique. (Keyword Constructive) - Kirk, makeup makes you look like you just got in a fight, but you don't act like it. Your facials should be causing you to wince in pain just a tad. You are more comfortable in front of the camera than Pike, but still the dialog is too methodical and sounds stage acted. Remember ladies you are not on stage so you do not have to over act it. Be more subtle and natural as the camera catches everything.
TalkerOne 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OK lets talk constructive critique. (Keyword Constructive) Pike - you are not talking naturally and are focusing too hard on the consonants, indicating that you aren't as comfortable in front of the camera as you need to be. It hurts believability. Your voice stays a little too uptight, another sign of being nervous.
TalkerOne 11 months ago
I wonder what girl!Spock would look like
DelawareOtaku 11 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@DelawareOtaku h t t p : / / w w w.buzzfeed.com/ashleytalong/star-trek-cosplay-hpz
devourerofbabies 7 months ago
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!!! MORE I BEG OF YOU MORE!!!!
lionmml 1 year ago 3
I saw this on Night of the Living Trekkie's facebook page... o.o I was like maybe it's ZOMZBIES.. but I was like this is the most interesting thing I've ever seen... o.o I like it
Leylaashley 1 year ago
Someone posted on facebook so I figured I'd look and it would be a parody. I was wrong but pleasantly pleased by this. Very well done!
echovoice 1 year ago
Fascinating. Subscribe.
Jordacar 1 year ago
Really well done. :)
Hakka84 1 year ago
Why isn't there more? WHY ISN'T THERE MORE??
SpooketteUndead 1 year ago 2
ONTD_Startrek agrees: You guys need to do the rest of the movie. We demand Girl!Bones and Girl!Spock like, yesterday.
wasslara 1 year ago 6
GIRL SPOCK SCENE IS NEEDED NOW.
Krizerd 1 year ago 10
I want this movie to be real SO BADLY. This entire idea is one of the greatest that I have ever heard of. What other films are you going to do? I can tell you, I would give vast amounts of money to see a scene or two from Inception re-done like this.
QueenOfDreaming 1 year ago 35
@QueenOfDreaming I must, I must, I must AGREE!!!! And if I were a billionaire, I would be funding the whole thing. :)
lionmml 1 year ago 4
That was really cool! I liked the idea of this and Pike was awesome. Kirk had all the looks and litlte motions from Pine in the movie down so well. I wish I could see the whole movie genderswapped!
BeccaDu 1 year ago 4
Makeup was great. So was everything else but I'm a makeup nerd. This looks like such a fun project.
evilcritter 1 year ago
As a thespian and a feminist (and, of course, a trekkie), I love this concept. This particular scene felt a little flat, but I'll definitely be following you guys with high hopes.
SinisterlySweet 1 year ago 9
The Salt Shaker at the end was out of this world!!!
keepitinthefamily 1 year ago 3
Good idea, but the acting wasn't all that wonderful.
BetterThanAThesis 1 year ago
Great work gals!
Glad to see Fringe's Agent Dawson making an appearance! Bring her back on the show please - there's a void of Charlie Francis.
Talenthief 1 year ago
Impressive performances... I'd have gone with a noun change or two but, nice. =D ~noirgwio
TheKaleidoscopian 1 year ago
The Actress playing Captain Pike was also in Fringe on Fox as agent Dawson....She's awesome!
NatalieCatania 1 year ago
I liked it, except for not changing "son" to "daughter", that moment was a bit 0_o
MrDavidHarrison 1 year ago
JT Kirk never looked so beautiful! Great actress, what else does she perform in?
mratoz 1 year ago 16
Wait! Just out of curiosity, since the male Kirk was a womanizer in the Alternate-Prime Universe, is female Kirk a manhunter in this universe? If so SIGN ME UP!!
tannerwaterbury 1 year ago 3
why?
thomasthetonkengine 1 year ago
Great job. Really enjoyed it!
athompson7 1 year ago 2
Great makeup job on girl-kirk. It looked real.
Unlisshed 1 year ago
What exactly is the point of this?
Frontigenics 1 year ago
@Frontigenics Fun.
athompson7 1 year ago
It was okayyy.... just needed more shaky cam and LENS FLARES!!! MORE LENS FLARES!!!! LENS FLARES THAT CAN BURN YOUR FUCKING RETINAS OUT!!!!!!
tannerwaterbury 1 year ago
Comment removed
darkknight95370 1 year ago
Weird watching this.
treksf 1 year ago
awesome work - i was thinking of doing something like this last year! keep 'em coming!
thejennascott 1 year ago
Brilliant
SocialPaintball 1 year ago
Fantastic!!!
bdddrap 1 year ago
Oooh! it looks so great guys!! Well done!
spil0003 1 year ago
Love this - Well done.
aurora197c 1 year ago
I love this!
It was an honor to be able to work with some amazing material and actors! I hope we did the scene justice JJ ;)
hammondcheezefilms 1 year ago