I feel like this Skylar Grey girl sings as a more beaten down woman in this song, and although she is amazing, I prefer how Rihanna does it-- a strong woman.
I may sing this for a talent show in a week . Look at my video of this and comment if i should or should'nt ! Please ! Im 13 and i love to sing but i dont want to embarress my self at camp so please be honest ! <3 thank you sooo much !
this version is way better and i love eminem but on the rihanna version when eminem comes in and sings the rap part,... it kinda ruins the feeling and all.
guys what are u all talkin bout? we all got it now: Skylar wrote it, wuuhu and rihanna baught it,yeeeeeay, so what? she gave it to rihanna and I believe that she thought about it so wouldnt just give it, we all know, so who cares?! we cant change it right now ;) Both, Rihanna & skylar sing amazin so wouldnt make sense to be sad that rihanna baught it cause its waaay to late for that now :)
I like Skylar's version better because she's singing. Rihanna is a amazing singer but I find the rap part a bit... out of place. I guess you can say. Anyways, both are talented but just like Skylar's because you can feel more of it, I guess.
I like Rihanna. I really do. But in her version of the song all she does is wail, which is depressing because she is one of the few people with actual talent in the music industry. Skylar Grey like Rihanna has talent that lies here. Rihanna's talent does best in songs like S n M or What's my name. I hate how they don't give Skylar any credit, though. When she preformed with Eminem and Dr. Dre, there was no light one her. Just a shadow of the two rappers above her.
@musicisdead411 of course skylar grey sounds diff than rhianna cuz the are two different singer and skylar grey def wrote the song she def got nominated for a grammy for writin it yea just sayin!
Skylar grey co-wrote love the way you lie, with alex da kid. This was the original song, then rihanna sang her part and eminem came up with his own verses.
@joker5915 actually she wrote it, learn your facts before you go on. But she gave it to Rihanna cuz it would sell more, or something like that, which is ridiculous, cuz this is amazing :) oh well
I think the reason I like this version better is because you can feel all the emotions in her voice. Sure, you can hear a song being sung, but just because they can sing it doesn't mean they have anything to back it up with.
skylar should be making her own records instead of selling her songs. i was heartbroken when i couldnt find this song on itunes. only rihanna's version is being recognized, and it doesnt help that she's being arrogant about it by claiming that all the songs on her LOUD album are "all rihanna songs, songs that nobody else could do." but guess what? skylar does it way better!! dont get me wrong, i like rihanna. but im also a strong believer that the real talent lies in the songwriter.
@XxLouisexX1903 Rihanna's voice delivers a powerful and hateful feeling. Skylar Grey's version gives me sad feeling, and more sad when thinking that she actually wrote this song. Her true feeling I guess.
@karisma8teen get out of your ignorant little bubble and open your ears, skylar grey is WAAAAAYYY better than rhianna. But with no disrespect to rhianna, this ORIGINAL version should be recognized!
ppl listen to da words
sharledalewis 4 days ago
but you`ll always be my heroe. Even though you' ve lost your mind,
ximbakaye 1 month ago
skylar sounds soo much betta dan rihanna! skylar's mucch betta! <3 this shud ve been official! by skylar...
ShanotraRokk 1 month ago 2
rihannas better at this!
MizzNicexx 1 month ago
This wasnt the best....... It was okay though. Part one is WAY better thought
129LeeLee 2 months ago
@129LeeLee eh
pswereTS 2 months ago
Way better then Rihanna actual singing talent not filled with autotune.
TheAlbinoSeal 2 months ago 2
better than Rihanna - cheap black whore!
kiemthan1000 3 months ago
@kiemthan1000 dont v rude
pswereTS 2 months ago
Even angels have their wicked schemes
And you take that to new extremes
But you'll always be my hero
Even though you've lost your mind <3 :'(
PunkPrincess64378 3 months ago
like it <3 <3
Nourlove98 3 months ago
I liked the non-rap version of the other one but hated the rap parts. This one is alot better...no rap and more emotion. Love it.
Moviestoexcape 3 months ago
@Moviestoexcape That was Eminem. Fuck you.
TheJosephJinx 3 months ago
@TheJosephJinx A Little touchy are we? Not everyone has to like the same thing, like Eminen for example or rap.
Moviestoexcape 3 months ago
@Moviestoexcape If it's Eminem yes they do. It's like a law.
TheJosephJinx 3 months ago
Skylar DOES express emotion in her voice; whoever says she sings like a robot OBVIOUSLY are talking about a very talented and emotional robot
TheOrchDork87 4 months ago
ways better than Rihanna! ♥
brotsmoe 4 months ago
I wish she got more publicity than Rihana
aznicecream2 4 months ago 5
I Love This Song <3
lover2885 4 months ago
if you listen to rihanna's und skylar's song at the same time you hear that rihanna's voice is more powerful and emotional.
Rihanna 4 president! :D
mumumu9009 4 months ago
love her <3
TheCityofdemons 4 months ago
Skylar: I LOVE TODD GLASS
Tosh: I love the way you like (;
Mrneall94 5 months ago
Skylark sings her song better than rhianna ever could
peden12004 5 months ago 3
Dance Remix By CARLO CAVALLI
Erinanicolai 5 months ago
skylar grey is the best singer ever!!!!!!!!! thats my point of view everyone has different point of views and i really want to meet her someday
gunuroxs1 6 months ago 2
i love rihanna...it's the only singer that make me cry! really...i love their songs
rababika 6 months ago
@thebluejayinsilence no, skylar has more emotion in her voice, you can actually hear her pain. <3
SamStringer123 6 months ago 4
How the hell does she sound like a robot?!
LittleRedBabee18 6 months ago
Love the way you lie ernesto!!!!
LittleRedBabee18 6 months ago
ninjas have thier wicked schemes :D
griedel91 6 months ago
RIHANNA HAS SO MUCH MORE EMOTION IN HER VOICE,SKYLAR SINGS LIKE A ROBOT.thank you.
thebluejayinsilence 6 months ago
@thebluejayinsilence and taht my dear deserves a thumbs DOWN :) thank you :)
MissMadiILYEW 5 months ago
@MissMadiILYEW its ok i knew i would get a few people who didnt appreciate that comment lol
thebluejayinsilence 5 months ago
@thebluejayinsilence lol well it was enevitable
MissMadiILYEW 5 months ago
so wonderful!
MausiiTaNz 6 months ago
The people that didn´t like this song are crazy!
DragonFly5563 6 months ago 5
I love her voice and honestly i think this should be her song instead of rihannas
LittleRedBabee18 6 months ago 4
@LittleRedBabee18 is this her singing:L
Theres no proof of that:P
BabehhCookiesX 6 months ago
@BabehhCookiesX its her singing i met her and she wrote this song and she sang part of it too!
RENAMADBRITTEIARRA 6 months ago
I like her voice, it's so cute (:
PialiebtJojo 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
7abet Angel's have their wicked schemes <3 la allaaah <3
IS2Za0SKa 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ ◄ ▲ ► ▼ dammit. i dropped my bag of doritos
SaraThatsMe100 6 months ago
She sounds so....vulnerable and innocent. Weird.
19belle97 6 months ago 5
Shes good but I love and im serious I love!!!! Arianas cover better!!!!! But thts just my opinion :)
missalicesan 7 months ago
So much better than rihanna and Eminem's version.
JcrushX3 7 months ago 7
why am i just hearing this? she is so G0000000D
ELau013 7 months ago 7
Angel's have their wicked schemes <3
brothersgirl10 7 months ago 54
@brothersgirl10 best line in the whole song
pswereTS 2 months ago
I feel like this Skylar Grey girl sings as a more beaten down woman in this song, and although she is amazing, I prefer how Rihanna does it-- a strong woman.
CoolerThanHamm 7 months ago 2
you have to watch this girls cover and other ones (: ttheyre pretty good
dogpaw93 7 months ago
@dogpaw93 lolz thx :]
BewwaMichelle 7 months ago
I may sing this for a talent show in a week . Look at my video of this and comment if i should or should'nt ! Please ! Im 13 and i love to sing but i dont want to embarress my self at camp so please be honest ! <3 thank you sooo much !
ahmazinggrace1 7 months ago
Skylar Grey is so much better than Rihanna, (:
taraleeking 7 months ago
I like the last "I love the way you lie" which font is that?
SvenjaSuperstar 7 months ago
Skylar's version is soo much better! THIS is what should be playing on the radio!
16lgs16 7 months ago
i like skylar's better because live i know it wouldnt sound different... but rihanna's a different story :/
BewwaMichelle 7 months ago
M 0:00 RE SKYLAR!
gleek4everandalways 7 months ago
love you skylar!
themaskeduser12 7 months ago
her version knocks all the bad breath out of me
sunshinegirl2231700 8 months ago
this version is way better and i love eminem but on the rihanna version when eminem comes in and sings the rap part,... it kinda ruins the feeling and all.
packersgirl100 8 months ago
whoever says rihanna sings this better all i have to say is "i love the way you lie"
Rainbowrandom890 8 months ago 128
@Rainbowrandom890 nah man rihanna is way better she can actually sing
lolfunnypic4536 7 months ago
@Rainbowrandom890 This chick sounds half asleep. Ri's is perfection.
Outrajess 6 months ago
@Rainbowrandom890 lmfao
pswereTS 2 months ago
The words about angels having wicked schemes are a lil questionable. Great melody and passion
Notyelfox 8 months ago
thumb up if ypu cant see the dislike bar <3
stefhonderd 8 months ago 7
skylar, i love the way you sing(:
xoxjoe3brosxox 8 months ago 5
This song iz so filled with feeling n it's Soooo good I like skylar better tho
Kkbieber1994 8 months ago
skylar singgg!
1998vampire1 8 months ago in playlist my faves
guys what are u all talkin bout? we all got it now: Skylar wrote it, wuuhu and rihanna baught it,yeeeeeay, so what? she gave it to rihanna and I believe that she thought about it so wouldnt just give it, we all know, so who cares?! we cant change it right now ;) Both, Rihanna & skylar sing amazin so wouldnt make sense to be sad that rihanna baught it cause its waaay to late for that now :)
helosch 8 months ago
I like this version better because it sounds much more real
TheSantja 8 months ago 5
I like Skylar's version better because she's singing. Rihanna is a amazing singer but I find the rap part a bit... out of place. I guess you can say. Anyways, both are talented but just like Skylar's because you can feel more of it, I guess.
LethalConformity 8 months ago 2
Bro i aint gonna lie she's fine
LuCkYRaWBoY 8 months ago
....♥
Betha1996 9 months ago
six people are completely stupid
imPuffinWithBilly 9 months ago
I like Rihanna. I really do. But in her version of the song all she does is wail, which is depressing because she is one of the few people with actual talent in the music industry. Skylar Grey like Rihanna has talent that lies here. Rihanna's talent does best in songs like S n M or What's my name. I hate how they don't give Skylar any credit, though. When she preformed with Eminem and Dr. Dre, there was no light one her. Just a shadow of the two rappers above her.
Seriafly 9 months ago 2
@Seriafly That's what she wanted, from what I understand. She wants to be known for music, not for her appearance.
MissHollyGolightly22 8 months ago
i kind of like this version better
BriannaFunnygirl123 9 months ago
Both versions are BRILLIANT, but where is Eminem on this one? Im no fussed like, still a class song
procter866 9 months ago
it's good.
but RIHANNA SOUNDS MUCH BETTER , rihanna has much more emotion in this song.
MileyMichigan 9 months ago
@MileyMichigan because she only sings one verse!!
alyssahill49 9 months ago
Comment removed
Seriafly 9 months ago
WOW!Brilliant!!!I Love it!<3
LOLO4everpeace 9 months ago
I love skylar grey,amazing
docwhogirlkat 9 months ago
Im OBSESSED with this songg! :)
kassagrace 9 months ago 3
hiya she dose not sound the same cuz rhianna sings wi eminem and the girls who is singing is skylar grey so ha get a brain in future
sophie10rules 9 months ago
@sophie10rules
WTF!?
1.Ok, She doesn't sound the same - SHE SOUNDS SO MUCH BETTER THAT RIHANNA!!
2.So what if Rihanna sings with eminem - Arina Grande done the same as Skylar and Arina still sounded great with Eminem or not :/
3.WE KNOW SKYLAR GREY SINGS THIS WHY DO YOU THINK WE WANTED TO LISTEN TO IT ? :L
Thumbs up if you agree that Skylar should sing this instead of Rihanna -_-
SiennahhStar 9 months ago 5
wunderschön :****
KleinKolibri 9 months ago
Comment removed
KleinKolibri 9 months ago
i love her!! she should make more songs!
1998vampire1 9 months ago
The song are being preformed so beautiful, I love the text and Skylar sing this song best way of all ways, no doubt. Reminds me of so much...
Thumbs up for Skylar (Y)
RolfTora 9 months ago
skylar is WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY better than rhianna.... just sayin
c1loveable 9 months ago
@musicisdead411 of course skylar grey sounds diff than rhianna cuz the are two different singer and skylar grey def wrote the song she def got nominated for a grammy for writin it yea just sayin!
kikicool01 10 months ago
go skylar grey!!
FallenAngel9977 10 months ago
I think its "Then the saint" But whatever .-.
annekeazureheart 10 months ago
skylar doesnt sing THAT well
she sounds almost like a frog
i mean i guess shes okay
but rihanna is way better
& besides SKYLAR DID NOT WRITE "love the way you lie"
THAT WAS ALLLLLLLLL EMINEM
this was posted on feb 2nd
the other vid was posted august 2010 !
SHE DID A COVER ON LOVE THE WAY YOU lie
& then rihanna bought the right & blah blah blah.
musicisdead411 10 months ago
@musicisdead411
Skylar grey co-wrote love the way you lie, with alex da kid. This was the original song, then rihanna sang her part and eminem came up with his own verses.
xRJFILMSx 10 months ago
@musicisdead411 yes... because these songs were definately posted onto youtube in the order that they were written... :/
Yes, Skylar Grey DID in fact write this first. THEN Eminem added his parts to it. I don't know why you would refuse to accept that...
eoneil55 10 months ago
@musicisdead411 chill
dirie5 10 months ago
I love this one so much more than what wats her face did. she cant sing, sorry if that offends anyone, Skylar can just sing better. Alot, better. =)
Underpressuregirl21 10 months ago 2
Aha wow I thought these were Ariana Grande's lyrics..but i guess not. Chek out her s too tho (:
DeathBite13 10 months ago
I like Skylar Grey better. She actually seems, I dunno, she sounds more powerful in soul somehow, even though not in voice.
SharpguardTheHard 10 months ago
OMG I LUV THIS SONG! <3
Mcfoo11 10 months ago
I like this version better.
chickenchopsocky 10 months ago 2
SHE LOOKS LIKE KE$HA!!!!!!!!
cupcakegurls909 10 months ago
@cupcakegurls909 she doesnt..? if she did, Skylar is the most beautiful version of her.
DefinitionInfinition 10 months ago
@DefinitionInfinition i meant in that picture,i know she is way prettier,its just she looks like a MESS in the pic.......get it?
cupcakegurls909 10 months ago
@cupcakegurls909 oh ._."
DefinitionInfinition 10 months ago
both skylar and rihana have great voices but rihanas voice fits more the lyrics are suposed to be sung with power skylar is too soft
glueslix 10 months ago
this version kicks ass.
PartyFreak690 10 months ago
That's soooo amazing *-*
Frema96 10 months ago
this is the first version... its also the best :)
raychriscarlson 10 months ago
Wait I forgot to click the like button
whitesnowable 10 months ago
Omg!!!!I love her voice more than Rihanna
whitesnowable 10 months ago
Lmaao I'm gonna remember these lyrics and sing them when with friends so they say "WTF?" and then I can say "This is the original stu
echidnah1 10 months ago
well i think that rihanna has a more powerful voice this person has a more calm voice
Roseyo111 10 months ago
To see if Rihanna wanted it incase ur konfused
joker5915 10 months ago
Itwas never Skylars song it was a demo to see if she wanted it so she dont own it
joker5915 10 months ago
@joker5915 actually she wrote it, learn your facts before you go on. But she gave it to Rihanna cuz it would sell more, or something like that, which is ridiculous, cuz this is amazing :) oh well
Rayne7Sunshine 10 months ago
i like this version better
bethanyjamesforevery 10 months ago
i love skylar's voice
it is so soft and pure
i like rihanna, but i think skylar's version is better
angelface123ish 10 months ago
Luv this song!!!!
alyssaap4 10 months ago
this is well good she is amazing :) i cant believe it was her song first i always thought it was rihannas x
xXcRaZyPuMpKiNxX 10 months ago
rihanna's better
sweetdeath25 10 months ago
i am impressed(::
jujubeejules55 10 months ago
even angels have their evil schemes,
and you take that to new extremes.
but, you'll always be my hero,
even though you've lost your mind...
0:32
XxMangoIceCreamxX 10 months ago 2
But you'll Always be my hero.
Even tho you've lost your mind... 0:43
i love this part<3
SkyLeeRayann24 10 months ago
i like skylar grey's version better
bella60906 10 months ago 114
@bella60906 me too. much better.
SkyLeeRayann24 10 months ago
skylar is good and makes any rap music sound good but i preffer rihanna for this song
alahli95 10 months ago
i like skylar better but she shoulda put eminem in with her! that would be the best ever :)
lovergurl275 10 months ago 3
this is way better than eminem and rihanna no offense... this song is amazing... Skylar Grey did awesome :)
tinkerbell95ninja 11 months ago
Skylar Grey is amazing,she should keep her songs, Rihanna better have paid a lot .
MMathersManiac 11 months ago 2
and rihanna recieves all the credit and becomes even more famous........
MajoG10 11 months ago
scratch that last post. Skylar has like no emotion when she sings this song, Rihanna sings it with feeling and emotion.. just sayn(::
linkinlover8901 11 months ago
Rihanna almost sounds mad in her version skylar's voice is so sweet.
linkinlover8901 11 months ago
love it ; love it ; love it ; love it ♥
XxMusicgoddessxX 11 months ago 2
Anyone can sing... but it takes skill to sing like THAT.
bballgrl90210 11 months ago 2
I think the reason I like this version better is because you can feel all the emotions in her voice. Sure, you can hear a song being sung, but just because they can sing it doesn't mean they have anything to back it up with.
japanesselilly12 11 months ago
skylar should be making her own records instead of selling her songs. i was heartbroken when i couldnt find this song on itunes. only rihanna's version is being recognized, and it doesnt help that she's being arrogant about it by claiming that all the songs on her LOUD album are "all rihanna songs, songs that nobody else could do." but guess what? skylar does it way better!! dont get me wrong, i like rihanna. but im also a strong believer that the real talent lies in the songwriter.
Harry4Hermione4Harry 11 months ago 49
eminem should be on this version unstead...
bakerskater47 11 months ago
luv her voise
Methdecal 11 months ago
' and youll always be my hero, even though you've lost your mind." MY FAVORITE PART EVVVERRRR ILOVEYOU
nextinline04005 11 months ago
where can i get this song?
ThaPianoMan15 11 months ago
an angel sent from above :)
crazyblondi6 11 months ago
She should be able to go further in her music carrier!
playwithjustice 11 months ago
Just so you all now
This is the ORIGINAL
NOT the 2nd part
eminem n rihanna did the cover
so this is #1
and rihanna&eminems cover is #2 :)
groxy2 11 months ago
I think that skylar has a better voice.. but rihanna suits the song better.. she sings it with more power.. which suits the song.. <3
XxLouisexX1903 11 months ago
@XxLouisexX1903 Rihanna's voice delivers a powerful and hateful feeling. Skylar Grey's version gives me sad feeling, and more sad when thinking that she actually wrote this song. Her true feeling I guess.
playwithjustice 11 months ago
100XX BETTER THAN OTHER 1..<3 THIS SONG
thecoolbucket171 11 months ago
story of my life.
bubbleybubbles1997 11 months ago 3
love the beggining <3
evilsisterslol 11 months ago
this is good but I prefer Rihanna! after all, it is Rihanna's..
SelGomezFan4Lifee 11 months ago
@SelGomezFan4Lifee after all rihanna bought this of skylar grey
ojfw200 11 months ago
@SelGomezFan4Lifee no its not
DriveMeNuts98 11 months ago
@SelGomezFan4Lifee not origonally. Skyler Grey wrote it first. rihannah baught it.
bubbleybubbles1997 11 months ago
@bubbleybubbles1997 which means she (Skylar) she wrote Rihanna's part in Love The Way You Lie ft. Eminem, right?? woah....
SelGomezFan4Lifee 11 months ago
@SelGomezFan4Lifee yep!!
bubbleybubbles1997 11 months ago
@SelGomezFan4Lifee actually, this isn't Rihanna's song, it's Skylar's.
Silvericewarriorcats 11 months ago
bettttttttttttteeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr than the other 1 xx10
thecoolbucket171 11 months ago
bettttttttttttteeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr than the other 1xx10
thecoolbucket171 11 months ago
its really amazing! iliked it soo much! iknow thts not rihanna singing but rihana sing it too right?
jasmine4457 11 months ago
Wow ! Rihanna sounds so different to the real the version on the c-d.
HelloKatie110 11 months ago
@HelloKatie110 that's because this isn't rihanna :P...this is skylar gray, otherwise known as holly brook
HitsBeforetheRadio 11 months ago 61
@HitsBeforetheRadio
Oh ok thanks !
HelloKatie110 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate it rihana wrote it. even if skyar wrote it but she singed horribe. rihana is way better
karisma8teen 11 months ago
@karisma8teen y the helll r u commenting if u hate it so much and she does not sing horrible she sings bester than u ever will so backk off
MegaCrispy23 11 months ago
@karisma8teen get out of your ignorant little bubble and open your ears, skylar grey is WAAAAAYYY better than rhianna. But with no disrespect to rhianna, this ORIGINAL version should be recognized!
randomperson52147 11 months ago
@HitsBeforetheRadio hahahahahaha!!!!!!!EPIC FAIL!!
cupcakegurls909 10 months ago
@HelloKatie110 Thats not Rihanna! :D
TheBlackBalthasar 10 months ago
<3 This song!! <3 <3 <3
TheKyeKee 11 months ago
Skylar Grey did write this song and its better than rhiannas version and the rapping makes it worse this is wayyyyy better
CreamKittyKat212 11 months ago 3
It was ok...
LoveKenzerz 11 months ago