Girls Aloud - The Loving Kind (Live at Paul O'Grady)

[west7689]

They all look so beautiful here!

[thecheryl1001]

I love you girls aloud

[TheSasiLP]

0.56 Chezza rulez!!!

[nancster97x]

sarah has ruined herself with all that botox <3 nicola

[lenny19100]

Lets just face it. Their all good singers. They wouldn't be there if they weren't. and GA just isn't GA without anyone of them. <3 all of them.

[mrinvincible2001]

amazing how well they did given that they started on popstars 2. hope they reunite at some point.

[nofar201]

I love sarah she is so beautiful

[talesref]

Sarah is a completely DISASTER, she should leave the band.

[SuperFlashDelirium]

Oh - and that ginger girl did brilliantly.

[SuperFlashDelirium]

Cheryl is flat and pitchy here....

[sbm1215]

Same dresses they wore at the Girls' Aloud Party when they did 'Love Is Pain'. Oh, Nicola's got a new dress haha

[t1a2o]

check out nadine's ironic face at 2:15 combined with her moves!

[t1a2o]

it seems to be a lot forced, clumsy and unnatural.

specially when it starts.

cheryl's the most gracious though.

her expression is just perfect..

has she ever worked as an actress??

[t1a2o]

is it me or it feels like someone told them to keep moving their hands and arms gently over their bodies and heads all the time? it feels like they keep looking at someone behind cameras guiding them. they didn't do it in other performances i've watched.

[nrsreject]

it's hard not to love cheryl <3

[mentonerodominicano]

Did Cheryl's voice really overcome Nadine's at 0:55? I would've loved they had focused the cam on her during that bit! 

[Silvicorio]

@mentonerodominicano I think so :)

[mconstanta]

2:24 - 2:26 Cheryl knew the camera was on her and she made a dreamy face!! hahah why i love her so muchh!!?

[cbear24able]

Kimba is the only one that actually looks like a real woman.

[BaCkToBlAcK2]

Sarah is definitely a better singer than Kimberley.

[jamie1904]

@bam824 yeah is normally good but she does suck here I just hope they get back together soon.

[articuno808]

I miss Girls Aloud. :'(

Hurry up and get back together already!

[09Baily]

Stop bloody finding things wrong with them, yes this isn't a great performance... but it was when it was first out, if you hear them on tour... they sung it brilliantly. All their voices together are brilliant, they all have different voices... not one is better than the other. They are all great.

[Charmedlassie18]

@09Baily because it is autotuned so it would sound good.

They cannot sing this song.

[jamie1904]

WHAT THE HELL IS SARAH DOING?!?! SHE HAS ALWAYS GOT TO SCREAM HER LINES!!!! SHE SUCKS!!! GO KIMBERLEY!! <3

[bam824]

@jamie1904

Sarah doesn't really suck. Her tone is uneven usually, same with Cheryl, but they don't suck. I do have an issue with this screaming she's been doing lately. We all know she can sing and belt out notes, but she doesn't have to do it for every-damn-line she sings. It gets to be rather annoying.

[TweanCoyle]

-.- cheryl was awfull ?

[bourjois01]

i love nadine but she seems to over do it a little

[RallyDude92]

@bourjois01 That's her 'tud, man!! She is the best in the performance, so she wanted to show it!

[srmelomano]

I find it weird how they barely look at each other, unlike the Sugababes, for instance. Anyway, it was a great performance! Love this song.

[Bubika0716]

@srmelomano yeah but the sugababes had 3 member changes while they had none. maybe they looked at each other too often:) I don't think we should read too much into them not looking at each other

[girlsaloudrules2010]

love nicola shes always been me fav go girl :) and love cheryl's little clap for nicola at 1.35 and nadine smiles at nicola at 1.38

[webby686]

i love the nicola and kimba part. they are my favorites. both so beautiful :P

[aussieapril]

@webby686

Definitely!!! They have such nice voices and they don't try too hard! Just simply wonderful! They are also the best vocalists after Nadine! :)

[nady1991]

cheryl concentrates alot on this song. which is great to c how much she wants to do well. nadine is just enjoying herself so much here.

[RallyDude92]

@nady1991 love nadine!! she was getting her strut on! so what your saying is, cheryl needs to stop concentrating to sing well?!?!lol!

[nady1991]

@RallyDude92 lol i just think she needs to have more fun and smile a bit more in this. like nadine does.

[RallyDude92]

Cheryl was shite. GO NADINE!!!!!

[TheVivaladida]

Great, as usual Nicola and Sarah rule it!

[richardsonjames1971]

I don't think it is fair to keep comparing each girl's performance. They are all great singers, beautiful and excellet in their own right. I have no favourite, I buy their music because I like all of the band, not one member inparticular.

[xzxplaygirlxzx]

Cheryl can sing she is the best

[slanker786]

sarah harding is the bestest!

[XxXxNiAmHXxX]

face it Nadine is the best nd will knock Cheryl off the charts with her new song!

[McFlabagast]

@XxXxNiAmHXxX How wrong you were...

[XxXxNiAmHXxX]

@McFlabagast You wait and see...

[DegrassiInstantStar]

Nicola is the STAR of this song and this album era!!

[rockthecasbah100]

I don't get why people say sarah and cheryl can't sing I think they are very good singers sometimes there better then other times, but you can't base that on one performance.

[aussieapril]

@rockthecasbah100

They are good singers but unfortunately they are the two weakest singers of the group! You can hear how bad Sarah is when she tries too hard!

[Charmedlassie18]

@rockthecasbah100 have you seen them on GMTV? They are even worse

[2black4music]

nadine a bit of show off

[RallyDude92]

Well, since none of the girls can match her, she'd have to show off.

[babbiek8]

CHERYL CAN SING!

if cheryl cldny sing then why the fuck wld they have put her in a band yeah!!!

and why wld she be at number 1 or single and album

and why wld she be always preforming on shows on telly!!!

all of them can sing the whole point they survived 9 years and i will support them all the was and also cheryl is very popular its just because the audiance know what she has went through and tbh i love her for everything about her she is 10 tyms a better person than anyone puting her dwn

[movebutters]

cheryl cant sing. WOW.

[jhwb256]

Seriously?

Listen to her harmonies at 0:50 and on the second part. They're flawless everytime on every performance. There are some people in the group who can't keep pitch holding out the same note. It's not fair to say she can't sing. She obviously can. She might not be the best soloist of the group, but she can sing. I'd take her harmonies over Sarah's any day.

[movebutters]

i think she can hold a tune. i dont think she can sing. seriously, if you put her up against esmee denters, nicole scherzinger, (beyonce isnt a fair example, because she cant sing, she can SANG) even lady gaga.... cheryl cant really compare. she is BEAUTIFUL though, ill give her that. i think that within the context of girls aloud, shes fine, but i dont think she has a good enough voice to justify going solo. but thank-u for challenging me intelligently & not like a screaming fangirl :)

[jhwb256]

Perhaps.

I think it's more a matter of opinion than anything. When I think of people that can't sing, I think of Ciara. I definitely wouldn't call Cheryl a Ciara. I prefer Cheryls tone and although she doesn't have full control, I think she has great potential.

But that's just my opinion. Thank you for not responding like a screaming fangirl. Always makes things a little easier.

[jhwb256]

And as far pinning her against Esmee Denters and Nicole Scherzinger, regardless of their vocally capabiliy let's take a look at their careers: Esmee is nothing without her youtube covers. Obviously I'm not seeing her everywhere, at least here in the US. And Nicole had 2 or 3 singles, but nothing special. That's why she went back to PCD. If she's not heading them, she really has no career.

So kudos to Cheryl for being more successful than them, even though "she can't sing".

[rozzerss]

shes an amazin singer ur just jealous cause shes fukkin famous

CHERYL IS A LEDGEND

CHIM ALL THE WAY

[movebutters]

well Nicole IS the Pussycat Dolls, so that's not really a fair comparison, she's practically a solo artist anyways. And Esmee's song Outta Here did quite well internationally. Cheryl Cole isn't really about the singing. anybody who listens to her album can tell that she's not a great singer, she's about the personality and the image. Don't get me wrong, I loves her FFTL performance on X-Factor. I'm just criticizing her singing, not her performing.

[rozzerss]

well she didny get choosen from popstar the rivals cause she canni sing

[Beebers2006]

Cheryl getting a solo record deal is like Geri Halliwell getting a solo deal. The weakest member of a band with a big fan base that's clearly based on popularity more than talent. :(

[k4t5]

shit!!!!!!!!

[SparklingxLipgloss]

I love Sarahs voice and all their dresses are gorgous ♥ :)

[goandeatshitcunt]

I Cannot stand Cole. Kimberley's the best, and not just because she's from Yorkshire ;)

[lucy2089]

Couldnt agree more!

[MissMurray101]

I just love Cheryl, she's so sweet and has the biggest smile ever!

GA<3

[jadeyykinns]

OMG. to the people who criticize Cheryl for not being able to sing live (when she clearly can, or she wouldnt have gotten in the band in the first place!):

You bashed Britney Spears for miming on The X Factor, and now you're bashing Cheryl Cole for singing live. Make up your fucking minds!

[megawwefan99]

Exactly! She can sing, she's just not as strong a singer as Nadine or Nicola. And that's a good thing because if they were all the same they would drown each other out!

[jadeyykinns]

Exactly! I'm glad someone agrees with me!

[roxygirly12]

agree with u 100%!!!! <3 CHERYL

[movebutters]

i dont think people are bashing cheryl for singing live. theyre bashing her because she CANT sing live. or at all.

[webby686]

nadine's hand gestures are a little much. lol. trying to grab the spotlight.

[MGirlsAloudFan]

They all so gorgeous in this :) Especially Nadine's hair, Cheryl smile, Nicola's dress, Sarah's eyes and just Kimberly being Kimberly :)

[Charlienmeg]

How in the name of everything that's good and honest did anyone in their right minds think Cheryl Cole would make a good singer? My dog howling is better to listen to. The rest of them are better but that's really not saying much at all.

[WestEndOnBroadway]

NICOLA IS STUNNING.

CRACKING VOICE.

[xNOTxMEx]

No offence but the note from Sarah at 2:59-3:04 was awful!

Sarah did that note in a lot of performances and I sometimes wonder if Sarah doing that note put people off buying the single.

Thank goodness that note wasn't on the CD!

Love the song and performance though :)

[hotnsassy84]

lmao never noticed b4 hahah

[moneymoreman]

al stunning...and the song is brillaint....

[dodgeyjammer]

they are all gorgeous!!!

[lutonfc23]

this is a fucking tune! how can cole cheat on her? i would anything for her and to her!!!!

[SeanieRockz]

I think this was a bad choice for the 2nd single, Rolling Back The Rivers In Time had a better melody, I don't think it fitted in well with the vocal range, it was two low or something. Nicola's voice is amazing live, while Cheryl get's all the hype and her voice is crap live.

[sweetiepie1509]

i dnt c y they dont giv nicola more solos cos she has one ov da best voices in the group just listen to her singing on the medleys at wembely

[suchagreatperson]

and btw i think sarah´s doin exceptionally great in here!

cheryl´s gotta mistake at the beginning

[suchagreatperson]

looks like nadine is doin her own show over there haha

obviously wants to do it all for herself

[megawwefan99]

like always.

[Phoenixbird27]

I think it should have done better than number 10 in the charts too. I think the vocals are not suited to live performances, there seems to be too many high parts that stand out as out of tune. I also don't think Sarah's voice is suited to ballads like this, and giving her the high part wasn't the best idea...

[jay1murphy]

I 100% agree with this comment

[aboytheme]

i think this is great song and should've done better in the charts.

[jarnet1021]

completely agree

deserves higher than the number 10 spot

such a catchy song as well!

[latinocoolguy83]

Someone needs to turn off Sarah's Mic!!!! Ugh!!! She keeps ruining their performances....I'd rather they mime if they going to sound this bad. Let Nadine sing all the notes.

[megawwefan99]

Nicola.

[laura151511]

How good is nicola in this and cheryl and kimba SArah tries to over power and just comes out wiv bum notes

can't wait till 29th of to out of control tour in aii at men

[MGirlsAloudFan]

Sarahs first note is a strange one :S They all really get into it dont they lol Love G.A :D

[ILOVEGA959]

Sarah needs to stop trying to overpower the band and work on that flat note! other than that brilliant!

[lunalilonike]

LOL at sarah 2:51 "wth are you doin nadine"

[Katrina981993]

they had some intense faces on this! loved it! was Nadine showing some stomach?!?

[BreannaBanana1523]

I think its just the light hitting the dress. I love this song and they did fantastic

[louiseeboo]

yeaa she is. its like a top + skirt.. she wore it on the christmas party thing aswell

[poppoya]

Thanks for posting. Love this song and GA!

[FeastsandFires]

Thanks for posting! They did wonderful!

[curro93sim]

Aww first comment *.*

This is fantastic!!!! They all sing very good!! Thanks alisenr, you're always so fast!