I'd have to say that for the solo, GH3 probably did a better job. It's diffiucult to chart with the limits of these music games. HMX did better on verses, IMO.
Also, GH3 probably got to watch Tom Morello actually play through the solo to get some hints.
@Thom2509 The wah wah part is an F chord, it has 3 notes in it, so GH3 charted that part much more accurate by charting it as a GYB chord instead of a single note
Since this is a game and it doesn't have any effects pedal mechanic they should have done something different to represent the distortion like GH3 did, there's too big of a disconnect between what you're hearing and what you're playing.
To me, it's drum chart is exactly the same as the other 2 RAtM songs in the game. The only difference being that the other two songs start with rolls, and one of the songs has the same beat on the blue pad.
21,035 people added MainAXE to Xbox live
drcarmine9 1 month ago
really wish they would just give us the entire battle of los angeles album, plus killing in the name =)
LoneRebelX 7 months ago
what's with the drums, is it a bot?
DarkNyghtmareX 10 months ago
LOVE THIS SONG
hamzilla1000 10 months ago
I don't know why people talk shit about these games and tell them to go play a real guitar.
I play the bass, and I would love to have any of these games on my PC. It would be great, because you don't really need skills to do this.
Another different thing is the fact that not everything shown in the game is as real life...
FRSyndicate2 1 year ago
they should have killing in the name on rockband. that would be nuts on drums
mazurchris 1 year ago
Rock band sucks compared to guitar hero.
MrSkyman457 1 year ago
I lol'd at the solo, and the background video in the moment of the solo....xD its all wrong
AllanKun47 1 year ago
This was xbox live huh
2813Jasper 1 year ago
AWESOME!!! The drummer actually did the exact same fills that Brad does when he plays the actual song!!!!
kilosnew 1 year ago
rock band noobs its all about gh3!!!!!!!!!!
sk8t561 1 year ago
goood job whoever the hell u r
24dkiller 1 year ago
srlsy. they should make a rb game based on RATM, that would be awseome
gustavpeders 1 year ago
@gustavpeders they really should...or a Guitar Hero: RATM, SG and Audioslave Edition.
nlvg6585 1 year ago
In relation to the tab sequence on a real guitar, guitar hero got it better...
Hookedonlemons 1 year ago
SP covers the best drum part .....3:18
imflammabl3 2 years ago
such a nasty drum fill, haha! +1
amontoya86 1 year ago
am I seriously the only who doesn't give a damn on which one is better? I just came to hear the song and decide to or not to download it
mrfixitagain 2 years ago
I'd have to say that for the solo, GH3 probably did a better job. It's diffiucult to chart with the limits of these music games. HMX did better on verses, IMO.
Also, GH3 probably got to watch Tom Morello actually play through the solo to get some hints.
torkoal531 2 years ago
this is better on gh3
HolyBlast2 2 years ago
hold up so how much is this and what songs come with it.
stefansnake 2 years ago
The guitar is charted terribly. Not just the beginning, but also the solo. I expect more than this from Harmonix.
Coheed93 2 years ago
This song is charted very well, IMO. HMX made the choice not the to chart the Wah-Wah pedal parts as chords/other notes.
And, as for the scratching solo; how can you call that badly charted? There's no convention as to how stuff like that should be charted.
Thom2509 2 years ago 7
You see, i play guitar, so Im judging the intro based on that. Its not all one note (well it is, but with wakkas). It shudnt be charted as one note.
And the scatching doesnt seem to match the pitch of the note at times.
Again, i LOVE Harmonix, but i have to say that GH3 did a better job.
Coheed93 2 years ago
You see, I play guitar. So I'm judging the intro based on your giant fucking ego.
obeyme3 2 years ago 2
O.o
nice way to contribute to the argument u dumb fuck.
so now, knowing your shit=huge ego.
wow. just, wow.
Coheed93 2 years ago
I wouldn't be surprised about how well you know your own shit. It apparently doesn't stink. Probably tastes like fudge too.
obeyme3 2 years ago
oh my god O.o
you know what, Im not going to argue with you, b/c u have nothing to say.
Coheed93 2 years ago
I wasn't surprised, considering HMX have never charted Wah-Wah stuff like that (example; Even Flow by Pearl Jam,)
I agree that the solo doesn't match the pitches of the scratches, but I still feel the chart is appropriate for the situation.
Thom2509 2 years ago 2
well, i guess. I just personally think that they shud have identified it differently. thats all.
Iunno, it bugs me. but it doesnt matter, cuz i play drums more than guitar, so no big deal
Coheed93 2 years ago
@Thom2509 The wah wah part is an F chord, it has 3 notes in it, so GH3 charted that part much more accurate by charting it as a GYB chord instead of a single note
mario1136 1 year ago
GH3 chart wins, unfortunately. Since I sold the game.
But I will buy this for bass and drums.
Felldohswrath 2 years ago
guitar seems terribly charted
gordofredito 2 years ago
Doesn't seem to be charted right at certain parts.
Janootz 2 years ago
Effects pedal distortion!
Since this is a game and it doesn't have any effects pedal mechanic they should have done something different to represent the distortion like GH3 did, there's too big of a disconnect between what you're hearing and what you're playing.
nonzz3ro 2 years ago 2
This is one of the VERY few songs where I prefer the GH3 chart. O well, looks kinda cool on drums, so I will probaly download it.
But really Harmonix, stop making boring charts for the Rage Against The Machine DLC!
TheDeadPlayers 2 years ago 9
To me, it's drum chart is exactly the same as the other 2 RAtM songs in the game. The only difference being that the other two songs start with rolls, and one of the songs has the same beat on the blue pad.
splync 2 years ago
@TheDeadPlayers: The GH3 chart is much better than this.
Dogmatic2120 2 years ago