Added: 3 years ago
From: jimmyhvac
Views: 1,887
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (38)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Franz Vs Grinderman???

    Contempary Vs Experimental.

    To make the most profit, you have to sell to the largest auidence. To do this you have to conform material to fit certain criteria depending on the particular demographic, your record Co. Intends to market your shit too.

    RecordCo. In turn define's the contempary, through its distrubution network....!

    Grinderman is some what less radio friendly therefor Isn't bound in the same ways as a band like Franz, in Song Duration for instance &.....

  • Dont Shoot Arch Duke Franz Ferdinand, you might start a War... Nick Cave seemed Pretty Cool.. LikeHAwkWind, He Should Cover Sprit of the Age or somthing. Some People are intamadated by creativity... Mostly because they feel their own talents go un-noticed... ..or...they are justcocks LEEBOY10k. If criticism inst constructive then its just an opinion.... I dig SpaceYRock thats mine..

    I dig the non-suggestive...yet de-tached impilcations, that it tends to dealwith..

    and its erh PSychelsdic Roots

  • In all honesty, Anyone is creative enough to make a song about a honeybee flying to mars, it's not like it's some kind of amazing skill that only grinderman posess

  • Anybody can do anything tard. Its weather they actully do it or not that matters, RU gona prove it? I think Grinderman is the missing link between Hawkwind and the ScreamingTrees. But in all Honesty I can't say I've heard that much of them. Hey Alkipranos why dont you go Saturn Uranus, Necktune my Venus then Pluto Mycurry of seamen. Mars sounds like Farce. Suger cane come sit on my venus Honeybee lets fly to mars. Honeybee awareness, Apiary. Get your bees out, life on Mars? Nah it 'sshit.

  • What are u on about? I may be billingual, but i still cant understand all the bullshit ur writing

  • What the fuck are you talking about dude?

    Saturn Uranus...

    Neck-Tune My Venus lol

    Pluto, Mercurry of Seaman Lol

    Can't think of Anything S

    Jupiter than; Honeybee lets fly to Mars.

    Nick CAve did a pretty good

    SugerCane-Venus

    HoneyBee-Mars

  • Do yourself a favour and just shut up

  • Lol, you Know I just couldn't do that for you tony6.

    Guess I'm just a sadist.

    You can duck the creativity issue if you like, but it would make you my bitch, for about 5 minutes.

    Me think's your going to have to Husshup yourself.

    Unless you can prove your thesis on lyrical creativity.

  • Firstly, I ain't anyones bitch, bitch. Secondly, correct me if i'm wrong, but weren't you the one that introduced this 'creativity' theme to our debate??

    Anyway, back to the question of lyrical creativity - all musicians are creative in some aspect, some less than others admittedly. I don't particularly agree with your statement 'Anybody can do anything (tard). Its weather they actully do it or not that matters'. I'd say that some musicians feel less comfortable with some forms of ...

  • ...lyrical creativity, clearly not a boundary that holds grinderman back. However, some bands prefer to remain slightly more subtle with how 'odd' their lyrics get, and others are creative in much more sophisticated ways (e.g Franz Ferdinand). You can't really judge a band purely on their lyrical creativity (and for that reason I won't say that is why I think Franz are better than Grinderman). It is all just a matter of opinion of course, but on the basis of the 2 band's performances...

  • ...,(and in particular how the crowd responded), I'd say that Franz were better than grinderman at latitude.

  • In all honesty i think we have the biggest retard that has ever posted a comment on youtube, i think you have a missing link in ur brain you faggot oxeyechai.

  • Hey after all the ammunition I fired off for you, I would've expected a more creative response.I like Franz Ferdinand, I'm playing a bit of a devils advocate here... But Tony Son you are one fickel Son of a bitch, Franz are a very mainstream, Contemperary outfit, to be considered as such, famously inhibits creativity... The fact that GdMan are a non-contempary band, means they have less pressure on them to produce (RF)Unit Shifters and greater licence to work with more complex composition's.

  • I wouldn't call ff mainstream, but anyway u can shove grinderman up ur arse.Franz Ferdinand will do whatever they want regards their creative talent, they do not feel restricted by these unwritten laws of mainstream music.Grinderman and all this other shit sound the same to me anyway - boring and depressing.Why would i want to listen to that? erm how am i fickle? and why tony?

  • im sorry im not taking sides but why is every one saying they were rubish i was at the front and me and my freinds thought they were realy good im just wondering why every one sas it was rubish the music was good the performance was good what was so bad about it please reply but dont get angry and starrt ranting on about rubish as every one is entilted to there pinions just id like to no why they were bellow par

  • I have no problem with any of your comments but please use full-stops and commas more as it reads like you're out of breath!!!

  • ok sorry, but why did every one think it was bad.

  • thought FF were amazing, absolutely loved every minute of it. I don't know how people can say they were appalling

  • na FF were the best

    interpol were dire

    tbh the comedy tent was the place to be

  • You had to have been in the crowd jumping about ;D, i thought they were good and i couldnt smell the toilets.

  • Go to hell you idiot, how can u say they were appalling? They were the best band there by far.You clearly have a very bad taste of music, it was an amazing performance by them.

  • havent you heard of a thing called "opinion" you retard, all of my mates said they were apalling, including one who is a massive FF fan, and they werent the best band there, that was between Grinderman, Clinic and interpol from what i saw, but like i said thats MY OPINION

  • I understand people are entitled to their opinions but to say they were appalling is just going too far. You were probably standing miles away from the stage and stoned.

  • well, your wrong on both counts. perhaps when you get a taste in music beyond the NME, and see more gigs you will realise how uninspired and lacklustre they were.

  • Well retards tend to attract other retards which is why you AND your mates said they were crap. How can you say their performance was appalling when they were the only band there that night that got the crowd going. The majority of the crowd were enjoying themselves unlike you.

  • Besides you are missing my point, i said FF performance was below par, many people agreed with me that i spoke to at the time and since. Perhaps you can't acknowledge a differing opinion because your throat is so far down alex kapranos cock. p.s call me a retard again and ill pull your pubes out with a sandwich toaster. and if you reply to this comment, it automatically makes you a cock, more so than what you are now.

  • lee got owned

  • You actually said earlier their performance was appalling not just below par so that makes liar as well as a retard.

  • no, its called having a vocabulary that extends beyond two words, something which you know little about. But as you replied to the earlier comment, and called me a retard again, you are officially a cock and im gonna pull your pubes out with a sandwich toaster.

  • sorry, but you might need to update your definitions of 'appalling' and 'below par' before you boast about having a good vocabulary. The words hardly have the same meaning

  • U fucking wanker, i will electrocute u with a sandwich toaster u fucking idiot. I will also rip ur balls off and feed them to your hamster.

    ps grinderman were the shittest band I've seen in my life, i mean how can u say a band that sings about a honeybee flying to mars are good? this clearly displays that you suck hitlers cock.

  • 1) NOTHING with Nick Cave in, is shit

    2) I dont have a hamster

    3) Hitlers corpse has never been found so....

    4) Singing about a bee flying to mars shows far much more imagination than a band that has done nothing but steal imagery from leftist western european art movements and steal music from post punk 80s bands.

    My last post,cos im bored of this, now YOU fuck off

  • true, a Honeybee flying to Mars is not good IMO... the song would be far better if Nick replaced little honeybee with a house sparrow.

    From watching ITV2's abysmal coverage of Lat'08, seems Franz put on a pretty good show.

  • Hey LeeBoy10k.... Name 5bands you like for each decade you've been alive

  • I'm not a great fan of FF myself, but surely opinions are better gained by hearing and not sight?

  • haha there were so many moshes.... i almost got that drumstick....... i dived haha :P

  • i was right near the front and my friend caught a drumstick:D best show ever!

  • Yeah, brill! My faves. Wish there was more...

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more