Added: 4 years ago
From: leoemotions
Views: 106,900
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (116)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wonderful!!...even it's a "lip sync"

  • She is the BEST singer, yet the WORSE lip singer I've ever seen.

  • I clearly remember that day!

    Was shown at the Fantastico in two parts. (two Sundays)

    Congratulations for the video!

  • This is lipsynced ... but who cares ... this is the most beautiful song of the album!!

  • you can see cleary the edtion at 2:42

  • This was Dubbed by the Production of "Fantastico"

  • 103,982  views <3

  • even though this performance was lipped, but, it's her song and still her who sings this in studio. but, she doesn't look like she is lipping.

  • I've always felt that My All from Butterfly, After Tonight from Rainbow and this song all have a similar Latin verb and what's really amazing is that lyrically, they create a vicious love cycle

  • this is not lipped.. damn.. people think she lipped performances, she's just that good... i could still se her breathing

  • @upoutmyface Hate to break this to you but just because she's breathing doesn't mean she's singing. In case you haven't noticed, every living person breathes all the time

  • she could just stand there n put one of her cds on instead of singing and Id still pay to see it!

  • ONE OF HER BEST SONGS AMONGST MANY OTHERS. <3

  • Beautiful here. who care about lipped.

  • Love this song, I"ll have to cover it soon. And my latest Mariah cover is Touch my body! :)

  • mamacita te amooooooooo nojodaaaaaa jjajajajajajaj que voz

  • i love the song

  • Eu sou apaixonada com esta música!! Uma das mais lindas do album Charmbracelet!!!

    Mariah estava tão linda nesta performance!!! Perfeita!! =)

  • Wow...this one was actually lipsynced -___- you can tell cuz she never takes a breath and it sounds exactly like the track. Mariah usually likes to "change it up" when she sings live. Oh well. Im just slightly disappointed. Shes still amazing :)

  • no dislikes:)

  • i love this song love it super it make`s me remember someone that i can`t seems to forget jujuju its tears me up

  • audio perfeito, imagem perfeita, e a Mariah perfeita como sempre!!! parabéns pelo vídeo!!

  • the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • defintely not lip!!! she was just 33 then and this song is not some thing too hard for her to sing such as "i want to know what love is" or "when you believe" or "without you"..... these are extremely hard..... this one she just only uses normal pitch and technique and short breathe!!!

  • @26ninetialsfox

    It is lipped, but who cares.

  • rly i only wanted......

  • this one is Lipp-Sync !!

  • Friend, Thanks for posting this video!!!! I still remember the day I watched the Fantastic! hugs!!!

    (Amigo, Obrigado por postar esse vídeo!! Ainda me lembro do dia que assisti no Fantástico!!! abraços!!!)

  • i think she lippin it....

  • @Princesslingling911 ....she did....but atleast she was gorgeous..

  • SIMPLESMENTE DIVA DAS DIVAS

  • I know that she is lipsyncing...so wuteva!!!Sometimes singers need to do that bcoz they are humans...they sick and lost their voice...that happen frequently...If I were her I'll do da same too! =P

  • During these few years and era's she didnt sing live outside of America. Its only been in the past 18 months that she sang live in Europe for several years.

  • ella es incomparable, nadie cubre tanto rango vocal de una forma tan completa y limpia...

  • she is a diva and deserves it!

  • Sooo lipsynced. Such a shame!

  • I love you so much!!!!

  • oh my gosh i love this song it makes me cry ;(

    Mariah you are my life the best thing that happens to me I love youuuuu .

  • She usually lips her international TV performances. Who cares, anyway? It's not a concert. Her voice is sensitive, and I'm glad she does everything she can to preserve it... minus all the drinking, but who'd ask of her to quit that? xD

  • this song reminds me of my all

  • and after tonight

  • @marsattacksu yeah i was also thinking of that to

  • @marsattacksu@cmandmc1991 me too...

  • 1 of my favs but i hate dat she lipped it...

  • sad song... if this has been released charmbracelet album will definitely have a #1. So as 'the one'.

  • the VIEW performance sucked!!!!!!

  • If she lipped then its a cop out.

  • I like the vocal, especially in the last, high, part!

  • Simplismente MÁÁRA

  • Yes, she did lip this. I played the recorded track and this both at the exact same time and it went smoothly through in unison to the end.

    BUT...who cares if she lipped this. It's not like she's the only artist who does lipsyncing. It's HER who sang it after all. Just enjoy the song, people. :)

  • When she lips it looks so fake.

  • who the hell cares if she lip sings SHES A GREAT SINGER SO STOPLOOKING IF SHE LIPSINGS DUMBASS

    MARIAH IS GREAT IM A BIG FAN OF HERS

  • amooo mariah , cantora maravilhosa ....

  • beatifull beatifull beatifull beatifull beatifull beatifull beatifull beatifull

    ONLY THIS

  • I love this song! and also, great set design!

  • Comment removed

  • because it's in a foreign country. During promotion for new cd's it's very common for artists to lip becuse of the exhaustion of being in SO many different countries in such short a time and performing SO much

  • <3 Ive been listening to this song since like 4 am...wow is it perfect :(

    Such gorgeous song!...

  • Amooooooo Mariah!!!!!!!!

  • easiest way to tell when she's lip syncing. when she's fakin she moves around more. like more A LOT more hand movements. and when she is really singing she scrunches her face. no joke

  • its not play back you can here the mic when she puts her hand on it at 3;12

  • i love Mariah, who never made playback? Hum, look for Britney she makes playback all the time, is her sign. i love MiMi and some playbacks won't make me don't like her anymore.

    heheh ~

    Te amo MiMi (Amo o Brazil) ...

  • she did lip sync on this one but who cares. it's a beautiful song that describes my feelings to a tee when me and my boyfriend broke up

  • wooww

    I'm in love with this song!

  • this goes to my ex who broke my heart in a billion peices i hope i can put them back together

    lamb of mc

    SATTELITE JONES ((()))

  • The guitar is so amazing with the voice of Mariah Carey

  • This is not live people!! you are stupid if you believe it!! Same, exactly to the note, as the studio version. No facial expressions, she's focusing like it was a stupid music video

  • its playback but she rarely does it.. we all know she can sing so its easily forgiven. she was probably sick. i love her.. shes just such a beautiful person.

  • yeah you can tell its too close to the studio version but true we all no she can sing this easily live if she wanted to. GREAT JOB MARIAH... REALLY HELPS through my situation :(

  • Hey guys I'm Brazilian, and I can say to you the truth... This performance and the other "Through the rain" was playback...I think she was tired to sing live.

    But in 1999 she sung in Hebe's program here in Brazil and that's all live.

  • her voice is so powerful! xD

  • I´m brasilian and her fan but all the show wasn´t live she just came to Brasil because she was going to Argentina or something like this!!!! It wasn´t live

  • It s not LIVE!(((

  • wow amazing...its live..!!dont u know it!!! love that

  • She is GREAT!

    I loved that!

  • MissDanielle is right! why people do that is beyond me... but this performance because the same day she sang through the rain and it sound EXACTLY the same as the original recording

  • you know, half her performances that are here on youtube that she's 'lipped' aren't actually lipped at all. Half the time she has sung live but some idiot put the original recording over it. I'm not saying thats the case here, though I think it is, but just in general. Mariah performs live more than people actually think

  • This is not lipsync. There something wrong with the sound-timeing on this video...

  • I love Mariah, but this is lip-synced.I have listened to this song too many times....So, I know this is exactly like the track...no new breathing or anything....

  • She's lip syncing on this - but atleast it's much better than her singing this song on THE VIEW. THAT was a nightmare.

  • i couldn't disagree more. at THE VIEW it was live (not sure about the end, though), and it was way better. It certainly was not a nightmare, in my opinion it was great.

    moreover, she looked prettyer if it's possible

  • she looks beautiful

  • I dind't know that she already come to Brazil :S

  • SIMPLESMENTE MARIAH

  • love this song

  • i love you mariahhh

  • Ñ sou muito fã da Mariah carey + uma coisa é certa ela canta muito, e tem algo que a diferencia das outras Divas pq/ ela canta com sentimento!

    E aquele agudo derruba todas rsrs...

  • such a beautiful song....aghhhhhhh

  • Já gostei mto mais da Mariah. Embora meus gostos tenham mudado um pouco, não deve-se negar que ela continua sendo uma das melhores cantoras do mundo, senão a melhor. Ótimo vídeo!!!

  • People lets understand we all know that mariah, whitney and even beyonce can all sing! Don't you think sometimes they get tired of singing all the time. I mean come on they've sold millions and we know they can sing!

  • i know this is lipped but who cares? its still a beautiful song....i love the falsetto tone in this song so pretty!!!! FOREVER MC!!!

  • awh amaximc

    'who cares if it is lipped its still her voice 100% who the hell gonna be singin live every damn time? '

    i just luv ur comment!totally agreed!

  • They're all faking it. Not only is she lipping, her guitarists are pretending to play.

  • The guitarists are not pretending to play... I know that because he's my boyfriend and he told me that he was really playing, and by the way, he's an EXCELENT guitarist...

    Mariah can really sing.

  • The guitarists are not pretending to play... I know that because he's my boyfriend and he told me that he was really playing, and by the way, he's an EXCELENT guitarist...

    Mariah can really sing.

  • one of my favourite songs ever

  • very good memories of the time when Mimi visited Brazil,,,,,I recorded every single appearence, performance, and this song in special reminds me so much of that time....

  • my fave song off charmbracelet such a beautiful song, i would have loved it to seen it live but playback is alright cuz it is her angelic voice so its all good, love ya mariah #1

  • love this song

  • very fantastic performanced,,,im in love,,so much in love.....mrrg007..let me tell you are you there that time that was performed that song,,,excuse me hah a lip sync is very hard to perform...why?find it...plizz''dont take it personally..

  • why playback? ? ? ?

  • who cares if it is lipped its still her voice 100% who the hell gonna be singin live every damn time?

  • What year was this from? Mariah rocks!! Love Her!!!

  • sooo she was sick if u saw her interview she said she was sick...no one's perfect okay...but who cares mariah iz still the best

  • Love the song, ashame it is lip synching..

  • its a lip synch

  • Oh Mariah Carey, love her ballad songs!!!

  • omg!!! she so dmn guud

  • Such a beautiful song. Such a fake performance...

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more