Gregorian - Meadows of Heaven (Nightwish cover)

[aae1234]

I think Annette should sing over this version, now THAT would be something!!

[jjpyae]

Nighorian

[blajdzik]

It's really good!

[LaraVermillion]

Mir gefällt das gar nicht.

Niemand Außenstehendes versteht den Metal, dann kommt irgendeine vertrottelte Band daher und macht aus gutem Metal so einen verpopten Mist und alle: "Woooaaah, wie schön! :]" Als ob das jetzt besser wäre als das Original.

So war das zum Beispiel auch mit David Gerett, als er Metallicas Master of Puppets coverte. Der Typ ist so feige, er coverte nicht einmal das Solo, und somit nahm er dem Lied endgültig seine Seele.

[Kirichan03]

@LaraVermillion Aber es IST besser! Du willst mir doch nich erzählen, dass Anette besser singt!

[LaraVermillion]

@Kirichan03 Ich finde die Umsetzung von Gregorian einfach schlecht. Vielleicht passt Anette nicht ganz zu Nightwish, aber Meadows of Heaven klingt ja auch nicht wie das alte Nightwish, was Anettes Gesang wieder angemessen macht. Für mich ist das einfach ein Lied, was man nicht covern sollte. Und da wir noch in einem freien Land leben, wollte ich meine Meinung dazu äußern.

[MrJottes]

Ich persöhnlich finde die Stimmen zu verarbeitet.

Ein bischen mehr originale Stimme wäre nicht schlimm. ;)

Aber absolut: Der geilste Cover von Meadows Of Heaven!

Like it. ;)

[Fenridor]

My life would be complete if these guys did a collaboration with Hansi from Blind Guardian. It would be the best thing to ever happen in music. Just imagine the sound they could make singing together...

[nmvaladanzouj]

I'm so used to hearing men singing because of my upbringing that this version is still beautiful. Yes, they're no Annette, but it's still appealing. It also brings a new perspective to the song.

[MsSoklo]

GREGORYAN DU HAY ES??

[himynamesariella]

@MsSoklo EXACTLY my reaction hahaha

[paulagibbs2011]

I like it both ways

[100henriettes]

Mr. Lawrence White solo part is like Heaven! :))

[WooperShark]

Very emotionally moving!

[rockonwild]

I am sorry but that song feels more emotional with a woman singing it.

[100henriettes]

@rockonwild

I don't agree, but we are others!

[rockonwild]

@100henriettes there is something about a woman's singing voice that a man's singing voice just don't have :)

[grytoria]

monkwish

[IVIWAY99]

wow que maravillada, prescioso cover, pero me quedo con la version original ya que la voz de Anette es mas dulce y capta mejor la idea d ela cancion, pero ahora gregorian va en mi repertorio de bandas favoritas *-* xoxo

[TheIceThorn]

It's pure epicness imbued of epicness!!

[kamilam75]

Piękne...



[BluW0lf]

As epic as the original in it's own way.

[TheCrimsonDeep]

I don't liked much of vocal, but, this instrumental version is amazing <3'

[glupsamja]

Thanks for posting the video!!!

[angelsdoweep]

I much more like this than the Anette version...

[zippymk13]

I love this, one of my all time top 5 songs

[JZnative1]

Exelente!!!!! I just kind of miss a sweet femeale voice.... But still a master piece folks

[MrJuha82]

i love some melancholic songs but maybe this is too melancholic one to me ):

Beautiful !!!!!!!

[elfenoire01]

ah non je prefere l'original

[icoteru]

A los que votan negativos: ¿¡si no os gusta qué mierda hacéis aquí?!

[WICCA227]

vuena version...yea



[WICCA227]

me late

[Mikosch2]

I'm an absolute fan of Nightwish, but there's no way leading around confessing this version is actually better. Still waiting for their first Epica cover!

[GUDA1411995]

@Mikosch2

I'm waiting for their first Tristania or After Forever cover!!!!

:D

[NymphaNivis]

Soft and tender vocal is much better than Annete's sharp and loud voice...Perfect:)

[PrazB2JC]

Gregorian music is a genre all its own. Amazing and powerful! This particular song is my all-time favorite - the depth of voices intricately entwined with passionate instrumentals brings to life Meadows of Heaven. I'd love to hear more of the same from Gregorian - hauntingly, beautiful harmony! Spectacular!

[endorianki]

I kinda like this version better, because in the original they had these singers with annoyingly loud voices that just messed the beauty of the song up and made it seem fake and modern...

[TheReignOfTheKnight]

@endorianki You are pretty right!!

[Virginsnow111]

@endorianki yes, yes ,yes, the gospel singers were too much in the original.

[NwDevotion]

TTT-TTT Que lindo se escucha xDDD

Me gusta mas la original con la dulce voz de mi amor Anette, pero esta es muuuuy buena *___*

[endorianki]

@NwDevotion Yo prefiero esta canción :P

pero, sí, Anette tiene muy buena voz :) !

[deutschesmaedchen]

like this better without the gospel singers.

[MrNeoAvalon]

Отлично!

[playgroundlove91]

if you sing the original over the top it all harmonises beautifully! it's fun! :D

[liveforlife2494]

THIS IS SO AMAZING. LOVE THIS COVER!!!

[nemohssin]

nice song!!! but I did not like the end

[KiyoAyavi]

.....damn.

I was crying when I listened to the original version, thought I'm over it and now THIS song! *sniff*

[DiabolicDominion]

Good Cover and a nice Guitar-solo...!!!

But in my opinion not better than the original...

[sarajevoogirl]

schönes Lied zum Nachdenken !!

[antonsdefrancua]

Interesting and Original!

I like both NW song and Gregorians version!

[bonestorm99]

It just doesn't feel right without the soul singers.

[giantsfan245]

@bonestorm99 I agree, the soul singers near the end, hitting those insane high notes are awesome

[justinlwerner]

Gorgeous version of this song!

[Qabcdefghijklmnop]

Very beautiful and the lyrics are just brilliant.

[AeternusAnima]

Better than the original. :)

[YorkGod1]

oooo this is different nice different any song i should especially checkout?????

[BadJoke1994]

is so fucking awesomeeee

[WasTed1337]

i love it !

[TearisShatteredMoon]

@TheHomicidalHatter Tarja is great yes but she is still around, anette is not bad nor is new nightwish, they didnt die just revamp as long as we still have both why not just listen to what you like and bid pace to that you don't?

[Mandysall]

I think this version is better than the original! *-*

[ZPTheart32]

@Mandysall No!

[Mandysall]

@ZPTheart32 Don't be angry ;) It's just my opinion...I can't stand Anette voice in Nightwish music...I prefer this to the original ;)

[YehezqueLNox]

they should do a live performance with nightwish, it sounds great.

[o0PrincessofTears0o]

Elle est belle cette chanson. Mais je préfère quand c'est Annette qui chante.

[OzzInter]

@o0PrincessofTears0o

Je prefere quand c'est TARJA qui chante

[o0PrincessofTears0o]

@OzzInter Moi aussi mais ce que je veux dire, c'est que sur cette chanson, je préfère Annette! ^^ en tout cas, ça fait plaisir que ce groupe est repirs Nightwish parce que ma mère a des CDs d'eux.

[bleedingangelshaun]

Gregorian win the internet?

[asssssy]

@TheHomicidalHatter then go listen to her single project... 

[anniescumpikTH]

A duet would be awesome.

[TheSwede88]

hmm..this version is good. But I think I prefer a female voice to this song :P

[isa2409icma]

@TheSwede88 agree.

[destinedforloveable]

WOW,THIS SONG BRINGS HAPPY TEARS TO ME,I HAVE ANXIETY AND I PLAY THIS AND IT JUST SOOTHES ME,I LOVE ALL GREGORIAN MUSIC THOUGH.THEY HELP ME MAKE IT THROUGH THE DAY

[SorrowenaBlutenstein]

-It's so symphonic choir.

[Sun2strider]

@TheHomicidalHatter there are many singers which have voice like Tarja Turunen or even better (sorry for my english)

[HexReinette]

@TheHomicidalHatter I can see where you're coming from, but Nightwish is still my favourite band with annette ^^ I mean, I think she's an alright singer and Tuomas is a genius. Personally, I think some of the best songs they've done were on DPP, but hey, I realise that it's a matter of taste :)

[howdydiddlyneighbour]

WOW.... i was actually blown away by this, i like nightwish's version, but this, for me, is just perfection for this song

[sparileidlon]

I'd let gregorian rape my children

[Marianne019]

@sparileidlon Spare us your fu****** sick mind

[SirKickz]

@sparileidlon

lol

as opposed to letting them have your children, I suppose?

[xphantomax]

Very beautiful cover. But it still lack's the spirit and shivers that gospel choir gave to this song.

[Oscarbrash]

Nightwish version is better and more emotive

[Firewalkerbg]

Best scenario - Nightwish kicks Anette and replaces her with this very Gregorian choir :o

[Nulinya]

@Firewalkerbg You bet. *grins* Of course they have to do a cover of MY fav song in the entire world. (only vid I have posted. "Die Happy) first.

[thirzje]

There Good in Capitals! o=

C=

[Mikosch2]

Still waiting for their first Epica cover!

[MrGhost6662]

they should make a duet of this song :D it would be EPIC !!!!

[mixyourworld]

@MrGhost6662

I'm making one.

[mixyourworld]

@MrGhost6662 doing one.

[MrGhost6662]

@mixyourworld within Nightwish and gregorian ? ? ?

[withintemptationrock]

beautiful<3

[Nightwithe]

The fact that Gregorian considered it good enough to cover proves that it must be a good song

[albertopinoncerezo]

Hmm thats great,

but the original version

is better.



[meela1000]

Beautiful cover...

[Wolfesscythe117]

This is like. Climbing into heaven myself.

[kashre001]

Most artists who do a cover,try to make the cover more complicated,which in certain cases,ruins it. But , this cover is so simple . Truly intoxicating .

[psyho212prk]

Beautiful cover.

But not such emotional and touching as the original.

[musicalprodigy7]

Beautiful <3

[gugus2345]

Sympa!

[sirenia4]

This cover is breath taking. I absolutely love it.

[sirenia4]

This cover is breath taking. I absolutely love it.

[withintemptationrock]

i like it.. better than most covers. i find this relaxing and peaceful lovely

[ruellan2003]

Wonderful ! Very well done ! peter ruellan global music

[jacko28182]

Tuomas should be knighted for the songs he writes. He's a fuckin genius. Especially as he's not english.

[deutschesmaedchen]

@jacko28182 uh do you actually think that writing English lyrics is THAT hard if you're not a native speaker? hahaha. 

[batuhanenez]

Wow a good cover :D

[Ametrino19]

very unusual that sonone covers a song which isnt a single no??

[jhoneygoddess]

I like it!!!

[MrLifeafterdeath666]

not bad...

the last part of the song sounds like one of the song in Sirenia...

[1980nightwish]

er gaat niks boven de nightwish versie maar dit is toch wel een van de beste nightwish covers

[V4mpIr3L4dY]

Precious.

[VitaminJ]

Pretty neat, very creative I must say!

[AROTBEL]

I have heard this group since time but Nightwish was more behind, never I thought these men could do something like this, honestly isn't bad, I liked it.

Good job...

[xxxxxLIAxxxxx]

A-M-A-Z-I-N-G! Meadows of Heaven is one of my fav musics... I love Nightwish! And this cover is fantastic too!

[JanVollertsen]

I like this version, because the vocals and the choir passages sound so epic!! The singer does a great job!! but I also like the version of Nightwish :)

[Kwandike1279]

great cover

[StewieSwan]

I like the guitar solo in this cover much more than the original

[OzzInter]

Superb, but I still prefer Nightwish's original

[SoullessDeparture]

Very nice cover!

[ValiantsAce]

Brilliant

[bizse87]

i love this song...<3

[ADyingFaith]

Oh this is wonderful. The sound of the voices and the lyrics are so perfect together.

I want this at my funeral. My whole adult life so far has been plagued with childhood nostalgia and a deep longing for the past.

[Hnkl7]

This is nice^^

[wildjezz]

it's different, but nice;)

[Nighthunter1991]

the vocals are great!!!

But I think the orchestration and instrumentation of nightwish is better...

You should mix them :D

[BeAngeled84]

just goosebumps... amazing

[synne16]

His voice is relly beautiful, but I still think NW do the song better, but that's just because I'm used to NW's version : P

But it was still beautiful ; )

[MelodyOfTheDamned]

Nothing that simply amazing and breathtaking!! I cannot say anymore, especially at the beigining!!

[Thebirdking2009]

exelente version de meadows of heaven

[A4calypse]

I think this is the real piece of their gregorian chants. the most beautiful

[Soadevafan933212]

Is this a metal band? O_O, I like their cover of NW still, im curious of this band

[Foxidor]

what's that ending all about?

[NightwishaL]

Beautiful ! <3

[petsitterlinda]

I prefer female vocals for this song. Anette's voice captures the purity of a child with her vocals. For me, no cover will match the Nightwish original.

[NeoAndyDS]

I don't think covers are supposed to match the original versions of songs, to be completely honest.

[daggerls]

@petsitterlinda

yeah, it doesn't match with original, but they're beautiful in different way.

[CROgirlMJ]

Epic... only they and NW can do this...

[bobitsuki]

Simply amazing!!!!

[agenn23]

When the vocals started, I was worried, I didn't think it would sound good. Boy was I wrong, This is wonderful! Both versions are amazing.

[Calplaya]

@agenn23 I was thinking the exact same thing lol

[alirioaimola]

Awesome! Wonderful!

Perfect version.

I agree, this song is a masterpiece by Tuomas.

Very good!

[YviiLotion]

its a beautiful song with beautiful lyrics. i like both versions very much. as many of you said.. you just cant compare them at all. but one think is for sure: tuomas created a masterpiece..

[CarpeCerevesi]

The Nightwish version was really good but I can't really compare this version to theirs because they are of different genre. I think this is a good cover though. :)

[Deshatar]

@CarpeCerevesi

I think so too^^

[jksheavymetal]

i preffer nightwish version, but this is very goog job, love it!

[dcow123]

Much more emotional than Nightwish version, well done!

it's the first time i actually enjoyed this song.

[Symphony2DX]

Pretty good! and i'm a huge nightwish fan.

[celticgirl08]

I can't believe it!! O_O it's a perfect cover!!

i didn't know the existence of this cd. Love it **

[fermatos]

Extremadamente Excelente (Gregorian)

[626tigger]

ew.

personally. i dont like this at all.

Nightwish's was 10x better.

but anyways. nice try.

[Sniperkitten971]

Awesome, this Nightwish song is just a fucking masterpiece !!

[king1flo]

This cover ist baaaaaaaaaaaad

nightwish's version is much better

[yorwan]

OO Magnifique, surprenant au premier abord mais alors... vraiment magnifique

[b27bdrtskstan]

Love this song.i prefer nightwish version than this...anyway,good work beb..

[dnunes1973]

I like more this version than the Nightwish one! Great work...

[TheToiletmonster]

Same, not a big fan of the new vocalist at all

[sirari7]

Great! But doesn't quite beat the original.

4 1/2

[Kasusable]

Nothing against Nightwish.

[DiscoveryChaos]

Its cool but the original is very better

[StefaniaCXI]

Very powerful and emotional cover...

[angelspikebuffy]

This version is better.. Lve his voice.... *melts*

[xut0piax]

This is nice great job love it!! nightwish version better though :)

[emmanuel18702]

du trés tés bon boulo bravo grégorian je m atendai a une interprétation superbe . c es t au dessus de ce que j imajiné cla donne une autre grandeur au titre de Nightwish sans pour autant y enlever son aurigine mémorial.moi qui suis fan de deux groupes je ne suis pas déssus thuoma devrais etre fierre de cette reprise

[ticaylonen]

nice hear this song in lyric version.. because original this song was for tarja type o voice.. very nice.. love more than anette version ^^

[brennobastos]

Certamente um dos melhores trabalhos de Gregorian.

[ionionk]

beautiful  <3

[ricseberke]

with Anette's voice it seems so pure, I cannot feel this here, but all in all is not bad.

[1AzureSky]

It works better with a female voice, but this is a very good cover!

[OpheliaLestrange]

the cathedral-feeling is cool...but the male voices with this lyrics....they just don't have Nettan's emotions...

[eliza1919]

lol! I like more this version than the Nightwish original!

[DominiqueSMP]

Very good! ;D

[VesinT]

Good cover :)