萧敬腾 背叛

[620026200]

歐陽盆栽

[andrew80615]

我倒是覺得有些咬字不清楚

可能太緊張了

[5442gbh]

真是好聽 讚!

[firzennet]

his voice sounds so much more powerful than the other guy. the other guy obviously struggled to reach the high parts while this guy is just hitting all the notes with power and vibrato.

[chilamification]

老萧最后唱到肚子痛 ><

[MUJI333]

萧唱歌有一个特点，非常能踩稳节奏，可能和他打鼓有关。他是一个­懂得唱歌的人。这首歌明显是他唱得更好。还有，他的外型也太屌了­～

[CandiceL0818]

老蕭這唱得，簡直無可挑剔。無論是共鳴、氣息控制或是感情的投入­，perfect! 他唱歌真是自學的么? 好神啊...羡慕...

[wenllllllllllin]

非常喜欢～～好厉害～～



[joycietea]

<3_____<3



[LuHuWei]

單就這首歌聽聽嘛，偏向蕭敬騰.....

有可能是兩人心態不一樣，是楊之前唱過，蕭挑來唱

那蕭唱得較好也是正常...

[OrgrisVhal]

imba

[jeff991010]

他能跟周杰倫比繞口令 2人都口齒不清 不過2人都唱得很好聽 

[MrBfyee]

萧敬腾后面那段爆发点实在让人无法自拔！强&赞。

[frank630729]

技巧用的太多 感覺就覺得好油



[a52013149587]

哈哈 這不是變成  殺人歐陽盆栽的結局嗎？

[sumiji888]

其实他唱歌会让我紧张

[forevereverrr]

i don't like his version.his voice is loud..but.he dosen't seen like he's singing from his heart..he's okay....yang zhong wei is better! in my opinion

[cheakist]

@forevereverrr Yang is much older than Hsiao so they interpreted the song differently. I don't know who is better but Hsiao's rendition and voice gave me goosebumps all way through. To me Yang seemed to have struggled a bit with the high notes. I am not a fan to both of them but I think Hsiao's vocal range is much wider than Yang's. I respect your opinion though.

[anc68001]

幹到底怎麼用丹田唱的 中氣十足

[Jason17868]

天阿畫面卡卡的

只能用聽的

[benis155]

操妳媽的唱聲樂的

[MeioKaraoke]

@lousi994 這個跟這個影片有甚麼關係阿?

[yungchih69]

一堆不會唱歌只會盲目崇拜的 白癡 

[Deadlikeme16]

What is he singing???

[SMLeadable]

加油噢!盆栽！！！！

[yungchih69]

蕭 技巧更多更細膩 中氣更足　音色更純淨 但是有時候這種悲傷的歌 不需要唱得太油

反而 真誠 直接的感情 就可以了 無謂畫蛇添足 蕭有點太油 太耍技巧 這有R&B的西式技巧　但是　我認為其實　當人真的在歌訴　悲傷時　還有心思耍帥　耍技巧嗎？　不太自然。　再減少一點油　跟刻意的技巧　會比較好。　

[101Qoo]

@yungchih69 你會說江惠唱歌刻意用技巧嗎 不會 因為你已經根深柢固的認為江惠就是唱這樣 而蕭敬騰 不過是你不認為他唱歌就是這樣而已

[SMLeadable]

@yungchih69 我認為你只能在家吃屎

[vpv20564]

我起雞皮疙瘩了.....

[xgyg]

不管大家说萧和杨怎么唱法不一样，感情不一样。我要说的是：只有­萧老大的歌声才能打动我，我没有那么专业地知道萧的技巧是什么表­达的感情是什么版本，我知道我被萧的歌打动到了

[xgyg]

love萧老大！！又man又萌

[tehtarikkkkkkkk]

杨和萧都是我欣赏的歌手，但是如果以这首背叛的表现，我会把票投­给杨，因为他唱得很悲情，完全符合这首歌的意境。而萧敬腾，用他­那独特的嗓音诠释也很不错，但是在这首歌上他注重的是技巧而不是­感情，所以个人比较喜欢杨的。以上纯属个人意见，希望萧帮歌迷不­会介意。

[kwwongeric]

百聽不厭，好正！

[23207253]

都很厲害啦= = !!

[sanctuarygo]

聽聲音，會把票投給蕭。

但張開眼票還是會不自禁流到楊那，那表情太有殺傷力了

[oiu61532]

真的好懷念喔,好幾年前了呢.... 當時天天都想看星光...

[qiana0213]

怀念～

[MissiMissay]

my heart stops when he sings <3such a cutieeee i love him<3

[oicq747285250]

2:50 無敵了 高音得不得了居然還能假音，而且更高音！

[Bratzpipe]

he said a few words wrongly but wow his voice is so powerful ;) better than original in my opinion

[200310663]

其實就這一首歌而已 蕭敬騰唱的比較好吧 因為完全不會有曹格的感覺 可是老實講楊宗緯的版本跟曹格差不多 沒什麼新鮮感 不過像人質或雨天那些我就很喜歡楊宗緯的 太完美了

[passionkev01]

2.50 秒的那個高真音轉假音 聽起來真的很專業.

[passionkev01]

1.55 秒的那個高真音轉假音 聽起來真的很專業.

[MrBeens9877]

雖然萧敬腾的唱功很好,但在感情方面,仍是楊宗緯較好(主觀的覺­得)



[cocoononly]

我愛蕭蕭!!

[seeduboyou]

我覺得說他唱得不好的人只是不習慣他那與普通台灣男歌手不同的唱­法，他能唱這麼高音又不刺耳其實已代表他起碼有一點唱歌方面的才­華。我真的非常喜歡和佩服蕭敬騰的就是他獨特又迷人的歌聲，還有­他不管別人的看法，誓要順著自己風格的個性。不是人人都會喜歡，­可是他自己是為對音樂無比的熱誠才會上台給我們獻唱。 蕭敬騰加油！

[foxs91]

I really PREFER this version compared with 楊宗緯's. this is more powerful and full of passion. it's only my opinion anyway.

[ilikeella0829]

蕭靜騰超棒 :)))

他現場唱歌根本和CD沒兩樣~~~ !!

[DMGX5423]

@ilikeella0829

我觉得他live 唱得比cd 好听（in my opinion)

[yiaphwee]

出来的声音很平面，没弹性也没起伏。。。。。。。。。听不出好在­哪？

[2010tonylee]

Excellence.....

[josephine330]

太完美了～～

唱到如此的境界，

敬腾你是人吗？是神啊！！！

[sophia0822]

不管聽多少次都覺得好聽~ 很耐聽~

[SHOWisLOVE]

O.O 哇！也太强了吧！

[forfreedom0117]

這是要問，在被背叛的時候應該哀傷還是應該怨恨？

我覺得蕭是在怨恨自己，為什麼會讓自己愛的人去背叛自己...

有種很無奈的 淡淡的恨

[maplesuck8888]

jam's unique voice !!

[microcarpa1]

唱到最後已經進入無人領域了~~共鳴從喇叭傳出來好強大~~但老­實說楊的唱法感情比較深

[kamelp]

3:28-3.30 萧好像太用力唱， 把胃弄疼了。

[zuizai98]

杨的好吧，萧有点唱在录音棚里的刚觉，比较专注效果。杨在现场放­的很开

[sangyui]

我覺得佢唱呢首歌發揮係好過楊宗偉~

但係佢唱唔出被背叛既心情

只係唱出佢自己個人風格

冇左呢首歌應該有既感情

[SpankRamen2]

This dude is okay, but I like 楊宗緯 way way more. He's just the better singer.

萧敬腾 sounds like he's straining & forcing himself too much, whereas 楊宗緯 doesn't have to try as hard.

[jonny00000000]

觉得萧把这首歌唱得太过用力了， 把感情都遮盖了变成有点怨恨的感觉了。。 但如果没那么用力的话应该会很完美！！

[benis155]

唱聲樂喔

[qq8339903]

帥呆 了

[stevepok]

he are super duper strong!!! wish i able to have half of his voice~

[MeiMei9493]

不喜欢那个胖胖的评委，感觉他们两人都各有各的特色。

 只是杨宗纬体现出来的感觉是悲伤的。

[WalkerYable]

楊和蕭版都不錯

楊的演釋哀傷一點

蕭的演釋仇怨一點

[aquachaoslemon]

@WalkerYable

[babybluee130]

this is THE BOMB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LOVE IT~~~~~

[85jane]

love his songs !! jyjy xD

[a0423812574]

哇 超man 唱歌超有魅力

[leowintec]

好聽

[m150063]

隔了好久才再找背叛來聽，發現蕭敬騰的聲音唱這首歌最令我印象深­刻。但僅此是聲音...

[push0678]

幹林周罵勒~包皮疙瘩掉滿地

[meigsa]

Oh mon Dieu, mais quelle voix!! <3

[TheXiaoguanzi]

太棒了，看到摇头晃脑的死胖子就讨厌

[HAMADI0204]

@j000z11 

[bbtpink]

omg badass hairstyle ;) love it~ So different from his good boy look :p

[aa26390678]

rock~

[122512328]

2:00秒間奏的地方拉的長音實在太震撼,也太有特色了

[siuchu610]

不懂說為何, 就是只喜歡敬騰的聲音, 任何時候的敬騰都愛~

[asdf121250]

楊宗緯唱歌也很油啊...

感情感覺比較多是因為唱哭腔的關係吧

不過兩個都唱的很好 只是型不一樣

所以大家各取所好囉

[hkrunrunrun]

蕭唱歌的方法和楊的非常不同

蕭的唱腔給我的感覺是很注重表達歌聲的力量和那種技巧

這當然是好,但是過份技巧會令整首歌覺得油了一點

反而楊的技巧表現比較平淡一點,但感情方面的確淋漓盡致

個人比較愛楊的唱腔

[v115746]

現在已經不能再聽到蕭這樣的聲音了~~

[ilove391314]

很同意,我喜歡他這種唱法,現在的唱法跟其他歌手唱流行曲都差不­多了...

[vintersummer]

听了３年，还是觉得杨的好！当然萧的也不错！只是，怎么说呢，只­是力量多了些吧！

[hkrunrunrun]

蕭歌聲表達的技巧我覺得稍微油了一點

[abc7659971]

偏愛 楊一點 感情用的很好 蕭的聲音是比較有力量!樣比較奈聽

[hang1991921]

我覺得佢用li個look黎唱li首歌好有霸氣

[kkssw]

@hang1991921

绝对赞同，霸气无法挡

[shing5562]

最型依個look

依家好樣衰

[fanmarkloren]

楊感情多一點, 蕭本身的聲音迷人, 仍愛蕭多一點, 呵呵

[dino601161]

從pk到現在發片 我覺得這還是他最帥的髮型...

[ericseero]

我覺得楊宗緯比較好

因為佢唱果feel唔同左

比人耳目一新既感覺

整體上係100分

[kellyc130]

He is just too good. Love his singing.

[chineseboy1993hk]

很有震憾力

very powerful and emotional and his voice is very good too but his singing technique lack a bit of varieties

but still i find his version the best too

[hang0011]

我都覺得楊同蕭2個都唱得好

但我都是偏蕭敬騰版本多一點

我覺得蕭唱背叛好一點

可能用蕭的power唱尾段的時候比較深感覺

[tat158]

太強啦,,,屈機的聲音,,,,

[ropacscoo]

I like his hair in this video. His new hair style made him look too "common".

[udonknownething]

我不明白为什么有些人喜欢把杨说的一文不值，我两个都很喜欢，他­们两个都有很特变的嗓音，非常的不同，both really amazing!!。你老绝的谁唱得很烂的话，你唱一首来听听啊­。。。。

[pokerfish124]

唱功一流..没得说~~

[sexychink]

His voice might not be as beautiful as Gary Cao's but this guy sings with WAY more feelings and emotion. Definitely better than Gary Cao singing THIS song!

[vkevin100]

楊唱的太娘了

這種歌手還蠻多的

這是事實

楊宗緯唱到期盼我就想兔了

[VioletBurgundy]

I just went to 曹格's concert recently. I really like him. But I must admit I like this 萧敬腾's rendition much better because he sang with his heart and soul. He showed so much emotion that I almost feel as if he really sacrificed himself to make the other person happy.

[MathhewNg]

強烈要求4大天王改成5大天王..

入圍者只有敬騰一個..哈哈!

[erwinlma]

這男的真特別, 我是32男也很欣賞他...

[beankan]

很強.....很棒的演出

[siuchu610]

我也不討厭楊, 其實有很多歌手唱歌也很好, 但我只愛敬騰, 是唯一的愛, 期待12月26日快來臨, 在小巨蛋見證我的最愛洛克先生第一次個人售票演唱會~

[smap123smap123]

我雖然我不討厭蕭 但我認為楊唱的比較好 蕭都是靠一些技巧 楊的腔調是自然的

但兩位都很棒唷 蕭到現在也進步很多了

[katkk617]

個人喜好啦...我也不討厭楊可是我個人就是喜歡蕭也是給你所說­的技巧迷到了..百聽不厭的,,而且他現在的成績比第一班任何一­個好吧!!!

[PMSism]

lmao, if he is deaf, then you should be a dog which cant sniff. =)

[094253004]

haha gary chaw is better than this. His is version makes this one sound like a deaf person signing xD

[joaocarlosmachon]

爆发力太厉害了。。。。。。。。。！！！哇塞！

[Turbo1Love]

when i watch this video, i just pause n 4get everything around me...seriously. he is king of this song...to me at least.

[siuchu610]

我又來重聽一遍喔~ 實在太好聽了~ 百聽不厭~

祝王妃專輯及王妃改版大賣~ (我已經一早買了~)

[procrastinatingpig]

我也是！哈哈！

敬騰現在的造型才好看嘛～

以前造型有點。。 = =

[senthyril]

he looks constipated or going to super saiyan when he sings, just saying

[zelda0521]

@senthyril

LOL

[senthyril]

what did i say?

[siuchu610]

音域很廣, 歌路很闊, 唱什麼歌都好好聽~

[lovona09]

this guys sings much better than jay chou for sure

[Yangace]

He has great dynamics in his singing style

[nigoape11]

OMG...!!!!!This guy is amazing ....!!!!he sing alot better than jay chou....this is wht u call singing....

[lyanmok8877]

唱得不错~不过原唱者唱得比较更有感情及动人(对我来说而已)~­

[Turbo1Love]

he is the best singer in my heart. he is wonderful, hes amazing. idk how to descirbe how perfect he is, i need a dictionary.

[VonElephant]

這個發型比較適合他...

[xiaobaobei92]

thumb up ofcst ...best best

[josephine330]

超帅的辫子头！！！！！

[kylesandrock]

I like his hair style, but currently cannot see this style of him. I miss that.

[tobto1]

great performance!!!

[fybisthecode]

很有霸氣的髮型!

[ecoemaco]

好喜欢这时候的发型！好喜欢他的声音！

[SelfObessed]

萧敬腾，永远第一！

[ccsj1ss]

如果一段感情僅僅有悲哀，主角肯定不會對這一段情念念不忘。也不 會寫一首歌來記念。

相反， 如果主角對這一段感傷的往事還是那麽牽掛，那也表示他仍對另一半­ 有著無限的情深。

蕭和楊的歌聲里有著無限的哀傷，曹格的歌里除了悲傷， 卻仍流露著情深的感覺 。

[imsqzdk]

但歌词并不是曹格写的

[BigBadPianist]

比较喜欢萧敬腾。

[ICUCICU]

HE.ASKA N GARY ALSO SING VERY WELL...

[esther1239]

vry vry vry nice~~

[alexyapweikeat]

i think Gary is still the best..lol

[yvette74731]

拜託..比楊宗緯好聽多了,也少了很多油~

[annylovers]

这发型多帅啊~~~ 谁逼他剪得？ 是超级星光大道吗？可恶。。。

[annylovers]

你才白痴，那时候还没签唱片公司。

[lijiaqi5]

I like his original image and singing much better than the way he is now (the result of getting lost in show biz + being misled by his record company?) However, his singing is still great and if it's a shame that he spends too much energy on activities that don't benefit his singing.

[fredparadise]

I think he sing way better than gary and Yang zhongwei . Powerful voice. Super.

[slk343]

He is so awesome!

[zouxue]

萧敬腾的确在这首歌上比楊宗緯表现出色.

[recluseone]

No doubt he's a different type singer as compared to Aska, but for this particular performance, we really can't deny that he sang much better than Aska & has his very unique style on presenting this song. Aska is still good to a certain extend with his own style. Personally, i would like Jam more than Aska more!

[q93105]

不僅歌唱的好!!!也有偶像的外表!!!為演藝圈注入新的生力軍­吧1!!6月2日~6月15日預購專輯囉1!!

[didosz339]

To jkgodlike4: plus, can you get famous and popular like him by singing other people's songs and just compete three times?

Apprently not because then you will understand how talented it is. Stop barking like a dog here. Thanks.

[didosz339]

to jkgodlike4: do you even have a brain? He sings other people's songs because his own first album comes out in June, 2008!! He does not have his own songs to sing yet. I do not understand why you keep beating him down while watching a lot of his videos. Is this called jealousy or are you just too bored??

[kevxon]

唱得很好，长得很帅

[recluseone]

try sing other's song n c whether it makes u famous, LMF songs i think maybe or maybe wee meng chee's

[nightlove321]

gary can keep skin liao.. u replace him la

[resist321]

bt i feel dat yang sings wit mo feelings n mo touchin although dis sings beta...

[llondobell5]

nice,,,too nice...

[lottiecc]

he sings so much better than yang zhong wei

[freestyle217]

唱得很好，长得很帅，表情有点儿小狰狞。

[juzbrenda]

i love his hairstyle here.. so sad whn he cut his hair.. sigh..

love his voice.. its superb!!! he'll be a star one day, i'm sure..

all the best to him!!

[ganpaoji]

我好怕以后再也听不到这种好声音

[roses4youjem]

Xiao is actually 9 years younger than Yang. Yang lied about his age. Give him 9years and he'll blossom.