I am using your video on "LIE TO ME OST" post at viki, I hope y ou don't mind. It is available to open a new video and see who is the streemer :) means you. Thank you again.
There is no accent. The English was sung perfectly. At first, I thought they were messing around but apparently, there's a real debate going on here. I'm intrigued. Other than taking the poster's word for it, the only definitive evidence I can find against the Nana camp is that I don't see this song listed anywhere in her discography on her own site. Can someone point to it?
@dongdepdzai You misunderstood me. I was saying that I didn't see this song in Nana's discography online. (I have Kelly's CD myself.) You would know it's Kelly because you posted the video. But for those who say that it is Nana, there is one sure way to defeat their argument and that is to show that Nana never recorded this song.
I can read and understand what Thomas wrote and share what he feels for his love. My wife to be is Thai and i've never felt so blessed. Thank you so much for posting this.
There is in fact is a slight accent slur. But, this version is very sweet in any language. The gentle sense of the rain is nicely conveyed in her voice and music
She sounds a lot like Judy Collins! Great Cover Version! I have heard The Toys 1960s version, but the best in my mind is The Fleetwoods their harmonies are perfect and the harpsichord on the recording is excellent!
@cpcrame I think she just meant to specific Kelly's voice, "Cantonese accent" is nonsense in a English video. Thanks for your consideration of this mv (I see you've commented twice in a short time).
I watched and her flow is entirely different which is something that can't be faked. Different singers have different breath flows and that particular video that i watched was definitely not her.
Well, this version is clearly "on". It might not be the original lyrics sung by The Toys but grammartically still correct. Just the meaning is slightly different! Sarah Vaughan also sang it with "on".
This version is being sung by Nana Mouskouri, not Kelly Chen. I know because I've had this recording for years. Both women sound great, and also very similar to each other. But there is a grammatical error in Chen's version: for her, the birds are "high up on the trees" while for Mouskouri, they are "high up in the trees".
you might hear "on", but I hear "in". I'll grant that it is not that clear. But the rest of this song, especially the arrangment, sounds exactly like the recording that I have which is by Mouskouri. If you listen to the other clips of Chen's performance on youtube, the phrase "high up on the trees" is enunciated much more clearly, which could be taken as another difference between this performance and the ones that are indisputably Chen's.
ok I don't want to argue the point to death. Let's agree to disagree on that. Nana may have also made the same grammatical error. I just wanted her to get proper credit for her performance. It's still a beautiful rendition!
Be it 'up in' or 'up on,' I personally prefer this (Nana's) version over the other one I heard claimed to be by Kelly. I really like the acapella introduction on this version.
I can't seem to find this anywhere on itunes though. Do you know where I can find it??
this song makes me cry~~~ the melody is so soft and relaxing... makes me think of how life is beautiful amidst all the problems there are in the world...
Isn't that the woman who sang the soundtrack for "An Empress and the Warriors?" I loved that theme song so much. I wanted to download it but it was in cantonese or Mandarin and I just found out those languages existed when I watched the movie and did research. Long story short I never got the song can you help me?
You can just convert this video "A Lovers Concerto" to a mp3. I use a program called "VideoGet" which saves Youtube videos to your hard drive as a video, or as a mp3.
Isn't that the woman who sang the soundtrack for "An Empress and the Warriors?" I loved that theme song so much. I wanted to download it but it was in cantonese or Mandarin and I just found out those languages existed when I watched the movie and did research. Long story short I never got the song can you help me?
what the hell are you talking about benedictlee.. her songs are so good!! joey yung songs suck the most and she wins best singer every year.
another note about kelly: Her biggest highlight of her star career she said to teh media, is gaining herself the award TOP 10 ppl in teh world for her contributions to poor children in china.
this is a beautiful song, thanks so much for sharing it and yes ditto above - i've been looking for the title of this song for so long, always hear it but never knew the song..is the the original melody by bach - menuet in G by any chance??
Yes, it is minuet in G,, but not by chance. The Toys version (1965) is still the best, and ranks up there with "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow" as the best of the 60's girls groups tunes.
@kellybag Yes, Minuet in G, which is 3/4 time, whereas this is 4/4. It's actually from the Anna Magdalena Bach notebook , and wasn't necessarily written by Bach himself. The notebook was a teaching manual Bach compiled for his family, some of which he wrote.
WOW! JUST WOW!!!!!!
ElZappata 6 days ago
S'alright,I suppose..cant beat The Toys tho.
martyw34 2 weeks ago
This is Flock of Seagulls.
cyberdavon 3 weeks ago
Unbelievably beautiful. Takes my breath away.
nooyawkfun 3 months ago
this is sooo beautifullll!!!!!!!!!!!
wickedgirl411 3 months ago
So different to Barbara Harris but what a great voice. So smooth and controlled.
From Bach to The Toys to Kelly..what a great tune.
akafudge 3 months ago
ฟังก่อนนอนเเล้วอารมณ์ดี คิดถึงคุณเเฟน........ ความรักที่มาจากใจ
จะไม่แปรเปลี่ยนไป รักแท้ตลอดกาล
eunhaezaa 7 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
I LOVE THIS SONG... IT MAKES ME FALL IN LOVE OVER N OVER AGAIN.....
bella2death 7 months ago
I LOVE THIS SONG... IT MAKE ME FALL IN LOVE OVER N OVER AGAIN.....
bella2death 7 months ago 3
Hi ^^, thanks for upload this cute song :D.
I am using your video on "LIE TO ME OST" post at viki, I hope y ou don't mind. It is available to open a new video and see who is the streemer :) means you. Thank you again.
Bobasuicida 7 months ago
@Bobasuicida You welcome!
dongdepdzai 7 months ago
I like this love song, it make a wonderful mind for me.
diamilin 10 months ago
Great!!! song ever.
piyoy1994 10 months ago
love this song
MrHappiness101 10 months ago
lol. if you say its from nanamouskouri , then prove it. find the discography and show us.
jojolo123 10 months ago
you can tell if it's a good song when you get goosebumps :D
starsafterlight 10 months ago
this is 100% kelly and her english is just perfect ! love it !
jimmytang01 1 year ago 2
lovely song
jutatinee 1 year ago
@jutatinee It always is.
dongdepdzai 1 year ago
There is no accent. The English was sung perfectly. At first, I thought they were messing around but apparently, there's a real debate going on here. I'm intrigued. Other than taking the poster's word for it, the only definitive evidence I can find against the Nana camp is that I don't see this song listed anywhere in her discography on her own site. Can someone point to it?
nooyawkfun 1 year ago 2
@nooyawkfun Her album's cover contents this song in list can be found in many sites on Google. You can easily find it.
And the others, please stop thinking this isn't Kelly. *facepalm*
dongdepdzai 1 year ago
@dongdepdzai You misunderstood me. I was saying that I didn't see this song in Nana's discography online. (I have Kelly's CD myself.) You would know it's Kelly because you posted the video. But for those who say that it is Nana, there is one sure way to defeat their argument and that is to show that Nana never recorded this song.
nooyawkfun 1 year ago
What are you Moussaka-eating spunk-muppets talking about? This is Kelly Chen.
jucklowe 1 year ago 7
@jucklowe LOL They ate too much baklava...
nooyawkfun 1 year ago
This is not Kelly Chen. This is NANA MOUSKOURI and the accent is Greek not Cantonese.
66LuckyDog 1 year ago
this song keep lots of memory of mine. i really really love this song
TheRSWings 1 year ago
i don't understand that cm @@.
the song is wonderful
songlongtu 1 year ago
The singer is Nana Mouskouri, one of the greatest & most popular singers of all times. She is from beautiful Greece.
earthenly 1 year ago
ฟังเพลงสบายๆ เย็นๆ กันน่ะครับ ^^"
topperza 1 year ago
ความรักของฉันในประเทศไทยส่งฉันเพลงนี้เป็นแล้วฉันรู้นี้เป็นหญิง beautifull ที่สุดในโลก; พรเพ็ญฉันจะรักคุณตลอดไป
thomasthomas5656 1 year ago
@thomasthomas5656 หวานหวังว่าคุณและแฟนของคุณจะมีความสุขด้วยกัน :)
P/s (in case Google's translation goes wrong): Sweet, hope you and your girlfriend will be happy together!
dongdepdzai 1 year ago
@dongdepdzai
I can read and understand what Thomas wrote and share what he feels for his love. My wife to be is Thai and i've never felt so blessed. Thank you so much for posting this.
grizzled8353 1 year ago
@thomasthomas5656
I understand what you wrote here, and feel quite the same about my wife to be. May blessings and happiness follow you and your love for all time.
grizzled8353 1 year ago
@thomasthomas5656 หวังว่าคุณจะรักกันเเละมีความสุขด้วยกันตราบนานเท่านานเลยค่ะ
0875256950 10 months ago
There is in fact is a slight accent slur. But, this version is very sweet in any language. The gentle sense of the rain is nicely conveyed in her voice and music
ggin1 1 year ago
beatiful
y0hita 1 year ago
She sounds a lot like Judy Collins! Great Cover Version! I have heard The Toys 1960s version, but the best in my mind is The Fleetwoods their harmonies are perfect and the harpsichord on the recording is excellent!
starblue1986 1 year ago
เห้อ....ปีนี้หลังสงกรานต์ ฝนจะตกไหมน๊อ...
topperza 1 year ago
Excelente!!!!!!!
paulgomes100 1 year ago
I've been trying to purchase a legal copy...cannot find it on itunes...any help??
flash7843 1 year ago
the best version everrrrrrr!!!!!!!!!!
hoatuyet4306 1 year ago 2
Your voice so cold i feel like im in the snow
cutietops2000 2 years ago
Errr... What do you mean? o.O
I never thought Kelly's voice sounds "cold".
dongdepdzai 2 years ago
Absolutely wonderful! I have never heard a clearer voice!
muehljenny 2 years ago
@muehljenny I 100% agree!
cpcrame 1 year ago
Man, this is Kelly Chen!
dongdepdzai 2 years ago
I think this singer is Nana Mouskouri. I have her CD
truongnguyen53 2 years ago
hello, can u tell me where did u get the raining picture in ur video, plz?
thaolynguyen94 2 years ago
How Lovely ! , How beautiful !
iNaohisa 2 years ago
I also think it is Kelly Chan singing.
Her voice is quite sweet & tender here
Thanks for sharing !
3muimui 2 years ago 4
So nice, so gentle and so peaceful... Love this song so much! :")
MTee1455 2 years ago
This is Kelly Chen :)
Trucish 2 years ago 2
I think this is Kelly Chen, I have this CD:)and I can hear her Cantonese accent
nicole1987302 2 years ago 6
@nicole1987302 I'm curious where you hear the accent. For me, here English is so clear that I may even say it's better than American singers.
cpcrame 1 year ago
@cpcrame I think she just meant to specific Kelly's voice, "Cantonese accent" is nonsense in a English video. Thanks for your consideration of this mv (I see you've commented twice in a short time).
dongdepdzai 1 year ago
@dongdepdzai Haha it's because I keep coming back. I love this version.
cpcrame 1 year ago
love this song
sangdueng 2 years ago
wow i luv this song
SJbbwgsd 2 years ago
This is a beautiful song. If you want to hear it sung really bad check out Mrs. Miller. Its so bad!
nuchems 2 years ago
I am still wondering why no one is posting Mouskouri's version. It would be quite interesting hearing her rendition.
johanua 2 years ago
This song is sung by KELLY CHEN. No doubt!
Kellychen7 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is actually Sarah Brightman...i have it on a cd of hers.
cmae53 2 years ago
This is kelly chen -____- Why wouldn't I know? I'm Kelly's fan for years now. You think I can't recognise her voice?
Kellychen7 2 years ago
Obviously you don't recognise here voice if you still think it's her!
cmae53 2 years ago
You watch it yourself then.
Place this behind youtube's url:
watch?v=BinpNTXiX0I&feature=related
Kellychen7 2 years ago
Obviously not if you still think it's her!
cmae53 2 years ago
I watched and her flow is entirely different which is something that can't be faked. Different singers have different breath flows and that particular video that i watched was definitely not her.
cmae53 2 years ago
You say whatever you want. This video IS sung by Kelly.
Kellychen7 2 years ago
I love this! And this video fits this song just so well! This song(with this video) calls up my memories, thank you! Lovely! <3~
^ ___ ^
pinkstrawberrymuffin 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol this version is undoubtly Kelly Chen's
I don't like her music but I guess she has done a great job fooling you all!
johanua 2 years ago
Well, this version is clearly "on". It might not be the original lyrics sung by The Toys but grammartically still correct. Just the meaning is slightly different! Sarah Vaughan also sang it with "on".
johanua 2 years ago
This version is being sung by Nana Mouskouri, not Kelly Chen. I know because I've had this recording for years. Both women sound great, and also very similar to each other. But there is a grammatical error in Chen's version: for her, the birds are "high up on the trees" while for Mouskouri, they are "high up in the trees".
pookypie3 2 years ago
...But in the version we have here (which you say is Mouskouri), she says 'High up on the trees,' no?
mangarda 2 years ago
you might hear "on", but I hear "in". I'll grant that it is not that clear. But the rest of this song, especially the arrangment, sounds exactly like the recording that I have which is by Mouskouri. If you listen to the other clips of Chen's performance on youtube, the phrase "high up on the trees" is enunciated much more clearly, which could be taken as another difference between this performance and the ones that are indisputably Chen's.
pookypie3 2 years ago
i also hear "on"... "up-on" is very clear in this version
musardus 2 years ago
ok I don't want to argue the point to death. Let's agree to disagree on that. Nana may have also made the same grammatical error. I just wanted her to get proper credit for her performance. It's still a beautiful rendition!
pookypie3 2 years ago
Be it 'up in' or 'up on,' I personally prefer this (Nana's) version over the other one I heard claimed to be by Kelly. I really like the acapella introduction on this version.
I can't seem to find this anywhere on itunes though. Do you know where I can find it??
mangarda 2 years ago
it ok...
but never lyk da oldie beat
shadowphurba 2 years ago
eautiful voice...may have liked to have seen more slides (pics)
msk7046 2 years ago
i go to the bed, bye bye
junghyunjune 2 years ago
Esta es una linda versión de Lover's concert. ¿Es la voz de Kelly Chang?
urrutiasanchezcarmen 2 years ago
This beautiful rendition is by Nana Mouskouri (not Kelly)
ilovelux 3 years ago
this song makes me cry~~~ the melody is so soft and relaxing... makes me think of how life is beautiful amidst all the problems there are in the world...
myflee 3 years ago 3
Amen!
Tonrod123 3 years ago
so cool to reminisce those good happy childhood years of my life..tnx for posting this vid...bless you
obukyahab 3 years ago
又甜又美sweet song
vinxzson 3 years ago
titopaoli
It's a very nice version
titopaoli 3 years ago
Well, I love the original version, but this...this is GREAT!!!!
Its just beautiful and soft and so wonderful!
It has more feeling in it when it is sung like this.
ILoveJaneAustinBoys 3 years ago 2
just download it from limewire... the singer is kelly chen... the tittle is just A Lover's Concerto
themostgorgeous 3 years ago
Isn't that the woman who sang the soundtrack for "An Empress and the Warriors?" I loved that theme song so much. I wanted to download it but it was in cantonese or Mandarin and I just found out those languages existed when I watched the movie and did research. Long story short I never got the song can you help me?
ShutYourStinkingTrap 3 years ago
It's not on LimeWire. Anywhere else to download it from?
StephiAnn 3 years ago
i def got it from limewire... just put kelly chen first maybe...
themostgorgeous 3 years ago
You can just convert this video "A Lovers Concerto" to a mp3. I use a program called "VideoGet" which saves Youtube videos to your hard drive as a video, or as a mp3.
OldTimerGuy58 3 years ago
please can somebody tell me where i can get a copy of this song? want to use it for my wedding! Thanks
rachelharri82 3 years ago 4
the song is so great,i heard this song when i was in taiwan back 2001,its good to reminisce good old days,love you kelly
skuterista24 3 years ago 3
Isn't that the woman who sang the soundtrack for "An Empress and the Warriors?" I loved that theme song so much. I wanted to download it but it was in cantonese or Mandarin and I just found out those languages existed when I watched the movie and did research. Long story short I never got the song can you help me?
ShutYourStinkingTrap 3 years ago
Love this song~!! so pretty
genvithenameless 3 years ago 13
can someone tell me where can i download this song? want to use as my phone ringing tone.
donise95 3 years ago 3
癒される(´ω`)
pomeityan 4 years ago
Uhu. thumbs up for 1314920 ^^ :D
KellyxProperst 4 years ago 3
I in love this song synsince the first time
I heard
cafenesz 4 years ago 3
una bellissima voce!
ANTICHITASCIPPA 4 years ago 3
NNNNNOOOOO where the heck is the REAL one i luv that song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
chocolatbuny 4 years ago
oh, Kelly Chen, this Hong Kong lady is better at singing this than her canto-crap.
benedictlee 4 years ago
what the hell are you talking about benedictlee.. her songs are so good!! joey yung songs suck the most and she wins best singer every year.
another note about kelly: Her biggest highlight of her star career she said to teh media, is gaining herself the award TOP 10 ppl in teh world for her contributions to poor children in china.
1314920 4 years ago 5
I love this song ... and this is the best rendition I've ever heard ... what a beautiful voice.
arjo55 4 years ago 2
Love this song n the rain too.Make me feel in peace n hormony n no problems.
Syazwin86 4 years ago
I hope you all know that this music was written by JS Bach in the 18th century , dedicated to his wife Anna Magdelana
123strauss 4 years ago
That's disputed. Most people now attribute it to Christian Petzold.
dwayne2005 4 years ago
That's interesting . Care to tell me more about this .
123strauss 4 years ago
Comment removed
jucklowe 1 year ago
I love the world....
dirkslan 4 years ago
played over and over again..never ever get tired of this beautiful song..
thanks !!
donise95 4 years ago 3
very nice,
kizer44 4 years ago 2
Such a nice version with a soft instrument. It seems more better than the original. Nice uploading and many thanks.
wafu2dati2eh 4 years ago 2
i love this version!
er2006 4 years ago
So very nicely done. What a voice. Not very many singers sound this good with only a few instruments. Thank you Kelly. JMR
jmpconstco 4 years ago
,,,,,,,,,,Kelly Chen 's voice is very amayzing!!
skyani 4 years ago
confieso que me gusta más con The toys pero esta versión no es mala, bonita voz y muy dulce música, bravo!!!
gracias!!!
okumanami 4 years ago
Es un Hermosa Canción!!!
me encanta!!
Bravo!
y ahora se quien la canta =D
Thanks!
Kathitaxmin 4 years ago
very good~ a beautiful song
mkmrua 4 years ago
wow~~~this is the version sung by Kelly Chen, a Cantonese super star
tdywatdywa 4 years ago
First time hear, love with this song. Bagus skali.
balikona 4 years ago
Very nice song. Very good vocal, too.
dudoy83 4 years ago
What a beautiful rendition.
jeminijem1 4 years ago
so luvly!!!
ims0301 4 years ago
who sings it?
luvar07 4 years ago
artist Kelly Chen
dongdepdzai 4 years ago
BEAUTIFUL SONG,BEAUTIFUL VOICE!!! What else can I say?
5a7azar 4 years ago
So romantic, so soft, so melting...Thanks...
stardust0826 4 years ago
love this song very much.
summerchl22 4 years ago
My love sent it to me ^^!
dongdepdzai 4 years ago
I'm going to send it to my love too!
Holyriver 4 years ago
this is a beautiful song, thanks so much for sharing it and yes ditto above - i've been looking for the title of this song for so long, always hear it but never knew the song..is the the original melody by bach - menuet in G by any chance??
kellybag 4 years ago
Yes, it is minuet in G,, but not by chance. The Toys version (1965) is still the best, and ranks up there with "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow" as the best of the 60's girls groups tunes.
youtootube99 4 years ago
@kellybag Yes, Minuet in G, which is 3/4 time, whereas this is 4/4. It's actually from the Anna Magdalena Bach notebook , and wasn't necessarily written by Bach himself. The notebook was a teaching manual Bach compiled for his family, some of which he wrote.
cfortunato58 1 year ago
am jealous of your lover
ilovelux 4 years ago
just brilliant
cuckooshoe 5 years ago