Great version, thanks. It's not clichéed, the way you sing it. I'd say it's more 'over done', so it's refreshing to hear someone who gives this great song some heart. :o)
You have a lovely voice .... I prefer your ballads. That's probably because I'm a ballad singer also...anyway, keep singing! I love your voice. You can check out my band on my channel... loveofthecelt
this is my favorite tribute to the horror of war. im from the usa and the son of a veteran of 3 wars and yes i sometimes am ashamed of our countries ways. we all are not in agreement with our leaders views.
Pardon my english. I hope you could one of these days come in France with your guitar, (if)choose the north, Somme or Pas-de-calais, choose a field in summer, walk along the way on the left or on the right, it doesn't matter, and be sure to find soon a little cimetery hidden among the corns, and yes if you read the dates on the grave stone: born in 1897 killed in 1916, no offense if you sing this song and play your guitar in the cimetery, they are for ever 19.
the states always go in at the end and say we won!!!!!! lol and all the fights the pick they seem to always pull out of (loose) lol ..... Canadian perspective
I discovered this song with your post. Greatly done. If you intend to visit the Somme you're invited, truly. By the way my neighbourg is australian and his old parents are living in a new house at the end of my garden. I'm surrounded with australian...
Did they play the drum slowly, just makes me sigh. My mother is german, I know for sur that WWI was a pure slaughter...
Thanks for the post:) The truth is we are impressed with your work and your familys. Hope this clears this all up. Look forward to your vids. Never meant any disrespect. Peace:) Hanna
Please stop hassling out MAGICMOUNTAINVIDEOS. They are entitled to their opinions. They get the point and are now not very impressed with me......maybe even less than they were to begin with. Well, that's probably not true, either way leave em alone please.
are you singing with a bit of a sore throat? I can hear a tiny rasp towards the end of the song that you don't normally have. It's a cold or you have been partying!
let it heal brother! don't wreck those pipes man! (:))
Received response. Yes you have been featured in our webcast. And have always enjoyed your vids. Hannah has a bur. Our site on tripod will be down for systemwide Maintenance till after 5 pm EST. Sorry about any misunderstanding. Check out the webcast over 26 million have viewed it on Tripod and Hughes satelite.Have a Good day. Mary Rose
It is a very moving song and you performed it well. Thanks. I had a hectic day and this video caused me to stop and reflect. You also responded with "The Band Played..." which is, if I recall correctly, the first video of yours that I saw and one of my most favorites. I hope all of that made sense. Namaste
In answer to your qustion: The US has Memorial day, the last Monday of May - for the solders who have died in war and Veterans day (Nov 11th) to comemerate the end of WW1 and to honor all veterans.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Hey ya think the USA was maybe? involved in WWI at the end. Lost us, do you live under a rock?. You live because of the sacrifice of Americans in both worlds wars. You are deleted from our site!!!! Hannah
Give it a rest Mountain. I'm American and even I'm sick of hearing the arrogance. I know what we did and didn't do. I'm proud of the good things and not so proud of the bad. History is history no matter how hard we try to change it and the super thing about that? It's right there for all of us to read. Depending on our own experiences and where we are in the world,, we process information through our own filters. We see things different sometimes. We're human that way.
You didn't denigrate anything. We all have to be able to look at things through our neighbor's eyes. Just because we think something's great here in the good ol U.S.A. doesn't mean it is/was good for other countries. Compassion, understanding, empathy--a damn sense of humor--we have to find this stuff inside ourselves when we start talking to others who might not share our enthusiasm. As Forrest Gump would say, "Sorry I had a fight in the middle of your Black Panther party." WTF?
I find what you said about "you live because" really offensive and egotistic. There was plenty of sacrifice going on, not all American. And it was all a waste. War is a waste.
cracking voice!well done,love this song!i've not long heard it myself but make sure i do it on every gig now i've learnt it too!goes down well!
Dan.
neutronstar64 1 year ago
Thanks muchly!
Pablo668 1 year ago
Great version, thanks. It's not clichéed, the way you sing it. I'd say it's more 'over done', so it's refreshing to hear someone who gives this great song some heart. :o)
LiteGauge 2 years ago
Thanks very much!
Pablo668 2 years ago
One of my favourite songs of all time - a fantastic version you done there
boynebattler 2 years ago
Thanks!
Pablo668 2 years ago
You have a lovely voice .... I prefer your ballads. That's probably because I'm a ballad singer also...anyway, keep singing! I love your voice. You can check out my band on my channel... loveofthecelt
loveofthecelt 2 years ago
Thanks very much. Will do.
Pablo668 2 years ago
well done great video hope you like my version i sent you
madfortrad5958 2 years ago
Thnaks, I'll check it out.
Pablo668 2 years ago
Hey Pablo..I was just thinking you would do well at a Gary Moore song
userbrentcarter 2 years ago
Oh thanks. Wishing Well would be my choice.
Pablo668 2 years ago
Amazing, this is another song I sing on here, we seem to have similar tastes. Wonderful song and well sung friend. 5 stars
JohnMcCash 3 years ago
Hey John, thanks again.
Pablo668 3 years ago
freedom fighters,, never forgotten...
sandroaraujo3 3 years ago
Thanks.
Pablo668 3 years ago
this is my favorite tribute to the horror of war. im from the usa and the son of a veteran of 3 wars and yes i sometimes am ashamed of our countries ways. we all are not in agreement with our leaders views.
dsmith1731 3 years ago
Like I have said before, I'm not anti-US, and I spoke a little foolishly.
I did this song because it's a passionate anti-war song and as a rememberance day tribute.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Pardon my english. I hope you could one of these days come in France with your guitar, (if)choose the north, Somme or Pas-de-calais, choose a field in summer, walk along the way on the left or on the right, it doesn't matter, and be sure to find soon a little cimetery hidden among the corns, and yes if you read the dates on the grave stone: born in 1897 killed in 1916, no offense if you sing this song and play your guitar in the cimetery, they are for ever 19.
zardozfrance 3 years ago
Thankyou for watching. Yeah, I'd love to go to France and see the Somme.
Pablo668 3 years ago
the states always go in at the end and say we won!!!!!! lol and all the fights the pick they seem to always pull out of (loose) lol ..... Canadian perspective
usuckamydick 3 years ago
Thanks for watching! I'm not touching that!
Pablo668 3 years ago
I discovered this song with your post. Greatly done. If you intend to visit the Somme you're invited, truly. By the way my neighbourg is australian and his old parents are living in a new house at the end of my garden. I'm surrounded with australian...
Did they play the drum slowly, just makes me sigh. My mother is german, I know for sur that WWI was a pure slaughter...
FARANSI95 3 years ago
Thank you very much. I'll let you know if I get a chance to go there.
Pablo668 3 years ago
*sigh* that was lovely, Paulie
LorCaWilGra 3 years ago
Thanks Cat!
Pablo668 3 years ago
Beautiful vocals as always....great work. It's a pleasure listening to your soul...thanx
fuffermucker 3 years ago
Thanks to you!
Pablo668 3 years ago
Thanks for the post:) The truth is we are impressed with your work and your familys. Hope this clears this all up. Look forward to your vids. Never meant any disrespect. Peace:) Hanna
MagicMountainVideos 3 years ago
No worries, peace! Thanks for watching.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Hey guys,
Please stop hassling out MAGICMOUNTAINVIDEOS. They are entitled to their opinions. They get the point and are now not very impressed with me......maybe even less than they were to begin with. Well, that's probably not true, either way leave em alone please.
See, this is exactly how things like WW1 happen!
Pablo668 3 years ago
excellent! i always liked this song! another excellent video paul!
1211210 3 years ago
Thanks very much!
Pablo668 3 years ago
just love your version, really good..
alanfromdarwen 3 years ago
Thankyou. :)
Pablo668 3 years ago
I was unfamiliar with this song until a couple of years ago - & I've loved it ever since. Great job here. 5*****
derekeverett 3 years ago
Thanks a heap.
Pablo668 3 years ago
are you singing with a bit of a sore throat? I can hear a tiny rasp towards the end of the song that you don't normally have. It's a cold or you have been partying!
let it heal brother! don't wreck those pipes man! (:))
Helen
pixiepqueen 3 years ago
Hey Herlen, yeah, getting over a cold. Though I'm always a little.....raspy over here. Always have a low level cough thing going on.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Very wonderful. Nice way to remember
karryn13 3 years ago
Thanks very much Karen.
Pablo668 3 years ago
arrrrgh, I mean Karryn. sorry.
Pablo668 3 years ago
No worries! :)
karryn13 3 years ago
omg. i start bawling my eyes out every time i hear this song.
but you did a really good job on it.
MTGirlCait 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thanks very much!
Pablo668 3 years ago
Great job Paulie! I'm most familiar w/ the Furey's verion and you definitely did that justice.
bardsrback 3 years ago
Thanks very much!
Pablo668 3 years ago
Wow, sweet and melancholy. I haven't heard the original, but I'm certain I'd prefer your version. :-)
Great job, Paulie!
ReinaDelCid 3 years ago
Hey Reina, thanks a heap.
Ahh I think if you heard the original your opinion would differ.
But thanks for the big call just the same.
Pablo668 3 years ago
dude i can't even listen to this.
it's too sad. how can there still be wars?
it's madness, isn't it?
filemen2 3 years ago
Too true. Great anti-war song. I consider myself extremely lucky not to have had to fight in a war.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Received response. Yes you have been featured in our webcast. And have always enjoyed your vids. Hannah has a bur. Our site on tripod will be down for systemwide Maintenance till after 5 pm EST. Sorry about any misunderstanding. Check out the webcast over 26 million have viewed it on Tripod and Hughes satelite.Have a Good day. Mary Rose
MagicMountainVideos 3 years ago
Yeah will do. Thanks for that. Like I said, happy to chat with Hannah via-pm to explain myself. Suffice it to say, I'm not anti-US.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Very nicely done!
Blinkazoid 3 years ago
Thanks!
Pablo668 3 years ago
thanks dude. good tune.
runner1956 3 years ago
Thankyou!
Pablo668 3 years ago
welcome mate!
runner1956 3 years ago
Great song, very nicely performed, and the mustache is kind of...umm...well, the song was nice at least :D
misterblue66 3 years ago
HEY! That moustache is hot sex incarnate!
Thanks for the several kind words in there....somewhere. ;)
Pablo668 3 years ago
I would so do you.
If I wasn't married.
And in Japan.
And younger.
And attractive.
And interesting.
Good God. Why don't I just open a vein and save us all the trouble?
Deejeroo 3 years ago
Jesus Deej, don't!
Don't even think that way.
It must be my moustache addling your brain.
Pablo668 3 years ago
*whew*, you're right. I think it was the 'stache.
I felt a bit lightheaded there.
Deejeroo 3 years ago
That was lovely, thank you.
Deejeroo 3 years ago
Thanks very much.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Hey! I loved the song and you've performed it just beautifully. 5*s!
Svetlailieva 3 years ago
Thankyou Svet!
Pablo668 3 years ago
It is a very moving song and you performed it well. Thanks. I had a hectic day and this video caused me to stop and reflect. You also responded with "The Band Played..." which is, if I recall correctly, the first video of yours that I saw and one of my most favorites. I hope all of that made sense. Namaste
kaburto1966 3 years ago
Thanks very much Karen. Yeah I tacked 'The band played' on there because it has much the same themes and I thought it appropriate to the day.
Pablo668 3 years ago
In answer to your qustion: The US has Memorial day, the last Monday of May - for the solders who have died in war and Veterans day (Nov 11th) to comemerate the end of WW1 and to honor all veterans.
cz2509 3 years ago
Cool, thanks for that. Well, this is for them too!
Pablo668 3 years ago
gorgeous song, I'm gonna download it
kalaway 3 years ago
Thanks.
Pablo668 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hey ya think the USA was maybe? involved in WWI at the end. Lost us, do you live under a rock?. You live because of the sacrifice of Americans in both worlds wars. You are deleted from our site!!!! Hannah
MagicMountainVideos 3 years ago
OK then. Touchy. Try not to find offence where none is intended.
Pm me if you'd like me to explain myself.
I'm on your site?
Pablo668 3 years ago
Give it a rest Mountain. I'm American and even I'm sick of hearing the arrogance. I know what we did and didn't do. I'm proud of the good things and not so proud of the bad. History is history no matter how hard we try to change it and the super thing about that? It's right there for all of us to read. Depending on our own experiences and where we are in the world,, we process information through our own filters. We see things different sometimes. We're human that way.
Deejeroo 3 years ago
Sorry about that Paul. Didn't mean to break up the party.
Deejeroo 3 years ago
It's all good.
Pablo668 3 years ago
I certainly wasn't trying to denigrate the US or the part they played in WW1.
I should have been a diplomat.
Pablo668 3 years ago
You didn't denigrate anything. We all have to be able to look at things through our neighbor's eyes. Just because we think something's great here in the good ol U.S.A. doesn't mean it is/was good for other countries. Compassion, understanding, empathy--a damn sense of humor--we have to find this stuff inside ourselves when we start talking to others who might not share our enthusiasm. As Forrest Gump would say, "Sorry I had a fight in the middle of your Black Panther party." WTF?
Deejeroo 3 years ago
He he thanks awfully.
Pablo668 3 years ago
I'm sure it's your loss and not Paul's.
Zebonka 3 years ago
I find what you said about "you live because" really offensive and egotistic. There was plenty of sacrifice going on, not all American. And it was all a waste. War is a waste.
pixiepqueen 3 years ago
Can I get an Amen?
Deejeroo 3 years ago
amen
pixiepqueen 3 years ago
Very moving and so nicely sung. On behalf of all that were lost in these times I thank you.
DrPlum 3 years ago
Thanks very much.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Aww, that was lovely.
JennHood93 3 years ago
Nov 11th is Veterans Day in the US where we honor all American veterans of all our wars.
Very nice song! Very invoking! Check out my tribute video to WWI pilots. Thanks!
RoninDave 3 years ago
Beautiful ! And with more emotion in our day of commemoration in France...
Franck
Soulaire et Bourg
France
Franck867 3 years ago
Thanks very much. I want to go and see Flanders and the Somme one day.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Ok boy, I am living no so far from there and I had some family died in, so, if you need (good) compagny for that, just let me know.
For that day, I played "the blue cockade"
Franck
Franck867 3 years ago
Wow. If I ever head to Europe I'll let you know.
Pablo668 3 years ago
Like always , you did an amazing job. Great vocals. Keep it up.
Love Britt
LapperProductions 3 years ago 2
Oh thanks Brit.
Pablo668 3 years ago