the 'benchmark' version of this concerto. in my esteem, belongs to horowitz in his monoaural recording from the 1930's with albert coates, one to which this video fails to measure up. the distortion in his playing magnified with age, as it has with so many great pianists, along with the greater inaccuracies that people "in the know" dismiss as inconsequential in light of the larger message and artistry of these demi-gods...
I believe there is an evil magic in this piece, you can see it in the face of whoever plays it. see towards the end even Horowitz loses his calm expression and that is so genuine...
@xxcocoloco You are so right on. I had not noticed. I was too busy watching Vladimir Horowitz gently tickling the keys with hardly any unnecessary exaggerated body movement so many other ostentatious artists use to try to impress. Thanks.
I read somewhere that Rachmaninoff and Horowitz were very close friends, and I think some of that comes through here, in Horowitz's great passion for the music. Some of which may be his passion for his friend!
Ahh - the most enjoyable concert I ever attended was, and always will be, spring of 1978, Chandler Pavilion, Mehta, LA Philharmonic, Horowitz performing this piece. No words can describe it! Afterwards we waited outside the side entrance. He appeared from inside, grinned from ear to ear with pleasure at the adoration, and was hustled into a Mercedes - no autographs that night!!
Thumbs up if the Rach 3 took you over a year to conquer.........I studied this piece exclusively for roughly 14 months to achieve mastery..... So worth it!
I LOVE the way how he plays with ABSOLUTELY NO unnecessary body movements. That stability itself sets the stage for enjoying the music without being distracted by the performer, and demonstrates absolute mastery.
@nevertheless123 I super agree. Playing with the least gestures and movements make a performer look more effortless. As they see, music should come from "within", not from external expressions.
small mistake at 06:17 left hand there...but it's the only one I can notice! I bet he didn't care so much about perfection by that time (and age), after all, he is the god in this concerto...
thanks for uploading: unbelievable really, but true. What is the meaning of life? For Rachmaninoff to have written this, for Horrorwitz to have performed it, and for us the rank and file to pay up to make sure them two made a living. And perhaps buying an icecream during intermission so that the vendor can make a living too.
There is no greater admirer of Horowitz than I ... but one crucial element of his interpretation has always bothered me - when he states the first melodic theme in octaves, he is brilliant - romantic, cantabile, et al ... but listen closely to each of his recordings, when the orchestra answers with the same melody, the piano is supposed to be merely an accompaniment. Even Rachmaninoff played it as such, but Horowitz overpowers ... the effect isn't allowed to happen.
I take it back the...the more I watch this the more I like mehta, I think it was his haircut that just pissed me off haha. And also, 8:02-9:30...its just so perfect
I really don't like Mehta that much, am I like totally weird? And also, this is the first time I've seen this (I've heard it before but not horowitz) and have literally been moved to tears hahaha
Am I the only one who finds 1:05 to 1:24 just undisputed? I've heard Argerich, Kissin, Lisitsa, Kern... get drowned by the orchestra here. But only Horowitz makes this what you call a piano concerto: he not only complements the orchestra, he makes this part a compelling introduction.
Brilliant performance of one of the best pianist in the history of classic music. Listening him performing his master and friend Rachmaninov is one the most thrilling experiences you can experience. He will endure for ever as the best pieano player.
Horowitz always amazes me! Did you guys know he and Rachmaninoff were really good friends? Rachmaninoff and Horowitz would play duets together on Rachmaninoff's two grand pianos at his home. Rachmaninoff also quoted once that "The only person that can play my third concerto better than me is Horowitz."
Hands down, the most exciting and complex piano concerto ever written, followed closely by Tchaikovsky's. I loved Martha Argerich's interpretation, but it takes a real Russian for this piece of masterwork.
You're watching a genius. He made the first recording of this work 48 years before this concert. He had the unqualified approval of the composer, who never played this piece in public after hearing Horowitz play it. They played it together in the Steinway basement in New York. Rachmaninoff supposedly told friends he "swallowed it whole."
This is beautiful - I am truly horrified i hadn't discovered horowitz until this evening! If none of you have seen the movie shine, if you are rach 3 fans check it out for sure. Anyhow, back to the point, a formidably incredible performance; moving, passionate and with such ease - truly stunning
Luckily I heard him in 1975 here in Chicago and will never forget it, he was the greatest Pianist I ever heard and even in his 80's played better then most anyone.
Sicut ex atris caeli nebulis fulgor candidus surgit et terra tremescit tonitruo, sic tangunt digiti sui nervos !
Anakazijn 1 day ago
@Benhos - thats because the piano concert #3 is one of the most difficult pieces to play created for piano ever.
liciying 1 month ago
OVERWHELMED BY GENIUS! PLEASE..PLEASE DON'T EVEN MENTION BIEBER IN THIS ARENA..AT ALL! BE SERIOUS!
sweetcolima 2 months ago 2
the 'benchmark' version of this concerto. in my esteem, belongs to horowitz in his monoaural recording from the 1930's with albert coates, one to which this video fails to measure up. the distortion in his playing magnified with age, as it has with so many great pianists, along with the greater inaccuracies that people "in the know" dismiss as inconsequential in light of the larger message and artistry of these demi-gods...
utubuser10 2 months ago
look how cool this guy is ye ha
farq69er 2 months ago
I believe there is an evil magic in this piece, you can see it in the face of whoever plays it. see towards the end even Horowitz loses his calm expression and that is so genuine...
benhos 3 months ago
@benhos
Well a lot of pianist consider this concerto to be the most difficult to play.
Valk72 3 months ago
Rach 's best friend playing like Rach would like it to be played.(his own words)
MrFtrancoso 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He's okay, but he's nowhere near Justin Bieber in terms of musical accomplishments.
kewkabe 3 months ago in playlist More videos from xeniamusica
@kewkabe
What the hell - do you dare to compare that "low IQ music maker" to this genious ?
rkj1963 3 months ago
@rkj1963 Did you just say Justin Bieber makes music? Ö
geldschijter 2 months ago
wow. i hear a little bach in this.. :)
meesbroersen 4 months ago
watch lazar berman playing this concerto.
paganviodio 4 months ago
Rachman Turner Overdrive! (sorry....)
southville108 4 months ago
Oh how I love Horowitz!
principessadolce22 4 months ago
Increíble. Vaya obrón! Y enorme Horowitz!
Monxiful 5 months ago
rocked my fucking face off....
albertj32091 5 months ago
lol the conductor doesn't lead, horowitz does!
xxcocoloco 5 months ago 2
@xxcocoloco Oh, yeah! That's always the way it is, or at least supposed to be!
TheSapphirestation 5 months ago in playlist Liked
@xxcocoloco You are so right on. I had not noticed. I was too busy watching Vladimir Horowitz gently tickling the keys with hardly any unnecessary exaggerated body movement so many other ostentatious artists use to try to impress. Thanks.
PhoenixCanDo 3 months ago
This one and Argerich's (who is sitting here listening to Horowitz) are my favourite.
HJKey 5 months ago
hell I love the way the conductor stands there just watching Horowitz...freaking awesome
Sortin87 5 months ago
@Sortin87 Oh yes ... so awesomely true.
PhoenixCanDo 3 months ago
I read somewhere that Rachmaninoff and Horowitz were very close friends, and I think some of that comes through here, in Horowitz's great passion for the music. Some of which may be his passion for his friend!
RolandRiopelle 5 months ago
Great Horowitz with a great Rachmaninov!
UmbyPoldo 5 months ago
Ahh - the most enjoyable concert I ever attended was, and always will be, spring of 1978, Chandler Pavilion, Mehta, LA Philharmonic, Horowitz performing this piece. No words can describe it! Afterwards we waited outside the side entrance. He appeared from inside, grinned from ear to ear with pleasure at the adoration, and was hustled into a Mercedes - no autographs that night!!
ScottHolliday1 7 months ago
Love this piece and love the drama Horwitz adds in. His hands just move like it's the easiest thing in the world, but I know this piece isn't! Bravo!
TheSapphirestation 7 months ago
I cannot describe what i feel when I listen to this concert... simply wonderful, a masterpiece!!
noobe29 7 months ago
The conductor always looks at the tempo from Horowitz. He is playing his thing, and I think, it was a good idea :-)
ballaststoffel2 7 months ago
Thumbs up if the Rach 3 took you over a year to conquer.........I studied this piece exclusively for roughly 14 months to achieve mastery..... So worth it!
jsavino96 8 months ago
This man makes it look so darn easy....
xaviervandepoll 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Incredibly calm, in control and magnificent. A master. It would have been great for Rubinstein and Horowitz to have done a duo.
macrossmatrix 8 months ago
Incredibly calm, in control and magnificent. A master. It would have been great for Rubenstein and Horowitz to have done a duo.
macrossmatrix 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If he travels he transports his piano in his nose.
vosster 9 months ago
Horowitz pwns!!!
nicecoolstuff13579 10 months ago
If there is a God, its Horowitz
gettoezblaster 10 months ago 3
I LOVE the way how he plays with ABSOLUTELY NO unnecessary body movements. That stability itself sets the stage for enjoying the music without being distracted by the performer, and demonstrates absolute mastery.
Watch and learn Lang Lang.
nevertheless123 10 months ago 39
@nevertheless123 I super agree. Playing with the least gestures and movements make a performer look more effortless. As they see, music should come from "within", not from external expressions.
jjg7 8 months ago
@nevertheless123
Absolutely of your opinion !!!
tat6368 1 week ago
Speechless, What is that piano? STEINWAY of course but what model? what year? sounds great!
epinedas 10 months ago
Comment removed
NellyJamba 6 months ago
@epinedas
This is the Steinway concert series that they don't even stock at Steinway Hall
NellyJamba 6 months ago
Breathtaking...
vanlowen 11 months ago
That's the perfect example of sounds that sparkle.
erken 11 months ago
08:30 orchestra gets owned.
physphilmusic 11 months ago
small mistake at 06:17 left hand there...but it's the only one I can notice! I bet he didn't care so much about perfection by that time (and age), after all, he is the god in this concerto...
physphilmusic 11 months ago
Awwwwww wheres the cadenza :(
Vesivian 1 year ago
lo spettacolo nello spettacolo ... che meraviglia !
cuoylyf 1 year ago
@dale731 solid wikipedia-ing
hazzza109 1 year ago
I was gonna ask for an HD version of this, but I just remembered that HD didn't exist when this was recorded.
sugarkang 1 year ago
Brilliant!
TVTasten 1 year ago
Brilliante!!!
Julia0071000 1 year ago
Comment removed
Julia0071000 1 year ago
Comment removed
Julia0071000 1 year ago
My god that was brilliant!
jrcollings 1 year ago
wouldn't it be awesome to arrive at your first day of collage and play that!
maximos118 1 year ago
thanks for uploading: unbelievable really, but true. What is the meaning of life? For Rachmaninoff to have written this, for Horrorwitz to have performed it, and for us the rank and file to pay up to make sure them two made a living. And perhaps buying an icecream during intermission so that the vendor can make a living too.
pianomike1 1 year ago 19
Those old steinways sound so much nicer
logosthedestroyer 1 year ago
terrible recording.
WunIde 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@WunIde You really must be kidding
Morfee 1 year ago
There is no greater admirer of Horowitz than I ... but one crucial element of his interpretation has always bothered me - when he states the first melodic theme in octaves, he is brilliant - romantic, cantabile, et al ... but listen closely to each of his recordings, when the orchestra answers with the same melody, the piano is supposed to be merely an accompaniment. Even Rachmaninoff played it as such, but Horowitz overpowers ... the effect isn't allowed to happen.
Music4ibc 1 year ago
The most beautiful and skillful interpretation of the First Movement. Too bad it was cut short.
ely422 1 year ago
What can I say... breath taking and soul gripping. The most beautiful and skillful interpretation of the First Movement. Too bad it was cut short.
ely422 1 year ago
I just watched the performance by Martha Argerich here on yt of the same movement....
I have to say Horowitz's playing is orders of magnitude better, left me speechless really...
poddyweb 1 year ago
I take it back the...the more I watch this the more I like mehta, I think it was his haircut that just pissed me off haha. And also, 8:02-9:30...its just so perfect
Wally773MTG 1 year ago
I really don't like Mehta that much, am I like totally weird? And also, this is the first time I've seen this (I've heard it before but not horowitz) and have literally been moved to tears hahaha
Wally773MTG 1 year ago
What do those rails on the side of the piano do? I have seen them on some but not on others.
ephelduath606 1 year ago
Am I the only one who finds 1:05 to 1:24 just undisputed? I've heard Argerich, Kissin, Lisitsa, Kern... get drowned by the orchestra here. But only Horowitz makes this what you call a piano concerto: he not only complements the orchestra, he makes this part a compelling introduction.
wordlesssong 1 year ago
mistake at 9:20 but who cares horowitz gave the ultimate feelings to auidence.
caldornain 1 year ago
Brilliant performance of one of the best pianist in the history of classic music. Listening him performing his master and friend Rachmaninov is one the most thrilling experiences you can experience. He will endure for ever as the best pieano player.
cseas1 1 year ago
@cseas1
Xtreaming 1 year ago
it's like 08:30 -> 08:50 minutes are tagged with Horowitz's name. best personal involvement in this concerto
Xtreaming 1 year ago
Horowitz always amazes me! Did you guys know he and Rachmaninoff were really good friends? Rachmaninoff and Horowitz would play duets together on Rachmaninoff's two grand pianos at his home. Rachmaninoff also quoted once that "The only person that can play my third concerto better than me is Horowitz."
modelstatue 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
painful for my ears
rolldito 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he is jewish
kelloggcerealxoxo 2 years ago
And Jackonn is black what is the problem!?
misterbsln 2 years ago 2
derp derp
HumanLarva 1 year ago
dum dee dam dum dee dam dum dee dam dum! 2:47-2:49
mrculterreux 2 years ago
I love love love this recording...
MikeyAC86 2 years ago
Delicious...
rebeccanubodys 2 years ago 2
His technique is flawless, I've never seen hands so relaxed!
I wish i could play like that....
Jinda89 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
little bit heavy .
Dennischek 2 years ago
Hands down, the most exciting and complex piano concerto ever written, followed closely by Tchaikovsky's. I loved Martha Argerich's interpretation, but it takes a real Russian for this piece of masterwork.
smithadamdave 2 years ago 2
Well, Ukrainian from the looks of it, but incredible all the same.
sairamnagarajan 2 years ago
LOL headbutting Horowitz on 8 : 57
An awesome performance, btw
Peter0414 2 years ago
It is effortless for Horowitz.
ayuprnkcller 2 years ago
No second movement?
talonboy5432 2 years ago
100 years!
nucciagabriella 2 years ago
concertos 2 & 3 are like, the greatest things ever.
fledgehog 2 years ago 13
@fledgehog 1& 4 are awesome too!
About the performance, ABSOULUTELY SUPERBLY FANTASTICALLY AMAZING! IT"S SO AMAZING I"M MISPELLING A LOT OF WORDS!!!
werq34ac 2 years ago 4
So, so beautiful. 8:31 - 8:50 transports me in an other world.
Lyapazavecunhee 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not bad
Upum12 2 years ago
bravoooooooooooooooooooo! Master Rachmaninov.
CYDONIA2001 2 years ago 2
today 100 years of being composed this concerto!!
eltachimetro 2 years ago 11
Horowitz is beyond words.
sprescott3 2 years ago 3
his second piano concerto is more beautiful...but the third is grander in spirit
dalecampbl5 2 years ago 3
rachmaninoff's music is so beautiful
lukard2 2 years ago 6
Vladimir Horowitz is so musical. There was always so much magic in Horowitz's playing.
cattleman6420012000 2 years ago 12
You're watching a genius. He made the first recording of this work 48 years before this concert. He had the unqualified approval of the composer, who never played this piece in public after hearing Horowitz play it. They played it together in the Steinway basement in New York. Rachmaninoff supposedly told friends he "swallowed it whole."
dale731 2 years ago 53
This is beautiful - I am truly horrified i hadn't discovered horowitz until this evening! If none of you have seen the movie shine, if you are rach 3 fans check it out for sure. Anyhow, back to the point, a formidably incredible performance; moving, passionate and with such ease - truly stunning
antoniasd 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Sokolov's interpretation is the best for me.
nbharakey 3 years ago
Luckily I heard him in 1975 here in Chicago and will never forget it, he was the greatest Pianist I ever heard and even in his 80's played better then most anyone.
pearlmuth3 3 years ago 52
@pearlmuth3 You never heard Argerich?
ludolxx94 1 year ago
@ludolxx94 Argerich plays it much worse.. It doesen't have this passion in her interpretation.
Pirotechnik1995 1 year ago