hilary duff and joel madden - jilary - it was real love!!

[maebabydancer]

Funny cause half of those pics are of Nicole and Joel they r just blurry!

[Judcc]

Would you rather go to Joel and Nicole, they are very very happy, Hilary and I wish him bad in his false life and marriage, his reputation falls to the bottom, not being happy or personally (do not expect this will happening not spoken with his sister, the family is red hot Duff) or at work.

[Judcc]

I'm glad that Joel with Nicole, but I'm glad with that unnameable Hilary this man for his love is a lie. Not stand, nor want. He is getting cheated on Hilary. Are also contract for a single document, and dealers said that they do and say not to prejudice his work and to be famous.

[Judcc]

Hilary's silly that was cut with Joel and he.

I do not know if your love run forever.

[kimbizzler89]

she was soooo skinny the entire time they were together, then they broke up...and she started to look healthy again :S

[7marysun7]

hi ,i hate joel .he make hilary duff anorexic ,she is fine with mike now....good video!

bye!

[cheekyoziechick]

He will never get over the love he felt for her but he has moved on to bigger and better things now. I love him and Nicole together and they are such proud parents. He's the best!

[AshKatalyst]

Aww. I love them both. Arent they sweet.... :) Anyways, good job on the video! ;D

[eline55]

Thank you :D

[Wudupbro]

what song is this!

[eline55]

the 1st song is "i will be" and the 2nd song is "when you're gone" , both songs are by Avril Lavigne (:

[Wudupbro]

Yo thank you so much! the first one is so good!

[eline55]

no problem!

& i like the first one too!

[PiinkPriincessPolkaD]

i love them @ 4:52

[xXjaleyproductionsXx]

i think things happen for a reason...so they were cute...but its over noww.... i think they are good parents thoughh...(nicole and joel:))

[yellow2]

i like this video!!

=]

[eline55]

thank you (:

[nicolefan76]

jilery sucks

[BRONXPEPE]

why did they break up they did look cute togther but he also looks good with nicole

[dongwookbaby]

love the pix in 4:54...hilary is way too pretty compared to nicole..she looks like a chiuachua..

[goshxe]

good job. the vid is really nice

[eline55]

thx:D

[goshxe]

i miss JILARY!

[eline55]

me to!i dont like hilary with mike, but i like joel with nicole i bet that they r a good mommy and daddy

[KTB4793]

aw. i loved them.

[eline55]

yeah me to, sad that they broke up

[007bri007]

aww sweet vid, but u shud move on, joels with sum1 else noe with a baby, hes not hangin on past and neithers hilary so why are you?

[eline55]

i have move on now, this vid was 2 months ago, i have already a new video of joel and hilary in their new lives, it is called "hilary and joel together and apart" u have to check it out plz,

[lizzieMG4]

im in love with this video!!!

[eline55]

ooh that's sweet:D

[RalEnCeTyYy]

awesome video , what is the name of the first song ?!

[eline55]

thx,

song: "i will be" by avril lavigne, i love it!

[iZahOlly15]

that was amazing!

great job!

;)

[eline55]

thx

[wondufful]

:-( miss them together

[eline55]

i miss them to!! so much

[lizzieMG4]

Great job, great great!!

I love Hilary and joel together, they made the perfect couple i feel really sorry for the break up!!

Awsome job, i love the song!!!

:)

[eline55]

i feel sorry for the break up to!... they where so perfect!!

do you know who dump who? cuse i read everytime something difrent on internet sometimes they said that joel broke up by phone and sometimes they said that hilary broke up with joel .... do you know it?

[lizzieMG4]

yeah people made a lot of things, and im don't have sure either! but i read in a recent interview with Hilary that she break up with him, cause just wasnt right anymore! But i don't know! i guess we will never know ;) i respect that she doesnt wanna talk about that! xxxx ;)

[eline55]

yea she has her on live...it's just something between hilary and joel

[Brendagc22]

great job!

[eline55]

thx!