Understanding Mumbai Attacks : By Salman Rushdie

[36245634]

GREAT SIR SALMAN RUSDIE HE ONLY SAY TRUTH..

[aliahsan257]

What he misses out is the question of the support base of groups like Al-Qaeda, Taliban, Hamas, Jaish e Muhammad, etc. The support does come from the existence of the injustice (a priori). You can see this if you plot the increase in radicalism in Pakistan and Afghanistan over the course of the last decade as American presence is being increasingly felt.

[JagjeetMann]

pakistan is the most fucked up country on earth, a failure in almost every sense, all the pakistan defenders dont even live in their country LOL what more proof do you need, they've lost every war against india and half of their territory was turned into Bangladesh, they are a fucking failure, brainwashed opium smoking druggies, a miserable disgrace. pakis you and the flooded bengali's destiny is to be invaded and reunified back into INDIA!!!!!! where you originally come from and belong!!!!

[DATTAINDIAN]

thank u sir u r right sir we think what you are thinking indians proud of you truely secular

[biswadeeprath]

Excellent comment by Salman Rushdie...

[XXXFreeSpirit]

Pakistanis must solve everything with Islam-economics, hunger, flood, science...and pray harder to Allah. The current level of Islam in Pakistan is not enough.

Pakistan, the homeland and heaven for Muslims needs more and more purification-of Hindus/ Christians/Ahmadiyyas/Shias/Se­­culars, until only the purest of the pure Muslims, most pious beards, more Arab than the Arabs are left. Pakistan needs to totally cleanse itself, until there is no joy, no color left in Pakistan. Only Islam.

[citizenOfNowhere777]

@XXXFreeSpirit That';s noy what islam teaches, you fanatic wahabi.



[qwertyui66771]

17 LASHKAR PIGS WATCHED THE VDO.

[GrandmasterTigerfist]

Pakistanis can only talk and have no act thats why they dont have any economy.

[tarun1982]

@GrandmasterTigerfist they are such pussies!! OH GOD!! .. every war they started they tried to attack from the back and sent militants into the country and they STILL LOST!! and the stupid thing is they dont have respect or dignity either.. they continue to gloat. So, thank you Pakistan for accepting your cheapness and showing it in your behaviour :) I'm glad you have Zaid Hamid. He helps your image. Why dont you all join him?! He is the

[usherban]

@drnskahlon This is western propaganda, you've no idea about paks potential -

/watch?v=tcVpdB7IxlA

/watch?v=3jIv5XUcIzI

[GaiusIuliusTaberna]

Why are apologists for Islamic fundamentalism so vulgar? Do you idiots think that if you curse in English, god can't hear you? Every fifth word out of you people is fuck, or fag, or dick... and yet you would have Salman killed for writing a novel... and you wonder why we in the west take issue with you. Guess what? We won't even let you kill each other, let alone kill us. All that is over. Call that imperialism if you like, I don't care.

[rambo300able]

i love rushdie..



[citizenOfNowhere777]

@rambo300able Rushide is a joke.

[Ameenmohib]

Fuck Rushdie .

[FistFuckingJesus]

@Ameenmohib "Fuck Rushdie"

Well done! See? That is what Free Speech is all about. You say what you think and you don't need to worry about anyone coming to cut your throat. Great, innit?

PS Fuck Muhammad!

[rajhe]

Will they put their weapons down if Palestine and Kashmir issues are resolved ...no one has asked that question before ...obvioulsy the answer is 1 big NO . Rushdie explains it very well ..

[aceman42]

@rajhe yes indeed and that was the essence.it was very well said by salman

[citizenOfNowhere777]

And how did this guy Rushdie become important? What a clown!

[muthushiv]

@citizenOfNowhere777 By muslims issuing Fatwa!

[citizenOfNowhere777]

@muthushiv You do not understand Islam enough to know that being a Muslim is not enough to issue fatwa.

[JonDavidson]

If you just do what we say, we'll stop attacking you. That was Hitler's rationale. And the Chamberlain government kept appeasing him, and kept appeasing him, and Hitler kept demanding more; because he knew he could. Appeasement doesn't work; it promotes more and more demands and threats, from people who are convinced you are a sucker.

[DYORPEEPS]

Rushdie in an interview said "All the world's terrorist groups are in Pakistan". That statement alone speaks volumes about his logic and state of mind.

[dethica]

@DYORPEEPS

answer me this....is that statement wrong?

[DYORPEEPS]

@dethica Of course it's wrong. That's why I said it.

[JustAStoner]

@DYORPEEPS To everyone else "all the world's terrorist groups are in pakistan" is a perceived factual statement which could be debated by presenting facts and not your illogical analogy of that statement with logic and state of mind. Your statement actually speaks volumes about ur state of denial than his of his state of mind.

[DYORPEEPS]

@JustAStoner Your youtube name says it all.

Outside of verbal masturbation that sums up to fuck all, do you have anything to actually say?

[DYORPEEPS]

Rushdie is just a bitter and messed up mind now. His logic is no different to that of a gun toting brainwashed American but with better diction.

Most muslims do not want what extremist muslims want, that's why extremists are in the minority. But this phony war on terror that he supports, along with his war mongering friend Chris Hitchens, is creating more sympathy and recruitment for extremists. Logic seems to fail this narcissistic idiot.

[MrEventhorizon]

well said Sir Rushdi. Much respect !!

[lqacwaz1]

SR's brain has been a sad victim of that fatwa. (not many people know that before the fatwa, TSV god good reviews in the Iran press!)

Now he surrounda himself with sycophants who applaud his inane imperialist rants. He could have spent his time better thinking of a proper ending to his novel 'The Enchantress of Florence' - that book cruises somewhat promisingly, then lands with a thud!

[lqacwaz1]

@lqacwaz1

sorry, corrections:

TSV god -> TSV got

surrounda -> surrounds

[gulhasantek]

behenchood salam gandu daas rushdie!!!

[samuidave]

Rushdie, logically speaking, seems to suggest that because Al Queda would not disband if there were peace in Palestine or Kashmir there is no reason to seek peace.  This is his noble high ground?

[4166861633]

i protest,Go away, i dont want listen ur rubbish rushdie

[TheShams786]

Bastardddddddddddd  Salman

[amansharma06]

arundhati roy is a fucktard

[bhazarik]

Rushdie uttered the absolute truth.

[paalu84]

" sarashid " hinduism is world's best religion which gave priceless things like yoga, peace and meditation.

but

ur islam gave only cruelity and terrorism.

[christayk]

Religious perspectives only clouds logic. Islam didn't create terrorists. Selfish politics did.

[andrer2006]

salman rushdie - well said. I like it when he says - "even if we give them Kashmir, would all of the terrorists put their AK47s down and start with a plow on a farm?"...That is the truth. Even if we give these fanatics anything, all of this would just not stop.

[manyobbo456]

what you would see is an end to grass roots support for the freedom fighters , you could then seperate terrorist such as indian mujaheeden and let , whilst LET fights for kashmiri freedom , other groups as for other stuff ,

[andrer2006]

I am guessing you are Muslim? I wanted to ask you then since you say kashmiri freedom - since when was Kashmir a muslim state? You are the only group of people in this 21st century who still wants to fight for causes that would have been valid only in the 7th century AD. I dont think I can reason with you - the whole world is enemy to you, and vice versa.

[manyobbo456]

yes im muslim , Kashmir is not about making a muslim state, just as tibet is not about making a buddist state or northen ireland is about making a catholic state its about the right of self determination , and following un resultions. The people of kashmir were robbed of their chance of independence , they want nothing to do with the caste system of india they want to be free from rss and shiv senu they are peaceloving but indain army commits huge war crimes

[sarmystic]

Oh, and what do LeT and Jaish e Mohammed do? blow kisses?

[manyobbo456]

at least Let and JeM dont go and rape women in kashmir, then try to hide it... or transfer land to hindus. What they do to is provide flags to kashmiris wishing to celebrate a Pakistan 2020 world cup victory

They are freedom fighters , you wouldnt call Forces Françaises Libres terrorist would u,

Everyone in the world has the right to self determination, following UN resolutions , no Human rights Abuses and saftey from RSS and Shiv Senu crazies.

[sarmystic]

wtf u crazy bastard..these terrorist organisations kill innocent men, women and children. Those are the worst human rights abuses. Stop calling blowing up people as freedom struggle. Right now pakistan is suffering from its own creation - Taliban. I hope JeM and eT start doing the same so u realize what the loss if ur friends and relatives mean...especially when they r illed without any reason.

I dont support Shiv Sena and RSS.

[manyobbo456]

You have to diffrentiate beetween terrorist such as american created Al Qaeda and Freedom fighter such as LeT, lashkar does not do suicide bombings,it only engages in fire fights with occupying forces.

You refer to the Pakistan Taliban and mehsud, who are actually created by RAW, but soon we will defeat them .

India needs to dismantle RSS terror Structure and compensate all those killed in state sponsored violence

[sarmystic]

beta freedom figheters dont kill innocent men women and children What lashkar did in mumbai was a suicide attack mission. Lekin ek ladka unmein se pakda gaya and he;s opening pakistan's hypcrisy to the world. You want human rights? then stop supporting taliban. Shiv sena and rss are not taking anybody;s rights..though I must tell you I dont support them like u support laskar and jaish e mohammed.

[lqacwaz1]

@sarmystic

Ah, a lot of you define: suicide killings = terrorism

non-suicide-killings = counterterrorism

sick!

[paalu84]

salman rushdie is a old pig.

[andrer2006]

he is saying the right thing - the terrorists would not stop even if we give them this whole world

[doniffi]

What foolish guy has been asked to analyse this, he calls all other than him mother fucker in his books and it is shame that people are clapping in his ridiculous analyses.

[avi2015]

it is nt about islamic

its about paki and indian be it muslim sikh hindu all r against paki muslim terrorist

[elfidanto]

another islamic moneky? why does islamic people love wars, fights, suicide bombing civil wars...and then u fucking bastard go around claiming islam is religion peace actually outside India it is religion of piss only indian muslims are the most peaceful

[BrownSpice85]

I understand Mr. Rushdie's point, but why is he making it seem like Pakistan and its people are the worst in the world? Not all of us bad or supported the Mumbai attacks. I'm Pakistani-American and I thought it was very wrong. I think he should stop blaming and pointing fingers at the whole country and its people and instead blame the people and groups who did it. He shouldn't blame the whole nation for something that it didn't do, afterall Pakistan does not have hands, now does it?

[andrer2006]

If you are so against it, now is the time to raise your voice and make yourself heard in your home country. I hear you have Sharia law now. I am just waiting for another 5 years, and we are going to see Afganistan Part II, but only this time it will be in Paki.

[manyobbo456]

Israel supported india with free drones during the war that turned it around, as for sharia law we had that implace from 1969-1994 . The justice english based justice system in india and pakistan is very slow. As for pakistan becoming afgan part 2 ppl have been saying pakistan will disintegrate every day since 14th august 1947 , the whole india of rushing forward independence was to make pakistan collapse. India will be like nepal in 5 year the Maoist in control

[sarmystic]

actually pakistan did disintegrate..in 1971

[aliesneo]

Brilliantly stated by one of the greatest contemporary intellectuals; there are two issues here: civil unrest in kashmir from the dragoonian presence of the indian military and the manipulation of local sentiment by foreign agencies, predominantly based in pakistan; and terrorism sponsored by organizations that have no discernible goal other than destruction of secular democracies. Arunadhati Roy, as prolific as she may be, is guilty of confabulating the two issues!

[97972844]

Is there any chance that the two of you could actually say somehting concerning the video?

[paalu84]

salman rushdi is a big fat asshole

[binoyrakesh]

salman ushdie has an iq of over 170. every word uttered by him more than makes sense.

"drag us back into mid ages at gun-point... " this is a power struggle more than anything else.

[basraali2]

behnchood kuta madarchood

[abhiincanada]

I saw other partsof this discussion & the panelists were successful in hitting the nail on its head. Salman Rushdie's work I have read sparingly but hadn't been an admirer yet. However, he has been brutally honest in this discussion & has exposed the truth behind terrorism and extremism. There is another part he reads a paragraph from his past work about Bombay and that was something I had not read earlier. It was truly beautiful and characterized the real sentiment of the city and its people.

[m4rashid]

yea this is clearly a "balanced" debate!.....sarcasm!!

[ISIpaki]

Barking dogs seldom bite. This is the only thing which these bastard indians can do.

[sunilkhosia]

theu have biten u in 1971 behanchod abhi wazirsthan, balochistan aur kashmir ko azad karana hai . . .

[singhp002]

I thought we fucked you up in 1971 war..

[sarashid91]

too bad we fuked u up in 1947,1965 and 1999!! stupid twats.... U indians seem to forget about ur defeats...

By the way, i'm pashtun, i'm not a big fan of pak government right now because of what they doin to my people in waziristan.. but nonetheless u indians fuk with one pakistani and we'll fuk u up as we did in the other 3 wars... cowards attacked from behind in 71!!!

[singhp002]

Actually you are fucked all the time. Insted of listing to what your government says, you should type "India pakistan war" in google and see the wikipideia....Let me know if you want the link...So you were fucked every time and you will be fucked in each front....now fuck off......and dont cry..

[sarashid91]

yeh bring wikipedia into it....pajee 12 bajgayee u stupid shit... thats the most biased info on the whole planet!! u guys hate talking about the other wars and only talk about 71 cause u KNOW u got hammered in the others!! go and live in ur bollywood dream world cause thats the only place u can become heroes....

[kashsoldier]

pashtun faggot, we don't give a shit who you are. You are from the porki land filled with Pigs, grunting all the time. India will use chemical weapons one day to cut down the breeding of pigs.

[sarashid91]

u make me laugh u prick... come and bring it on u cow worshipper, go and drink cow piss, and by then way if u wanna use nukes we'll send one over called the Ghauri missile... its shaped just like ur shiva lingam!! LMAO!! u motherfuckers are as doccile as the cows u worship... ur great prithvi raj couldn't even stand up to us and you still can't...

[singhp002]

And who hate talking about 1965...Even though your dad america was fighting 1965 from your behalf...still you are fucked..even though USA was supporting you in 1971 still you got fucked...lol..

[sarashid91]

u stupid F.U.C.K. america always was and is an enemy of pakistan, the only reason they're being nice to us now is because the US uses PAK airbases to attack targets in AFG. Pakistan only lost 1 war to India and thats 1971, at least were man enough to admit it unlike u cow piss drinking cowards... u throw heavyweight threats yet u can't even wipe the floor with us u bunch hairy pussyholes...

[singhp002]

Let me answer all your questions for you.

(1)You motherfucker admit the loss of 1971 since we showed you your "HAISIYAT". In 1965 we had a victory though it was not that big but still victory is victory. You attacked us to free Kashmir but you fucking lost and even USA could not help you win

We are not only threatning..Soon you will see the result..You are shivaring..USA drones are fucking you every fucking day..Ya all are fags...Can USA even think of doing that to us?? lol...ya gay ass pussy.

[sarashid91]

how many times are u gonna mention america??? see, u know u got battered... u fukn hairy cunt if u were so tough wot took ur "Special Forces - Black Cats" so long to rid mumbai of a group of poorly armed bandits? answer me that u gay black bastards.. if ur "Special Forces" took so long to disarm/neutralise THESE threats then ur the one that should be shivering when it comes to an indopak war!! LMAO, stupid fuck, hairy pussyhole, go get a haircut!!

[singhp002]

You motherfucking dogs (who fucks among their family),it took time to get rid of those pussies because they were hiding..Its hard to find rats hiding in whole...We have shown you 3 times our toughness...motheruckering loosers..You can only kill innocents..once you see our army..you fucking surrender...Ask your dad Niazi..ha ha ha

[sarashid91]

wot do u mean HIDING??? u knew where they were u were just scared to go after them... i seen an interview of ur solider saying that himself u pussyholes!!pppppppffffftttt showed us ur toughness???? wot toughness? u pussyholes are either too fat (hairy sikhs) or too skinny (black hindus) wot the fuk are you gonna possibly show us, u won 1 war (71) and thats it.... u got hammered in the rest, u indians make me laugh LMAO hahahahahahahahahahahaha

[singhp002]

Actually you are a reatard with a low IQ since your prostitute mothers is your fathers sister and your gay father is your mothers brother.I dont want to say how brave we are..but eveyone know that American drons are coming to Pakistan and fucking your citizen everday...You motherfuckers are USA's servent. A country with so low self respect.lol..and you are Pakistani..have some pride and self respect and then we wil talk..now fuck off you servent of USA....

[sarashid91]

LOL! low IQ? its the sikhs who are VERY well known for low iqs and their constant stupidity at least we don't go around advertising our sisters in bollywood music videos inviting the whole world to drool over them. gay dads and prostitutes mothers...LMAO u make me laugh i love pissing off people like you cuz u come out with some outlandish bullshit which doesn't make sense.. servant of US? ur a servant of russia, ask any pak citizen, they hate americans

[sarashid91]

(continuation)

...and don't worry, the rate india are going ur bound to have another 10 terrorists cum down and kill another 200 indians. bunch of pussyholes, as mentioned before ur only brave on the cinema screen...go get a haircut...

[singhp002]

sulli motherfucker..you will not get it and i am not surprised....suck the dick of USA and try to find your cousins to fuck them..HA HA HA..Low level shit..Fucking drive taxis and clean the shit of USA....And yeah..you will not get what i say..you need at least some sort of common sence..motheruccker..

[sarashid91]

go and learn how to spell u turbaniator!! ur the taxi drivers with that pathetic stupid indian accent u have wen u speak english. and by the way UR the one that needs to understand where i'm coming from... admit ur defeat pussyboy!!

[singhp002]

HA HA ..Paki pussy start craying..thats what you motherfuckers are good at..and yeah..learn some english so that you can go and drive some taxi. Low level IQ is crying...HA HA HA HA....Paki pussy....I see same kind of behavior of fucking Gilani..USA fucks you and you cry...Low level shitty motherfuckers..

[sarashid91]

LMAO!! 10 terrorists fuk you and u cum out with sum bullshit excuse that they were hiding, ur manmohan singh looks like he has baaaad constipation and has some trapped wind that needs to be released!! LMAO... u did the same crying in 99 when we fuked u over and who cried to that US then?? thats right Vajpayee and the rest of india begged the UN and US to tell PAK to retreat behind the LoC...

[singhp002]

Go and suck the dick of a Pig..and your mother will tell you how to do it since she has been doing it under the burqa...Madherchood...Pakis can only be laughed at...They are like jokes of this world..

[sarashid91]

go shave ur sisters hairy pussyhole u fukn takan sikh bhainchod...if anyone eats pigs, its u haraami motherfuckers...ur wasting ur time if u think u can make me angry by abusing me in this way, i can tell that ur getting pissed off!! LOL... u've admitted ur humiliating defeat and all u can talk about is pigs!! LOL

[elfidanto]

teri pen di ....saaleya....porki...bund paad deyaanga ...samajh laggi...saale pig eating bastard....jaa jaake camel pis pee ke aa...bhosadi deyaa.....twaadi bund paad deyaaange je ladai wajj gee taa....yad rakhi aae gall..taiyaariyaa kar lo twaade aakhri din chall raye ne bas..PAKISTAN KHATAM KARNA hai hun...te onde to kadaange baluchistan te sindh,....te teri maa nu weee kadaange..saala bhosadi daa

[sarashid91]

speak english please u smelly hairy punjabi fuk, p.s. tell ur mom to shave her pussy hair... i got lost in the jungle between her legs yesterday... u think ur so tough, come and bring it, we've lived in defiance of the 'mighty' india for over 60 years, yet u still cant destroy us and u never will because u pussyholes eat too much vegetables...LMAO!

[elfidanto]

ooo u lost in your mothers leg yesterday...u mother fuck...its not a news for me you camel piss drinker...your islamic history is full of INCEST and you even started with a prophet who had incest with her daughter in law no wonder..all porkies fuck their own mothers and sisters...and poor porki do not know how to fuck...he gets lost in the legs....!! LMAOOO....send your wife to me i never get lost....stupid porki...check your english it is not english it is PigGlish....

[sarashid91]

Me? getting lost? u smelly sikh motherfuckers are so hairy even king kong would get lost. u indians are so full of shit, ur a hard bastard behind a computer screen and in films but u flap it wen it comes to a face to face meeting... I bet u anything u woudlnt say that to my face, u indians eat too much vegetables hence ur as doccile as the cows u worship and the cow piss u drink and the eight legged freak u worship and the shiva lingam (penis) u worship. blak bastards lol

[elfidanto]

so you are white? you are in delusion. I would only say one thing, " A pig will talk as dirty as pig"

[andrer2006]

I am hindu, but dont fuck with my fellow Sikhs.

[sarashid91]

LOL, get the fuk outta ma face u cow worshipper... dn't make me laugh....

[andrer2006]

Keep laughing while you can. Very soon you are going to be asked to bend over in Guantanamo. THen you are going to know what I am talking about.

[arjun12345a]

lOl get the shitt outta my ass u fucking pig faced prophet worshipper

[singhp002]

Go and fucking learn some english..so that you can at least understand if not get what i am writting..lol...I am not sure if you understand this one ..Ha Ha Ha..

[sarashid91]

hahaha ur sooooo funny, u sweaty, smelly sikh motherfucker go fuk a cow...

[elfidanto]

sardaar ji do not call it English...actually in orkut communities it is known as PIGGLISH-english of pakistan....main taan kenna ek waari changi ladai wajje..te apna punjab kattha karke enna mulleya kaddiye baar....saaleya ne poori duniya ch agg laayi hai

[andrer2006]

lol! Hmmm...if I remember right, Kargil is now under Indian control. So how did you kick our ass? Your dont believe everything that your press tels you now do you? O wait, now it is the sharia law, pretty soon you will have to get sex from your sister and not feed her if you dont screw her! what a mess. Why dont you pakis move away to the middle east.

[sarmystic]

dude, how did u win kargil btw? u invaded and we pushed u back..thats a victory fr u? wow...enough said

[manyobbo456]

isreali scum came to your defense, ghandi would not have approved but RSS are taking over india, hemant karkare was killed by RSS in a false flag operation because he was investigating RSS terrorism

[soniameh]

@sarmystic

i'll tell u how thats a victory for pakistan , after loosing 4 wars with india , not loosing at kargil is a victory for them

[tarun1982]

@sarmystic dont talk to muslims.. its a waste of time

[aniketranade]

@sarmystic The only country where they claim one thing to be a victory...and then two of the most powerful men at the time (Nawaz sharif and Musharraf) blame it on each other..LOL