If only he had the same passion about his people's occupation of my old homeland, Northern Ireland. He never said a damn thing about his government's "Super Powers Act" which allowed Brits to pick Irish kids up off the street and detain them at Castlereagh for up to a week and be allowed to torture them. They even had a name for it called "Manbreak" where they would literally physically break an Irish person to get information. What a hypocrite.
I think Roger should just keep doing music and perhaps not talk the rest of the time. I couldn't care less what he thinks about anything. Every time I hear him talk my interest in his music decreases. I have been a devoted fan for about 30 years now. Truly I have. But my sympathies are beginning to shift to the Gilmour camp. BTW, I agree with the notion of a free Palestine. I just don't like artists and politicians when they speak.
@paxomatic2 "I just don't like artists and politicians when they speak" -- Artists are citizens too. They are in a position of prominence. Most celebrities use their amplified voice to engage in narcissism. Roger Waters is a hero because he uses his voice, even though it pisses people off, to speak to power about real issues that are affecting the poor and the marginalized over the whole world. I salute him!
“… the Israeli government's actions toward the Palestinians awaken horrific memories of my family's experiences under Hitlerism: the inhuman walls, the checkpoints, the daily humiliations, killings, diseases, the systematic deprivation. There's no escaping the fact that Israel has occupied the entire country of Palestine, and taken most of the land, while the Palestinians have been expelled, walled off, and deprived of human rights and human dignity.” – Holocaust survivor Suzanne Weiss
@phellenic Uh, Jordan is the majority of Palestine.
Two things, the Hashemites are the minority but they rule over the 70% Palestinian majority.
Also HOW LONG did Jordan have Martial Law for anyway, after The Six Day War? It was 25 years and no one ever said shit about it, in fact, this is probably the first time you're hearing it.
I can just IMAGINE what you'd have to say if ISRAEL had martial law for 25 years!!!
In reading the comments it seems that the Zionist fools are spewing no content as usual. Goes to show you what kind of gene pool these zionists are from. The bottom of the barrel. Roger is awesome. Long live Pink Floyd!
Fu*k palestine. Fu*k these stupid whack job muslims who want nothing more than to spill innocent civilian blood. Maybe this fu*ktard bleeding heart should put on a jewish skull cap and walk around the west bank or gaza strip for a few hours. (He'd probably be dead or kidnapped within seconds). Mus-tards have no respect for human life or basic human rights.
@belutes "Maybe this fu*ktard bleeding heart should put on a jewish skull cap and walk around the west bank or gaza strip for a few hours. "
I just saved $200 by not seeing this libtard's show. He'd be a lampshade or speaking German of not for the smart people also understanding the cancer that the cult of Islam is upon this globe.
No wonder he writes such dark lyrics. He escaped with his life while Syd Barret did one pill more and crossed over. I'm glad Gilmour left this sick bastard.
Desmond Tutu, Nelson Mandella, Winnie Mandella, Ronold Kasrils, the South African Union of Students and the South African Student Congress have all called Israel's policies and actions toward the Palestinians as apartheid. On Aug 4th, South African students stated "...We lived apartheid, we suffered apartheid, we know what apartheid is, we recognise apartheid when we see it. And when we see Israel, we see a regime that practices apartheid."
@phellenic "We lived apartheid, we suffered apartheid, we know what apartheid is, we recognise apartheid when we see it. And when we see Israel, we see a regime that practices apartheid.""
South Africa is a ghetto now and the child rape capitol of the world. And this is purely an observation based in history....show me the last nation that prospered under a black leader. I wish to hell one would, but America got one and now it's doomed too. Too much white hate to govern remains in them.
@mrUSConstitution1 I agree with what you've said however I wouldn't pin America's current downward spiral on Obama simply because he's black; he's just on a continuum that started with Lyndon Johnson.
@SatchmoSings - if you believe palestinians are treated as equals in Israel, you must also believe in the right of return for palestinians given that that right is accorded to jews.
you cant have it both ways my friend - the Russel Tribunal found aparthied policies in the occupied lands and in Israel proper.
Yes, this is the same Russell Tribunal that only pronounced guilt against the US and its Allies in Vietnam but never against the North Vietnamese nor National Liberation Front.
Nice to see where you stand, right in the middle of the good old double-standard and proudly so!
@SatchmoSings - all you do is point the finger at others (jordan, north vietnamese) or quickly dismiss the informed because you know that Israel is a murderous apartheid state that is the piriah of the world - history will not be kind to the zionists and people like you will be remembered with utter repulsion
@phellenic Israel is a pariah in YOUR world not "of the world;" this explains why Israel gets a five billion dollar CPU factory/research center from "Intel" while 440,000,000 Arabs in 22 countries can't even attract a factory to sew doll clothes.
Also, this apartheid, let alone "MURDEROUS" apartheid is a damn lie; there is no Apartheid in Israel or in the West Bank; you make this accusation because you're a Jew hater.
@phellenic What are you babbling about, one of the statesmen who appeared before the Russel Tribunal last year was Haneen Zoabi, an Israeli parliament member of indigenous Arabic origin, in other words A PALESTINIAN!!! How could it be an Apartheid if the Arabs in Israel have their own political parties and parliament members???
@HeadofIbis - what are you babbling about? I didn't say anything it was the Russel Tribunal made up of an eminent panel of international jurists that came to the conclusion that israel practices apartheid in israel and occupied Palestine - for example israel refuses to allow the palestinian refugees the right to return to the land that was confiscated by the european colonial zionists back in 1948.
@phellenic I read the report issued by the Russel Tribunal, it's complete hogwash. They compare the occupation of "Palestine" to the South-African occupation of Namibia. WELL GEE, Namibia was a sovereign country, PALESTINE DOES NOT EXIST!!!!!!! They are just like you, can't decide if "Palestine" is a country occupied by Israel or it's just Israel with "Apartheid". They're just going for broke, throwing any accusation possible, maybe something will stick.
@HeadofIbis wait what Palestine does not exist and Israel does? Before WWII and the allies helping you get a small homeland Palestinians lived there. Hope was you would get along but you fostered the same bigoted hatred that the Nazis had against Jews. I've heard Israelis say that cause the Palestinians are week they don't deserve to live there I guess with that logic the Holocaust was deserved too? Your Zionist logic and religious zealot-ism is f-d up and drives the whole world back
Roger Waters is a piece of shit, I thought he was a piece of shit when I heard he left England over the hunting ban, but this just proves he is a piece of crap
Do not understand how someone can be so "liberal" but can be so evil at the same time
And oh yeah Roger, as usual total agreement and man, this is the first time I had delved deeply into your political side. Good to see all this lately after 30-40 years of apathy, right! Take care and I'm gonna listen to K.A.O.S.
@PinkTitanium@HeadofIbis Arguing, name calling and stiff-necked-ness have got to stop. There have been ample examples of violence on both sides. But the influence of the richest men in the world keep you fighting to your own demise, if you continue to disrespect and hate your fellow man. Do you teach this to your children, too? Are you going to sell them into the same system and continue this? Share the land, love and forgive your neighbor, STARVE the MACHINE!
stop the billions in foreign aide to isreal & give it back to american tax payers & let isreal expansionalist deal with their own problems.........how can you ask palestinians to leave palestine? fuckin' wankers
Roger Waters is simply uninformed, I just lost any respect I had for him.
1st of all, the West Bank isn't "occupied", cuz it's not a country, this territory never belonged to a sovereign state, so legally speaking it's DISPUTED TERRITORY, not "occupied".
2nd, Israel offered the Palestinians complete autonomy beyond the green line with total dismantling of all the Jewish settlements, TWICE - but the Palestinians said "no". If they love their freedom so much, WHY did they turn it down???
@HeadofIbis i encourage you to learn more about: the BDS movement (Boycott, Divest and Sanctions),
the status of Palestinian refugees who live deprived of their land in refugee camps in Lebanon, Jordan, Syria and more..., the open-air prison called the Gaza Strip, encasing over 1 million Palestinians and patrolled and bombed by man-less drones.
@PinkTitanium Gaza isn't a prison, they got a border with Egypt that would be wide open, if the Hamas weren't so collaborative with the Muslim Brothers and their plan to turn Egypt into a Sunni-Muslim theocracy - no wonder they don't let anybody out. That doesn't stop Gazans from smuggling in everything they need, including illegal drugs and Iranian rockets, thousands of which were rained on Israeli cities for the past decade.
and please enlighten me, why is there a seperate definition for Palestinian refugees, according to which their number only INCREASES as the years go by, while other refugee populations in the world are dwindling? Could have something to do with having their own UN relief agency which pours on them more funds than all refugees in the world combined, quie an incentive to maintain their "refugee" status, no? Could also be related to the fact Arabic countries deny the Palestinians local citizenship.
@HeadofIbis Do you know why Arab states do not extend local citizenship to Palestinians? It is because if that happened they would cease to exist as a nation and would simply become absorbed into those neighbouring arab populations.
@angryafghan The problem is that they think the only way to become a nation is to destroy an existing one: Israel. They express their intent with slogans like "Millions of martyrs march to Jerusalem!", "With blood and fire we shall reclaim Palestine" and "The tree and rock will shout: the Jewish infidel is hiding behind me! Come and slay him, ye faithful!" and Roger Waters simply ignores their calls for genocide of Jews.
@HeadofIbis and what relevance can that possibly have to the increasing numbers of Palestinian refugees? It's like you're oblivious to what daily life is like for a Palestinian in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, the Palestinians do not even have the luxury of participating in boycotts because their essential goods are mostly smuggled in. So again, what on Earth does Palestinian resistance to occupation have to do with their increasing numbers as refugees?
@angryafghan That's the point, half of these so-called "refugees" never set foot anywhere in the middle east. An Arab of Palestinian descent who is 4th generation born in America is not a "refugee" and enjoys no rights as such.
Besides, the people in Gaza and West Bank are suffering from the occupation, true enough; but when they were offered by Israel complete autonomy in their territory their leadership turned it down. They were offered a free country and they simply said NO.
@angryafghan You "can't take" back what never belonged to you. The Jews built a beautiful country, with cities, roads, agriculture, industry, commerce, institutions - these achivements don't belong to any Palestinian. Let them build their own country instead of trying to destory Israel.
@HeadofIbis Arab countries don't deny the Palestinians local citizenship, you moron... The Palestinians keep their Palestinian identity for the right of return. It's not about them living as citizens in Arab countries, it's about the legal definition of a citizen of Lebanon, and a refugee living in Lebanon, with negotiations with Israel
And in case you don't know, Gaza has the highest birth rate in the world (and the entire Palestinian population has a high birthrate)
@HeadofIbis ... the population of the Palestinian refugee population has grown.
Even Israel acknowledges this, by the fact that they encourage settlement activity to make-up for their naturally low and socially different birthrates.
Learn to read instead making so many stupid accusations
@skinnywhop87 Your reply made me FACEPALM: you both deny what I say AND prove me right - and you call ME the moron?? You say so yourself, it's about the definition of a Palestinian refugee in Lebanon: THEY ARE DENIED LOCAL CITIZENSHIP!!!
Furthermore, refugee population by international law can't "grow", you don't suckle legal refugee status from your mom's tit. An Arab of Palestinian origin 4th generation born in America is not a "refugee", he's an American national.
@HeadofIbis I didn't prove you right, I corrected your facts. For one you said "Arab related countries deny Palestinians as local citizens"
Which is not true, in Egypt and Jordan Palestinians can maintain their full Palestinian identity. In Lebanon and Syria, it's different because they're in land disputes with Israel, which if the Palestinians applied for local citzenship, then they can be used as a political tool by ISRAEL to deny rights of return. I explained this to you clearly
@skinnywhop87 You're deploying smoke-screens frantically. Palestinian identity (which they have) does not equal CITIZENSHIP. They can keep their identity all they want, but they should get local citizenship.
Lebanon isn't in a "land dispute" with Israel. Syria wants the Golan back, but when Israel offered it to them Bashar Assad refused - and none of this has anything to do with the Palestinians, who, I repeat, are systematically and unlawfully denied local citizenship in these countries.
@HeadofIbis And yes, if someone of Palestinian origin (especially in America), was born in America, they can still apply for duel national identity.
The Palestinians are using this as a political tool, the exact same way Jewish nationalists used 70 years ago, to create a political cause for the creation of their state. Also, if Palestinian REFUGEES, gave up their REFUGEE status, it would legitimize the crimes Israel has committed. By maintaining their REFUGEE status, they can say they're
@skinnywhop87 They can't apply for any "dual citizenship" cuz Palestine doesn't exist as a sovereign country and never has. You want to build a country called "Palestine"? Be my guest. But they have no right to "return" to Israel because they don't originate from this state and never even set foot there, case closed.
@HeadofIbis Many are from within Israel proper. Almost the majority of Gaza's population is from places like Jaffa, Tel Aviv, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Sderot, ect. And they should have the right to return there, since their exclusion was created BY Israel. You are completely ignorant to history and cold hard facts if you most Gazans were born there. Gaza is classified as the largest refugee camp on earth. Do you know nothing about the Bedouins who are now forced in Gaza, who lived until recent times
@skinnywhop87 Debating you is an insult to the intelligence. Fucking SDEROT?!?!? Sderot was established in the 50's as a transition camp for Jewish immigrants, after Israel was long established as independent. No "Palestinian" lived in Sderot you idiot. FAIL
Oh and by the way, Bedouins are NOT Palestinians. Bedouins HATE Palestinians, that's why they volunteer to the IDF to stop Palestinian terrorists from terrorizing Israel, because they are also victims of their atrocities.
@skinnywhop87 Listen, Roger made this video because he went to Israel and saw a big wall. He asked "what's this wall for?" and they told him "to keep Palestinians out". Both him and you must understand: Palestinians in the west bank are NOT ISRAELI CITIZENS! There is no "Apartheid" there because they don't belong in this country, never have, and the wall is there to stop them from comitting terrorist attacks that claimed the lives of thousands of innocent Israeli civilians this past decade.
@HeadofIbis Lebanon has land disputes with Israel, both in southern lebanon, and to mining rights in the Mediterranean.
And since you say Palestinians in the west bank (which we both seem to agree is THEIR legal land). aren't living in Apartheid. Then maybe you should tell that to the ISRAELI citizens who make up nearly half a million in population in the OCCUPIED TERRITORIES, which have constructed ILLEGAL settlements where Palestinians can't obtain land or rights, or even access THEIR ownland
@skinnywhop87 Israeli civilians make up about 300,000 in West Bank, not nearly half a million. So what if they live there? This territory is indeed occupied, but from whom..? It was annexed by Jordan after the 1949 war. In the Israel-Jordan peace accords they were offered this territory back but relinquished any right to it. Today under international law it belongs to NOBODY and anyone can build there whatever they want, you can build fucking Disneyworld in the West Bank if you want.
@HeadofIbis If there's no apartheid, then explain this huge wall that cuts into PALESTINIAN territory.
Explain why there's roads in the west bank that only people with ISRAELI license plates can drive on... Also explain why within Israel Jewish and Non-Jewish primary schools are SEGREGATED.
Also explain how even ethopian jews are treated like second class citizens within Israel.
Israel is apartheid, you have to be ignorant on the term, or israeli policy to deny this fact
@skinnywhop87 I already explained, the wall was constructed to stop Palestinians from infiltrating Israel and comitting terrorist attacks. Very effective :-)
Schools in Israel are separate because the communities historically were built separately. But there's no legislation in Israel that prohibits an Arab from enrolling in an Israel-Jewish primary school, high-school, college or university = No Apartheid. FAIL
@skinnywhop87 And what does this have to do with Ethiopian Jews, you buffoon? Racism against ethnic minorities is a phenomena that exists in every country. Unfortunately, it exists in Israel as well, and last week there was even a huge anti-racist protest there. But there is no legislation in Israel that discriminates in any manner nor any way between members of different ethnic or religious background, Ethiopians, Arabs or others = No Apartheid. FAIL
@skinnywhop87 YOU are the one who is ignorant as to the nature of the term "Apartheid". You need to go buy a dictionary and stop shouting empty slogans.
@HeadofIbis also, the 2010 massacre on the flotilla: in international waters, Israel massacred 9 peace activists. the racist policies that make life unbearable for Palestinians who hold Israeli ID cards, and who make up 20% of Israel's population.
@HeadofIbis AND, the illegal, apartheid wall, that separates families from each other, from their own land, from water, and often from the jobs they "once had". the illegal raids, in which children are seized, and families are terrorized, by Israeli forces, in the West Bank.
@PinkTitanium What Apartheid are you babbling about, Palestinians in the West Bank aren't Israeli citizens, and the wall was built to stop them from mass-murdering Israeli citizens, thousands of which were slaughtered at their hands in past decades in the Intifadas and Jihad-inspired terrorist attacks. JUST 3 DAYS AGO!!! A West-Bank resident tried to stab a 12yo Jewish girl in Jerusalem, he crossed into Israel through an unfenced portion of the border area.
@HeadofIbis let alone the hundreds of UN resolutions that Israel is not abiding by, disrespecting the whole planet. israeli politics are cruel, whether you like it or not, it's a fact. israeli politics are making 7 billion people angry, israeli politics, like a woman scorned, takes out its inhumanity and anger on the wrong people. please do not support inhumanity, please support peace. israeli politics are not after peace, it's after greed and more racist brutality.
@PinkTitanium Israeli-Arabic citizens are ministers in the Israeli government, they are represented in the Knesset the Israeli parliament, have Arabic political parties and right to vote, there are even Arabic judges in the Israeli high-court. You don't know SHIT about this country, sir. Meanwhile, Palestinians can't even get a citizenship in Lebanon, can't get a job or a house. In the 1990's almost 300,000 Palestinians were expelled from Kuwait and nobody even blinked.
@HeadofIbis i didn't ask you to misinform me with your hasbara excuses... i'm telling you to get informed about the things i have stated above. and that, my friend, is what you didn't do before replying to me. so how am i to respect your answers with a sensible reply? it's impossible. i hope one day you'll see your wrongs and make them right, until then, enjoy the BDS movement.
@PinkTitanium So you're denying that 3 days ago a hate-crime on nationalist and racist grounds took place in Jerusalem, the capital of Israel, in which a Palestinian resident of the West Bank attempted to murder innocent Jewish children, and having failed he fled and narrowly escaped the police? Is that a fact or some "hasbara"?
@PinkTitanium "boo hoo Israeli politics are so cruel" the Hamas charter states that one of the Palestinian national movement's goals is the extermination of the Jewish race not only in Israel but ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD. That seems absolutely sound and justified to you, doesn't it? Not in the least cruel and inhumane? oh wait, nah it's probably some more "hasbara" on my account isn't it? Yeah, keep telling that to yourself.
I always thought Roger really knew where it was at politically even though I'd rather go to a Gilmour concert any day. Although he's got some talent in music and word, I think maybe some of Roger's best talents have not yet been utilized. First of all, they should lock up that Bono and give Roger his job because Roger really has balls when dealing with the world's swine.
I think he'd make even a better statesmen than a singer or a bass player. WTG, Roger. I never doubted his political philosophies, and his lyrics are cool too. But I wonder how he manages now without David Gilmour playing bass for him during studio sessions while he watches with a set of headphones on smoking a cigarrette.
Top Comments Rodgers you rock without brains! FF Around 4:30
“I fully and entirely endorse …what do they call, ah-ah? … Boycott within”
“…and Ronny, I’m with you heart and soul” Suffice-it-to-say, without brains. Age or damaged goods Roger Waters you are SO clueless, you give mental retardation a bad name.
the best thing roger can do is giving a FREE "wall"concert in palestine! that would rock Pal & the free world.It would also scared the shit out of israel
LOL... it's getting really old to try to silence people who oppose injustice and apartheid 'anti-semite.' everyone knows it's a deliberate tactic used and abused by israel. and calling jews who oppose such things 'self-hating jew.' if you only knew how ridiculous and stale you sound...
thank you mr. waters. i have joined the BDS against israel. greetings from USA
@batfrend And people like you are nothing more than deluded tofu eating Jihad lovers who don't seem to realize that the people they support hate them as much as they hate Israelis. Just ask Vittorio Arrigoni.
@earthwormjah hahahahaha BTW i saw ur channel, I lol'd at the comments insulting you hahaha, I see youre a brainless troll, im not wasting more time with you. PS: Are u really from Angola? if u are, mind your own impecunious country instead of talking non-sense and defending criminals. Bye
@124235346 A story generally involves a plot and characters, and civilized people do not refer to "Retarded" people any more. But thanks for your insightful comment!
@124235346 Since your comment contained no intellectual information, I worked with what was there. Thank you for that fascinating insight into what i'm sure is an amazing world of pithy internet catchphrases!
@earthwormjah go suck a dick lol... im only gonna tell u that this is not "blind Israel hatred" AT ALL. If you defend israel's crimes u are a brainwashed dumbass.
@124235346 And I take it you know this because you are from Israel or the territories? Your comment is not terribly intelligent, and my responding to you calling me a dumbass would be the same as arguing with a small child (apparently, thinking and grammar are not prized attributes amongst the Israel hating crowd). If you don't have anything smart to say, run along like a good boy and go play with your guitar.
@earthwormjah dude u are stupid... its not about "hating israel" its just being sympathetic with the palestinians... 1)that land is literally stolen, Israel could just have created their state in any other country (obviously u didnt know about this, and since u think its all about "blind hatred" i deduce you have never read a shit about the big zionist lies and u know nothing about the truth) Oh btw im a medical student and my grammar is perfect, and im also a talented musician :).
Just because he dosen´t suport Israel actions someone call him a Neo-Nazi Jew hater??? So we have all to suport Israel actions is that it?? Ok so you can call me a Neo-Nazi Jew hater to, F........ you very much.
Arabs and Muslims one hundred years ago did not commonly use it. Nor did they see the country to which the name applied as a separate country. For them, it was an indistinct part of a larger geographic entity, Bilad ash-Sham (usually translated as Syria or Greater Syria). Nor did it have a territorial division of any name that corresponded in its boundaries even roughly to those of the political entity Palestine named and set up by the international community at San Remo in 1920. Go to Jordan.
How funny when Israelis say there is no Palestine. Pull out any pre48 map. A lie is a lie. Since we've concluded Zionists lie about the most obvious facts, then we must logically proclaim Zionism is an ideology followed by lying thieves. Btw - there never was an Israel. It was named that by followers of Jacob.
It will take brave men like Roger W speaking out to end Israeli oppression. Roger is successful and rich and cannot be blackmailed into unconditional support for Israeli madness.
@sharonbeni28 (Roger Lives in the US state of New York, Just outside NYC.) Think on this: When a celebrity sees a thing that is reprehensible, should he ignore it just because he can't address all the planets myriad issues? A wrong is a wrong. And we all must choose our battles. If all one has is a single magnifying glass, then hold it over something will ya!
Roger, I cannot believe that you out of all people are blind to the truth and you are USED very cleverly by anti peace movement like BDS, go and join also your other friendly IHH, rethink.
It's disappointing that so many (as indicated by the percentage of video "dislikes") would support racist, criminal, oppressive, inhumane, brutal, terrorist Zionazi Israel, Thankfully ... while Israel becomes increasingly fascist, the world is, simultaneously, becoming increasingly aware of Israel's crimes. Injustice against one is injustice against all. Zionazi Israel is a pariah state. Zionazi Israel WILL fall. Palestine WILL be FREE !!
Israel is an occupying force. Until they face that fact they will always deny the obvious. We on the outside are able to see the reality while the ones you who benifit from this situation try to shout us down. Pity the fools who say something against Israel, the glass holy....... Shame on me as well, I suppose. I have zero issue with Jews, I do, hoiwever, have issues with Israel which is not synonymous with "Jew".
I'm with you, my man. You may have been one mean SOB in the day but now, you're getting the focus of that on the right things. Love ya and always will. Keep up the fight, Roger. You have the floor..............
Dear Roger, you are a very telented musician but as a politician activist you are less then POOR. You have no idea about what's going on in Israel and it's history. All you hear is the continual lies and slandings from the world media & the British media at the top!
Sadly, such statements of anti-Israel groups, who simply ABUSE the freedom of speech are only makes Israel to squeeze into such dark actions and build The Wall - where no one listens to Pink Floyd anymore, but only to "HaTikva"!!!
Whilst Roger her was painting graffiti on Israel's anti-terrorism wall, people in Sudan were been subject to one of the most horrific genocides in modern times. Way to use (waste) your influence. He describes BDS as "loving" whilst Omar Bargoutti makes no secret of his intended aim, which is to bring about an end to Israel as a Jewish state.
The ignorance of the people on here calling the Palestinians terrorists is so ludicrous they're not even worth answering. Read a book once in your life instead of getting spoonfed your ideas of the world from Sky News and the Sun.
If only he had the same passion about his people's occupation of my old homeland, Northern Ireland. He never said a damn thing about his government's "Super Powers Act" which allowed Brits to pick Irish kids up off the street and detain them at Castlereagh for up to a week and be allowed to torture them. They even had a name for it called "Manbreak" where they would literally physically break an Irish person to get information. What a hypocrite.
kencoa 3 days ago
70% of IS-RA-HELLS GDP comes from donations from other states so you really have to think who is the parasitic murderer hmmmmm thats a tough one
fistthatwillbustlips 3 days ago
fuckin jews to the gas hitler was right
fistthatwillbustlips 3 days ago
wow what an embarrassment LOL.
ImNeilPatrickHarris 1 week ago
LOL "I fully and entirely endorse.....what are they called again?"
angryafghan 1 month ago 6
I think Roger should just keep doing music and perhaps not talk the rest of the time. I couldn't care less what he thinks about anything. Every time I hear him talk my interest in his music decreases. I have been a devoted fan for about 30 years now. Truly I have. But my sympathies are beginning to shift to the Gilmour camp. BTW, I agree with the notion of a free Palestine. I just don't like artists and politicians when they speak.
paxomatic2 1 month ago
@paxomatic2 "I just don't like artists and politicians when they speak" -- Artists are citizens too. They are in a position of prominence. Most celebrities use their amplified voice to engage in narcissism. Roger Waters is a hero because he uses his voice, even though it pisses people off, to speak to power about real issues that are affecting the poor and the marginalized over the whole world. I salute him!
originalfunkyfry 1 month ago
@originalfunkyfry That's nice.
paxomatic2 1 month ago
My Dear Rodger,
Can we please focus on America and stop defending these idiots?
In part, because I cannot go to any Arab nation and build a church
In part, because muslim’s caused something I cannot forget, 9/11
In part, because muslim’s breed extremists like no other religion
In part, because France is 20% muslim and growing fast, England too
In part, because we have seen muslim clans that kill each other
In part, because we have seen muslim’s behead others
wtfwtf47ify 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
In part, because I am an “infidel”
In part, because of muslim’s intolerance towards others, including themselves
In part, because their holly koran says muslim’s must rise against infidels
In part, because their holly koran says muslim’s are allowed to lie to infidels
wtfwtf47ify 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
In part, because their holly koran says muslim’s are allowed to kill infidels
In part, because many muslim’s want sharia law and “fatwa”
In part, because I’m a proud American and my dad was a WWII veteran
In part, because I love my country and don’t want another Egypt
In part, because I LOVE MY CHILDREN and what them to grow up like me
wtfwtf47ify 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Please God, the Almighty, let my children grow up without these concerns
Please God give them life without fear that the muslim’s bring
Please God give them the strength to fight back if times get desperate
Thank you Lord for helping me see truth clearly and for all the people who served… the ones that died and survived to protect our freedom
Happy Holiday’s to everyone!
wtfwtf47ify 2 months ago 2
Roger is always on the side of truth and liberty and justice. The dislikers must be on the opposite side of this discussion...
ParanoidAndification 2 months ago
FREE PALESTINE!
3RamakerBaz 2 months ago
Roger, you certainly got people talking. Brilliant!
edicionesxv 2 months ago
RON PAUL 2012!
d0ct0rd3ath 2 months ago
Roger , keep up the good work,We all should boycott Zionist government of Israel . Zionist and Jewish are two different things.
dariuana 2 months ago
Roger, stick to music, and stop with this propaganda.
tomrulesify 2 months ago
@tomrulesify 1. everything is propaganda. 2. regardless of the any issue regarding the middle east, making boycott illegal is fucking stupid.
sexdrugsRnR 2 months ago
Right on. As always Roger, well said.
dragondigger 3 months ago
idiot
jonnytrooper 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
“… the Israeli government's actions toward the Palestinians awaken horrific memories of my family's experiences under Hitlerism: the inhuman walls, the checkpoints, the daily humiliations, killings, diseases, the systematic deprivation. There's no escaping the fact that Israel has occupied the entire country of Palestine, and taken most of the land, while the Palestinians have been expelled, walled off, and deprived of human rights and human dignity.” – Holocaust survivor Suzanne Weiss
phellenic 3 months ago
@phellenic Uh, Jordan is the majority of Palestine.
Two things, the Hashemites are the minority but they rule over the 70% Palestinian majority.
Also HOW LONG did Jordan have Martial Law for anyway, after The Six Day War? It was 25 years and no one ever said shit about it, in fact, this is probably the first time you're hearing it.
I can just IMAGINE what you'd have to say if ISRAEL had martial law for 25 years!!!
But when the Arabs do it, you give them a "pass."
SatchmoSings 1 month ago
Hell yeah boycott Israel!!!
The420Gunslinger 3 months ago
Roger you have the best political views of any musician I know. Love pink floyd by the way
Mrjetlee24 3 months ago
HEY ROGER !!! SHOW WAS PHENOMENAL !!!! THANKS A LOT !!!!
sam0xin 3 months ago
Great Roger, you are an amazing guy. See you in Vancouver next may!!
pinkalifa 3 months ago
In reading the comments it seems that the Zionist fools are spewing no content as usual. Goes to show you what kind of gene pool these zionists are from. The bottom of the barrel. Roger is awesome. Long live Pink Floyd!
Mrspeakerofthehouse2 3 months ago
Roger you are a hero
farrokhsca 3 months ago
Free Syria and Palestine
thesyrianexpatriate 3 months ago
Fu*k palestine. Fu*k these stupid whack job muslims who want nothing more than to spill innocent civilian blood. Maybe this fu*ktard bleeding heart should put on a jewish skull cap and walk around the west bank or gaza strip for a few hours. (He'd probably be dead or kidnapped within seconds). Mus-tards have no respect for human life or basic human rights.
belutes 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@belutes "Maybe this fu*ktard bleeding heart should put on a jewish skull cap and walk around the west bank or gaza strip for a few hours. "
I just saved $200 by not seeing this libtard's show. He'd be a lampshade or speaking German of not for the smart people also understanding the cancer that the cult of Islam is upon this globe.
No wonder he writes such dark lyrics. He escaped with his life while Syd Barret did one pill more and crossed over. I'm glad Gilmour left this sick bastard.
mrUSConstitution1 3 months ago 3
Desmond Tutu, Nelson Mandella, Winnie Mandella, Ronold Kasrils, the South African Union of Students and the South African Student Congress have all called Israel's policies and actions toward the Palestinians as apartheid. On Aug 4th, South African students stated "...We lived apartheid, we suffered apartheid, we know what apartheid is, we recognise apartheid when we see it. And when we see Israel, we see a regime that practices apartheid."
Thank you Roger - you are a gentlemen
phellenic 3 months ago
@phellenic "We lived apartheid, we suffered apartheid, we know what apartheid is, we recognise apartheid when we see it. And when we see Israel, we see a regime that practices apartheid.""
South Africa is a ghetto now and the child rape capitol of the world. And this is purely an observation based in history....show me the last nation that prospered under a black leader. I wish to hell one would, but America got one and now it's doomed too. Too much white hate to govern remains in them.
mrUSConstitution1 3 months ago
@mrUSConstitution1 I agree with what you've said however I wouldn't pin America's current downward spiral on Obama simply because he's black; he's just on a continuum that started with Lyndon Johnson.
SatchmoSings 3 months ago
@phellenic Apartheid is the state sanctioned separation of races, enforced by laws. There are NO such laws in Israel
Jewish & Arab babies are born in the same delivery room, attended by the same doctors & nurses
At Hadassah Hospital 1/3 of the medical staff is Arab
Jews & Arabs share meals in restaurants and travel on the same trains, buses & taxis, and visit each other’s homes
Haifa U - 20% of students are Arab
This is NOT apartheid.
SatchmoSings 3 months ago 2
@SatchmoSings - if you believe palestinians are treated as equals in Israel, you must also believe in the right of return for palestinians given that that right is accorded to jews.
you cant have it both ways my friend - the Russel Tribunal found aparthied policies in the occupied lands and in Israel proper.
zionism = nazism
phellenic 1 month ago
@phellenic
Zionism = Nazism = Jew Demonization = Jew Hater
Yes, this is the same Russell Tribunal that only pronounced guilt against the US and its Allies in Vietnam but never against the North Vietnamese nor National Liberation Front.
Nice to see where you stand, right in the middle of the good old double-standard and proudly so!
SatchmoSings 1 month ago
@SatchmoSings - all you do is point the finger at others (jordan, north vietnamese) or quickly dismiss the informed because you know that Israel is a murderous apartheid state that is the piriah of the world - history will not be kind to the zionists and people like you will be remembered with utter repulsion
phellenic 1 month ago
@phellenic Israel is a pariah in YOUR world not "of the world;" this explains why Israel gets a five billion dollar CPU factory/research center from "Intel" while 440,000,000 Arabs in 22 countries can't even attract a factory to sew doll clothes.
Also, this apartheid, let alone "MURDEROUS" apartheid is a damn lie; there is no Apartheid in Israel or in the West Bank; you make this accusation because you're a Jew hater.
SatchmoSings 1 month ago
@phellenic What are you babbling about, one of the statesmen who appeared before the Russel Tribunal last year was Haneen Zoabi, an Israeli parliament member of indigenous Arabic origin, in other words A PALESTINIAN!!! How could it be an Apartheid if the Arabs in Israel have their own political parties and parliament members???
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis - what are you babbling about? I didn't say anything it was the Russel Tribunal made up of an eminent panel of international jurists that came to the conclusion that israel practices apartheid in israel and occupied Palestine - for example israel refuses to allow the palestinian refugees the right to return to the land that was confiscated by the european colonial zionists back in 1948.
no right of return = apartheid = racism = zionism
phellenic 1 month ago
@phellenic I read the report issued by the Russel Tribunal, it's complete hogwash. They compare the occupation of "Palestine" to the South-African occupation of Namibia. WELL GEE, Namibia was a sovereign country, PALESTINE DOES NOT EXIST!!!!!!! They are just like you, can't decide if "Palestine" is a country occupied by Israel or it's just Israel with "Apartheid". They're just going for broke, throwing any accusation possible, maybe something will stick.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago 2
@HeadofIbis wait what Palestine does not exist and Israel does? Before WWII and the allies helping you get a small homeland Palestinians lived there. Hope was you would get along but you fostered the same bigoted hatred that the Nazis had against Jews. I've heard Israelis say that cause the Palestinians are week they don't deserve to live there I guess with that logic the Holocaust was deserved too? Your Zionist logic and religious zealot-ism is f-d up and drives the whole world back
Wrapped01 2 weeks ago
Rock musicians should stay the fuck out of politics.
432ps1 3 months ago
Roger Waters is a piece of shit, I thought he was a piece of shit when I heard he left England over the hunting ban, but this just proves he is a piece of crap
Do not understand how someone can be so "liberal" but can be so evil at the same time
Maybe it is a european thing
Roger go die asshole
Knock1225 3 months ago
And oh yeah Roger, as usual total agreement and man, this is the first time I had delved deeply into your political side. Good to see all this lately after 30-40 years of apathy, right! Take care and I'm gonna listen to K.A.O.S.
Peace to All
jhamptonjr 3 months ago
@PinkTitanium @HeadofIbis Arguing, name calling and stiff-necked-ness have got to stop. There have been ample examples of violence on both sides. But the influence of the richest men in the world keep you fighting to your own demise, if you continue to disrespect and hate your fellow man. Do you teach this to your children, too? Are you going to sell them into the same system and continue this? Share the land, love and forgive your neighbor, STARVE the MACHINE!
Peace to All
jhamptonjr 3 months ago
Mother should I build the wall?
SolidSmush 3 months ago
stop the billions in foreign aide to isreal & give it back to american tax payers & let isreal expansionalist deal with their own problems.........how can you ask palestinians to leave palestine? fuckin' wankers
marbleheadband 4 months ago
Roger Waters is simply uninformed, I just lost any respect I had for him.
1st of all, the West Bank isn't "occupied", cuz it's not a country, this territory never belonged to a sovereign state, so legally speaking it's DISPUTED TERRITORY, not "occupied".
2nd, Israel offered the Palestinians complete autonomy beyond the green line with total dismantling of all the Jewish settlements, TWICE - but the Palestinians said "no". If they love their freedom so much, WHY did they turn it down???
HeadofIbis 4 months ago 2
@HeadofIbis i encourage you to learn more about: the BDS movement (Boycott, Divest and Sanctions),
the status of Palestinian refugees who live deprived of their land in refugee camps in Lebanon, Jordan, Syria and more..., the open-air prison called the Gaza Strip, encasing over 1 million Palestinians and patrolled and bombed by man-less drones.
PinkTitanium 4 months ago
@PinkTitanium Gaza isn't a prison, they got a border with Egypt that would be wide open, if the Hamas weren't so collaborative with the Muslim Brothers and their plan to turn Egypt into a Sunni-Muslim theocracy - no wonder they don't let anybody out. That doesn't stop Gazans from smuggling in everything they need, including illegal drugs and Iranian rockets, thousands of which were rained on Israeli cities for the past decade.
HeadofIbis 4 months ago 2
and please enlighten me, why is there a seperate definition for Palestinian refugees, according to which their number only INCREASES as the years go by, while other refugee populations in the world are dwindling? Could have something to do with having their own UN relief agency which pours on them more funds than all refugees in the world combined, quie an incentive to maintain their "refugee" status, no? Could also be related to the fact Arabic countries deny the Palestinians local citizenship.
HeadofIbis 4 months ago 6
@HeadofIbis Do you know why Arab states do not extend local citizenship to Palestinians? It is because if that happened they would cease to exist as a nation and would simply become absorbed into those neighbouring arab populations.
angryafghan 1 month ago
@angryafghan The problem is that they think the only way to become a nation is to destroy an existing one: Israel. They express their intent with slogans like "Millions of martyrs march to Jerusalem!", "With blood and fire we shall reclaim Palestine" and "The tree and rock will shout: the Jewish infidel is hiding behind me! Come and slay him, ye faithful!" and Roger Waters simply ignores their calls for genocide of Jews.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago 5
@HeadofIbis and what relevance can that possibly have to the increasing numbers of Palestinian refugees? It's like you're oblivious to what daily life is like for a Palestinian in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, the Palestinians do not even have the luxury of participating in boycotts because their essential goods are mostly smuggled in. So again, what on Earth does Palestinian resistance to occupation have to do with their increasing numbers as refugees?
angryafghan 1 month ago
@angryafghan That's the point, half of these so-called "refugees" never set foot anywhere in the middle east. An Arab of Palestinian descent who is 4th generation born in America is not a "refugee" and enjoys no rights as such.
Besides, the people in Gaza and West Bank are suffering from the occupation, true enough; but when they were offered by Israel complete autonomy in their territory their leadership turned it down. They were offered a free country and they simply said NO.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis and Inshallah they will one day take back what is theirs!
angryafghan 1 month ago
@angryafghan You "can't take" back what never belonged to you. The Jews built a beautiful country, with cities, roads, agriculture, industry, commerce, institutions - these achivements don't belong to any Palestinian. Let them build their own country instead of trying to destory Israel.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis After WWII, Allied nations THREW OUT 15.5 MILLION Germans but it seems that Germany absorbed them all.
Poland alone threw out 8.5 million and took their homes and land and no one says shit about this.
SatchmoSings 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis Arab countries don't deny the Palestinians local citizenship, you moron... The Palestinians keep their Palestinian identity for the right of return. It's not about them living as citizens in Arab countries, it's about the legal definition of a citizen of Lebanon, and a refugee living in Lebanon, with negotiations with Israel
And in case you don't know, Gaza has the highest birth rate in the world (and the entire Palestinian population has a high birthrate)
This explains why the
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis ... the population of the Palestinian refugee population has grown.
Even Israel acknowledges this, by the fact that they encourage settlement activity to make-up for their naturally low and socially different birthrates.
Learn to read instead making so many stupid accusations
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 Your reply made me FACEPALM: you both deny what I say AND prove me right - and you call ME the moron?? You say so yourself, it's about the definition of a Palestinian refugee in Lebanon: THEY ARE DENIED LOCAL CITIZENSHIP!!!
Furthermore, refugee population by international law can't "grow", you don't suckle legal refugee status from your mom's tit. An Arab of Palestinian origin 4th generation born in America is not a "refugee", he's an American national.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis I didn't prove you right, I corrected your facts. For one you said "Arab related countries deny Palestinians as local citizens"
Which is not true, in Egypt and Jordan Palestinians can maintain their full Palestinian identity. In Lebanon and Syria, it's different because they're in land disputes with Israel, which if the Palestinians applied for local citzenship, then they can be used as a political tool by ISRAEL to deny rights of return. I explained this to you clearly
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 You're deploying smoke-screens frantically. Palestinian identity (which they have) does not equal CITIZENSHIP. They can keep their identity all they want, but they should get local citizenship.
Lebanon isn't in a "land dispute" with Israel. Syria wants the Golan back, but when Israel offered it to them Bashar Assad refused - and none of this has anything to do with the Palestinians, who, I repeat, are systematically and unlawfully denied local citizenship in these countries.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis And yes, if someone of Palestinian origin (especially in America), was born in America, they can still apply for duel national identity.
The Palestinians are using this as a political tool, the exact same way Jewish nationalists used 70 years ago, to create a political cause for the creation of their state. Also, if Palestinian REFUGEES, gave up their REFUGEE status, it would legitimize the crimes Israel has committed. By maintaining their REFUGEE status, they can say they're
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 They can't apply for any "dual citizenship" cuz Palestine doesn't exist as a sovereign country and never has. You want to build a country called "Palestine"? Be my guest. But they have no right to "return" to Israel because they don't originate from this state and never even set foot there, case closed.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis Many are from within Israel proper. Almost the majority of Gaza's population is from places like Jaffa, Tel Aviv, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Sderot, ect. And they should have the right to return there, since their exclusion was created BY Israel. You are completely ignorant to history and cold hard facts if you most Gazans were born there. Gaza is classified as the largest refugee camp on earth. Do you know nothing about the Bedouins who are now forced in Gaza, who lived until recent times
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 Debating you is an insult to the intelligence. Fucking SDEROT?!?!? Sderot was established in the 50's as a transition camp for Jewish immigrants, after Israel was long established as independent. No "Palestinian" lived in Sderot you idiot. FAIL
Oh and by the way, Bedouins are NOT Palestinians. Bedouins HATE Palestinians, that's why they volunteer to the IDF to stop Palestinian terrorists from terrorizing Israel, because they are also victims of their atrocities.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis ... in the Negev
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis .... in exile from their ancestral home, and plan to return when the political environment is suitable.
Please actually learn the history, legality, and terminology of this situation. It actually makes sense when you know what you're talking about
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 Listen, Roger made this video because he went to Israel and saw a big wall. He asked "what's this wall for?" and they told him "to keep Palestinians out". Both him and you must understand: Palestinians in the west bank are NOT ISRAELI CITIZENS! There is no "Apartheid" there because they don't belong in this country, never have, and the wall is there to stop them from comitting terrorist attacks that claimed the lives of thousands of innocent Israeli civilians this past decade.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis Lebanon has land disputes with Israel, both in southern lebanon, and to mining rights in the Mediterranean.
And since you say Palestinians in the west bank (which we both seem to agree is THEIR legal land). aren't living in Apartheid. Then maybe you should tell that to the ISRAELI citizens who make up nearly half a million in population in the OCCUPIED TERRITORIES, which have constructed ILLEGAL settlements where Palestinians can't obtain land or rights, or even access THEIR ownland
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 Israeli civilians make up about 300,000 in West Bank, not nearly half a million. So what if they live there? This territory is indeed occupied, but from whom..? It was annexed by Jordan after the 1949 war. In the Israel-Jordan peace accords they were offered this territory back but relinquished any right to it. Today under international law it belongs to NOBODY and anyone can build there whatever they want, you can build fucking Disneyworld in the West Bank if you want.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis If there's no apartheid, then explain this huge wall that cuts into PALESTINIAN territory.
Explain why there's roads in the west bank that only people with ISRAELI license plates can drive on... Also explain why within Israel Jewish and Non-Jewish primary schools are SEGREGATED.
Also explain how even ethopian jews are treated like second class citizens within Israel.
Israel is apartheid, you have to be ignorant on the term, or israeli policy to deny this fact
skinnywhop87 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 I already explained, the wall was constructed to stop Palestinians from infiltrating Israel and comitting terrorist attacks. Very effective :-)
Schools in Israel are separate because the communities historically were built separately. But there's no legislation in Israel that prohibits an Arab from enrolling in an Israel-Jewish primary school, high-school, college or university = No Apartheid. FAIL
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 And what does this have to do with Ethiopian Jews, you buffoon? Racism against ethnic minorities is a phenomena that exists in every country. Unfortunately, it exists in Israel as well, and last week there was even a huge anti-racist protest there. But there is no legislation in Israel that discriminates in any manner nor any way between members of different ethnic or religious background, Ethiopians, Arabs or others = No Apartheid. FAIL
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@skinnywhop87 YOU are the one who is ignorant as to the nature of the term "Apartheid". You need to go buy a dictionary and stop shouting empty slogans.
HeadofIbis 1 month ago
@HeadofIbis also, the 2010 massacre on the flotilla: in international waters, Israel massacred 9 peace activists. the racist policies that make life unbearable for Palestinians who hold Israeli ID cards, and who make up 20% of Israel's population.
PinkTitanium 4 months ago
@HeadofIbis AND, the illegal, apartheid wall, that separates families from each other, from their own land, from water, and often from the jobs they "once had". the illegal raids, in which children are seized, and families are terrorized, by Israeli forces, in the West Bank.
PinkTitanium 4 months ago
@PinkTitanium What Apartheid are you babbling about, Palestinians in the West Bank aren't Israeli citizens, and the wall was built to stop them from mass-murdering Israeli citizens, thousands of which were slaughtered at their hands in past decades in the Intifadas and Jihad-inspired terrorist attacks. JUST 3 DAYS AGO!!! A West-Bank resident tried to stab a 12yo Jewish girl in Jerusalem, he crossed into Israel through an unfenced portion of the border area.
HeadofIbis 4 months ago
@HeadofIbis let alone the hundreds of UN resolutions that Israel is not abiding by, disrespecting the whole planet. israeli politics are cruel, whether you like it or not, it's a fact. israeli politics are making 7 billion people angry, israeli politics, like a woman scorned, takes out its inhumanity and anger on the wrong people. please do not support inhumanity, please support peace. israeli politics are not after peace, it's after greed and more racist brutality.
PinkTitanium 4 months ago
@PinkTitanium Israeli-Arabic citizens are ministers in the Israeli government, they are represented in the Knesset the Israeli parliament, have Arabic political parties and right to vote, there are even Arabic judges in the Israeli high-court. You don't know SHIT about this country, sir. Meanwhile, Palestinians can't even get a citizenship in Lebanon, can't get a job or a house. In the 1990's almost 300,000 Palestinians were expelled from Kuwait and nobody even blinked.
HeadofIbis 4 months ago 2
@HeadofIbis i didn't ask you to misinform me with your hasbara excuses... i'm telling you to get informed about the things i have stated above. and that, my friend, is what you didn't do before replying to me. so how am i to respect your answers with a sensible reply? it's impossible. i hope one day you'll see your wrongs and make them right, until then, enjoy the BDS movement.
PinkTitanium 4 months ago
@PinkTitanium So you're denying that 3 days ago a hate-crime on nationalist and racist grounds took place in Jerusalem, the capital of Israel, in which a Palestinian resident of the West Bank attempted to murder innocent Jewish children, and having failed he fled and narrowly escaped the police? Is that a fact or some "hasbara"?
HeadofIbis 4 months ago 2
@PinkTitanium "boo hoo Israeli politics are so cruel" the Hamas charter states that one of the Palestinian national movement's goals is the extermination of the Jewish race not only in Israel but ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD. That seems absolutely sound and justified to you, doesn't it? Not in the least cruel and inhumane? oh wait, nah it's probably some more "hasbara" on my account isn't it? Yeah, keep telling that to yourself.
HeadofIbis 4 months ago 2
I always thought Roger really knew where it was at politically even though I'd rather go to a Gilmour concert any day. Although he's got some talent in music and word, I think maybe some of Roger's best talents have not yet been utilized. First of all, they should lock up that Bono and give Roger his job because Roger really has balls when dealing with the world's swine.
brofjw 4 months ago
I think he'd make even a better statesmen than a singer or a bass player. WTG, Roger. I never doubted his political philosophies, and his lyrics are cool too. But I wonder how he manages now without David Gilmour playing bass for him during studio sessions while he watches with a set of headphones on smoking a cigarrette.
brofjw 4 months ago
Top Comments Rodgers you rock without brains! FF Around 4:30
“I fully and entirely endorse …what do they call, ah-ah? … Boycott within”
“…and Ronny, I’m with you heart and soul” Suffice-it-to-say, without brains. Age or damaged goods Roger Waters you are SO clueless, you give mental retardation a bad name.
wtfwtf47ify 4 months ago 2
Roger Waters...Respectttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt :)
whateveregy 4 months ago
the best thing roger can do is giving a FREE "wall"concert in palestine! that would rock Pal & the free world.It would also scared the shit out of israel
Starray111 4 months ago
Israel is a Lunatic State... I boycott Israel.
237Michael 4 months ago
Israel = Axis of Evil ........... Occupation 101 on you tube
sexpolice101 4 months ago
The greatest songwriter musician ever Thanks Roger youre voice is reasurring in a world full of injustice and Netanyahoo is nothing but a Kosher Nazi
doikus 4 months ago
Roger Waters is a man!!!!
MrElkhan72 4 months ago
Thank you Roger! FREE PALESTINE!!!
Salutes from Chile!
fagt92 4 months ago 7
Roger Waters is a bloody legend.... Read his lyrics in the song "HOME" from radio KAOS about what's happening to America today.
The words from his early 90's album read like an American prophesy:
" When they overrun the defences A minor invasion put down to expenses
Will you go down to the airport lounge? Will you accept your second class status
A nation of waitresses and waiters.. Will you mix their martinis
Will you stand still for it...... Or will you take to the hills.....?"
Next verse
StopFundingIsrael 4 months ago
@StopFundingIsrael
When the cowboys and Arabs draw down
On each other at noon
In the cool dusty air of the city boardroom
Will you stand by a passive spectator
Of the market dictators
Will you discreetly withdraw
With your ear pressed to the boardroom door
Will you hear when the lion within you roars
Will you take to the hills?
StopFundingIsrael 4 months ago
antisemites. the law he refers to forbids boycotting certain neighborhoods, uneducated masses...
moonlityd 5 months ago
STOP THE WAR, STOP THE PERSECUTION, LOVE FOR LIFE, LOVE AND MORE LOVE.
icroacia 5 months ago
the persecuted become the persecutors, shame on US supported Israel..... Free Palestine - Love from Ireland
Fair Play Roger - Legend
Dewie101 5 months ago
From the cultural milieu of Mr. Waters:
Search Youtube for: "London BDS activists disrupt BBC Proms"
yiftb 5 months ago
Comment removed
yiftb 5 months ago
Roger Waters has balls to stand up against Cancer called "Israel"
Adebay25 5 months ago
Grazie Roger !!! FREE PALESTINA !!!!
MrFabri64 5 months ago
Shut up and sing.
MartyHiggins 5 months ago 2
you disappoint me, roger
brandinator22 5 months ago
LOL... it's getting really old to try to silence people who oppose injustice and apartheid 'anti-semite.' everyone knows it's a deliberate tactic used and abused by israel. and calling jews who oppose such things 'self-hating jew.' if you only knew how ridiculous and stale you sound...
thank you mr. waters. i have joined the BDS against israel. greetings from USA
sherhak 5 months ago
Fuck Roger Waters, the three brain cells Roger has left might be better used for something other than blind Israel hatred.
earthwormjah 5 months ago
@earthwormjah Fuck off! people like u r nothin more thn flag waving goosesteppers.
batfrend 5 months ago
@batfrend And people like you are nothing more than deluded tofu eating Jihad lovers who don't seem to realize that the people they support hate them as much as they hate Israelis. Just ask Vittorio Arrigoni.
earthwormjah 5 months ago
@earthwormjah hahahahaha BTW i saw ur channel, I lol'd at the comments insulting you hahaha, I see youre a brainless troll, im not wasting more time with you. PS: Are u really from Angola? if u are, mind your own impecunious country instead of talking non-sense and defending criminals. Bye
124235346 5 months ago
@earthwormjah cool story retarded jerk
124235346 5 months ago
@124235346 A story generally involves a plot and characters, and civilized people do not refer to "Retarded" people any more. But thanks for your insightful comment!
earthwormjah 5 months ago
@earthwormjah "Cool story" is a popular catchphrase.. learn some english before talking shit.
124235346 5 months ago
@124235346 Since your comment contained no intellectual information, I worked with what was there. Thank you for that fascinating insight into what i'm sure is an amazing world of pithy internet catchphrases!
earthwormjah 5 months ago
@earthwormjah go suck a dick lol... im only gonna tell u that this is not "blind Israel hatred" AT ALL. If you defend israel's crimes u are a brainwashed dumbass.
124235346 5 months ago
@124235346 And I take it you know this because you are from Israel or the territories? Your comment is not terribly intelligent, and my responding to you calling me a dumbass would be the same as arguing with a small child (apparently, thinking and grammar are not prized attributes amongst the Israel hating crowd). If you don't have anything smart to say, run along like a good boy and go play with your guitar.
earthwormjah 5 months ago
@earthwormjah dude u are stupid... its not about "hating israel" its just being sympathetic with the palestinians... 1)that land is literally stolen, Israel could just have created their state in any other country (obviously u didnt know about this, and since u think its all about "blind hatred" i deduce you have never read a shit about the big zionist lies and u know nothing about the truth) Oh btw im a medical student and my grammar is perfect, and im also a talented musician :).
124235346 5 months ago
Comment removed
yiftb 5 months ago
Comment removed
yiftb 5 months ago
Roger you rock!
Arjuna1901 5 months ago 22
Just because he dosen´t suport Israel actions someone call him a Neo-Nazi Jew hater??? So we have all to suport Israel actions is that it?? Ok so you can call me a Neo-Nazi Jew hater to, F........ you very much.
jmgcg 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Roger waters is a neo-nazi jew hater!!!
forrestlynx 5 months ago
"I have in my hand, A piece of paper, signed by the German chancel- No, I'm just kidding. That has nothing to do with that."
DyingPulseProduction 5 months ago
Arabs and Muslims one hundred years ago did not commonly use it. Nor did they see the country to which the name applied as a separate country. For them, it was an indistinct part of a larger geographic entity, Bilad ash-Sham (usually translated as Syria or Greater Syria). Nor did it have a territorial division of any name that corresponded in its boundaries even roughly to those of the political entity Palestine named and set up by the international community at San Remo in 1920. Go to Jordan.
wholewheatpita 5 months ago
How funny when Israelis say there is no Palestine. Pull out any pre48 map. A lie is a lie. Since we've concluded Zionists lie about the most obvious facts, then we must logically proclaim Zionism is an ideology followed by lying thieves. Btw - there never was an Israel. It was named that by followers of Jacob.
Yazen1965 5 months ago
It will take brave men like Roger W speaking out to end Israeli oppression. Roger is successful and rich and cannot be blackmailed into unconditional support for Israeli madness.
Yazen1965 5 months ago
nazi israel is finally is exposed VIVA PALESTINE
TARASONE100 5 months ago
I adore you
Cocknajo 6 months ago
Who gives a fuck about the genocide (fuck all that)
as long as I get my hotel by the sea side
what the fuck do I care if brown people die (fuck all that )
I've got my beer and i've got my American pride
fuck all that I have my Pink Floyd tapes
I''ve bought the rhythm who cares if the message gets raped
poleske 6 months ago
BOYCOTT:General Electric CATerpillar
The Home Depot The Limited
Starbucks McDonald’s,estelauder,L'oreal
Delta Galil , Marks & Spencer ,Sara Lee
Coca-Cola , Intel
Danone (yogurt, HP, Lea & Perrins, Evian water, Jacob biscuits),
Kimberly-Clark (Kleenex, Kotex, Huggies),
Johnson & Johnson, Nokia, Nestlé ,Timberland.
arcz10 6 months ago
Israeli anti-boycott law is another brick on the WALL
deserticus18 6 months ago
roger is under attack from hasbara internet army, lol. i wish these shills would stfu.
go roger. boycott israel.
sherhak 6 months ago
We Love Sovereign Isreal! Restoring courage in the Jewish state!
Hypocrite Waters! Arrogant ... he tries so hard not to be condescending...
"what do they cawl it?.. that means "to talk down to somebuddy!"
jerryknoff 6 months ago
WHERE IS ROGER WATERS ON SYRIA? IRAN? SOMALIA? DARFUR?
He is nothing but a jew hater!
joy00923 6 months ago
FREE LONDON AND COME SYRIA. YOU HYPOCRITE
sharonbeni28 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
roger waters, start preaching about the liberation of england
look what happened with the segration of your immigrants. i bet you would love to have them as your neighbors
sharonbeni28 6 months ago 3
roger waters, start preaching about the liberation of england
look what happened with the segration of your immugrants. i bet you would love to have them as your neighbors
sharonbeni28 6 months ago
@sharonbeni28 (Roger Lives in the US state of New York, Just outside NYC.) Think on this: When a celebrity sees a thing that is reprehensible, should he ignore it just because he can't address all the planets myriad issues? A wrong is a wrong. And we all must choose our battles. If all one has is a single magnifying glass, then hold it over something will ya!
LLH97921 6 months ago
Man i wish hwe would drop the polotics and just try being a musician,,,
chriswilder100 6 months ago
LONG LIVE ISRAEL
what is paleshitine, never heard of it
PROUSA77 6 months ago
Zionis Israel is a BASTARD state and deserve to only BEGGING / BEGGAR the American People Urinated Money to live less they'll PERISHED from EARTH.
mandore100 6 months ago
Why isn't Rogers protesting the Hamas terrorists who kill their own people?
I think the answer is clear.
rokedetbamidbar 6 months ago
who is this drunk englishman
habby06 6 months ago
Roger, I cannot believe that you out of all people are blind to the truth and you are USED very cleverly by anti peace movement like BDS, go and join also your other friendly IHH, rethink.
emotty 6 months ago
waters, sod off you tosser! Israel's economy is booming. how's that BDS workin out for ya bleedn has been?
holseyd 6 months ago
Boycotter les proprios de dieu & The Wall, an enormous task. WELL DONE ROGERS
simplesanstete 6 months ago
It's disappointing that so many (as indicated by the percentage of video "dislikes") would support racist, criminal, oppressive, inhumane, brutal, terrorist Zionazi Israel, Thankfully ... while Israel becomes increasingly fascist, the world is, simultaneously, becoming increasingly aware of Israel's crimes. Injustice against one is injustice against all. Zionazi Israel is a pariah state. Zionazi Israel WILL fall. Palestine WILL be FREE !!
noaid2israel 7 months ago
Their political agenda has been proved many times by facts as wrong?
They are losing in election every time?
Their numbers in parliament decreased to 2.5%?
They lost the public support?
- Their dilemma in a democratic system—
***What to do?***
They are trying to impose their opinion on Israelis by foreign intervention!!!!
And they have the guts to call it democracy!!
Hey- Compete for your ideas –this is democracy!
Imposing your ideas by foreign intervention is-not democracy!
MordechayAriely 7 months ago
Israel is an occupying force. Until they face that fact they will always deny the obvious. We on the outside are able to see the reality while the ones you who benifit from this situation try to shout us down. Pity the fools who say something against Israel, the glass holy....... Shame on me as well, I suppose. I have zero issue with Jews, I do, hoiwever, have issues with Israel which is not synonymous with "Jew".
Shame on Israel. Shame.
eatmoresoap 7 months ago
Comment removed
eatmoresoap 7 months ago
I'm with you, my man. You may have been one mean SOB in the day but now, you're getting the focus of that on the right things. Love ya and always will. Keep up the fight, Roger. You have the floor..............
eatmoresoap 7 months ago
Get off the drugs and learn about what that law is about before you tell Israel what to do you drunk...
RBReadBeard 7 months ago
Get off the drugs and learn about what that law is about before you tell Israel what to do you drunk...
RBReadBeard 7 months ago
i dislike Roger because He was a dick. But was awesome in PF
Feycot 7 months ago
Dear Roger, you are a very telented musician but as a politician activist you are less then POOR. You have no idea about what's going on in Israel and it's history. All you hear is the continual lies and slandings from the world media & the British media at the top!
Sadly, such statements of anti-Israel groups, who simply ABUSE the freedom of speech are only makes Israel to squeeze into such dark actions and build The Wall - where no one listens to Pink Floyd anymore, but only to "HaTikva"!!!
rtmnmk 7 months ago
Comment removed
rtmnmk 7 months ago
Whilst Roger her was painting graffiti on Israel's anti-terrorism wall, people in Sudan were been subject to one of the most horrific genocides in modern times. Way to use (waste) your influence. He describes BDS as "loving" whilst Omar Bargoutti makes no secret of his intended aim, which is to bring about an end to Israel as a Jewish state.
dancingpill 7 months ago
The ignorance of the people on here calling the Palestinians terrorists is so ludicrous they're not even worth answering. Read a book once in your life instead of getting spoonfed your ideas of the world from Sky News and the Sun.
TrustmeUK 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why the dislikes?! D: He is a genious!
DivisionFire 7 months ago
David Gilmour >>>>>>>> Roger Waters
WonderBread006 7 months ago
undotrination, you are so blind, if the palestinians want peace how come you are firing rockets into Israel every day!
how come you have Hamas...a TERRORIST orginization governing your people,you are a tipical of the type of madmen that surround Israel
i wont be replying to your rants as you are not worth it...you want peace my ass!
1Belfastborn 7 months ago