This report was a fabrication from CNN,Americas central command for MIND CONTROL..Russia was NOT the aggessor,they responded to Georgia murdering South Ossetian people.This was a good move by Russia.The American news media,is the reason Americans are the some of the dumbest people on earth,The american news media,is lies,lies,and more lies.GO Russia
hlwanmoe1981 -- HOW do you explain ... where PUTIN showed he is dictator ,, I can not find one thing ... HE made Russia STRONG and people will vote for him , whenever he SHUT up BUSH and vampires like HIM ,, all over the world ,,, GOD BLESS RUSSIA ....
Georgia becomed part of Russia in 1800 seeking for a protection form agressive neighberhoods (Iran and others), then after revolution of 1917 new soviet goverment had gived independece for everybody, and then Georgian SSR had entered USSR in 1937 or 36 separatly from South Osetia SSR and Abkhazia SSR.
your brave soldiers can only murder innocents and wounded peacekeepers, then they were beaten like nothing to do, and if you idiot dont know history of your own country, i know mine: south osetia and abkhazia sovit republics had added to USSR year before geaorgia, and then I.V. Stalin had integreated them in georgia soviet republic
Today (23 Feb 2009) Russian citizens (Russians, Ukrainians, Belorussians, Georgians, Ossetians, Abkhasians, Germans, Finns, etc., etc.) celebrate Homeland Defender Day (former "Soviet Army Day"). My congratulations and best wishes to Defenders!!! :) :) :)
whats wrong with all you? soght ossetia is part of georgia. fucking putin and midvedev want to take georgien lands. you dont know history of gergia and shut fuck up. fuck those mothers whe does'n like and rispects georgia and georgiens. south ossetia is part of georgia and get fuck out of georgia you fuking russians. we cilled ossetiens becouse of thay dicervied that and we will cill agein who has problems with us georgiens. fuck russia
This video is Bullshit. Filled with untruthful propaganda. Georgia started this conflict with the killing of more than 1000 ossetian people. Russia is just defending Ossetia. Look at some news channels from europe, and Asia. they will show you how it all started. the same day of the olympics 8/8/08. Georgia bombed South ossetia. This is a plan with America, Nato, and its allies to start another WW3. This video is completely fake. The information is incorrect. Shame on so called American Press
plzzz dont listen to THIS PROPAGANDA SHIT, GEORGIAN PIGS KILLED 2000 INNOCENT PEOPLE, THERE IS EVEN VIDEOS HERE THAT WHERE TOOK BY GEORGIANS SCUM, DEATH TO ALL GEORGIANS, HAIL RUSSIA!!
Georgia started war on 7th of august at night. They started bombing city Tshinaval with rocket (GRAD) weapon - this is crime. A lot of citizens died.. 10 russian pacekeepers were killed
ONLY NEXT DAY:
Russia move 58 army to protect russian citizens and pacekeepers..
Saakahvilli kissing American ASS - This war started US because of presidential electtions to raise up Mccain rate..
The Americans! This culprit in the loss of life in South Ossetia is John McCain! He needed a war to extradite Russia for agresera and raise its rating on the U.S. presidential elections! Saakoshvili - puppet! Blood Ossetian children at the hands of McCain and the U.S. government!
YOUNGF0X -Russia is strong but is not rival for NATO --- WHO in NATO will be willing to FIGHT against RUSSIA .. GREECE is not sych country, A lot of former soviet states will not fight against RUSSIA, WHO will fight against NATO ,, CHINA ,RUSSIA Middle EAST,ASIA, LAtin AMERICA .. CAN you win NATO ass licker .,, NO .. FUCK NATO , USA creation,
since your talkin about war a i bet US citizin dont want war since you talk about NATO and who will fight and how you say this it seem like you rather have the world to come to a end come on buddy WORLD PEACE usa should never got in to this crap
I think you are wrong, I'm Asian..I hate Communists! Especially Dictators.....Putin(Russia), Hu Jin Tao(China), Than Shwe(Burma), Musharat(Pakitstan)...etc..
You are the one who is idiot and racist, asshole. Oh, I forgot Puttin is not Communist but fucking dictator. Your stupid dump Red Army is sucks! Open your mind retard.
I fear the whole invasion was planned by the Americans. Now Russia is left with little voice over the signing of the missile defence system. Clearly Americans and the west wants a confrontation with russians so as to control the vast oil and natural gas reserves it got. The western media as always portray Russia as an agressor. I pity the the western nationals who live under false propaganda's aired by their media.
where is fukin pussy america and coward Nato who can only invade weak countries like Iraq and Afghanistan.......despite security councils emergency meeting russia still movin in Georgia......and fukin Bush only requesting to Putin Plz plz cease fire...........fukin pusy
-- RUSSIA is capitalist shit the same as USA .. RUSSIA is not going DOWN .. USA is going DOWN .. YOU SEE GEORGIA is (USA whore) .. GEORGIA is going to PAY for what they have DONE .. FUCK USA . YOU GOT THAT .. RUSSIA is not the same country ,, I am from former Yugodlavia ... I HATE WHAT USA has done to SERBIAN PEOPLE THERE .. CROATIA expelled 350.000 Serbs in 1995 with help from USA . FUCK USA . GEORGIA will pay for this. I do not hate GEorgian PEOPLE .
MiaRossa --- CAPITALISTS acctually do not HATE HITLER .. THEIR worse nightmare was JOSEPH STALIN, -- USA bombed SERBIA 1999 took 15% of SERBIAN LAND and gave ti to the ALBANIANS ...FUCK USA . VERY SMART MOVE BY RUSSIA .. GOD BLESS RUSSIA .. GO RUSSIA . BOMB GEORGIA and kick USA out of there .
I just gave you an example of your poor statement and you just supported it once again. Russia will be paying dearly for all this so don't flatter yourself.
Georgia armed by USA thought it could get away with an attack on SO. Russia has to draw the line somewhere and protect it's area of influence. They can't let American puppet states proliferate on its borders, just like America can't let pro-Russian countries on its borders. Georgia is going to learn this the hard way...
--- NOT MANY people KNOW ... THAT "JOSEPH STALIN" worse dictator of ALL TIME .. IS FROM GEORGIA ... BORN and RAISED .. NOW think about GEORGIA once more ..
LOL Everybody who has been to high school knows this. Congratulations now we know you have been to high school. What that has to do with anything, Hitler was born in Germany so..... does that mean we need to go wipe of the entire German nation? I don't think so.
Learn your history Soviet Union Attacked Finland and Poland in 1939 and The leader of there Country Was A Georgian by the Name of Joseph Stalin.Who Murdered 40million of his own People and Put His Top Aircraft Designers in Death Camps Georgia and USA are Starting War over OIL and thats the end of it!
The Nazis invaded small countries and so is Russia doing it now. If Russia gets away with this who's next Turkey? Lets send some troops there so we can see if the Russians are that hard? Remember we've got nukes too you Ruskes and we can destroy your cities with a touch of a button. So stop bullying little Georgia you Nazis.
The white race suffers a demographic catastrophe. Already die much more whites of that born... The white race degnerates with the miscegenation... Wars between whites contribute to diminish still more the white race. Whites cannot die! Yes for perpetuation of the white race!
Hey guyz!! Georgians have killed 1200 russian citizens. That was the only reason for attack from the russian side. The lies in american TV media around this issue are so obvious that I am freaking scared. God forbid that we will be fighting... Saakashvili must get sued for doing it!!
Hitler invade Poland in 1939 on a pretext of defending Germans in Poland, but he wanted too do was conquer Poland. Russia wants Georgia back into the Russian Federation and that's end of it.
It really is too late, the U.S. has to enter now, every ally they have at the moment will ponder what the U.S. really would do for us?, if in need.
A staunch ally, who quietly has the 3rd largest troop force in Iraq to aid the U.S. helps to defend Americans in Iraq and that superpower 25 times over does not come to aid you in your darkest hour.?!?
If Russia does not pull out of Georgia the U.S. will enter this war.
OPEN YOURE EYS RUSSIA IS WRONG THEY ARE KILLERS AND LIARS PIGS THEY STINK DRINK WODKA AND KILL INOCCENT PEOPLE. REMEMBER 94-95 when INGUSH people were killed and genocided. OSSETIA IS CRIMINAL AND SO IS RUSSIA.
Fuck you , stupid pig! Georgia wats Osetia to be the part of Gergia! Osetians don`t want it and they pleased Russia to help, because Georgia keeping going to kill ALL Osetians without choise!! Can`t you see?! Russia doesn`t want to any was
In 1999 I wrote to the Russian Embassy in protest to Russia military action Chanzia. I warned them at the time, that the hardliners were going take over the Kremlin and they did under Vladimir Putin. The West ignored what went on then and they are doing it again in 2008 over Georgia. Actions are better than words USA, and just condemning them will not stop Russia one bit from what it wants to do in the end, and that is to control Georgia.
Handle your business Russia. Slap that bitch Georgia back to the stone age! This little bitch country needs to know it's place in the world! Under Russian Feet groveling for mercy!
Georgia needs to get to NATO thats why the kill all ossetians to have no problems with borders. And they only have time left for deember. Saakashvili is under US control
South Ossetia is a INDEPENDENT state apart from Georgia control.
Georgia should fxxx off and give that state up! Stop pretending to be some poor innocent country under attack cuz no one is going to help you. They fight Russia and that is bring doom to themselves. Russia is the world's second strongest country in terms of military, if they continue to fight, there is no doubt in the end Georgia government WILL BE ELIMINATED...
(I'm not a Russian and I'm not one-sided without a reason!)
If I were in the U.N. i would huddle the ambassadors together And say something simple...what the fuck...then I get the chinese ambassordor in there and have him say what the fuck. Who started this shit and what's going on...I heard 1400 casualties...What's going on...stop this crap now. But you know that part of the world they love to fight...I wanna know personally...Is this a boxing match or what... I personally served with the Georgians and there and awesome soldiers, I sure i'd say the same
die to Russians and Russia where was Russians when Georgians where fighting against the Pompeus? jumping on the trees or eating the shit of wolf
shockwavedec 1 month ago
World peace!!!! Мира во всем мире!!! მსოფლიოში მშვიდობისა!!!
(Но если будет так же Россия себя в обиду не даст) слава России
TERAPITable 1 year ago
Fuck Georigia
alexganger 1 year ago
western media is just BS
marcusos1111 1 year ago
А какого хуя они, выделяя территорию Грузии, Южную Оссетию с Абхазией туда загребают?????????????????
Kaperang 1 year ago
This report was a fabrication from CNN,Americas central command for MIND CONTROL..Russia was NOT the aggessor,they responded to Georgia murdering South Ossetian people.This was a good move by Russia.The American news media,is the reason Americans are the some of the dumbest people on earth,The american news media,is lies,lies,and more lies.GO Russia
b2flyer1 1 year ago
This guy can't even say South Ossetia properly, and is too stupid to realize that S.O. has been independent since the early 1990's
monkeyman1140 2 years ago
hlwanmoe1981 -- HOW do you explain ... where PUTIN showed he is dictator ,, I can not find one thing ... HE made Russia STRONG and people will vote for him , whenever he SHUT up BUSH and vampires like HIM ,, all over the world ,,, GOD BLESS RUSSIA ....
aviomaster 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Russia started the war by supporting the rebels. That's it!
hlwanmoe1981 3 years ago
Georgia becomed part of Russia in 1800 seeking for a protection form agressive neighberhoods (Iran and others), then after revolution of 1917 new soviet goverment had gived independece for everybody, and then Georgian SSR had entered USSR in 1937 or 36 separatly from South Osetia SSR and Abkhazia SSR.
cheaterstd 3 years ago
your brave soldiers can only murder innocents and wounded peacekeepers, then they were beaten like nothing to do, and if you idiot dont know history of your own country, i know mine: south osetia and abkhazia sovit republics had added to USSR year before geaorgia, and then I.V. Stalin had integreated them in georgia soviet republic
cheaterstd 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Today (23 Feb 2009) Russian citizens (Russians, Ukrainians, Belorussians, Georgians, Ossetians, Abkhasians, Germans, Finns, etc., etc.) celebrate Homeland Defender Day (former "Soviet Army Day"). My congratulations and best wishes to Defenders!!! :) :) :)
BarbbaRossa08 3 years ago
whats wrong with all you? soght ossetia is part of georgia. fucking putin and midvedev want to take georgien lands. you dont know history of gergia and shut fuck up. fuck those mothers whe does'n like and rispects georgia and georgiens. south ossetia is part of georgia and get fuck out of georgia you fuking russians. we cilled ossetiens becouse of thay dicervied that and we will cill agein who has problems with us georgiens. fuck russia
paatakvitsinadze 3 years ago
Yeah,they were part of Georgia,but the majority did not want to be part of Georgia anymore.
Dudtz 3 years ago
It Bushes Report.
Tomppa655 3 years ago
This video is Bullshit. Filled with untruthful propaganda. Georgia started this conflict with the killing of more than 1000 ossetian people. Russia is just defending Ossetia. Look at some news channels from europe, and Asia. they will show you how it all started. the same day of the olympics 8/8/08. Georgia bombed South ossetia. This is a plan with America, Nato, and its allies to start another WW3. This video is completely fake. The information is incorrect. Shame on so called American Press
chugo145 3 years ago 2
plzzz dont listen to THIS PROPAGANDA SHIT, GEORGIAN PIGS KILLED 2000 INNOCENT PEOPLE, THERE IS EVEN VIDEOS HERE THAT WHERE TOOK BY GEORGIANS SCUM, DEATH TO ALL GEORGIANS, HAIL RUSSIA!!
Vin4enco 3 years ago
WHO SARTED:
Georgia started war on 7th of august at night. They started bombing city Tshinaval with rocket (GRAD) weapon - this is crime. A lot of citizens died.. 10 russian pacekeepers were killed
ONLY NEXT DAY:
Russia move 58 army to protect russian citizens and pacekeepers..
Saakahvilli kissing American ASS - This war started US because of presidential electtions to raise up Mccain rate..
that the truth
Mikkko777 3 years ago
fuck usa russia never told bush why he attack irak but this asshole bush tells russia why attack georgia FUCK USA
MaMaiTiiMinte 3 years ago 2
die for NATO....RUSSIA will clean USA clan at least..
akbarbudiono 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck not russia fuck sturid russians end hitler putin
giousageo 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The Americans! This culprit in the loss of life in South Ossetia is John McCain! He needed a war to extradite Russia for agresera and raise its rating on the U.S. presidential elections! Saakoshvili - puppet! Blood Ossetian children at the hands of McCain and the U.S. government!
VLaDMaTT21 3 years ago 2
YOUNGF0X -Russia is strong but is not rival for NATO --- WHO in NATO will be willing to FIGHT against RUSSIA .. GREECE is not sych country, A lot of former soviet states will not fight against RUSSIA, WHO will fight against NATO ,, CHINA ,RUSSIA Middle EAST,ASIA, LAtin AMERICA .. CAN you win NATO ass licker .,, NO .. FUCK NATO , USA creation,
aviomaster 3 years ago 5
since your talkin about war a i bet US citizin dont want war since you talk about NATO and who will fight and how you say this it seem like you rather have the world to come to a end come on buddy WORLD PEACE usa should never got in to this crap
Watchavideo2 3 years ago
I think you are wrong, I'm Asian..I hate Communists! Especially Dictators.....Putin(Russia), Hu Jin Tao(China), Than Shwe(Burma), Musharat(Pakitstan)...etc..
hlwanmoe1981 3 years ago
your are idiot, what to say else
PUTIN IS NOT COMMUNIST №1
HE isnt our priesdent now №2
and theres so much dumb thins in your post... so i will stop.
cheaterstd 3 years ago
You are the one who is idiot and racist, asshole. Oh, I forgot Puttin is not Communist but fucking dictator. Your stupid dump Red Army is sucks! Open your mind retard.
hlwanmoe1981 3 years ago
Only one rule apply in dis world "Might is right"
Shahzada1prince 3 years ago
you are right.
Boyoma1000 3 years ago
South Ossetia is under attack from GEORGIA
BigWhoreHouseIsrael 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I fear the whole invasion was planned by the Americans. Now Russia is left with little voice over the signing of the missile defence system. Clearly Americans and the west wants a confrontation with russians so as to control the vast oil and natural gas reserves it got. The western media as always portray Russia as an agressor. I pity the the western nationals who live under false propaganda's aired by their media.
RonyKoshy 3 years ago
UP THE PROVOS.........
borderfox1916 3 years ago
Russian bullies. Czechoslovakia 1968.
FOD2B 3 years ago
where is fukin pussy america and coward Nato who can only invade weak countries like Iraq and Afghanistan.......despite security councils emergency meeting russia still movin in Georgia......and fukin Bush only requesting to Putin Plz plz cease fire...........fukin pusy
Shahzada1prince 3 years ago
Georgia is not a member of NATO and Russia can veto anything the Security Council wants to do.
usmc6891 3 years ago
do you mind we are very busy killing many pakis at the moment gotta go i need to wipe my arse with the koran
darrenscotchbrook 3 years ago
Russia is strong but is not rival for NATO
YOUNGF0X 3 years ago
-- RUSSIA is capitalist shit the same as USA .. RUSSIA is not going DOWN .. USA is going DOWN .. YOU SEE GEORGIA is (USA whore) .. GEORGIA is going to PAY for what they have DONE .. FUCK USA . YOU GOT THAT .. RUSSIA is not the same country ,, I am from former Yugodlavia ... I HATE WHAT USA has done to SERBIAN PEOPLE THERE .. CROATIA expelled 350.000 Serbs in 1995 with help from USA . FUCK USA . GEORGIA will pay for this. I do not hate GEorgian PEOPLE .
aviomaster 3 years ago
Ubij sve Srbe i Ruse!!!!
miden851 3 years ago
MiaRossa --- CAPITALISTS acctually do not HATE HITLER .. THEIR worse nightmare was JOSEPH STALIN, -- USA bombed SERBIA 1999 took 15% of SERBIAN LAND and gave ti to the ALBANIANS ...FUCK USA . VERY SMART MOVE BY RUSSIA .. GOD BLESS RUSSIA .. GO RUSSIA . BOMB GEORGIA and kick USA out of there .
aviomaster 3 years ago
I just gave you an example of your poor statement and you just supported it once again. Russia will be paying dearly for all this so don't flatter yourself.
MiaRossa 3 years ago
Georgia armed by USA thought it could get away with an attack on SO. Russia has to draw the line somewhere and protect it's area of influence. They can't let American puppet states proliferate on its borders, just like America can't let pro-Russian countries on its borders. Georgia is going to learn this the hard way...
thugix 3 years ago
Trained by USA not armed and most of its weapons are Russian
usmc6891 3 years ago
--- USA occupied SERBIAN land KOSOVO .. WHAT you can DO .. YOU can say: FUCK USA GO TO HELL ... GO RUSSIA .. KICK USA zionist scum FROM GEORGIA ..
aviomaster 3 years ago
--- NOT MANY people KNOW ... THAT "JOSEPH STALIN" worse dictator of ALL TIME .. IS FROM GEORGIA ... BORN and RAISED .. NOW think about GEORGIA once more ..
aviomaster 3 years ago
LOL Everybody who has been to high school knows this. Congratulations now we know you have been to high school. What that has to do with anything, Hitler was born in Germany so..... does that mean we need to go wipe of the entire German nation? I don't think so.
MiaRossa 3 years ago
Hitler was Austrian.
usmc6891 3 years ago 2
Learn your history Soviet Union Attacked Finland and Poland in 1939 and The leader of there Country Was A Georgian by the Name of Joseph Stalin.Who Murdered 40million of his own People and Put His Top Aircraft Designers in Death Camps Georgia and USA are Starting War over OIL and thats the end of it!
omnadrener 3 years ago
Haha...american parasits come here...
we have a big suprise for u
or better as soon we ll come in america
for long time:))
kurjakcina 3 years ago
The Nazis invaded small countries and so is Russia doing it now. If Russia gets away with this who's next Turkey? Lets send some troops there so we can see if the Russians are that hard? Remember we've got nukes too you Ruskes and we can destroy your cities with a touch of a button. So stop bullying little Georgia you Nazis.
turner60 3 years ago
The white race suffers a demographic catastrophe. Already die much more whites of that born... The white race degnerates with the miscegenation... Wars between whites contribute to diminish still more the white race. Whites cannot die! Yes for perpetuation of the white race!
Matutoboy 3 years ago
Everbody knows that USA country murderers!!! Georgia must stop killing peaceful people in Ossetia!!! This is genocide!!!
PaulLibre 3 years ago 3
Why doesn't Russia stop killing peaceful Georgians as well? Or is it one rule for Russia and another for the rest us?
turner60 3 years ago
Hey guyz!! Georgians have killed 1200 russian citizens. That was the only reason for attack from the russian side. The lies in american TV media around this issue are so obvious that I am freaking scared. God forbid that we will be fighting... Saakashvili must get sued for doing it!!
CuzTK 3 years ago
Hitler invade Poland in 1939 on a pretext of defending Germans in Poland, but he wanted too do was conquer Poland. Russia wants Georgia back into the Russian Federation and that's end of it.
turner60 3 years ago
It really is too late, the U.S. has to enter now, every ally they have at the moment will ponder what the U.S. really would do for us?, if in need.
A staunch ally, who quietly has the 3rd largest troop force in Iraq to aid the U.S. helps to defend Americans in Iraq and that superpower 25 times over does not come to aid you in your darkest hour.?!?
If Russia does not pull out of Georgia the U.S. will enter this war.
doomkrakin 3 years ago
OPEN YOURE EYS RUSSIA IS WRONG THEY ARE KILLERS AND LIARS PIGS THEY STINK DRINK WODKA AND KILL INOCCENT PEOPLE. REMEMBER 94-95 when INGUSH people were killed and genocided. OSSETIA IS CRIMINAL AND SO IS RUSSIA.
tamerlan4 3 years ago
Fuck you , stupid pig! Georgia wats Osetia to be the part of Gergia! Osetians don`t want it and they pleased Russia to help, because Georgia keeping going to kill ALL Osetians without choise!! Can`t you see?! Russia doesn`t want to any was
chubrikstrekozyobrik 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dum-fuckd christains!
Bible thought u pricks to only drink blood and tag islam as terrorist!
burn the bible and urinate on it!
Death to the christains! U dogs fought islam and now fight ur-selfes!
DUMBOS
britishcan 3 years ago
Russian is bastards Fuck off from Caucass
and Georgia teretory
hbe7777 3 years ago
In 1999 I wrote to the Russian Embassy in protest to Russia military action Chanzia. I warned them at the time, that the hardliners were going take over the Kremlin and they did under Vladimir Putin. The West ignored what went on then and they are doing it again in 2008 over Georgia. Actions are better than words USA, and just condemning them will not stop Russia one bit from what it wants to do in the end, and that is to control Georgia.
turner60 3 years ago
***FUCK USA***
Serioga1983 3 years ago 3
bussines of US.. u will see them shown soon.
watch this movie.. u will understand everything
put in search bar
Zeitgeist - The Movie: Federal Reserve (Part 3 of 5) after u watch federal reserve try this...
Zeitgeist - The Movie: World Trade Center (Part 1 of 4)
and so on!!! watch it full...
wake up neo ... Us involving Russia into this conflict
serjio77777 3 years ago
***** FUCK RUSSIA *****
lovelymadmex 3 years ago
Handle your business Russia. Slap that bitch Georgia back to the stone age! This little bitch country needs to know it's place in the world! Under Russian Feet groveling for mercy!
LOJANOS 3 years ago
Georgia needs to get to NATO thats why the kill all ossetians to have no problems with borders. And they only have time left for deember. Saakashvili is under US control
Pruzhina13 3 years ago
I can't wait to see when Russia captures Saakashvili.
monkeyman1140 3 years ago 2
South Ossetia is a INDEPENDENT state apart from Georgia control.
Georgia should fxxx off and give that state up! Stop pretending to be some poor innocent country under attack cuz no one is going to help you. They fight Russia and that is bring doom to themselves. Russia is the world's second strongest country in terms of military, if they continue to fight, there is no doubt in the end Georgia government WILL BE ELIMINATED...
(I'm not a Russian and I'm not one-sided without a reason!)
XedGeneral 3 years ago
If I were in the U.N. i would huddle the ambassadors together And say something simple...what the fuck...then I get the chinese ambassordor in there and have him say what the fuck. Who started this shit and what's going on...I heard 1400 casualties...What's going on...stop this crap now. But you know that part of the world they love to fight...I wanna know personally...Is this a boxing match or what... I personally served with the Georgians and there and awesome soldiers, I sure i'd say the same
Armysmithaz 3 years ago
cease fire is over.i heard awhile ago
GR33NPAPERS 3 years ago