When Johnny Comes Marching Home Again

[TheDomtar]

These words are not enough to express this movie: EPIC BEAST BOSSS AWESOME

[fmj29redux]

im 18 and this is my favorite movie. fuck special effects. i like great movies with great actors, plots and scenes like this!

[Captain1diot]

Just watched Staleg 17, had to listen to this again.

[TrgdyAnn]

Klassic Willam Holden. One of my fav War Movies!

[LuanThompson666]

ahuauhauh ahh eu racho

[JojexD]

é baixinha e lesbica curti uma xaninha tem q para com isso mano só cata mina feia e corta esse cabelo senao nem uma garota bonita vai se quer chegar perto de vc

[LuanThompson666]

huauhauha vai se fude

[JojexD]

luan comenta alguma coisa ae manolo e a tua namorada baxinha é mto feia vei e ainda bisexual

[TheMuddyMudcrab]

just watched this film and this is the best scene in it!

feeling patriotic to this although i'm german :D

[9akashi]

i had to hear this today

[SamGOML]

Sounds wierd but I wanted to listen to this song because of rememberance day !! R.I.P

[WorldWar2Boy]

Stalag 17 is the best funniest serious World War 2 movie ever made :)

And it is overall a very, very nice War movie. One of the best ever made, but my top 3 is The Great Escape (all time no. 1), The Longest Day and Where Eagles Dare. :)

[nukester]

Gay means happy, end of story. (forget all that homosexual bullcrap)

[myavo]

Yes because some people can have gay feelings and may not be happy about it.

[fishermen755]

i <3 stalage 17

[nycdweller]

One of my favorite movies - ever!!

[bizybuzz619]

i remember this the guy in the leather jacket was 1 of those special trained Nazis to infultrate american bases he was trained to sound american and act american

[mrs34n]

great movie classic

[DiscoDude82]

When I saw the second top comment, I thought to myself, "Dear god, there are people who don't know the definition of 'gay'?"

[primogennaio]

Didn't know the song was in this movie. We got Bin Laden! God Bless America.

[thefailmaster357]

21 one people didnt come marchin home again with johnny

[thefailmaster357]

that be wiered if the navy seal that shot bin laden was named johnny

[yrtuag]

This song stirs my soul. God Bless America !

[slicked25]

We got Bin Laden. Turn this song up.

[yrtuag]

@slicked25 AMEN !

[marcusmanslaughter]

The song is called "When Jhonny Comes Marching Home Again" It's an old civil war hymn. Brilliant fucking song.

[toby4700]

As much as I like this movie, there's no denying how freaking wierd it is. It bounces back and forth from Hogen's Heroes style comedy to blanket parties, people being killed, and a character ment to represent Holocaust victims.

[CoolerKing37]

@toby4700 Billy Wilder was a master at balancing the funny and the serious.

[toby4700]

@CoolerKing37 Apparently, and it is good to have a bit of humor here and there to brake up depressing mood.

[20thCenturyVole2]

@zikmam01 know your classic movies.

[zikman01]

Die Hard III.

[abundela76]

America gives hope to it's Soldiers in real life, terrorists in 'After-Life'!!!

[cmania26]

We'll all feel "gay" when Johnny comes marching home again

[crazy031089]

@cmania26 originaly feeling gay meant feeling happy (wikipedia: "The term gay was originally used to refer to feelings of being "carefree", "happy", or "bright and showy"") so they are not singing about homosexuality

[starrbeatlesqueen]

@crazy031089 Yeah. I wish it was still associated with talking about being happy and carefree. Now it's so stuck in people minds as the term for homosexuality that we don't use that word for its original meaning anymore.

[nonplayerzealot4]

@crazy031089 The term "gay" as happy, etc was commonplace and used in songs as far along as the 1960s. In the standard American lexicon, it was used predominantly to mean those things as well. I recently heard an FDR speech where he used it. Don't know when / how it took the alternate meaning so thoroughly. Just goes to show how language is ever evolving.

[jdmifsud14]

this scene makes me want to be with group of POW's and be apart of the war!

[LadyComment]

Andy Carroll, Liverpool's number 9 :))

[MrCokeman468]

This is one of my all-time favorite movies.

[iulian4ik1989]

this room remembers me to hogan's heros:) cool song. greets from germany!

[onzir]

I was singing and whisling this at army all-the-fucking-time xD

[4862cjc]

@onzir Dear Sir, I concur! As a matter of fact, I was standing up and swing my fist back and forth, as if I was following the Animal and Shapiro in the parade!

[LordRestor]

Ein wunderbarer Marsch!!! Bin durch "Stirb Langsam: Jetzt erst recht" drauf gekommen. Einfach wunderbar!

Grüße aus Deutschland!

[Jamesmac30]

This could be classed as a spoiler if you haven't seen the movie - luckily i have

[1991Pavle]

Po zimi kisi suncu snegu ili kosavi, mi bodrimo te uvek ZVEZDO, ma gde bila ti, pravi Delija, veran je ko pas uvek ZVEZDO racunaj na nas! NA NA NA NA NA

watch?v=rBefCdCpH7E

[NaziZombiefan82]

and wat war did dat take place?

[Kouma013]

There are kinds of scenes that you see only once in your entire life and never forget. This is one of them.

[MrGrange1000]

There was a time when the word GAY was nice and it almost brings a tear to my eye to see how it's different now. Nevertheless its a great song!!

[TheBlueCream]

fabulous scene...love this movie

[msvioletaa09]

18 people don't know good movie when they watch one

[fishingboy11]

lalalalalalalalalalalalalalala­lalalalalalal

[poxfin]

on kipru maassa taitavin hurraa hurraa

[jyfnjy]

If it wasn't for this movie Magnum would have never figured out Nuzo was a double agent in vietnam and then blown Ivans brains outs.....Only a few will know what I mean.... Did you see the sun rise this morning Ivan. Best seen ever, PERIOD...............

[js8533]

loved this movie. great scene good song.

[Depravedmaniac666]

Everyone oughta listen too the original song "Johnny I hardly knew ye" which was an anti war protest song.

[SoleMan117]

One of the greatest war movies ever made.

[fishingboy11]

get da guns and ammo and devend our contrey

[braziliannyc]

@BigSmoke2222

Search for

The McKenzie Break Intro

[JUNKKKIESfc2010]

Homeless homeless homeless homeless hoops

homeless homeless homeless homeless hoops

23 years without a ground and rovers rovers rent a ground

and theyll never ever ever own a home ... AGAIN

homeless......................­...............

[JUNKKKIESfc2010]

when ian goes marchin down the wing bermo bermo

when ian goes marchin down the wing bermo bermo

when ian goes marchin down the wing all the fans will stand and sing

WE ALL KNOW THAT BERMO'S gonna score!

[PlavusaProstakusa]

Po zimi , kisi , suncu , snegu ili kosavi , mi bodrimo te uvek ZVEZDO ma gde bila ti ! Pravi DELIJA veran je ko pas - pas uvek Zvezdo racunaj na nas !

[Ribulose15diphosphat]

I don't talk english, very well, but it seems to be a parody, or ?

[jdmifsud14]

@Ribulose15diphosphat its not a parody its a story about American Prisoners of War in Germany during World War 2. they are just singing a song to keep the motivation up :)

[BigSmoke2222]

I wonder if German soldiers did this in Allied POW camps. Too bad there arent movies about any of them

[jdmifsud14]

@BigSmoke2222 they probably did, have you seen the movie the battle of the bulge? cause in it the Germans sing this song and I guess its like patriotic to them so they sing it when the go to battle in the movie. but yeah they probably did sing to keep the motivation up.

[BigSmoke2222]

@jdmifsud14 Ah, i'll have to check out that movie. They sing THIS song or one of their german patriotic songs?

[jdmifsud14]

@BigSmoke2222 well they (the german troops) sing a patriotic german song in the movie "the battle of the bulge". If you want to see the video clip of the song, search on youtube: "Panzerlied Scene From Battle of the Bulge" and it should have the song in it.

[Lamporre]

@BigSmoke2222

John Irvin's got this one film planned called "Red Gold" about Italian POW's taken to North America. Dunno if it's gonna be made or not, but it would definitely be a new angle to see the war from.

[Prairielander]

@Lamporre My great uncle actually worked at a PoW camp here in Canada and many of the Germans were happy to stay there. Many even returned to Canada after the war. Most were all well treated and fed and could work in the farms or lumber camps. It is something not very well known either but Canada actually had over 30,000 PoW's mostly from Britain out of fear in case of invasion they would be let out.

[JimmySteller]

@Prairielander

There's a Canadian book called "The Other Side of the Bridge", part of the story set around the Second World War. Two of the characters are German POWs working on a farm in northern Ontario. It was one of my favourite parts of the story to see them interact with the main character, and how they slowly begin to really trust each other and communicate.

[Bigband78]

@Prairielander ,My 93 year old uncle Arnold spent 27 months in German prison camps after being captured in N.Africa and he's still alive.He loved this movie but don't mention Rudebacher soup to him,because the Germans fed them turnips and potato e peels to keep them healthy.By the way the German Plant(Peter Graves)just died recently and his brother James Arness (Gunsmoke) still is alive.

[TheADK1994]

@BigSmoke2222 they did germany and usa agreed to take care of POW

[Memati7777]

cool song

[MiracleKD18]

Gay song is gay song!

[Ranger360counterstrk]

Dunbar is the spy!

[BigSmoke2222]

@Ranger360counterstrk Dunbar isn't the spy silly, Price is, this scene reveals it, no need for a warning spoiler, hehe

[whyyoufatty]

@Ranger360counterstrk when you comes crying hell

[Ranger360counterstrk]

@whyyoufatty When you fail as a fail troll.

[Smiley6669]

Does anybody know who sang this in the 60's or early 70's? My brother had it on a 45 but I can't find that version on youtube. Theirs another Cival War song from that era also I can't think of the name, they sing about chasing the other side and using a gator for a cannon :)

[Smiley6669]

@Smiley6669 I found 1 of the songs I was looking for, "Battle of New Orleans, In 1814" by Johnny Horten, I was only off by about 150 years thinking it was a Civil War song but I haven't heard it in close to 30 years.

[Klauserl1977]

What is the name of this movie?

[Smiley6669]

@Klauserl1977 Stalag 17, the whole movie is posted on youtube in 10 minute segments, I remember watching it years and years ago, I'll watch it again when I get time.

[Yugo91]

@Klauserl1977 Stalag 17

[cheeseshoes]

I laughed when he got shot by his own men

[BigSmoke2222]

Great GREAT movie! I love this movie so much! Animal is so awesome! :P

[davebex13]

I'd like to pose a question. Did all of you realize when you saw this scene that he was the spy, or did you think he was trying to mess up the real spy's "mail system"? Just wondering...

[semisanity]

@davebex13 I thought he was the spy the first time I saw this scene. Don't know about other people.

[drlee2]

@davebex13 Yeah, I knew when I saw the scene that Price was the real spy. This is probably my favorite scene from the film, too...the irony of it all!

[Atalay9498]

@davebex13 very good question imho... it has been ages so I can't remember properly,but the guy seems to shiny and I guess I thought he was trying to find the spy..or both ways..

[Cdub2k]

@davebex13

No figured that he was the spy. At first I thought maybe the spy was Joey

[lks052077]

great movie

[switchstand]

One of the great movie scenes of "who's the fink" and "at last I've got my first clue".

[AragonKingofmacedon]

The people who dislike these are stupid terrorists and muslims! xD

[stevher]

I love this movie and this is the best part of it. Thanx for the video !!

[0000syu]

これはこの映画の中でも名シーンですねえ！

[metallicakid516]

Stalag 17 is a classic! I am only 16 and this is one of my favorite movies ever! The great escape was great but I like this movie alot more. William Holden brought so much to this movie! Some of my friends say its gay to like black and white movies but I dont care this movie is just too great! Oh and ANIMAL RULES!!!

[jaygill02128]

I've said this before but it bears repeating. Peter Graves does a STELLAR acting job in this scene. Just enough, no dialogue and we really get it. Really cool collected job in an awesome film! Look how he follws them back to the table and matter of factly and dilliberately yanks the cord out if the loop. Great

[MrMetal12332]

What the fck...what kind of idiots click on dislike!!!???

[barbozavera]

fernando torres liverpool´s number nine

[jrm8899]

sadly, they don't make movies like this anymore....an actual story with great acting...sorry kids, no explosions, no special effects....this movie would be tough to remake, ...but if anyone could ,it would have to be Clint Eastwood....i could see Matt Damon in the William Holden part and Leonardo DiCaprio in the Peter Graves part

[KirolyWas]

Forget what them boys is talking bout, I'm true-I'm true

You riding swangs you gripping grain, I do-I do

You candy red you candy blue, you popping trunk you jamming Screw

Don't know about you, but I'm true-I'm true

And THEY STOLE IT!! :-D

[reverent1993]

what is this with the lamp?!

[metallicakid516]

@reverent1993 The guy price is the rat who had been snitching on the men and the lamp is the flag for the mail if there a loop in the cord it means incoming mail if its down there is no mail

[NARUHINAISAWESOME]

My teacher showed me this movie a couple weeks ago I have to say it is one of the most exhilarating movies I have ever seen in my life so far besides 300. P.S. SPARTANS FTW!

[barbozavera]

torres torres!!

[iceninebx]

great song and a great movie

[theyarinsizadam]

11 saniye erol günaydın

[jcinla76]

Hopefully nobody will dare to make a remake of this amazing movie.

[m1dlguk]

@jcinla76 Steven Fry and Hugh Laurie parodied it back in the late 80's - a full featured film, not a clip or sketch. Never say no-one would dare, because they will.

[houlihanw]

@jcinla76 they fucking better not remake, we got too many crappy remakes already and William Holden will come out of his grave to light a cigar on your face and kick your ass.

[TheMaxACDCJohnLennon]

@jcinla76 or from the song!

[Sabinrene]

this is one of the top 3 movies in history imo.

[choff56]

@Sabinrene  absolutely aggree

[whyyoufatty]

@Sabinrene so fuckin what!?

anybody dont ask you about your favorite movie.

please die.

[indoorin]

I love this movie. But can anyone tell me what the song was that was intermixed with when johnny comes marching home again in the beginning?

[Stevens89265]

I have this film on DVD. Wonderful film. When I watched this scene, I watched this prisoners sing, and yet I never paid attention to Peter Graves acting in this scene. A few days after he died, I watched the film again. And I paid attention to P.G. in this scene. His acting was brilliant in this scene. I couldn't believe how I hadn't noticed this scene before. Wonderful acting. May he rest in peace.

[HihiouZabimaru182]

lol at 2:48!!! he's just like "omg i'm surrounded by idiots..." XD

[dino00555]

Outstanding Movie!

[sneezersneezer]

Such a cool scene, such a cool movie.  And William Holden was the best. Never be another like him. The only one who got close was Steve McQueen.

[Stevens89265]

I first watched this movie with my step-dad on Christmas break about 5 years ago. Now I own it. This my favorite scene.

[starrbeatlesqueen]

Even though Peter Graves is the bad guy in this movie, I love him in this. He's one of my favorite actors.

[starrbeatlesqueen]

RIP Peter Graves. He passed away today from sudden heart attack after collapsing. He would have been 84 this week on March 18. He is mostly notable for his role on Mission: Impossible! (the TV series and its revival) and the pilot captain in the Airplane! movies.

[VRichardsn]

Im so sad to hear it... :(

I ve just watched the movie Yesterday, and I wasn t aware of it.

Q.E.P.D.

[starrbeatlesqueen]

@VRichardsn Yeah I was real sad too. What was strange is that before he died, I was thinking about this movie and that he was one of the last ones from that movie still alive (in fact I thought he was the only one still alive, but there are still a few alive). However, he was the second to last of the major actors from the film. Richard Erdman is now the last member of the main cast (he'll be 85, come June).

Gil Stratton died 2 years ago at 86. The others died over 20 years ago.

[VRichardsn]

@starrbeatlesqueen

Time goes by so fast :(

[facebreaker82]

The nazi informer gets owned

[fireman041]

I love this movie ... from the US

[OldMamaSan]

Saw this movie 2 month ago for the first time. i love him. I'm from Germany, but i love to see the Germans so stupid. :)

[GrayEyesWorld]

why is this more popular in germany and sweeden than in the US? do sweeds and germans really like a song not in their language so much?

[Lilja20]

We love great music. We dont care what language its in. Just as long as the music and song is good.

[applehelperguy]

play it on the trombone

[starrbeatlesqueen]

I love this song. It was this movie that made me like the song in the first place. :)

Unfortunately, I don't think too many others appreciate it, but that's just my opinion.

Also, this is one of my favorite scenes of the movie.

[beatlord1]

im feeling so gay right now such a wonderful song cant get it out of my head either LOL=)

[hanseat1887]

yeah. i was searching for this song for a long time. it´s a song out of the movie: "die hard3"

[jwdundon]

is there a link to the DR. Strangelove version? 10 years I been looking for THAT version, so far NO LUCK!!!!

[clintonearlwalker]

It seems to me the entire movie of Dr. Strangelonve is posted on YouTube, or a least it was, I've watched it twice. I guess it still is.

[jwdundon]

@clintonearlwalker -- it is, BUT, I WANT the version of johnny FROM the movie, I can't find the composer!!!! OR VERSION!!!

ANY ideas?!

THANKS

[4490red]

Its an old Irish song, "Johnny I Hardly Knew Ye". Bastardized over the years into this.

[jdmifsud14]

by " Johnny" do they mean America? like "Johnny America"

[seanster42]

Old Civil War tune...sung by both sides during the war. "Johnny" being any soldier.

Great Scene. One of my favorite movies

[Beseda1989]

Johhny is reference to John Rourke, husband of Patrick Gilmore's sister.

[Schmidt1942]

Its a civil war song. It's expressing populations longing for the return of their friends and relatives who were fighting.

[RagingAura]

the rebels called the northerners the Billy Yanks

the northerners called the southerners

Johnny Rebel

the name stuck

[corampublico]

Does anyone know where to find this song with chorus or a name of it included the chorus (older version).

by all that is right and fair you american guys have the best military song and so forth!

[Salamanderkill]

The Die Hard version is a variant on this song titled "The Ants come marching home". Music sheet is very close.

Man, the flamers just dont know what to flame anymore. I guess its tough having to like that uncle who saves your ass every two seconds (militarily or ecenomically) and then have to tolerate their people. Anyways, back on planet earth ... hehehehehe

[leongedeon]

I see this movie when was a child, and this song is like brilliant in my memory

[OKStudios]

Do they really say "And we will all feel gay when johnny comes marching home"?

[D3m0n7x]

yes in fact they do that, ofcourse one must understand that the real defenition of gay means happy, not homosexual, that second meaning was added much later

[jdmifsud14]

yes and back then gay meant happy not homosexual.

[Smiley6669]

@jdmifsud14 This happy guy came into my grandmothers work place years ago and she told him she thought he was a very gay fellow, she meant it as a compliment but he took it as an insult and explained the new meaning of the word gay.

[jdmifsud14]

@Smiley6669 yeah times change, unfortunately everyone is familiar with the word "gay" as being homosexual and not "gay" as in happy and cheerful (not being homosexual)

[vaadaenmacchi]

william holden's finest movie!

[kmichellee81]

Great movie!!! Great song!

[lawrencelugar7777]

I heard this on Die Hard with a Vengeance.

I love this song!

[Robertz1986]

When Johnny Comes Marching Home is an extremely well known patriotic song, so I would be shocked if it wasn't already quite familiar to you (unless your really young or from overseas). Its a pro-federal government patriot song from the civil war.

[webisdreck]

fernando torres liverpools number 9!

[muzzyboy83]

Are you retarded?

[X1mi]

watch the movie, dipsh*t :P

[jmb307]

You think our POW's marched around like that during ww2?

[rifleman1122]

no. nobody does. it's just a movie

[MrTommySmith]

Fernando Torres, Liverpool's number 9! ;)

[Star15951]

i can play it on piano

[skulz66]

I CANT STOP SINGING THIS TONE

[CleverDjembe]

@skulz66

Well, I can.

[Harlequin122]

@skulz66

its unpossible, to do that ;)