take any "traditional" music group from the present and show them to someone from the 1950s and they will criticize it as "mindless" and "just noise." call me crazy, but i think this is the way of the future.
You obviously don't know what you're talking about. People created more experimental music than this almost 100 years ago. Read something about dadaism, Luigi Russolo (search for him here on youtube), John Cage, avant-garde, vorticism, futurism, or go to UbuWeb web site and learn something.
@TMTKowalski i never claimed to be an expert on experimental music nor did i imply that black dice were more experimental than some of the greats you mentioned
I was just saying that this kind of music can never be "the way of the future" like you said because experimental approach to music started at the beginning of 20th century, so there is no any logic in that. It's like saying that electric guitar and distortion is "the way of the future" but we know that people used it for decades, that's all.
@TMTKowalski experimental music has always existed, hell the first song ever written was an experiment. and with your electric guitar metaphor, you're implying that all experimental music is the same even though its not. when electric guitar came out, it was an experiment.i looked up one of Luigi Russolos compositions and read the wikipedia article on him and a lot of things he did which were highly experimental during his time have now become commonplace in music, which i think proves my point.
Yeah, yeah, it's a common place... I've been playing drums and guitar in several experimental bands and I don't see that people going nuts on Arnold Schoenberg or John Cage's music on first place, not to mention bands like this. Not even 1% of all people don't listen experimental music. Same thing was 100 years ago, but only now you get that artificial feeling that is popular because we have internet and it's easier to be aware of all these things.
@TMTKowalski let's compromise: when it comes to experiments in music, some elements achieve success and popularity, while some elements do not. a lot of things that are popular now were at one point experiments, but a lot of experimental things have not become popular. fair enough?
Where people will criticize this as being "mindless" or "just noise", we have to realize that approaching music as having rules is not understanding the originally intended function.
This stuff is post-modern and pushes boundaries, because it is so different from other styles. People should appreciate that aspect of it.
it may be all that, but it is still somewhat thoughtless. in the same way abstract expressionism is somewhat thoughtless (and pisses people off in the same way). i think i kind of fall in the middle. i know from experience that it is very easy to sound weird but pretty impossible to sound weird and wonderful at the same time. i don't think they pull it off.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Yay! Black Dice got a delay pedal for Christmas! Even these guys wouldn't defend this poo-poo. Jandek rules, and I grew up listening to Glen Branca but this is SUB PAR!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Yay! Black Dice got a delay pedal for Christmas! Even these guys wouldn't defend this poo-poo. Jandek rules, and grew up listening to Glen Branca but this is SUB PAR!
Their sound is ridiculous; right up my alley. But this seems like one awkward ass of a show. A Gang Gang or Lightning Bolt show is a lot more suited for a crowd.
@BansheeeeBeat it's the song creature from the album creature comforts
dunceman9 7 months ago
battles? wtf nothing at all like this
pizzaROX 10 months ago
What is there to learn from this?
TheJohnSanderson 1 year ago
Sounds like transformers making fuck.
MirroredxGh0st 1 year ago 3
goddamn
clistere2 1 year ago
im all out of pot this is no longer interesting.
raarset1 1 year ago
too bad the mic couldnt handle the face-melting bass...
PoorSlothtrop 1 year ago
take any "traditional" music group from the present and show them to someone from the 1950s and they will criticize it as "mindless" and "just noise." call me crazy, but i think this is the way of the future.
xbyiu97 1 year ago 4
@xbyiu97 haha. no.
flabbyballsack 1 year ago
@flabbyballsack k bro
xbyiu97 1 year ago
@xbyiu97
You obviously don't know what you're talking about. People created more experimental music than this almost 100 years ago. Read something about dadaism, Luigi Russolo (search for him here on youtube), John Cage, avant-garde, vorticism, futurism, or go to UbuWeb web site and learn something.
TMTKowalski 1 year ago
@TMTKowalski i never claimed to be an expert on experimental music nor did i imply that black dice were more experimental than some of the greats you mentioned
xbyiu97 1 year ago
@xbyiu97
I was just saying that this kind of music can never be "the way of the future" like you said because experimental approach to music started at the beginning of 20th century, so there is no any logic in that. It's like saying that electric guitar and distortion is "the way of the future" but we know that people used it for decades, that's all.
TMTKowalski 1 year ago
@TMTKowalski experimental music has always existed, hell the first song ever written was an experiment. and with your electric guitar metaphor, you're implying that all experimental music is the same even though its not. when electric guitar came out, it was an experiment.i looked up one of Luigi Russolos compositions and read the wikipedia article on him and a lot of things he did which were highly experimental during his time have now become commonplace in music, which i think proves my point.
xbyiu97 1 year ago
@xbyiu97
Yeah, yeah, it's a common place... I've been playing drums and guitar in several experimental bands and I don't see that people going nuts on Arnold Schoenberg or John Cage's music on first place, not to mention bands like this. Not even 1% of all people don't listen experimental music. Same thing was 100 years ago, but only now you get that artificial feeling that is popular because we have internet and it's easier to be aware of all these things.
TMTKowalski 1 year ago
@TMTKowalski let's compromise: when it comes to experiments in music, some elements achieve success and popularity, while some elements do not. a lot of things that are popular now were at one point experiments, but a lot of experimental things have not become popular. fair enough?
xbyiu97 1 year ago 2
I didn't that they use to be 4. That's awesome.
misterbn 1 year ago
Comment removed
ohhhhhdavid 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Boring...zZZZzzzzZZZZZ
pradaisgay 2 years ago
Comment removed
cordlock 2 years ago
does anyone know what that white effects processor/pedal thing is that bjorn (guitarist) is using is?
kontube 2 years ago
that's a korg kaos pad. not sure which model
bicyclesecrets 2 years ago
ahhh yes thanks, i believe its the KP1 actually
kontube 2 years ago
Where people will criticize this as being "mindless" or "just noise", we have to realize that approaching music as having rules is not understanding the originally intended function.
This stuff is post-modern and pushes boundaries, because it is so different from other styles. People should appreciate that aspect of it.
nicky560 2 years ago
it may be all that, but it is still somewhat thoughtless. in the same way abstract expressionism is somewhat thoughtless (and pisses people off in the same way). i think i kind of fall in the middle. i know from experience that it is very easy to sound weird but pretty impossible to sound weird and wonderful at the same time. i don't think they pull it off.
wayfarin 2 years ago
I will never understand battles to blackdice comparisons
KenKowwwrb 2 years ago
i think the black dice to animal collective is total nonsense. black dice is black dice. no comparison.
waxanimalparts 2 years ago
Battles are an excellent band from Earth
Black Dice are an excellent band from another dimension.
Ramentastic 2 years ago 22
battles are good, black dice is better
JustusTubes 2 years ago 8
Battles are poo.
sheriffsixtyfour 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they opened for battles...made me leave and not come back
bobtheblob916 3 years ago
wow battles should have opened for them
watchthematrix 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
crap!!!!!!!!
chup1ladas 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow this is some shit, and ive heard shit
trainteeth 3 years ago
HISHAM! I'm seeing him this weekend yes I am
findingusernamesucks 3 years ago
IT'S FEEDING TIME!!!! - Thanks for this :D
jimsottile 3 years ago
i luv em man. this is not music this is pure sound wall!
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yay! Black Dice got a delay pedal for Christmas! Even these guys wouldn't defend this poo-poo. Jandek rules, and I grew up listening to Glen Branca but this is SUB PAR!
CertainSparks 3 years ago
awesome.
BeQuietPeter 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yay! Black Dice got a delay pedal for Christmas! Even these guys wouldn't defend this poo-poo. Jandek rules, and grew up listening to Glen Branca but this is SUB PAR!
CertainSparks 3 years ago
You're just jealous you're not in possession of the immense power Black Dice withholds.
SomeShows 3 years ago 5
uhhhhhh
BigMuthaFuckinLion 3 years ago
was this the Godspeed You Black Emperor tour? If so, I saw them then...yay
ForOctavioPaz 3 years ago
@ForOctavioPaz I think this was a few months after that tour ended.
dannynanner 1 year ago
who was the guy playing the drums?
personpitch92 3 years ago
is it hisham with a nearly shaved head?
Sloth131987 3 years ago
Hisham Bharoocha! Yes, it is him indeed.
SomeShows 3 years ago
the song being played is "Creature" off of the album Creature comforts.
littlecatpiano 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck noise rock.
i saw dinosaur junior last year, thats about the most i can take as far as noise.
paintballpete89 4 years ago
check out animal collective - cuckoo
reserve judgement
let it kick your ass
SurfaceToday 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
this is horrible
Orbitman2099 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
agreed... no direction
SurfaceToday 4 years ago
no direction?
andersersand 2 years ago
is that a clear guitar??
man, i hate how the sound ripples in and out towards the end, just when the song is picking up for a sort of climax.
yosky5411 4 years ago
Yeah, it's a Ampeg Dan Armstrong Guitar. They're neat guitars. Justin Pearson plays the same model, only it's a bass, in The Locust.
SomeShows 4 years ago
i luv em mannnnnnn. this is not music this is pure sound
wall!
steliocockey 4 years ago 3
This kind of sounds like the song Heavy Manners.
ConfuseGISMGauze 4 years ago
gülesim geldi.
emireaksoy 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is stupid
wiggermaniafag 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you're stupid
drdpatches 4 years ago
that was supposed to be a response to the "this is stupid" comment
good video
drdpatches 4 years ago
Their sound is ridiculous; right up my alley. But this seems like one awkward ass of a show. A Gang Gang or Lightning Bolt show is a lot more suited for a crowd.
willisdholla 4 years ago
Man, are you kidding? I would love to see them all at the same time! Much rather than just one or the other.
SomeShows 4 years ago
thx very much
claus4 5 years ago