This is not good although Caballe posseses a great voice. Baroque is simply not her metier. I've heard her sing other things where she's clearly not imaginative enough to do justice to the material (say, Four Last Songs), but this is almost painful given her emotional detachment. Music is about communication, not just lulling us to sleep with beautiful pianissimi.
Who cares what you look like when you can sing like this it is shere beauty. Ranks with Price and Troyanos - all could melt any heart of stone with their rendition of this Handel masterpiece.
Supreme and Heavenly singing! Could it be that the make-up artists did not intend her to be viewed close-up? Hideous as it is in this video clip, it may have been fine for the theatre. What do you all think?
She sounds well but looks weird in those costumes. anyway the most important thing is the voice and the singing, and she does it brillantly. thanks for posting
MC is wonderful here. As far as the costumes go, what can one say? Montserrat is over the top in every way so why dress her like a normal person? Even a normal queen?
ok, bitches -- she is truly the LAST Prima Donna, costume/production temps notwithstanding. Understand, dears, costume and makeup are THEIR compensatory fantasy.
Ever seen her Tokyo "Poveri Fiore" from Adriana ?? With one breath, her last, according to the book, she traverses the entire width of the stage.
And you carp on about the excesses of costume/makeup lackeys.
sure she is, I do agree with your comment on the Tokyo Adriana, unbelievable, one of the most beautiful arias ever sung, whatever the costume, who cares?
One of the greatest singers of the 20th Century looking like a drag queen and sounding like a goddess; this is my favorite aria from the magnificent opera GIULIO CESARE.
A wonderful feat of vocalism, but the diction is almost unforgivable. The alteration and, ahem, the omission of a good portion of the text does bother me quite a bit.
The alteration and/or omission of segments of the text when ornamenting in the baroque rep was pretty standard performance practice when this was performed. It is a fairly modern affectation is to sing most everything without variations, because it is the fashion to think it's more authentic. Schools of thought come and go. Superb singing lives forever.
To hell the looks, but Ms. Caballe doesn't care that Cleopatra is not Norma, it seems.
alyzst 4 months ago
un sogno
MrNicomiami 5 months ago
ah,divine singing
callas777 7 months ago
This is not good although Caballe posseses a great voice. Baroque is simply not her metier. I've heard her sing other things where she's clearly not imaginative enough to do justice to the material (say, Four Last Songs), but this is almost painful given her emotional detachment. Music is about communication, not just lulling us to sleep with beautiful pianissimi.
Azzenstudent 8 months ago
This is Cio-Cio-Spatra'aria "Se pietà di me non senti, Pinkerton" from Georg Friderich Haencini's opera "Giulio Butterfly" :o)
idaspe 10 months ago
@idaspe Haha, there might be something to what you say... :D
dfgrbtr 9 months ago
@dfgrbtr ;)
idaspe 9 months ago
Who cares what you look like when you can sing like this it is shere beauty. Ranks with Price and Troyanos - all could melt any heart of stone with their rendition of this Handel masterpiece.
mspg2 1 year ago
Supreme and Heavenly singing! Could it be that the make-up artists did not intend her to be viewed close-up? Hideous as it is in this video clip, it may have been fine for the theatre. What do you all think?
dsenRuskin 1 year ago
The beauty of her voice is astonishing. My heart actually hurts everytime I hear her rendition of this aria.
AminasDream 1 year ago 2
She sounds well but looks weird in those costumes. anyway the most important thing is the voice and the singing, and she does it brillantly. thanks for posting
Ivanbelastegui 1 year ago 3
Esta es la consumacion.
Voz pura, sin cuerpo.
baunajuergen 2 years ago 2
This is the consummation.
Clean vocals, disembodied.
baunajuergen 2 years ago 5
Das ist die Vollendung.
Reiner Gesang, körperlos.
baunajuergen 2 years ago
She ate Anthony for lunch.
rabit818 2 years ago
MC is wonderful here. As far as the costumes go, what can one say? Montserrat is over the top in every way so why dress her like a normal person? Even a normal queen?
bjmiceli 2 years ago
Well said!
GeorgiNM 2 years ago
Wow, that is a BIG Cleopatra :-)
felisdomesticus5676 2 years ago
I always had the feeling that Montsy's sound was devine itself, beyond reality.
SENAFOREVER 2 years ago 4
Her *technique* is unreal. The way she maintains that tiny piano without ever compromising on color--stays soft and full and free. I swoon.
And yes, whoever did her makeup needs to be shot.
But I wish one could still be fat and get JOBS. :p
Caredhel 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SHE IS OFF KEY MOST OF THIS ARIA! YIKES!
ericscam 3 years ago
HUAH!!!
ES LA MEJOR CANTANTE QUE HE ESCUCHADO!!! y el aria preciosa!
GRACIAS por este video!!!!
Noeliamenendez 3 years ago 4
am now listening to her 'Tu che la vanita' which is supreme
Don Carlo is the most luxuriant opera music I know, and the the final duet, well, uh ..........
johngotwalt 3 years ago 2
Her make up costume hairdresser queen should have been shot!
Her singing is fantastico!!
montsyblackmaddona 3 years ago 3
ok, bitches -- she is truly the LAST Prima Donna, costume/production temps notwithstanding. Understand, dears, costume and makeup are THEIR compensatory fantasy.
Ever seen her Tokyo "Poveri Fiore" from Adriana ?? With one breath, her last, according to the book, she traverses the entire width of the stage.
And you carp on about the excesses of costume/makeup lackeys.
Re-group, dudes.
johngotwalt 3 years ago 8
sure she is, I do agree with your comment on the Tokyo Adriana, unbelievable, one of the most beautiful arias ever sung, whatever the costume, who cares?
gemmadivergy 3 years ago 2
She looks like Bozo the lady clown. Any more paint and her face is going to peal.
sicuro75 3 years ago
One of the greatest singers of the 20th Century looking like a drag queen and sounding like a goddess; this is my favorite aria from the magnificent opera GIULIO CESARE.
billyguns2 4 years ago 15
Hahaahahaha! But yes, I do love her voice!
("drag queen...")
CarnitineDeficiency 4 years ago 4
But aren't drag queen looking singing goddesses precisely what opera is all about?
SENAFOREVER 2 years ago
uh no... look up Charlottle Hellekante, Tuva Semmingsen, Magdalena Kozena, and Inger Dam Jensen... they are so not drag queens!
dangmills 1 year ago
A wonderful feat of vocalism, but the diction is almost unforgivable. The alteration and, ahem, the omission of a good portion of the text does bother me quite a bit.
Gigglingatagas 4 years ago
The alteration and/or omission of segments of the text when ornamenting in the baroque rep was pretty standard performance practice when this was performed. It is a fairly modern affectation is to sing most everything without variations, because it is the fashion to think it's more authentic. Schools of thought come and go. Superb singing lives forever.
benjaminvox 3 years ago 3
the legato, pianis, song in all its splendour. A wonder!
marioj34 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Montserrat: Believe in Jesus Christ and be saved (Acts 16:31, Your Bible)
osotoron 4 years ago
To hell with the words when they get in the way!
davidperk 4 years ago
un reina por donde se la mire y escuche! brava!
impresionante
lostgirl842 4 years ago
Sin palabras. Nunca deja de sorprenderme, qué voz!! Qué belleza, qué delicadeza, qué sentimiento!!! Qué diosa, BRAVO!!!!
SergioOliver 4 years ago
Ist this possible? Just amazing! BRAVA Caballe, angelic singing... almost on the evrge of impossible!
davit1982 4 years ago 3
Hideous make up, awful costume, GLORIOUS singing! What an unexpected thing this is -- Caballe a consummate Handelian, who knew.
tamerlano 4 years ago 3
friggin' glorious
chacowhacko 4 years ago 2