Thank you from me and my neighbors that can sometimes be excused for not loving my rock'n'roll, but who couldn't love this beautiful and totally enrapturing performance. G.B. to all who find it easier to breath having heard this...and better times to those others of us who are still not at ease. There will be rock'n'roll probably, later:) <3
If I am, conservative and I locate myself in the exigency of preferring the original composition, it would comment: " Bach this one furious!. But a reality is that already it is something of the modernity from not so past, not to be so conservative and to present to the audience of the current world contemporary harmony, for this way calling it with education, adapted to his tiny appreciative musical capacity. Being honest, they transmit feeling only one is agreeably.
Why did they sing the Sheets of the Violins? If the singers all would sing the lyrics, the piece would be a little bit better. I prefer a traditional Version.
Sweet and sickening. I hate to be vulgar but I might get through it if they removed their clothes. Rediculous trying to sell Bach with feminine charms.
Sorry but I think it's terrible. The voices are not good enough nor adapt to sing Bach. The arrangement is painful. Please let Bach alone and don't try to earn on him and meke it commercial thank
Sorry but I think it's terrible. The voices are not good enough nor adapt to sing Bach. The arrangement is painful. Please let Bach alone and don't try to earn on him and meke it commercial thank you
I agree. My reason for disliking this is that the key changes are downright korny. What Bach wrote was a flowing accompaniment to a song a praise. This is not only korny, but sappy. For me, it betrays the beautiful intent of the original piece and is, frankly, musically embarassing.
@ArcticGuardiaN Yeah, it's pretty horrible, but at the same time very accessible to the pop-music masses. I don't have a problem with making Bach more accessible to the average Joe.
When I get to heaven, I cannot wait to thank Bach for composing this piece - the best the history of music has ever had to offer. Of course Bach would say that the only thing that makes this great is that it exalts Jesus Christ. And I would have to agree with him on that one.
This is what music is supposed to do; aim straight at the listener's heart, and this performance does exactly that. Absolutely spell-binding. 5 big stars.
Beautiful melody from Bach's Cantata 147. However it must be noted that the simple melody itself was composed by Johan Schop with Bach adding the accompanying harmonies and instruments.
Nonetheless, I can't blame good old Santa that he only remembers that HowHowHowHowHow when he comes from the North Pole with his sleigh. No clue about Rudolf.
People, people, please, let us take a step back and look at our trivial arguments. This language of music transcends all boundaries of race and nationanality, so why can we not take this piece for what it is? A beautiful, simply beautiful song...
Jesu Joy of Man's Desiring was "played" on the church organ at my son's wedding, but it was a travesty ... barely recognisable ... how could anybody do this to such a lovely piece?
chill out you europeans! music is music and we respect your claim to Bach! we do have you with McDonald's though i was in hamburg and the Micky D's sucked. but we not gonna hate on germans cause of it.
I appreciate the frustration that very few of you dare to reveal, but try and be content knowing that when yet another 300 years have gone by this performance and its participants shall be long forgotten while Bach is still played and studied as the one of the greatest--if not the greatest--composers to have ever lived. Wealth is a poor substitute for Immortality... God is just.
You speak hypothetical time when Bach's music and men like him shall have become extinct. Men who were so precise in their work and tastes with adherence to rule. Beautiful things cannot be created casually. When those men and their work is gone then what shall those of inferior ability have to parody? How tall shall they stand when not on the shoulders or greater men? Your perfect world is an ugly place, void of light, and I hope to never see it.
everything, the heavens, that drenching downpour which makes us run to a warm place, the conversations with idiots, the thrill of an embrace; everything is made of the same stuff, it is in that where we find the eternal connection, not in the petty prides of men, especially of imagined men, imagined by pride so as to be magnificent to itself by division.
It is it's folly and becomes not of the garden but of ignorance, the darkness of not holding all precious.
I forgot that the internet was connected to Bazarro World. This is one of the most beautiful songs ever written, these ladies sing it with passion. BRAVO
Yes, but for the same reason the Mass is done in English, it's so the non- speakers can understand it, and understand the beauty and truth of the lyrics.
Man's Desiring? I'll tell you something about man's desire! I am a man and I desire to slap each and every woman in this video in the face with my manhood...
A real man doesn' t slap any woman in the face whether he believes she "deserves " it or not.
By the way, "desire" and "desiring" are two different feelings or aspirations, mind you --- if you happen to make the difference at all.
I take it you must be pretty vulgar, rude, and wonder if you are the right "man" (?) to pass any comment on any classical music, whether religious or not !!
Sorry, but I'm from Leipzig where Bach more then 20 years has worked, and so far we have here a great tradition in playing Bach, and such slimy presentation of a Bach cantata would not be acceptable here.
Thank you for your answer and comment which I truly understand. As far as Tradition is concerned, nobody can deny you the right to feel such an incredible genius must never be betrayed in any way. You may even think it is better to know Bach in His purest style than getting to know His Cantata through such a "slimy" rendering. Still I will argue that Celtic Woman might get some people to have an interest in Bach they would never have had otherwise....And this leaves Bach neat and pure for us !!
Music is all about life. And life is about time. This arrangement is (though clearly different from the original) very nice. With small parts rewritten into a style that is more popular nowadays, the arranger has made a valuable version of this wonderful piece. Maybe it wouldn't have worked 100 years ago, but now it does.
I know this will probably be interpreted as an attack on the singers, celtish music in general and any and all fans of Celtic Woman, but I assure you it is not. Yet, in my (admittedly not so humble) opinion, this version of Bach's masterpiece is a complete disaster. This style of singing, the orchestral arrangement, the transposition! (omg), and everything else is an affront to Bach and God alike. This music is holy, if performed correctly. This is pop music, and bad taste to bound.
@sprygeoffreya17 I enjoyed reading your comment but can honestly & with authority tell you that there is the one true God, and his name is JESUS; God loves you and has a plan for your future (refer Holy Bible, turn to the book of the prophet Jeremiah, go to chapter 29 & look at verse 11). All the best to you friend!
i have no problem with this version. i think that the members of Celtic Women capture the beauty of this song perfectly. Their voices bring a purity to the music that is unique to them. I truly appreciate this version.....Brava Ladies!!!
You cannot do this man's music badly at all. Bach indeed left it open to interpretation. Ask Virgil Fox. Read "Conversations with Casals," when some purist tried to confront him on how he interpreted Bach.
Who cares what you all say but this is one of the most wonderful sounding pieces. These ladies brought out the best of J.H. Bach compositions. Just my opinion.
Trying to be diplomatic about you, I am going to say ... You are somewhat intellectually "challenged". I can care less about Chloe's weight (she already lost lots of it since this performance), but you? Well, still stuck on stupid, right?
Oh oracle2world. I just wanted to help you understand what "What goes around, comes around" mean. Evidently, you begin to "get it". Congrats! Now, after reading my response, go back and read YOUR orignal post about Chloe, and see why I said what I said it.
I said Chloë was heavy. That is a true statement of fact. You said I was intellectually challenged and stuck on stupid ... without any evidence or basis in fact.
And Chloë is a "public figure" about whom anyone can write just about anything. Unlike me, who is protected by the YouTube Terms of Service that discourage personal attacks.
So ... exactly what IS your interest in Chloë? Just a casual fan?
oracle2world: It seems that you are trying to desperatly paint yourself as a victom, yet YOU were the one with the sarcastic personal attack on the performer. Oh yeah, she cannot defend herself, so you felt safe to do it. Anyway, it is one thing when an adolesant with no life experience does it, It is other when an adult does it. Stop wrapping yourselve in "legalities". YOU started it, not me. I can nontinue the exchange of sarcasm, if you want, so ... let it go, because I AM better in this.
Yes, you are right about "could" vs "couldn't". But, how does it relate to "stuck on stupid" ? You must be one of the "geniuses" who voted for "the ONE", right?
The days of Glen B. ( Goldberg ) Dinu L.(Jesus joy... ) and Ivo P. ( English Suites ) and Genious Trumpet Güttler and other Bach Heroes obviously are gone.
Sorry... I like too much the original version, I can't appreciate these modern-taste remakes... That bass drum is really inappropriate... Again, sorry: I'm pretty dogmatic about Bach! :)
Well, that 2 yes... although I think it's okay to take music and shape it into new styles. That enriches culture. The thing is that there is already so much sung in English, and well, Some tunes are just better when sung in german in my humble opinion. You would not want to sing a french chanson or a rousing soviet march song in English either hmm?
soy españolito de a pie y aunque no tengo buen oido para los idiomas a parte dl mio , tengo que decir que las cantantes tiene unas voces maravillosas , y que se bastan con 5 para lograr la intensidad de lo que muchos coros de ...... no consiguen .
I don't know what the fuck you people are talking about because this version of Bach's classic is fucking gorgeous!!!! I actually got goosebumps listening to this! I adore Bach and I adore celtic music (because I'm Welsh haha!) I think u put the two together and it's pure gold! Bach would love this!
is this an american puppy-micky-mouse-classic-concert. this is pink sugar shit. poor bach, poor genius! this video is for old american ladies with no brain...
Jesus is my friend
savemyplaylist 4 months ago in playlist bach
show de bola ..amei sua melodia ate mais que deus o abençoe abraços
celsoflautista 5 months ago
Thank you from me and my neighbors that can sometimes be excused for not loving my rock'n'roll, but who couldn't love this beautiful and totally enrapturing performance. G.B. to all who find it easier to breath having heard this...and better times to those others of us who are still not at ease. There will be rock'n'roll probably, later:) <3
mogramjo 7 months ago
wow that was SO BEAUTIFUL :*) but wasn't there two verses?
Carolarny1 8 months ago
If I am, conservative and I locate myself in the exigency of preferring the original composition, it would comment: " Bach this one furious!. But a reality is that already it is something of the modernity from not so past, not to be so conservative and to present to the audience of the current world contemporary harmony, for this way calling it with education, adapted to his tiny appreciative musical capacity. Being honest, they transmit feeling only one is agreeably.
Arturito28 9 months ago
A violista acha que ta tocando musica country
METALCLASSICO16 9 months ago
Absolutely horrible
spinalreflex 9 months ago
Can someone explain why this is bad? I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing that they changed the mood of the piece...
Mystified012 10 months ago
¡Qué horror! ¡Qué forma de destrozar a Bach! A Bach no le hace falta almíbar
gliteranbigai 10 months ago
I understand what they are trying to do. I hope they are successful. I am tired of looking a grey-haired audiences.....
trinitychurch 10 months ago
this is truly how to rape a beatiful piece of music.
blikeng 10 months ago
An Bachs Himmelslleiter haben die Damen ihre rosa Unterwäsche aufgehängt!
Kasemattenbaer 11 months ago 2
this is awful, the violinist plays it like a fiddle tune!!! This piece can only be done the way JSB intended. Not some junked up american version.
punkypenguin321 11 months ago
c'est marrant ce truc.... je suis musicien classique.... et malgré le côté "kitsch", c'est pas mal....
amadeusforever1 1 year ago
Why did they sing the Sheets of the Violins? If the singers all would sing the lyrics, the piece would be a little bit better. I prefer a traditional Version.
93mrpunkt 1 year ago
Beauty is Beauty, in Music or Form!
Bach's music is for all those who appreciate beauty in all its forms and glory!
orion888me 1 year ago
so badddddddddddd
frauleinedie28 1 year ago 2
@frauleinedie28 amen
punkypenguin321 10 months ago
Sweet and sickening. I hate to be vulgar but I might get through it if they removed their clothes. Rediculous trying to sell Bach with feminine charms.
RickMaltese 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry but I think it's terrible. The voices are not good enough nor adapt to sing Bach. The arrangement is painful. Please let Bach alone and don't try to earn on him and meke it commercial thank
jahnssen 1 year ago
Sorry but I think it's terrible. The voices are not good enough nor adapt to sing Bach. The arrangement is painful. Please let Bach alone and don't try to earn on him and meke it commercial thank you
jahnssen 1 year ago
I think this is a beautiful version of this piece one must be open to new things.
02brenb 1 year ago
what a horrible horrible interpretation of a beautiful piece
ArcticGuardiaN 1 year ago 19
@ArcticGuardiaN JAjaajaaja es una buena forma de comentar.
stephenykevin 1 year ago 3
@ArcticGuardiaN I completely agree! Horrible... They tried to make it even more beautiful but they just ruined it... Looks like Soap Opera Music! :/
joaotwin 1 year ago 2
@ArcticGuardiaN
I agree. My reason for disliking this is that the key changes are downright korny. What Bach wrote was a flowing accompaniment to a song a praise. This is not only korny, but sappy. For me, it betrays the beautiful intent of the original piece and is, frankly, musically embarassing.
yenrabaraho 1 year ago
@ArcticGuardiaN Yeah, it's pretty horrible, but at the same time very accessible to the pop-music masses. I don't have a problem with making Bach more accessible to the average Joe.
SLOBoe 11 months ago
@ArcticGuardiaN Totally agree. It's horrible.
PersonallyOptimistic 10 months ago
Que Fique para Sempre esse belo Cantico de Adoração
srliro 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ji ji ji me gusta que me monten los conejos con esa musica para indios jiji
animanaturaal 1 year ago
maravilloso maravilloso maravilloso...
animanatural 1 year ago
lindo , lindo lindo
fundacaogetulio 1 year ago
@fundacaogetulio :)
stephenykevin 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Poor rendition of this beautiful song.
The voices remind me of stray cats
in the night- hissing and screaming for affection.
Japanese1970 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why this unnecessary travesty of a marvelous Bach piece?
tinkthetrue 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my ears are bleeding
0igres 1 year ago
Marvellous .
ELENAPASTIME 1 year ago
ESTA MÚSICA ME LLEGA AL CORAZÓN. ENHORABUENA POR ESTE VIDEO, Montserrat
mllval 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
such awful fucking lyrics, they should have just made up their own.
savemyplaylist 1 year ago
When I get to heaven, I cannot wait to thank Bach for composing this
piece - the best the history of music has ever had to offer. Of course
Bach would say that the only thing that makes this great is that it
exalts Jesus Christ. And I would have to agree with him on that one.
D29418 1 year ago
When I get to heaven, I cannot wait to thank Bach for composing this piece - the best the history of music has ever had to offer. Of course Bach would say that the only thing that makes this great is that it exalts Jesus Christ. And I would have to agree with him on that one.
D29418 1 year ago
Bach est certainement la plus belle preuve du génie Chrétien !
Magnifique.
paulquiclet 1 year ago 3
amazing .. i was soooooooooooooo touched .. >.<
yumekaoto08 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Divino.....
Sou levado a sala do trono de Deus com essa linda e preciosa obra..
Cristo seja louvado...
vagao2008 1 year ago
Divino.....
Sou levado a sala do trono de Deus com essa linda e preciosa obra..
Cristo seja louvado...
vagao2008 1 year ago
j'adore la version originale mais celle-ci restitue à merveille l'esprit que j-s Bach
voulait sans aucun doute donner ! Superbe!
ducdelaval09 1 year ago
This song is .......is.....is......SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO pretty i fell like sunshine listoning to it
star4burst341hayley 1 year ago 5
@star4burst341hayley God bless you, sweetheart, that's one of the most beautiful assessments I;ve ever heard of Bach's delightful music!
stlivermore 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hideous attempt to "cover" the genius music in hollywood arrangement
vomorg 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hideous attempt to "cover" the genius music in hollywood arrangement
vomorg 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
kitsch
21436587abc 1 year ago
2:45 is amazing when the two voices collide
Maxbay89 1 year ago
Rien à voir avec le classique mais comme cela est bien joué et interprété. Bravo pour cette innovation !!!
MUREX641 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It's beautiful in a way, but pales in comparison to what Bach actually wrote.
Terrdemarzielle 1 year ago
nice voice.. I like it! I love the song..
abcdemy123456 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This version is just horrible. Polished kitschy crap.
I am not to found of the english lyrics either. They almost contradict the modest style of the original.
Sebideluxe 1 year ago
This is what music is supposed to do; aim straight at the listener's heart, and this performance does exactly that. Absolutely spell-binding. 5 big stars.
terrafirma91 1 year ago 7
i love it. :) Beautiful. i don't have any more word to say :)
kelis64 1 year ago 4
Amazing violn girl you are Beautiful in many ways!
TheCheesecurl 1 year ago
Beautiful melody from Bach's Cantata 147. However it must be noted that the simple melody itself was composed by Johan Schop with Bach adding the accompanying harmonies and instruments.
gigie555 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
ouch ouch ouch ouch my ears...
Mokinono45 2 years ago
i love the lyrics....
ChilSeongGeom 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Poor maestro Bach.
Horrible, kitschy!
The vocalists have a bad singing technique.
The orchestration is more than stagily.
That's Baroque music, no Disney movie soundtrack!
albertklassik 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm sure this makes Bach cry, in the bad way. This is no Bach..
gehaktmolen 2 years ago
whats the name of 3 singer?
singularku 2 years ago
Jesu, joy of man's desiring
Holy wisdom, love most bright
Drawn by Thee, our souls aspiring
Soar to uncreated light
Word of God, our flesh that fashioned
With the fire of life impassioned
Striving still to truth unknown
Soaring, dying round Thy throne
luchogd 2 years ago 4
Really great lyrics!
Nonetheless, I can't blame good old Santa that he only remembers that HowHowHowHowHow when he comes from the North Pole with his sleigh. No clue about Rudolf.
HenkPeelen 2 years ago
J.S. BACH is the FATHER
rostro67 2 years ago 4
-10.. Is Bach no't pop!
lequeze 2 years ago
always loved the Corrs... didn't know, they actually played classics though
kermittherabbit 2 years ago
These aren't the Corrs :S
tazarooni89 2 years ago
PRECIOSA VERSION ,
nowherepink 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
ASQUEROSA VERSION
Barbapippo 2 years ago
@Barbapippo : si no te gusta , no tienes por que oirla son bastante mejores que IL DIVO
nowherepink 2 years ago
it's o kay. Celebrate the melody and this great, German genius. The beauty given to the world by this man. Yes, a German gift, too. Celebrate.
davidgee100 2 years ago 2
People, people, please, let us take a step back and look at our trivial arguments. This language of music transcends all boundaries of race and nationanality, so why can we not take this piece for what it is? A beautiful, simply beautiful song...
TheMadRabbi666 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Jesu Joy of Man's Desiring was "played" on the church organ at my son's wedding, but it was a travesty ... barely recognisable ... how could anybody do this to such a lovely piece?
7uhuru 2 years ago
chill out you europeans! music is music and we respect your claim to Bach! we do have you with McDonald's though i was in hamburg and the Micky D's sucked. but we not gonna hate on germans cause of it.
loubadown 2 years ago
I appreciate the frustration that very few of you dare to reveal, but try and be content knowing that when yet another 300 years have gone by this performance and its participants shall be long forgotten while Bach is still played and studied as the one of the greatest--if not the greatest--composers to have ever lived. Wealth is a poor substitute for Immortality... God is just.
dolofonos 2 years ago
Yours is the attitude which will be forgotten as people come together.
Selfish prides, hostility to others enjoyment, and dark ignorance witll fade away to nothing.
marsCubed 2 years ago
You speak hypothetical time when Bach's music and men like him shall have become extinct. Men who were so precise in their work and tastes with adherence to rule. Beautiful things cannot be created casually. When those men and their work is gone then what shall those of inferior ability have to parody? How tall shall they stand when not on the shoulders or greater men? Your perfect world is an ugly place, void of light, and I hope to never see it.
dolofonos 2 years ago
everything, the heavens, that drenching downpour which makes us run to a warm place, the conversations with idiots, the thrill of an embrace; everything is made of the same stuff, it is in that where we find the eternal connection, not in the petty prides of men, especially of imagined men, imagined by pride so as to be magnificent to itself by division.
It is it's folly and becomes not of the garden but of ignorance, the darkness of not holding all precious.
knowing is connecting.
marsCubed 2 years ago
I forgot that the internet was connected to Bazarro World. This is one of the most beautiful songs ever written, these ladies sing it with passion. BRAVO
sithsquid 2 years ago
What is this??? This is BWV 147 which has drowned is syrup.
josefk64 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OMG in English. Bach was a German. Not in english. The real name is: Jesu bleibet meine Freude. The german song in German is better than in English.
Orionman8 2 years ago
Yes, but for the same reason the Mass is done in English, it's so the non- speakers can understand it, and understand the beauty and truth of the lyrics.
dalspartan 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@dalspartan ?? The Mass was done in German, Jesu bleibet meine Freude. I'm not so sure if J.S would like this version....
alprojazz 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Man's Desiring? I'll tell you something about man's desire! I am a man and I desire to slap each and every woman in this video in the face with my manhood...
Abracadamnit 2 years ago
A real man doesn' t slap any woman in the face whether he believes she "deserves " it or not.
By the way, "desire" and "desiring" are two different feelings or aspirations, mind you --- if you happen to make the difference at all.
I take it you must be pretty vulgar, rude, and wonder if you are the right "man" (?) to pass any comment on any classical music, whether religious or not !!
ottalski 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
jagara1 2 years ago
OMG in English... but still good.
Cipher123 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a great kitsch as we would call this in German
Alcetes 2 years ago
Das ist aber kein "kitsch" , sondern eine neue Idee, um dieses Lied vom Hertz zu singen... Warum nicht ??
( I am neither Irish nor German. I happen to be French, and try to be fair, that' s all )
ottalski 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry, but I'm from Leipzig where Bach more then 20 years has worked, and so far we have here a great tradition in playing Bach, and such slimy presentation of a Bach cantata would not be acceptable here.
Alcetes 2 years ago
Thank you for your answer and comment which I truly understand. As far as Tradition is concerned, nobody can deny you the right to feel such an incredible genius must never be betrayed in any way. You may even think it is better to know Bach in His purest style than getting to know His Cantata through such a "slimy" rendering. Still I will argue that Celtic Woman might get some people to have an interest in Bach they would never have had otherwise....And this leaves Bach neat and pure for us !!
ottalski 2 years ago
bravo!
dasgroover 2 years ago 4
Music is all about life. And life is about time. This arrangement is (though clearly different from the original) very nice. With small parts rewritten into a style that is more popular nowadays, the arranger has made a valuable version of this wonderful piece. Maybe it wouldn't have worked 100 years ago, but now it does.
This arrangement is like a salute to Bach.
jazzbassbone2000 2 years ago
Who doesn't love Bach? A great man and a great Lutheran.
Festizzle 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They ruined this song.
ihutforu123 2 years ago
M A R A V I L L O S O
rv8721 2 years ago
jesus bleibet meine freude...
why in english -_- stupid american's idea.
but cool song.
firstant 2 years ago
Thank your lucky stars that you have the unearned privilege of being able to scribble such trifles at Youtube...made you guess where.
stlivermore 2 years ago
You're welcome for saving from the Germans in WWII.
velvta 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I know this will probably be interpreted as an attack on the singers, celtish music in general and any and all fans of Celtic Woman, but I assure you it is not. Yet, in my (admittedly not so humble) opinion, this version of Bach's masterpiece is a complete disaster. This style of singing, the orchestral arrangement, the transposition! (omg), and everything else is an affront to Bach and God alike. This music is holy, if performed correctly. This is pop music, and bad taste to bound.
jakobdkp 2 years ago
You poor thing. We'll let the poor in Calcutta and the refugees in Darfur know of your troubles, so they'll know how truly lucky they are.
velvta 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Seriously, who cares if there's a god or isn't when it's obvious that bach believed in him and made it possible for anyone to enjoy his own joy
truthewes 2 years ago
This "performance" is a catastrophe.
They are destroying this masterpiece by Bach and smile while doing it. Like a bull in a china shop.
Erikkiel 2 years ago
I don't know if there's a God, but if there is, J.S. Bach is certainly the joy of His desiring.
sprygeoffreya17 2 years ago 20
hehe very nice
reh2reh 2 years ago
That was good!
calliegal235 2 years ago
@sprygeoffreya17 'Ol Johann knew. Read about his church. Joh 14:6 Col 3:16
Brucev7 1 year ago
@sprygeoffreya17 I enjoyed reading your comment but can honestly & with authority tell you that there is the one true God, and his name is JESUS; God loves you and has a plan for your future (refer Holy Bible, turn to the book of the prophet Jeremiah, go to chapter 29 & look at verse 11). All the best to you friend!
concertviolinist 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh my God!!!!! What a horrid alto!!! Had she ever heard of the way the instrument should sound!!!! Their place is KKK-Kirche,Kitche, Kinder....
musiccritic1910 2 years ago
If I could sing like that, I wouldnt be writing this......
MrSjales 2 years ago 5
This is the best.
stlivermore 2 years ago
i have no problem with this version. i think that the members of Celtic Women capture the beauty of this song perfectly. Their voices bring a purity to the music that is unique to them. I truly appreciate this version.....Brava Ladies!!!
bcugirl09 2 years ago 5
5 star. superb!!!!!
tuseslais 2 years ago
this is a great version... of course its not an original interpretation... but its great and the vocalists are wonderful!
LordAngelon 2 years ago 3
You cannot do this man's music badly at all. Bach indeed left it open to interpretation. Ask Virgil Fox. Read "Conversations with Casals," when some purist tried to confront him on how he interpreted Bach.
paladin313 2 years ago
Well said.
HamerD 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
awful - a sort of ANTI-Bach - Al Qaida?
kitschbuster 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please, give me an Axe...
vinceofgeneva 2 years ago
Jesus Christ
The JOY of Mans Desire
AMEN!!!
Itchhhh 2 years ago 6
beautiful... JSB would smile I think.
ekahiway 2 years ago 5
II thnk he would too.
Itchhhh 2 years ago
Es hermosisima creo que al escucharlo ya escuche lo mejor de comunicarse con dios y puedo morir feliz
humbertussss 2 years ago
Who cares what you all say but this is one of the most wonderful sounding pieces. These ladies brought out the best of J.H. Bach compositions. Just my opinion.
iggycandyman 2 years ago 3
I think these voices blend right into the music as if its one. It's like listening to a really good piano trill. Perfect melding of two.
Great performance!
SCHneiDen777 2 years ago 2
Simply Great! You can teach the heaven
leger34 2 years ago 3
5 stars
ChristianMarxist 2 years ago
The amount of control these ladies have with their voices just blows me away. This was nothing less than an amazing performance.
h0meskill3tt 2 years ago
Simply Beautiful!!
you can call me silly... but, it almost made me cry.. it's so beautiful
xXjoejonasluvmeXx 2 years ago 5
wow ... that blew me away ... absolutely fantastic ... I love those girls ... Adorable :D
gipskull 2 years ago
Hermosa la música y las músicas.
Camilo870913 2 years ago
What is the orchestra's name?
Very beautifull!!!
torracasantos 2 years ago 2
On the intro, is the main instrument a viola or a violin?
Guitar1horse1manzana 2 years ago
Chloë Agnew is a bit ... "heavy" ... to be diplomatic. Voice of an angel.
oracle2world 2 years ago
Trying to be diplomatic about you, I am going to say ... You are somewhat intellectually "challenged". I can care less about Chloe's weight (she already lost lots of it since this performance), but you? Well, still stuck on stupid, right?
bodzio4062 2 years ago
Is that your definition of "diplomatic". I'm glad you don't follow Chloë Agnew's weight, even though you seem to know quite a bit about it.
oracle2world 2 years ago
Oh oracle2world. I just wanted to help you understand what "What goes around, comes around" mean. Evidently, you begin to "get it". Congrats! Now, after reading my response, go back and read YOUR orignal post about Chloe, and see why I said what I said it.
bodzio4062 2 years ago
I said Chloë was heavy. That is a true statement of fact. You said I was intellectually challenged and stuck on stupid ... without any evidence or basis in fact.
And Chloë is a "public figure" about whom anyone can write just about anything. Unlike me, who is protected by the YouTube Terms of Service that discourage personal attacks.
So ... exactly what IS your interest in Chloë? Just a casual fan?
oracle2world 2 years ago
oracle2world: It seems that you are trying to desperatly paint yourself as a victom, yet YOU were the one with the sarcastic personal attack on the performer. Oh yeah, she cannot defend herself, so you felt safe to do it. Anyway, it is one thing when an adolesant with no life experience does it, It is other when an adult does it. Stop wrapping yourselve in "legalities". YOU started it, not me. I can nontinue the exchange of sarcasm, if you want, so ... let it go, because I AM better in this.
bodzio4062 2 years ago
bozio and oracle are "heavis" as Beavis and Butthead ,
nowherepink 2 years ago
nowhereping: I know you'd love to join, but U can't.
bodzio4062 2 years ago
I'm sure you meant to say 'couldn't care less' to say you 'can care less' does not make sense. Now who's stuck on stupid?
januarynitemare 2 years ago
Yes, you are right about "could" vs "couldn't". But, how does it relate to "stuck on stupid" ? You must be one of the "geniuses" who voted for "the ONE", right?
bodzio4062 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sorry to butt in, but technically it should be "genii" not "geniuses".
themanichero 2 years ago
violin
000nour000 2 years ago
Why Not ?
snancy2008 2 years ago
Poor Johann Sebastian B. !
The days of Glen B. ( Goldberg ) Dinu L.(Jesus joy... ) and Ivo P. ( English Suites ) and Genious Trumpet Güttler and other Bach Heroes obviously are gone.
We haven´t only a financial crisis.
drjekyll66 2 years ago
flot musik
dynamitten 2 years ago
i don't like the tranposition of the begining! I don't like sudden crashes in classical music , but the whole thing is very touching!
daliafayek 2 years ago
lovely, the best up to date version of this i've have ever heard,
dalosguitar 2 years ago
Sorry... I like too much the original version, I can't appreciate these modern-taste remakes... That bass drum is really inappropriate... Again, sorry: I'm pretty dogmatic about Bach! :)
pincopallino1984 2 years ago
Hmm pitty they don't sing it in german.
DeHeld8 2 years ago 2
nor does it sound very baroque either
lukphonp 2 years ago
Well, that 2 yes... although I think it's okay to take music and shape it into new styles. That enriches culture. The thing is that there is already so much sung in English, and well, Some tunes are just better when sung in german in my humble opinion. You would not want to sing a french chanson or a rousing soviet march song in English either hmm?
DeHeld8 2 years ago
wow, this song... I'm speechless.
Bigdrummerboy89 2 years ago 3
You mind my British English spelling -
I do not mind your taste.
Go on enjoying this rendition.
preruminator 2 years ago
soy españolito de a pie y aunque no tengo buen oido para los idiomas a parte dl mio , tengo que decir que las cantantes tiene unas voces maravillosas , y que se bastan con 5 para lograr la intensidad de lo que muchos coros de ...... no consiguen .
nowherepink 2 years ago
Thats another violinist I'd like to fiddle with. YUMMY!!
hogrider9 3 years ago 3
I don't know what the fuck you people are talking about because this version of Bach's classic is fucking gorgeous!!!! I actually got goosebumps listening to this! I adore Bach and I adore celtic music (because I'm Welsh haha!) I think u put the two together and it's pure gold! Bach would love this!
charly1330 3 years ago
You can't kill a good song? - Well, ...
DynablasterMick 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is musical diarrhoea.
preruminator 3 years ago
spell it right at least
navillusleahcim 2 years ago
It's fantastic. I love you this song.
majoradam 3 years ago
I think J.S. would love that!
VanBeathoven 3 years ago
für meine ohren ist es grauenhaft, besonders die letzten takte,
ich glaube auch die herzen der menschen, die nicht mit klassischer musik vertraut sind, wären eher mit schlichteren "echteren" Klängen zu rühren.
so klingt es, als ob die klaren töne der bachschen musik fett angesetzt hätten und kurz vor einem kreislaufkollaps stehen.
muss jetzt dringend als gegengift eine aufnahme von gardiner hören.
gaertlin 3 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
for people who like "best adagios". production for the idiots. poor bach, sorry!
moohoo08 3 years ago
Pardonne les Jean Sebastien, elles essayent de gagner leur vie.
BWV169 3 years ago
That's pretty cool I reckon.
Caoltan 3 years ago
96,000 hits and everyone rips it apart? I like it.
chuckbob08 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
did i hear correctly or did the redhead not snort a little during her part?
dchizzo 3 years ago
is this an american puppy-micky-mouse-classic-concert. this is pink sugar shit. poor bach, poor genius! this video is for old american ladies with no brain...
moohoo08 3 years ago
considering the ladies are from a group called "Celtic Women", your comment is very amusing.
yrael08 3 years ago 2
Se olvidaron de incorporar a Julio Iglesias
raulosvaldo1 3 years ago
raulosvaldo1: jajajajajajajajaaaaaaaa me l