Added: 2 years ago
From: CBS
Views: 133,323
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,476)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Candice shouldnt have been there!!!!

  • Replace Coach, Randy, Tyson with Rob C, Hatch, and Fairplay and there ya go!

  • @CCrossfan except Hatch was under house arrest and Fairplay is banned from Survivor; good choices none the less :)

  • @CCrossfan well Fairplay quit and Hatch I think was still in jail so...

  • @yaxerblax You don't do a Heroes vs Villains season without Hatch I'm sorry. You wait until he can play and you get him on there. Fairplay is rumored to be on S25, no reason why he couldn't have been brought back for a season like this

  • Parvati is so fucking hot

  • Jt, wanna marry me?

  • Am I the only one who thinks Jeff Probst is hot for a 40 something year old? Hell, just hot in general?

  • instead of james, rupert it should have been matty (gabon) and erik (fans vs favs) and instead of tyson coach and randy (useless villains!) it should have been todd (china) johanthin ( cook islands) and shane (panama)

  • "Let's see what happens if Tyson can get in an alliance that doesn't betray him."

    What about if Tyson finds a way to betray himself????

  • Heroes: 1. Ozzy 2. Yul 3. Amanda 4. Tom .W 5. Colby 6. Stephenie 7. Cirie 8. JT 9. Rupert Villains: 1. Boston Rob 2. Russell Hantz 3. Parvati 4. Richard Hatch 5. Jerri 6. Jean Robert 7. Jonathon Penner 8. Candice 9. Rob Cesternino
  • Alicia should of been here!

  • Damn I wish Matty from Gabon was there

  • @MrJJsmithy true that matty was much more deserving then players like james and rupert

  • BEST SHOW IN THE WORLD

  • @MrJJsmithy

    really?>

  • I think that Rob from Amazon, Jonny Fairplay from Pearl Islands, Elizabeth from Australia, Colleen from Borneo, Corinne from Gabon, Yau-Man from Fiji, Todd from China and Chris from Vanuatu should have came back.

  • @ChookaaFindlebean Fairplay already returned and quit so we will never see him again unless theres gonna be a Survivor Quitters.

  • having a redemption island on this season would of been interesting, i know it cant of happened cause it only first came into action in season 22, but some of the potential matchups would of been very fun to watch, eg tom vs cirie, rob vs tyson, candice vs amanda, j.t vs coach

  • AND GOD DAM Parvati is such a POSER like DAYUMMMMM !

  • No matter what if russel ever plays again and gets to the end he will never win, because of the way he plays, he plays to come final 3 but he dose not play to win, because if he did he would work on his social skills better to get more votes,

  • Where`s Rob C from Amazon

  • @belarusboy100 I wondered the smae thing since Jeff called him the smartest person to neve win Survivor.

  • I would have loved to see Fairplay back. I didn't even think his departure in Micronesia was that bad. It's not like he left because he couldn't handle it, he left because he had a family to raise. Granted, he shouldn't have gone on the show, but it's kind of like Jenna leaving on All-Stars... how can you blame them?

  • I WANNA FUK AMANDA...I BET SHE LOVES BIG BLACK COCK!!! sub me

  • Course im not happy you forgot the best player of all time Ozzy ;)

  • @luzenzo311 He turned them down on Heroes vs Villians actually, at least that's what I heard when this season started.

  • why does parvati and danielle look like they were filming for a porn movie in the entrance shot??? the expression on their faces... ew. I mean, amanda and courtney were skimpy too but they looked good 

  • @micheliewht I don't know about Dnille but Parvati is a whore. She shouldnt have won. She uses looks (as she isn't even that sexy), and that's it.

  • @ChookaaFindlebean And since she knows how to use that to get far in the game, she does deserve it. Everybody who knows how to gain an advantage out of something deserves to tribute from that.

  • I never understood why Sandra and Danielle but they were repalcements for Corinne and Jenna.Danielle repalce Corinne and Sandra repalce Jenna.I understand why they have Sandra repalcement for Jenna as both past winners.But Danielle has got nothing in comomon with Corinne.

  • This was my least favourite season of all. People were really different, good people went out early, boring people made it far. Just not enjoyable all round.

  • they must bring Yul Kwon and Shane Powers back for the next all stars

  • In what way was Sandra a quiet villain??

  • Parvati <3

  • They should bought back Eliza for Villians as was Jerri number 2 and too see if she whould get revage on her emmy

  • Why wasn't Johnny Fairplay on the Villains team?

  • @ReliableMyke after what he has done on fans vs favorits he will never be back to survivor... they hate him so much

  • @ReliableMyke Probst considered Fairplay "no longer a villain, just a quitter," after Micronesia.

  • @idolhollywoodhopeful Plus Probst hates him. And what Probst doesn't want, Probst doesn't get. Redemption Island, for example - he wanted Rob to win, so he made it so he could win.

  • @CyanideNightmair Don't forget that some people didn't have the time to go on.

  • this season was good.But it was just stupid game play

  • Probst rules

  • They should get Fairplay back.

  • @emcee2456 Probst and the producers hate Fairplay, so it's very unlikely that he'll ever be back. If I had my way though he'd definately have been in my male villains along with Hatch (as long as he wasn't in prison), Boston Rob, Russell and Coach. The problem is that there are so many male villains that would miss out, as I'd love to see the likes of Brian, Rob Cesternino, Shane and Judd play again as well.

  • Fuck i hate sandra

  • @imissspongebob

    why?.okay i agree its shame other players were such dumbbuts but at end of day she did play.I agree it whould been for third time like Colby Jerri Amanda Cirie to win

  • @Homeandawayguy No i hate her because she has never won a individual immunity. Her whole game plane mainly the season was vote our russel and she still couldnt of done that. like cmon. and she looks like a fat ugly troll

  • @imissspongebob explain how she looks like a troll?

    and your mad cuz she never won an invidual challenge?

    loololol

    you don't have to win challenges u know, have a social game and you could easily win (sandra)

    sandra is entertaining and glad she won two times AHAHA

    problems? then go suck ur sad porn u lonely virgin ~

  • @ownedzaros cause shes fat and ugly. why are you calling me a virgin, because i said she looks ugly?.... you obviously just type pure shit into your keyboard. i am open to my onpion. and its a high fact that most people who call people virgins are ones. i think this is that situation.

  • @imissspongebob do you even know how a troll looks like?

    fat and ugly? > not a troll.

  • i can't believe that parvati and russel controlled the whole game and neither of them won

  • i hate that cirie never gets credit for the micronesia alliance...

  • @thatkidevan because she didnt make the alliance Parvati brought over nat and alexis and the two of them were loyal to Parv and cirie and amanda were loyal to Parv

  • most intersing thing about all star season it says talk about forever.

  • if I were to choose who the heroes and villains are.. these people will be it.

    heroes: Stephanie, Candice, Sierra, Amanda, Sierra, Tom, Ian, Colby, J.T. and Rupert (well because he's super popular) but I'd rather see Terry... or maybe Savage from Pearl Islands (pretty crazy right?)

    for the villains

    Corinne, Jerri, Natalie, Parvati, Jenna maybe? (don't really know if she was a villain or not xD), Russell, Boston Rob, Coach, Shane and Todd.. maybe?

    yeah, I know I'm crazy! ;-)

  • @10respect

    You put Sierra twice LOL.YES JENNA IS VILLIAN

  • @Homeandawayguy oh yeah I did!! damn.. ELIZABETH FROM OUTBACK!! she would have been awesome to see once again

  • @10respect Instead of Todd, I would have replaced him with Jean Robert from China. He was a real jerk

  • @DallasSanDiego yeah? didnt really mind jean robert, all I know about that guy is him always getting a vote everytime he goes to tribal council. lol

  • It is good that Candice accepted this offer (she declined an offer to participate on Fans VS Faves because of medical school) . Heaps of people say she doesn't deserve to return, but she had guts to be the first person to mutiny.

    Same with Danielle, people say she isn't villain enough. After what she did to Terry and Courtney in Exile Island she totally deserves the spot.

    A little sad to see Amanda back though. Awesome player, but was just a little bit too forgettable.

  • Corrine was pursued [heavily] but did not want to quit her job again.

    Richard Hatch was invited but was under house arrest.

    Yau-Man was invited but had work obligations.

    Shane Powers made the cut but with Russell's emergence, was kicked out.

    Yul was considered but producers felt he didn't stand out enough.

    Ozzy was considered but the producers felt people had enough of him.

    Brian Heidik was considered but thought to be too repulsive.

    Right from Probst's mouth.

  • @DiamondUD

    Wasit Natalie Bolton and Twila asked but cut becouse of Sandra and Parvati?.

  • Cirie shold Won! our at least survived more longer in the game, she didn't have a chance because she is such a threat for a lot of people specialy the more stronger types, BRING CIRIE BACK FOR ANOTHER SEASON!!!

  • @glam144 agree!

  • Candice<3333333333333333

  • Amanda is hot.

  • @emcee2456 'How dare you talk about my future wife like that! ahaha

  • i would have liked to have seen ozzy or terry in this season and gotten rid of candice and danielle.

  • Say what you want about who should and shouldn't have been there, but this case made for one hell of a good season.

  • @Piecesof8

    Cast was okay but they all played stupid game they let Sandra win twice and dont get me worng i love Sandra but i wanted someone who hasit won like Amanda Danielle Colby Cirie Jerri Rob.

  • @Homeandawayguy

    There was definitely a LOT of stupid play this season. Everyone falling for Russell's tactics. Tyson's boneheaded move doing in Rob's entire alliance. JT's note. For a cast of all-stars, most of them played poorly. It just made for really entertaining TV, I think.

  • courtney shouldn't've been here in the first place and cirie should never have been on two let alone 3. shane was a lot better than cirie dammit I HATE her

  • LOL Russell and Parvati-the troll and the siren. 

  • If they had Corinne and Natalie on Villians with Jerri Corutney Parvati it been enterment gold.

  • Fantastic choices all together, with the exception of Amanda, who is plain dumb and does not deserve to be there...also Fairplay and Hatch should be here as well...this is the only thing I would change, the rest 19 players are brilliant!

  • ozzys a great player but he doesnt have hero/villain qualities, he has both so i think that would be hard to place him on one of the tribes.

  • todd from china should've been in this season

  • best season.

    really needed greg buis and hatch though.

  • That's really funny that they didn't even plan the whole heroes vs villains thing until they had them all together.

  • If everyone was available to be cast in HvV the tribes should have been: Villains: Boston Rob Russell Hatch (Replacing Randy) Coach Johnny Fairplay (Replacing Tyson) Jerri Parvati Courtney Corinne (Replacing DDL) Ami (Replacing Sandra) Heroes: Rupert Colby Tom JT Yau Man (Replacing James, James was overexposed by the time of HvV) Cirie Stephenie Sugar Sandra (Replacing Candice, Sandra suited the Heroes tribe) Kathy (Replacing Amanda, Amanda didn't suit the HvV format plus was overexposed)
  • Russell maybe not the best player in Survivor, but come on i loose my 50% interest in a season of survivor if it`s not Russell

  • Can he win? NO.

    Wow, LOL that was hilarious.

  • Interesting piece on facebook: Search "Survivor: Russell vs. Rob"

  • I'm surprised Ozzy from Cook Islands isn't in this season.

  • Candice should be on the Villains, Courtney shouldnt be here, so Ozzy gets a spot on the Heroes :)

  • @Survivor4Star

    How about Ozzy instead JT.

  • @Homeandawayguy no, JT is the man, i like Ozzy but not instead of JT

  • Definitely ozzy should be there

  • ozzie should have been there

  • Can someone please if Eliza was asked to appear or was condering?.

  • Coach rox!

    Everyone said they hated him and when he got voted off in Tocantins everyone cried and didn't care anymore about the season.

  • WHY WASNT OZZY THERE??

  • @sdimock1 because they couldn't have to many people from F vs F and James was more popular

  • WHY WASNT OZZY THERE??

  • Shame that Ozzy wasn't there :( I'M SO SAD :(

  • @Sillikoni Ozzie was pretty much a villain...he was such a douchebag that he was a villain lol

  • @SaveTheBestForU

    If Ozzy villian then iam Russhell Hartz.

  • @Homeandawayguy *Russell Hantz. Ozzy was SOOO cocky. He was so unbearable. Thinking he was so above and beyond everyone else.

  • @Sillikoni

    well hes on season now

  • Too bad Tyson was out so fast. I didn't get why Amanda was back. She to me was the least interesting player for me. Even though she made it to the finals twice, i still didn't remember her name. Fairplay, Ian and Hatch were missing.

  • @sabje30 hatch wasnt let out of jail he was approached but judge said no

  • Heroes Aras Colby Ozzy James Rupert Big Tom Christy Danielle Amanda Cirie Stephaine Sandra Villians Rob Shane Coach Russhell Tyson Randy Jerri Parvati Corinne Natalie Courtney Twila
  • my cast whould be if incudling winners. I whould make cast bigger and have 22 castaways.Becouse that way we chould see more past favourites and ones we hate

  • LOVE YOU MAN!!!

  • how the hell was yau-man and ozzie not in this....

  • @TheLangification yau-man declined due to work obligations, i heard that ozzy was asked back but declined because he and amanda had broken up but that might just be a rumor

  • The changes I would have made for HvV (if everyone was allowed to compete of course):

    Hatch replacing Randy

    Fairplay replacing Tyson

    Ami replacing Sandra

    Corinne replacing DDL

    Yau Man replacing James (I was tired of James by HvV)

    Sandra replacing Amanda (Amanda was a stale character by now plus Sandra was more of a hero)

    Kathy V replacing Candice

  • They should rename this season in Heroes vs King Russell

  • courtney, coach and sandra didn't really belong on the villains. courtney wasn't a hero either, so i don't think she really belonged in this all-star season. she basically did crap-all in china and just rode todd's coattails. as with coach, yeah he was probably the most disliked survivor of all time but he was more of delusional than villainous (plus he believed in playing the game with "honour"). sandra was more of a hero in pearl islands, aligning with rupert and standing up for him.

  • I think they should do a Big brother on survivor & visa versa. imagine Evil Dick & Dr. Will on survivor & Parvati & Russel on big brother

  • i dont understand why ozzy isnt casted in this season. i'd love to see more of ozzy & amanda's romance. cirie doesnt deserve to be on heroes tribe, she was one of the biggest villains at micronesia.

  • @LittleMissyJJ

    I know he should of been there instead of JT and Christy should of been there instead of Candice

  • i hope russell is on every season from now on. other wise the show sucks lol

  • @CanadianLPer i know! because now nobodys ever gonna live up to his awesomeness.

  • 3:20 Epic Jeff xD

  • i think ian should been in this sesion

  • @Dunken458

    m2 should been there instead of JT and Christy should been there instead of Sugar and Danielle should been on Heroes instead of Candice and Alicia should been there in Villians in Danielle spot.

  • @Dunken458 yeah as a heroe

  • @Dunken458 I completely agree

  • @Dunken458 ian is not a villian, he left the game, to his friend... -.-

  • still dont understand why ozzy wasnt picked for this season :(

  • Johnny Fairplay should have been on

  • @MyTalbert he quit; theyre never bringing him back again

  • @gg9kentucky yeah but i wasnt sure because he didn't quit he just told people to vote him out so i want sure if that counted as a quit

  • @MyTalbert

    not after he quit in fans vs favorites

  • @tanan18 i know but i didnt know it asking people to vote for you counted as a quit

  • I think Christy should been in this!.

  • russel is soo overrated, his season wasnt aired in that time, so nobody on this season didnt knew how sneaky he is, it was only reason he stayed in game so long...

  • @TestY0urMight ....wtf, he is the best player in survivor, he could play survivor 100 times and he'll make it to the final 3 every time, the crew actually told them that he is one of the best villans. Besides, he's on the villains, if they didn't use their brains and just assume that he's a threat then they shouldn't win.

  • @TestY0urMight

    It helped yes, but he was in the minority alliance and STILL owned Boston Robs ass and his alliance. He stayed in because plain and simply, he was one of the best strategic players ever (but one of the worst social players)

  • Boom jeff, there goes your money on rob. plz hand it back to me, this time, im with russel.

  • @Damienalixsouhabi boom, and there goes your money on crybaby russel :-D

  • hm I wonder who did they replace Yau-Man with...since Yau-Man was confirmed as asked. Must've been either JT or Tom...since they're too similar to each other

  • He said Russell was the biggest villain, wait to have me on the show... he comes nowhere near :)

  • I really HATE JT!!

  • 0:01

  • jeffs reason why candice is on the heroes tribe makes no sense, just admit the only reason you have her on is cause shes hot, same can be said for danielle and probably amanda for that matter, and cirie was the exact oppoiste of a hero in micronesia, had arguments with everyone and was a bitch, so glad she went off early this season

  • @gregmacfd3

    How was she bitch?.Amamda and Danielle got asked back becouse they are storng women

  • @gregmacfd3

    I read somewhere that Candice was originally going to be on the Villians and Sandra was going on the Heroes tribe, but they switched it because they though Sandra would be more interesting on the Villians. I'm sorry, but if you mutany on your tribe, that makes you a villian.

  • I really loved this season. I feel that asside from Richard Hatch, Sue Hawke should have been there. When they cast people like danielle and dont even show her

  • Eliza should be on here!!

  • @hyta100

    Yeah she whould been cool to have her on villians tribe with Courtney and Jerri and her rivaly with Parv chould countine.

  • I wanted Erik from Micronesia season to join this season. He was hilarious! :D One of my favorite survivors. Also, I'd rather see Ken from Gabon on the villain's tribe than Randy.

  • i want nigahiga on survivor..!!!!! or smosh!!

  • @yihanglee they whould die in a day

  • Natalie (Micronesia) and Brett (Samoa) Should have been on here too :D 

  • @tryjonysia I think they didnt include Brett because remember that noone knew how Russell played and if they had put Brett on he would tell everyone. This way is much funner :D

  • Comment removed

  • survivor heroes vs. villains would have been the best season ever if it was for all the douchebags who spoiled it for the fans (including myself) who didn't wanted to know the boot list, thanks a lot

  • @MrEmpoleon2010 i know exactly, espicially that survivorfan1234 dumbass

  • Jerri was nice in this lol.

    Russell was still a badass lol.

  • Well, I'm glad Jeff explained why some people were on certain tribes and not the other one but again, those are just opinions as are mine. I think Candice should be considered a villain for mutiny. I don't really consider Sandra a villain, she just did what she had to do to win and she won. She was also always loyal to Rupert. Yes, Danielle did vote out Terry but she had an alliance with Aras that started way before she alligned with Terry. I'm not sayin she's a hero but not a villain for that.

  • Comment removed

  • Can anyone answer this question? Why was Ethan Zohn not reinvited? or was he? He was one of the most top notch hero EVER. Did he decline or something?

  • @DanielsKDJ He's recovering from cancer.

  • COURTNEY IS THE BEST! :D

  • lol, did Stephenie just roll that football? Wtf

  • @PumaOPumaOPumaO

    its a coconut lol

  • Comment removed

  • i never liked JT.... :P

  • Tyson betrayed himself lol.

  • why does everyone hate candice. She's hot. Nuff said

  • @eefbeef09 Looks aren't everything. She is hot though xD

  • That heroes tribe was a joke, James is an idiot and Rupert is ridiculous. Stephenie being a hero is based solely on Palau, when on Guatemala, she was a miserable bitch. and oh, I didn't forget, but there aren't enough youtube comment characters for me to even begin to write what I want to say about Candice.

  • Uhh, Jeff... Penner mutinied with Candace. But anyway...

  • @TheGoblinChicken Yeah I htink Penner should have been on Heroes instead of Candice.

  • survivor nicaragua final 3:

    SASH, BRENDA, NAYONKA

  • @mwade6 Lol @ posting wrong spoilers

  • sandra the winner..parvati should'ved be the winner bcs she was with russell in aliance all the time and she outsmarted him too!!!!!!!!

  • jeff probst is such a good MC :O

  • GO RUSSELL! :)

    //mmacritic

  • shouldve gotten rid of randy, tyson and candice alll of them had no personalities and played crappy games both times. We couldve had peh-gee, dreamz, rob c, brian, shane, kelly w and plenty of others more deserving

  • @whale144 I agree...especially Peih-Gee not getting invited back wtf? I think it's only because Jeff doesn't like her...she's more of a hero than Candice/Sugar/Amanda

  • @whale144 Lol did you say Tyson has no personality? Go look up Survivor Tocantins Best of Tyson. This guy is freaking hilarious. I wish he had lasted longer, he got no edits this season. Him and Courtney make the one liners of Survivor

  • @TOshow1 i find him to be half of courtney