Added: 4 years ago
From: HOGdiddy
Views: 45,781
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (254)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hermione is more like Éowyn.

  • makes HP a lot darker, damn.

  • LOL The twins as the twins!

  • this is freakily well done :Dx

  • this is actually brilliant! lol

  • LOVE LOTRS & HP <3

  • gandalf and dumblemdore are the same person

  • Lord of the rings and harry potter are both amazing films and books, and you cannot compete each other films, as they all have their own flaws and awesomeness. Harry potter was made for this generation, and other generations will love it to just not as much. Lord of the rings was made for the generation of our parents and before as the books were written in the 1940's and reflects heavy themes of the world war and more, and we all love it to, just not as much as our elder generation do.

  • i thing HARRY POTTER MOVIE AND BOOKS ARE BETTER FROM ANY MOVIE OR BOOK AND SECOND IS LOTR AND THIRD THE PIRATES OF CA..... BECAUSE HP WROTE AND IT'S WRITTING A HISTORY ON CINEMA

  • Loved this!! Gotta say Potter is much better than LOTR but i loved this video :)

  • Fred and George -- "We shall see the Burrow again." lol

  • you cannot compare lord of the rings to harry potter. i'm not saying i hate harry potter. i actually love harry potter. but all i'm saying is that nothing beats lord of the rings. plus harry potter has similar facets to the lord of the rings i.e. sorcerer's stone and the ring, harry potter and frodo, ron and mary/pippin, hermione and sam, aragog and shelob, lord voldemort, sauron, dumbledore and gandalf, and the list goes on. lord of the rings rules the earth. period.

  • @FallofDarkness55 and I love LOTR immensely as well, however the amount of detail in HP (and the fact that she had to know every single detail of all seven books before writing) is just pure genius... so that's why it just stands above all others for me. It's very different from any series I have read. LOTR is great and detailed as well, but, for my taste, there's so many wars and a lot of them can be shorter. I don't think HP and LOTR are similar. HP has horcruxes/DH's, LOTR is based on a ring.

  • Comment removed

  • @HOGdiddy

    Tolkiens Middle Earth however is much more detailed than HP.

    Besides The Lord of The Rings he has numerous books on the history before the war of the rings took place, and the reason Tolkien has so much war in is because Tolkien both took place in the world wars so that carried into his writing.

  • @HOGdiddy The ring more or less is a horcrux, which is why frodo and sam set out on their long quest to destroy it. JK rowling stole a lot of ideas from JRR Tolkien and Greek Mythology. Also notice the similarity of dumbledore and gandalf, & aragog and shelob, etc.

  • @FallofDarkness55 I absolutely hate when people say JKR stole ideas from LOTR. BOTH series are absolutely unique. I'm sorry but in fantasy literature there are going to be similar themes and ideas, because almost all fantasy involves a hero who has to save some sort of world, and there's always mythical creatures and objects involved. It doesn't mean people stole ideas. Voldemort split his soul into seven and scattered it across the UK, the Snape SL, and loads more ... not the same.

  • @HOGdiddy And the ring held Sauron's soul hence the reason for Frodo and Sam's quest to destroy it. In essence, the ring is a horcrux. Enough said.

  • @FallofDarkness55 again, this was not suppose to be a which series/author is better debate. And what if the idea INSPIRED her? I still do not think she meant to have any connection, but did you ever think of THAT? Inspiration and copying is not the same thing. grow up.

  • @HOGdiddy "grow up"<-LOL! I have the right to my opinion and just because you don't like it doesn't mean i'm immature. And yes you have the right to your opinion as well.

  • @FallofDarkness55 yes, we all have a right to an opinion, but there's a difference between having an opinion and just being bitter. Saying HP is a copy of LOTR is just absolutely ridiculous.There's no way those stories are the same, and thanks for proving my point that LOTR extremists are annoying with this type of thing. Every story has similarities and I even acknowledged that with my video! But I understand the difference between "similarities" and "copying."

  • @FallofDarkness55 AND THIS ISN'T SUPPOSED TO BE AN HP IS BETTER THAN LOTR VIDEO! I made it because of the LOTR people bitching about HP, so I overlapped HP clips to the LOTR trailer, because like every frickin fantasy series, there are character similarities. I love both series, and I thought it was funny. Please people, stop turning this into a which-series-is-better thing. Ugh.... THEY'RE DIFFERENT.

  • @FallofDarkness55 agreed

  • @FallofDarkness55 Yeah, love HP but nothing beats LOTR. Totally agree:P

  • everything fits...

  • haha this is great! you really made it fit well

  • GJ mate GJ :)

  • These are my all time favorite books & movies

  • Wow! Haha. I love both HP and LOTR. But LOTR's my first love though.

    PS: The commentator below is right. Dobby is not evil like Gollum.

  • NO DOBBY CANT BE GOLLUM!!! BUT SIRIUS SHOULD BE ARAGORN

  • LOL the twins as Merry & Pippin, gotta love it.

  • I LOVE FRED AND GEROGE AS MERRY AND PIPPIN! =) AH, This video has made my day! :')

  • Holy shit, that was funn....wierd...

  • that was pretty good!

  • HAHA love it

  • This is what I would have done: Harry- Frodo Dumbledore- Gandalf Ron- Sam Fred and George- Pippin and Merry Sirius- Aragorn Lucius Malfoy- Legolas Hermione- Arwen Voldemort- Sauron Dobby- Gollum Ginny- Eowyn
  • that was pretty much how it was.. lol

  • Where is Severus Snape?

  • I know haha I realized I didn't have him in after I made it. But I'm making another one to a trailer for the two towers and he's in that one :D

  • dobbys the best

  • that was amazing!

  • that was incredible!

    amazing editing, all of the clips that you chose matched all of the voice overs almost flawlessly.

    great job!

  • lol Dobby

  • i agree Ian McKellen [Gandolf] should have played the second Dumbledore.

  • this ant bad accually

  • Amazing!

  • LAwl.. Lupin/Legolas smiled when he said "They are coming" or something like that :P

    huhu.. Poor Eowyn as Trelawney xD

    Of course Fred and George got to be Merry and Pip :j

    nais (y)

  • Wanted that or not Ian will be remembered as a wizard.

    I don't know does he even have any other roles except Gandalf and villain in X-men(I forgot his name).

  • If this was a trailer than this movie would really be worth watching.Great job.

    Did anyone notice how Michael Gambon with Gandalf's voice really looks like a powerful wizard.

    I think that Ian McKellen(Gandy) should play Dumbledore not Michael.But,now it's too late(unless they make a remake of HPs)

  • I heard that there were rumors with him playing Dumbledore a long time ago but he didn't want to because he didn't want to be known for just wizard roles.

  • I agree. Everyone thought it was Ian but it wasn't. I think it would be a little weird if Ian played Dumbledore because there wasa rivalry between the two for a while.

    This was a great video! I loved it when you had Merry and Pippin be Fred and George! Good idea!

  • This is an excellent video, very well made and truly enjoyable. I would love to see the same concept the other way around as well, I imagine it would be humourous.

  • HP 7 needs to have an epic charge at the battle of Hogwarts the way LOTR 3 does.

  • I heard that the final battle is going to take 30 minutes. :) I have high hopes for DH 1 and 2.

  • that is quite scary how well they fit together - great job!

  • LOL

    Brilliantly made, but just immagine if it was the other way round!

    With the Harry Potter vocals, and LOTR footage!

    THAT would be a lolable concept...

  • That was awesome and with both my favourite movies put together so much more awesome.

  • applaud

  • AWESOME WORK

  • wow. bravo! ^^

  • this is awesome.. if the mouths where in sync with the voices that would get me down the cinema pretty damn quick lol

  • nicely done,

    The lines really fit the video ^-^

  • you try doing something like this.

  • nice work but u spelled Gandalf's & Merry's names wrong, how i hav them here is right.

  • oops! well, I looked them up and that's what one site told me... booo.

  • no no, this is disturbing me lol

  • Wooo!!! :) Fred and George Weasly as hobbits! Amazing! :D hehe! :P

    And I'm so glad you used Sirius as Aragon! When I first watched lotr I was thinking 'I'm sure thats the person who plays sirius' but it wasn't, but they look so much alike! I don't know if thats just me who thinks that lol! :) and Dobby as Smegal/Gollum! Amazing!!! I loved it! :)

  • that was AWESOME!

    i absolutely love that you put Fred and George as Pippin and Merry :D

  • That was really clever, how do people come up with these ideas?

  • well made , ist so real , but i dont like the union of the two films

  • Harry Potter is nothin like Frodo Baggins

  • omg this looked real!!! WOW THIS WAS SOoO GOOD!!! and i love pippin and merry!! haha that made me laugh!

  • That was freakin awesome!!

  • LOL

  • this sucks... of cousre it is good madeand of a good quality, but this talking about how great it is and what a good movie it is... rubbish! beacause it is the harry potter movie style it sucks!!! just look how stupid harry lokks in the scenes!

    but never the less, well made, but wrong movie (harry potter), if it would have been a other one, id like to watch your vid

  • Obviously, you have not read the entire series. I have not met one person who has read the series, in its ENTIRETY, say it sucks. The story is absolutely brilliant. The movies kinda ruin it by taking out major plot lines and such... but the books are incredible. Nothing could surpass the creativity and thought that was put into the overall storyline to that series. And when you look back on it, it was like a mystery with breadcrumb clues dropped throughout the pages all way back to book 1.

  • Really awesome and great trailer. Imagine if it actually came out. It would own!

  • this was bloody FANTASTIC!!!!!!

  • Brilliant!

  • This rocked!

  • I wish LOTR was as long as HP - with 7 volumes at least...

  • its WAY Longer lol. There are so many other books but arent centered around the ring. but i think the other books are movie material too. The Hobbit is coming out though.

  • Yes I know the other works of Tolkien, and I love them too, but their style and story structure are very different from TLOTR.

  • Dobby is Gollum xD I luv it!

  • Brilliant job! You should have also put a Harry Potter title in the end, along with the LOTR title. But Well done mate =]

  • Wow. That was perfect.

  • FREAKIN AMAZING.

    love both these books/movies !!

  • wow this is really well made, have you done one the other way around-the sound of the harry potter trailer with images from LOTR?

  • Awsome trailer, well put together

  • wow, why don't you stop commenting on every lotr/harry potter video and telling the creators how dumb they are for the tiniest things. you did it on like two other vids too. why dont you try making one. its hard to make a good video.

    HOGdiddy, great video, the characters' mouths matched great with the words!

  • haha that was great!

  • Actually, I think Kreacher would be better as Gollum. Just a suggestion :D

  • I was thinking that but there wasn't enough scenes with Kreacher.. =/

  • that was great! it was totally in sync

  • hehe thts really good

    u should do a vice versa with lotr clips to hp trailer :P

  • i got an idea for you : Nevil - Gimli

  • gandalf and dombeldore is the same person in the video XD

  • wow, i like what you made the characters from harry potter to lord of the rings! well done

  • why do u people do that. its good in the begininng and end but when u get to the action music, u put stupid scenes. uhhh

  • In this trailer, I focused on the mouths matching the words. Not the action parts. If you want one with a lot of cool action scenes to the music, watch the other Harry Potter/LOTR trailer I made.

  • I <3 how u made Harry Frodo, Dumbledore Gandalf, Ron Sam, Fred and George Merry and Pippin, Sirius Aragorn, Voldemort Sauron, and Dobby Gollum! XD So faved!

  • Which scene is taht at 1 52? When the man is crying, who is the man and why is he crying? Can't remember this part.

  • It's a scene from the Goblet of Fire.

    Cedric's father's crying cos his son's just died

  • Fantastic =)

  • yeah =D

    remus lupin is my fav. character in hp and legolas in lotr xDD great ^^

    and dumbledore as gandalf is soooo brilliant! xDD

    5* and of course favs! ^^

  • Wow this is amazing, an incredible job. I am in awe.

  • well made :D 5/5 :)

  • Absolutly Brilliant

  • Hi, which trailer (lord of the rings) were you using?? I can't find it anywhere... :( Great job by the way!

  • Fred and George = Merry and Pippin

    Sirius = Elrond

    Gandalf = Dumbledore

    great maches those are :D and great video, indeed

  • ron = legolas haha ^^

  • nice!!!! my brother said that it was like the hp characters were syaing the lotr lines.

  • Fucking brilliant!

  • Awesom!

  • This was really well done! You've combined the two most awesome movie/book series ever! THANK YOU!!

    Frodo and Harry have so much in common, it's scary...

  • lol that is great!!

  • Very nice!

  • Quite easily the most impressive HP Vid I have EVER seen!

  • This is perfect! Lord of the Rings really matches with Harry Potter...

  • haha! Fred and george = Merry and pippin. can anyone else say perfect? : ) loved it!

  • Oh wait, I'm sorry. I was from the Goblet of Fire.

  • What is the clip at 1:52? It doesn't look familiar.

  • 1:52 is from "The Goblet of Fire." It's the scene in which Cedric's father is mourning over Cedric's death.

  • When I looked at it again, I realized that it was Cedric's father. When I first looked at it,though, I thought it was maybe a sneak peek from a future movie or something.

  • I watched this sooo many times since I favorited it last summer and it's still so amazing! :)

  • this is going on to my facebook.

  • oh yes it is Sawliet.

  • And Harry Potter is not a piece of shit, LOTRpunk!

  • I like this alot!

    Good job!

  • Cool! Good job!:)

  • Wonderful job! That was so well done!

  • Yes everything fits perfectly, especially with the characters.

  • that was good!!

    XoXo

  • Wow! so cool! I've never seen this done before with LOTR. I've seen about a million Pirates of the Carribean ones but none of these. Well done.

  • You combined my 2 favorite movies! Go you!

  • holy bugger O_O

  • OMG that was so good. It could be a real movie trailer

  • omg dobby is amazing as smeegul

    i love this soooo good

    xxx

  • ohhh.. nice!

  • Respect! that was really good!

  • Very nice ::D:D

  • Sweet!

  • very well done-really liked the choice of voices to characters!!

  • EFFING PRO.

  • very nice job :]

  • Nicely made! :D

  • het is echt goed. maar remus als legolas, dat is minder. legolas hoort mooi te zijn. van binnen zal hij mooi zijn. had sirius genomen als legolas maar het blijft goed.

  • lol great vid

  • wow i like it..he voices is fitted with the charater...i like ut...great job...thank u...

  • sweet

    the voices fitted by the one you used

  • yea it is the same...hi...im new...thank u...

  • Really grate!

  • this is a really good video....im not a lord of the rings fan, but i love harry potter, and its great

  • that is AMAZING! You did an awsome job on it, the parts and the words went like they belonged together! I LOVED IT! <3

  • Thank you =] and thank you everyone else who commented it. I want to make another one but... I don't have my editing program anymore =/ gaaa

  • that was absolutely amazing!

  • great! every part fit just perfect! very good job!

  • I know I commented but why is Fleur Shelob. How did you get rid of The Basilisk's Head when Harry Points the sword up and how did you get the images to show for a little bit while people were talking

  • I just used fleur as that because she did a scream that matched the scream on the trailer sound clip... and in that particular clip the basilisk wasn't in that scene so Ididn't need to remove it. I also have this editing program where I can overlay clips so that's how I did it.

  • You owned the video Excellent work I'd give you an A+ for superiour work. Congradgulations

  • Wow, this was great. The lip synching was right on, and the whole trailer was just amazing! Perfect clips!

  • Wow...I am shocked! You did great lip sinking; it's great!

  • That was wonderful!

    Yes, we have to deside what to do with our time...

  • wow....well what can i say ... perfect! 'dont leave me'.... everything was in time .. well done!

  • wow - this was really well done, good job

  • Very nice =D I like that harry was both aragorn and frodo =P

  • Great sychronizing! Everyone's roles were awesomely matched--Fred and George are so Merry and Pippin. The only other thing I would have liked to see is the dementors as the ringwraiths. It would seem as though JK Rowling took quite a few ideas from Tolkien, eh?

  • Dude, Tolkien influenced the fantasy genre in so many ways, you find traces and more of him in amazing amounts of literature. Don't underestimate J.R.R.!! (plus, he and I have the same birthday exactly 100 years apart)

  • Exactly. I don't underestimate Tolkien. I love the world he has created and want to learn as much as I can about it. Plus, the movies are awesome! You were born in 1992? I suppose that wouldn't make you 42, then.